Predicting Ticket Holder No-Shows: Examining Differences between Reported and Actual Attendance at College Football Games

Abstract

Reported attendance for most sport events is based on tickets disseminated, not actual number of spectators who physically enter the venue. Yet nearly all live sport event demand studies are based on reported attendance rather than the actual attendance. The current study examines multiple measures of home game attendance for NCAA Division I college football programs as reported from both game box scores and post-event scanned ticket audits provided to The Wall Street Journal. Regression models are utilized to examine factors that have a statistically significant relationship with three different measures of attendance: (a) reported attendance, (b) actual attendance, and (c) total number of ticket holder no-shows. Several independent variables, included demographic factors, measures of game attractiveness, and residual preferences, demonstrated such relationships with each measure of attendance when examining ticket usage data from 595 game dates during the 2017 season.

Keywords

demand attendance ticket usage no-shows college football

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bachman

(2018, Aug. 30). College football's growing problem: Empty seats. Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/college-footballs-growing-problem-empty-seats-1535634001

Biyalogorsky

, Carmon

, Fruchter

G. E.

, & Gerstner

(1999). Research note: Overselling with opportunistic cancellations. Marketing Science, 18(4), 605–610.

Borland

, & MacDonald

(2003). Demand for sport. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 19(4), 478–502.

Branvold

S. E.

, Pan

D. W

, & Gabert

T. E.

(1997). Effects of winning percentage and market size on attendance in minor league baseball. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 6(4), 35–42.

Brown

(2011, May 25). How sports attendance figures speak lies. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/sports-money/2011/05/25/how-sports-attendance-figures-speak-Iies/?sh=2d4140b62b2a

Cebula

R. J.

, Toma

, & Carmichael

(2009). Attendance and promotions in minor league baseball: The Carolina League. Applied Economics, 41(25), 3209–3214.

Charleston

(2008). Determinants of home atmosphere in English football: A committed supporter perspective. Journal of Sport Behavior, 31(4), 312–324.

Chastain

A. J.

, Gohmann

S. F.

, & Stephenson

E. F.

(2017). Beer availability and college football attendance: Evidence from mid-major conferences. Journal of Sports Economics, 18(6), 592–600.

Coates

, & Humphreys

B. R.

(2007). Ticket prices, concessions and attendance at professional sporting events. International Journal of Sport Finance, 2(3), 161–170.

10.

Cooper

(2019, Nov. 7). NCAA rules help UMD, others inflate attendance figures. Capital News Service. https://cnsmaryland.org/2019/11/07/ncaa-rules-help-umd-others-inflate-football-attendance-figures/

11.

Crawford

D. W

, & Godbey

(1987). Reconceptualizing barriers to family leisure. Leisure Sciences, 9(2), 119–127.

12.

Crawford

D. W

, Jackson

E. L.

, & Godbey

(1991). A hierarchical model of leisure constraints. Leisure Sciences, 13(4), 309–320.

13.

Davies

, Coleman

, & Ramchandani

(2010). Measuring attendance: Issues and implications for estimating the impact of free-to-view sports events. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 12(1), 6–18.

14.

De Schriver

T. D.

, & Jensen

P. E.

(2002). Determinants of spectator attendance at NCAA Division II football contests. Journal of Sport Management, 16(4), 311–330.

15.

Eddy

, Rascher

, & Stewart

(2016). Where is everyone? An examination of attendance at college football bowl games. International Journal of Sport Finance, 11(1) 26–45.

16.

Falls

G. A.

, & Natke

P. A.

(2014). College football attendance: A panel study of the Football Bowl Subdivision. Applied Economics, 46(10), 1093–1107.

17.

Falls

G. A.

, & Natke

P. A.

(2016). College football attendance: A panel study of the Football Championship Subdivision. Managerial and Decision Economics, 37(8), 530–540.

18.

Feddersen

, & Rott

(2011). Determinants of demand for televised live football: Features of the German national football team. Journal of Sports Economics, 12(3), 352–369.

19.

Fischer

(2013, April 29). Weather costs Twins deep into seven figures. SportsBusiness Journal. https://wwwsportsbusinessdailycom/Journal/Issues/2013/04/29/Franchises/Twins.aspx

20.

Garling

(2013, March 16). MLB puts squeeze on sneaky fans with app. San Francisco Chronicle. https://www.sfgate.com/giants/article/MLB-puts-squeeze-on-sneaky-fans-with-app-4360795.php

21.

Garrow

L. A.

, & Koppelman

F. S.

(2004). Multinomial and nested logit models of airline passengers’ no-show and standby behaviour. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management, 3(3), 237–253.

22.

Gitter

S. R.

, & Rhoads

T. A.

(2010). Determinants of minor league baseball attendance. Journal of Sport Economics, 11(6), 614–628.

23.

Hansen

, & Gauthier

(1989). Factors affecting attendance at professional sporting events. Journal of Sport Management, 3(1), 15–32.

24.

Howard

D. R.

, & Crompton

J. L.

(2004). Tactics used by sports organizations in the United States to increase ticket sales. Managing Leisure, 9(2), 87–95.

25.

Huang

, & Dixon

M. A.

(2013). Examining the financial impact of alcohol sales on football game days: A case study of a major football program. Journal of Sport Management, 27(3), 207–216.

26.

Hubbard

(2017, August 16). The end of season tickets. The Ringer. https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2017/8/16/16147716/season-tickets-end-secondary-sellers

27.

Karg

, Tamaddoni

, McDonald

, & Ewing

(2021). Predicting season ticket holder retention using rich behavioral data. Journal of Sport Management, 35(5), 1–14.

28.

Kim

, Magnusen

, Kim

, & Lee

H. W.

(2019). Meta-analytic review of sport consumption: Factors affecting attendance to sporting events. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 28(3), 117–134.

29.

Kim

Y. K.

, & Trail

(2010). Constraints and motivators: A new model to explain sport consumer behavior. Journal of Sport Management, 24(2), 190–210.

30.

Kleps

(2015, Sept. 14). The price of playing; NCAA's ‘out of date’ football attendance mandate makes it difficult on the likes of Akron and Kent State. Crain's Cleveland Business, 36(37), 0001.

31.

Lewis

, Wang

, & Wu

(2019). Season ticket buyer value and secondary market options. Marketing Science, 38(6), 973–993.

32.

Lim

W. S.

(2009). Overselling in a competitive environment: Boon or bane? Marketing Science, 28(6), 1129–1143.

33.

McDonald

(2010). The factors influencing churn rates among season ticket holders: An empirical analysis. Journal of Sport Management, 24(6), 676–701.

34.

McEvoy

C. D.

, & Morse

A. L.

(2007). An investigation of the relationship between television broadcasting and game attendance. International Journal of Sport Management and Marketing, 2(3), 222–235.

35.

Milewski

T. D.

(2013, March 6). Bucky's no-shows: 25 percent of purchased tickets go unused for UW games. The Capital Times. https://madison.com/ct/news/local/bucky-s-no-shows-percent-of-purchased-tickets-go-unused/article_0f005610-85d5-lle2-9b4c-0019bb2963f4.html

36.

Mills

B. M.

, Salaga

, & Tainsky

(2016). NBA primary market ticket consumers: Ex ante expectations and consumer market origination. Journal of Sport Management, 30(5), 538–552.

37.

Mitchell

, & Montgomery

R. D.

(2015). Beer and ball on campus? The issue of in-stadium alcohol sales. The Sport Journal. http://thesportjournal.org/article/beer-and-ball-on-campus-the-issue-of-in-stadium-alcohol-sales/

38.

Popp

, Bane

, Howell

, & Osborne

(2020). To serve and protect: Examining the relationship between selling alcohol in college football venues and negative fan behaviors. Journal of Applied Sport Management, 12(1), 73–82.

39.

Popp

, Jensen

, & Jackson

(2017). Maximizing visitors at college football bowl games. International Journal of Event and Festival Management, 8(3), 261–273.

40.

Popp

, Jensen

, McEvoy

, & Weiner

(2019). Quantifying the impact of adding a proactive outbound ticket sales force on revenues of NCAA athletics departments. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, 12, 205–225.

41.

Popp

, Jensen

, McEvoy

, & Weiner

(2020). An examination of the effects of outsourcing ticket sales force management. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Management, 21(2), 205–223.

42.

Price

D. I.

, & Sen

K. C.

(2003). The demand for game day attendance in college football: An analysis of the 1997 Division 1-A season. Managerial and Decision Economics, 24(1), 35–46.

43.

Pritchard

M. P.

, Funk

D. C

, & Alexandris

(2009). Barriers to repeat patronage: The impact of spectator constraints. European Journal of Marketing, 43(1/2), 169–187.

44.

Pyun

, Kim

J. J.

, & Kim

(2020). Which professional sport team has the best marketing performance in driving attendance? The stochastic frontier approach. International Journal of Sport Finance, 15, 55–68.

45.

Ramil

(2020, Jan. 13). Miami Heat innovation with data leads to agreement with Bucks. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/da-vidramil/2020/01/13/miami-heat-innovation-with-data-leads-to-agreement-with-bucks/#61da96b27174

46.

Rovell

(2009, Oct. 5). Corporations wasted estimated 43% of sports tickets last year. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/id/33182576

47.

Sampaio

C. H.

, Sordi

J. D.

, & Perin

M. G.

(2015). How price bundling affects football ticket purchases and consumption behaviour. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 16(3), 35–51.

48.

Satiani

, Miller

, & Patel

(2009). No-show rates in the vascular laboratory: Analysis and possible solutions. Journal of Vascular and Interventional Radiology, 20(1), 87–91.

49.

Schofield

J. A.

(1983). Performance and attendance at professional team sports. Journal of Sport Behavior, 6(4), 196–206.

50.

Schreyer

, & Däuper

(2018). Determinants of spectator no-show behaviour: First empirical evidence from the German Bundesliga. Applied Economics Letters, 25(21), 1475–1480.

51.

Schreyer

, Schmidt

S. L.

, & Torgler

(2016). Against all odds? Exploring the role of game outcome uncertainty in season ticket holders’ stadium attendance demand. Journal of Economic Psychology, 56, 192–217.

52.

Schreyer

, Schmidt

S. L.

, & Torgler

(2017). Predicting season ticket holder loyalty using geographical information. Applied Economics Letters, 25(4), 272–277.

53.

Schreyer

, Schmidt

S. L.

, & Torgler

(2018). Game outcome uncertainty in the English Premier League: Do German fans care? Journal of Sports Economics, 19(5), 625–644.

54.

Shackelford

, & Greenwell

T. C.

(2005). Predicting women's Division I sports attendance: An analysis of institutional characteristics. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 14(3), 139–147.

55.

Shaikin

(2005, Aug. 23). Attendance figures that count tickets sold, not turnstile clicks, make it hard for fans to reconcile what they hear with the empty seats they see. Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/la-sp-attendance-082305-story.html

56.

Siegfried

J. J.

, & Hinshaw

C. E.

(1979). Effect of lifting television blackouts on professional football no-shows. Journal of Economics and Business, 32(1), 1–13.

57.

Simmons

, Popp

, McEvoy

, & Howell

(2017). Tomorrow's fans gone today: Assessing constraints to student attendance at college football games. Journal of Applied Sport Management, 9(3), 13–23.

58.

Simmons

J. M.

, Popp

, McEvoy

C. D

, & Howell

S. M.

(2018). Using fan passion to investigate constraints to student attendance at college football games. Journal of Intercollegiate Sport, 11(2), 193–213.

59.

Soman

, & Gourville

J. T.

(2001). Transaction decoupling: How price bundling affects the decision to consume. Journal of Marketing Research, 38(1), 30–44.

60.

Stock

J. H.

, & Watson

M. W.

(2008). Heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors for fixed effects panel data regression. Econo-metrica, 76, 155–174.

61.

Subramanian

, Stidham

Jr. , & Lautenbacher

C. J.

(1999). Airline yield management with overbooking, cancellations, and no-shows. Transportation Science, 33(2), 147–167.

62.

Sulistio

, Kim

K. H.

, & Buyya

(2008, May). Managing cancellations and no-shows of reservations with overbooking to increase resource revenue. In 2008 Eighth IEEE International Symposium on Cluster Computing and the Grid (CCGRID) (pp. 267–276). IEEE.

63.

Sung

, & Mills

B. M.

(2018). Estimation of game-level attendance in Major League Soccer: Outcome uncertainty and absolute quality considerations. Sport Management Review, 21(5), 519–532.

64.

Sutton

(1998). Predicting and explaining intentions and behavior: How well are we doing? Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 28(15), 1317–1338.

65.

Sutton

W. A.

, Lachowetz

, & Clark

(2000). Eduselling: The role of customer education in selling to corporate clients in the sport industry. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 2(2), 56–69.

66.

Thaler

R. H.

(1980). Toward a positive theory of consumer choice. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 1, 39–60.

67.

Trail

G. T.

& Kim

Y. K.

(2011). Factors influencing spectator sports consumption: NCAA women's college basketball. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 13(1), 60–71.

68.

Trail

G. T.

, Robinson

M. J.

, & Kim

Y. K.

(2008). Sport consumer behavior: A test for group differences on structural constraints. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 17(A), 190–200.

69.

Watanabe

N. M.

, Yan

, & Soebbing

B. P.

(2019). Market disruption as a regime for athlete activism: An economic analysis of college football player protests. Sport Management Review, 22(5), 600–612.

70.

Wolfson

, Wakelin

, & Lewis

(2005). Football supporters’ perceptions of their role in the home advantage. Journal of Sports Sciences, 23(A), 365–374.

71.

Wooldridge

J. M.

(2010). Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT Press.

72.

Yost

J. H.

, & Rainey

D. W.

(2014). The consequences of disappointment in team performance among baseball fans. Journal of Sport Behavior, 37(A), 407.

73.

Zacharias

, & Pinedo

(2014). Appointment scheduling with no-shows and overbooking. Production and Operations Management, 23,788–801.

74.

Zhang

J. J.

, Pease

D. G.

, Smith

D. W.

, Lee

J. T.

, Lam

E. T. C

, & Jambor

E. A.

(1997). Factors affecting the decision making of spectators to attend minor league hockey games. International Sports Journal, 1(1), 39–53.

75.

Zuber

R. A.

& Gandar

J. M.

(1988). Lifting the television blackout on no-shows at football games. Atlantic Economic Journal, 16(2), 63–73.