The inter-healthcare transfer of the critically ill neonate is a critical aspect of larger neonatal intensive care, as it influences the safe transport of neonates from the receiving to the referring hospital. It is crucial then that the transfer process be safe and efficient so as not to compromise the already fragile condition of the neonate. The aim of the study was to understand the challenges advanced life support (ALS) paramedics face during neonatal transfers and to understand how the process could be made safer and more efficient. The objectives related to understanding the transfer process, the challenges linked to the critically ill neonate and the difficulties associated with the ambulance vehicle and equipment.
Methods
Using a qualitative research approach we sought the views of ALS paramedics at the forefront of transfers nationally. In-depth interviews were held with eight paramedics in KwaZulu-Natal and four focus group discussions with ALS paramedics in KwaZulu-Natal, Gauteng, Free State and the Western Cape in South Africa. A total of 35 ALS paramedics were involved in these group discussions.
Results
The study uncovered several challenges that paramedics face related to poor organisational preparation for transfer of the critically ill neonate, and other crucial issues that compromise the transfer such as inadequate or defective equipment.
Conclusion
There is a need for greater scrutiny of the transfer process and a commitment from stakeholders to begin addressing the challenges confronting the safe transfer of critically ill neonates.
HunterD., McCallumJ., HowesD.Compassion in emergency departments. Part 2: barriers to the provision of compassionate care.Emerg Nurse2018; 26.
2.
HenninkM., HutterI., BaileyA.Qualitative research methods.SAGE Publications Limited; 2020.
3.
BraunV., ClarkeV., HayfieldN.A starting point for your journey, not a map: Nikki Hayfield in conversation with Virginia Braun and Victoria Clarke about thematic analysis.Qual Res Psychol2019; 1–22.
4.
TuttyI.M., RotheryM.A., GrinnellR.M.Qualitative research for social workers: phases, steps and tasks.Boston, Mass: Allyn and Bacon; 1996.
5.
LiamputtongP., EzzyD.Qualitative research methods.South Melbourne: Oxford University Press; 2005.
6.
GubaE.G.Handbook of qualitative research.New York, NY: Sage Publications; 1994.
7.
BuetowS.Apophenia, unconscious bias and reflexivity in nursing qualitative research.Int J Nurs Stud2019; 89: 8–13.
8.
WiegersmaJ.S., DrooghJ.M., ZijlstraJ.G., FokkemaJ.Quality of interhospital transport of the critically ill: impact of a mobile intensive care unit with a specialized retrieval team.Crit Care2011; 15: 2–8.
9.
BarfieldW.D., KrugS.E., KanterR.K., Gausche-HilM., BrantleyM.D.Neonatal and pediatric regionalized systems in pediatric emergency mass critical care.Pediatr Crit Care Med2011; 12: 128–34.
10.
KageA., AkumaA.Audit on central newborn network transport documentation.J Paediatr Child Health2012; 48(Suppl 1): 278.
11.
MillerA., NovakL., WeingerM., BuerhausP.Processes and support tools for interhospital neonatal patient transfer: a preliminary study.Sage Journals2008; 52: 865–9.
12.
Carreras-GonzalezE., Brió-SanagustinS.Prevention of complications in the air transport of the critically ill paediatric patient between hospitals.Ann Pediatr2014; 81: 205–11.
13.
Parmentier-DecrucqE., PoissyJ., FavoryR.Adverse events during intrahospital transport of critically ill patients: incidence and risk factors.Ann Intensive Care2013; 3: 1–10.
14.
McEvoyC.G., DsclouxE., SchulerM.Evaluation of neonatal transport in Western Switzerland: a model of perinatal regionalization.Clin Med Insights Pediatr2017; 11: 1–7.
15.
DrooghJ.M., SmitM., HutJ.Inter-hospital transport of critically ill patients: expect surprises.Crit Care Med2012; 16: 26.
16.
BlakemanT.C., BransonR.D.Inter-and intra-hospital transport of the critically ill.Respiratory Care2013; 58: 1008–23.
KarlsenK.A., TrautmanM., Price-DouglasW., SmithS.National survey of neonatal transport teams in the United States.Pediatrics2011; 128: 685–91.
19.
WhyteH.E.A., JefferiesA.L.The interfacility transport of critically ill new-borns.Paediatr Child Health2015; 20: 265–75.
20.
WoodwardG.A., InsoftR.M., KleinmanM.E.Guidelines for air and ground transport of neonatal and pediatric patients.3rd edn.Elk Grove Village Illinois: American Academy of Pediatrics; 2007.
21.
JacksonL., SkeochC.H.Setting up a neonatal transport service: air transport.Early Hum Dev2009; 85: 477–81.
22.
KueR., BrownP., NessC., ScheulenJ.Adverse clinical events during intrahospital transport by a specialized team: a preliminary report.Am J Crit Care2011; 20: 153–62.
23.
GenteM., Di LalloD., FrancoF.[AUTHOR: PLEASE SUPPLY TITLE OF ARTICLE]J Pediatr2015; 41(Suppl 1): A15.
24.
ChangA.S.M., BerryA., SivasangariS.Specialty teams for neonatal transport to neonatal intensive care units for prevention of morbidity and mortality.Cochrane Database Syst Rev2008; (4): CD007485.
25.
OhningB.Transport of the critically ill newborn. e-medicine.Pediatrics2008.
26.
HiromaT., IchibaH., WadaK.Nationwide survey of neonatal transportation practices in Japan.Pediatr Int2016; 58: 311–3.
27.
SinghA., DuckettJ., NewtonT., WatkinsonM.Improving neonatal unit admission temperatures in preterm babies: exothermic mattresses, polythene bags or a traditional approach.J Perinatol2010; 30: 45–9.
28.
BouchutJ.C., Van LanckeE., ChritinV., GueugniaudP.Y.Physical stressors during neonatal transport: helicopter compared with ground ambulance.Air Med J2011; 30: 134–9.
29.
RomanoE., KaufmannM.Abstract: Quantification of vibration forces experienced by the newborn during ambulance transport.ibid.2012; 31: 167–8.
30.
GajendragragadkarG., BoydJ.A., PotterD.W.Mechanical vibration in neonatal transport: a randomized study of different mattresses.J Perinatol2000; 20: 307–10.
31.
LohE.Doctors as health managers: an oxymoron, or a good idea?Journal of Work-Applied Management2015; 7: 52–60.
32.
CraigR., MoxeyL., YoungD., SpenceleyN.S., DavidsonM.G.Strengthening handover communication in pediatric cardiac intensive care.Paediatr Anaesth2012; 22: 393–9.
AshokcoomarP., NaidooR.An analysis of inter-healthcare facility transfer of neonates within the eThekwini Health District of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
35.
MgciniD.T.The quality of neonatal inter-facility transport systems within the Johannesburg Metropolitan Region. Masters of Medicine, University of Witwatersrand; 2011.
36.
GunzA.C., DhananiS., WhyteH.Identifying significant and relevant events during pediatric transport: a modified Delphi study.Pediatr Crit Care Med2014; 15: 653–9.
37.
GrosekS.Air and ground transport of critically ill neonates and infants in Slovenia.Department for Pediatric Surgery and Intensive Care, University Medical Center Ljubljana2007; 88–91.
38.
McCaulM., HendricksL., NaidooR.Prehospital providers’ perspectives for clinical practice guideline implementation and dissemination: strengthening guideline uptake in South Africa.PloS One2019; 14: e0219761.
39.
American Heart Association, European Resuscitation Council and International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation.International consensus on cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care science with treatment recommendations.2010. Available at: www.circ.ahajournals.org/cgi/content/full/122/18
40.
DuffJ.P., TopjianA., BergM.D.American Heart Association focused update on pediatric advanced life support: an update to the American Heart Association guidelines for cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care.Circulation2019: 138: e731-9.
41.
McCaulM., ClarkeM., BruijnsS.R.Global emergency care clinical practice guidelines: a landscape analysis.Afr J Emerg Med2018; 8: 158–63.
42.
AcostaC.D., Kit DelgadoM., GisondiM.A.Characteristics of pediatric trauma transfers to a level I trauma center: implications for developing a regionalized pediatric trauma system in California.Acad Emerg Med2010; 17: 1364–73.
43.
ForondaC., Van GraafeilandB., DavidsonP.Handover and transport of critically ill children: an integrative review.International Journal of Nursing School Studies2016; 62: 207–25.
