Succeeding a Legendary Coach: A Preliminary Investigation into the NFL Betting Market

Abstract

Some coaches are so successful and have such an impact on their team that they are considered "legendary." When they step down from their position and the team transitions to a new head coach, there will likely be a great deal of uncertainty concerning how the team will perform in this new situation; thus, it may take time for the betting markets to adjust. The purpose of this study is to investigate the efficiency of a sports betting market for the rare situation in which a legend steps down from the head coaching position. Data from the National Football League are analyzed using a novel implementation of classification trees to determine if and when a market inefficiency exists in the subsequent season. We find a potential bias early in the following season before the market appears to adjust to the new coach.

Keywords

sports betting markets National Football League classification trees market efficiency point spread betting

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beal

, Norman

T. J.

, & Ramchurn

S. D.

(2020). A critical comparison of machine learning classifiers to predict match outcomes in the NFL. International Journal of Computer Science in Sport, 19(2), 36–50.

Buller-Russ

(2023). Top NFL head coaches of all time, including Andy Reid. Sportsnaut. https://sportsnaut.com/top-20-nfl-head-coaches-of-all-time/

Bunker

, & Susnjak

(2022). The application of machine learning techniques for predicting match results in team sport: A review. Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research, 73, 1285–1332.

Colquitt

L. L.

, Godwin

N. H.

, & Shortridge

R. T.

(2007). The effects of uncertainty on market prices: Evidence from coaching changes in the NBA. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 34(5/6), 86f–87f.

Dare

W. H.

, & Dennis

S. A.

(2011). A test for bias of inherent characteristics in betting markets. Journal of Sports Economics, 12(6), 660–665.

Davis

, Fodor

, McElfresh

, & Krieger

(2015). Exploiting week 2 bias in the NFL betting market. Journal of Prediction Markets, 9(1), 53–67.

Davis

, & Krieger

(20f 7). Preseason bias in the NFL and NBA betting markets. Applied Economics, 49(12), f204-f2f2.

De Ardo

(2024). Top 10 NFL coaches of all time: Bill Belichick's place among the greatest in league history. CBS Sports. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/top-10-nfl-coaches-of-all-time-bill-belichicks-place-among-the-greatest-in-league-history/

De La Riva

(2024). The best NFL coaches of all time, ranked. Ranker. https://www.ranker.com/list/all-time-winningest-nfl-coach-es/david-de-la-riva

10.

, Cogdell

, & Kasap

(2012). A comparative analysis of data mining methods in predicting NCAA bowl outcomes. International Journal of Forecasting, 28(2), 543–552.

11.

Di Filippo

, Krieger

, Davis

, & Fodor

(2014). Early season NFL over/under bias. Journal of Sports Economics, 15(2), 201–211.

12.

Elmachtoub

A. N.

, & Grigas

(2022). Smart "predict, then optimize." Management Science, 68(1), 9–26.

13.

Fernandes

C. J.

, Yakubov

, Li

, Prasad

A. K.

, & Chan

T. C. Y.

(2020). Predicting plays in the National Football League. Journal of Sports Analytics, 6(1), 35–43.

14.

Fodor

, Di Filippo

, Krieger

, & Davis

(2013). Inefficient pricing from holdover bias in NFL point spread markets. Applied Financial Economics, 23(17), 1407–1418.

15.

Garber

(2013). Greatest coaches in NFL history. ESPN. https://www.espn.com/nfl/feature/index/_/page/greatestcoaches

16.

Gifford

, & Bayrak

(2023). A predictive analytics model for forecasting outcomes in the National Football League using decision tree and logistic regression. Decision Analytics Journal, 8, Article 100296.

17.

Girdner

, Davis

, Fodor

, & Kirch

(2013). Early season NBA over/under bias. Journal of Prediction Markets, 7(2), 1–9.

18.

Hastie

, Tibshirani

, & Friedman

(2017). The elements of statistical learning: Data mining, inference, and prediction (2nd ed.). Springer.

19.

Healy

(2022). From George Halas to Bill Belichick: 10 best NFL head coaches of all time. Audacy https://www.audacy.com/national/sports/best-nfl-head-coaches-ever

20.

Humphreys

B. R.

, & Johnson

(2020). The effect of superstars on game attendance: Evidence from the NBA. Journal of Sports Economics, 21(2), 152–175.

21.

Humphreys

B. R.

, Paul

R. J

, & Weinbach

A. P.

(2013). Bettor biases and the home-underdog bias in the NFL. International Journal of Sport Finance, 8(4), 294–311.

22.

Jane

W.-J.

(2016). The effect of star quality on attendance demand: The case of the National Basketball Association. Journal of Sports Economics, 17(A), 396–417.

23.

Kahler

(2024). Coaches confidential: How NFL middle management secretly shares salary information. The Athletic. https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5354248/2024/03/25/nfl-position-coaches-salaries-confidential/

24.

Kalbrosky

, & Schuster

(2024). How 12 football head coaches fared as the replacements for legends like Bill Belichick and Nick Saban. USA Today Sports. https://ftw.usatoday.com/lists/how-12-football-head-coaches-fared-as-the-replacements-for-legends-like-bill-belichick-and-nick-saban

25.

Lock

, & Nettleton

(2014). Using random forests to estimate win probability before each play of an NFL game. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sport, 10(2), 197–205.

26.

Matheson

(2021). An overview of the economics of sports gambling and an introduction to the symposium. Eastern Economic Journal, 47(1), 1–8.

27.

Miceli

T. J.

(2023). On sports betting and uncertainty of outcome. International Journal of Sport Finance, 18(2), 97–104.

28.

New England Patriots. (2024). The Patriots and Bill Belichick have mutually agreed to part ways. https://www.patriots.com/news/the-patriots-and-bill-belichick-have-mutually-agreed-to-part-ways

29.

Pro Football Hall of Fame. (2024). Selection process. https://www.profootballhof.com/hall-of-famers/selection-process/

30.

Pro Football Reference. (2024a). List of all the pro football franchises. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/index.htm

31.

Pro Football Reference. (2024b). Coaches, records, and coaching totals, https://www.pro-football-reference.com/coaches/

32.

Roumani

Y. F.

(2023). Sports analytics in the NFL: Classifying the winner of the superbowl. Annals of Operations Research, 325, 715–730.

33.

Santorsa

(2012). Ranking the 50 best NFL head coaches of all time. Bleacher Report. https://bleacherreport.com/articles/1168549-ranking-the-50-best-nfl-head-coaches-of-all-time

34.

SAS Institute Inc. (2023). The HPSPLIT procedure. In SAS/STAT® 15.3 user's guide. SAS Institute Inc.

35.

Soebbing

B. P.

, Wicker

, & Weimar

(2015). The impact of leadership changes on expectations of organizational performance. Journal of Sport Management, 29(5), 485–497.

36.

Sutton

C. D.

(2005). Classification and regression trees, bagging, and boosting. In Rao

C. R.

, Wegman

E. J.

, & Solka

J. L.

(Eds.), Handbook of statistics, volume 24: Data mining and data visualization (pp. 303–329). Elsevier B.V.

37.

Tallent

(2023). 25 greatest head coaches in NFL history. Athlon Sports. https://athlonsports.com/nfl/25-greatest-head-coaches-nfl-history

38.

Vandenbruaene

, De Ceuster

, & Annaert

(2022). Efficient spread betting markets: A literature review. Journal of Sports Economics, 23(7), 907–949.