Comparative Study of the Analgesic Effect of Transcutaneous Nerve Stimulation (TNS);Electroacupuncture (EA) and Meperidine in the Treatment of Postoperative Pain

Abstract

Seventy two patients, from 15 to 60 years old, in good physical status and submitted to surgery in the upper or lower abdominal, rectal or lumbar areas were studied. In the immediate postoperative period, they were randomly divided in three groups and each group was submitted to one of the following treatments: intravenous meperidine, transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TNS) or electroacupuncture (EA). Each treatment was divided in two phases with one hour interval between them. Each phase was constituted of 30 minutes of stimulation in case of TNS and EA and fractionated administration of meperidine in all groups. The pain level was evaluated through a visual analogue scale before and after each phase of treatment. The results were compared among groups and, on each group, between the phases of treatment. In all surgery types, the postoperative pain relief presented by TNS and EA groups of patients was greater than that of meperidine treated group. But, the analgesia presented by the EA treated group of patients lasted longer and increased with the repetition of treatment. The differences of behaviour of TNS and EA analgesia suggest that their neurochemical mechanisms may not be the same.

Keywords

analgesia electroacupuncture transcutaneous postoperative pain

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Dundee

J.W.

and Loan

W.B.

Drugs used in pain relief. Journal of the Royal College of Surgeons of Ireland

Vol.3, 3–10, 1966.

Pomeranz

and Cheng

Supression of noxious responses in single neurons of cat spinal cord by electroacupuncture and its reversal by the opiate antagonist naloxone. Exp. Neurol. Vol. 64, 327–341, 1979.

Cheng

R.S.S.

and Pomeranz

Electroacupuncture could be mediated by at least two pain relieving mechanisms: endorphin and non-endorphin systems. Life Sci. Vol. 25, 1957–1962, 1979.

Omura

Pain thresold masurement before and after acupuncture: controversial results of radiant method and the roles of ACTh-like substances and endorphins. Acupuncture & Electro-Therapeut. Res., Int. J. Vol. 3, 1–21. 1978.

Melzack

R.C.

and Wall

P.D.

Acupuncture analgesia. A psychophysiological explanation. Minnesota Medicine Vol. 57, 161–167, 1974.

Andersson

S.A.

and Holmgren

, Analgesic effects of peripheral conditioning stimulation - III. Effect of light frequency stimulation; segmental mechanisms interacting with pain. Acupuncture & Electro-Therapeut. Res., Int. J. Vol. 3, 23–36, 1978.

Andersson

S.A.

and Thoren

Acupuncture: activation of physiological mechanisms or change in meredian energy flow? In: Yokota

and Dubner

, Current Topics in Pain Research and Therapy, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, 1983. pp 147–157.

Terman

G.W.

Lewis

J.W.

and Liebskind

J.C.

Multiple endogenous analgesia systems activated by stress in the rat. In: Yokota

and Dubner

, Current Topics in Pain Research and Therapy, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, 1983. pp 81–94.

Xiao-Ding

Shao-Feng

and Wen-Xiao

Inhibition of sympathetic nervous system by acupuncture. Acupuncture & El ectro-T. herapeut. Res., Int. J. Vol. 8, 25–35, 1983.

10.

Andersson

S.A.

Ericson

Holmgren

and Lindqvist

Electroacupuncture. Effect on pain thresold measured with electrical stimulation of teeth. Brain Res. Vol. 63, 393–396, 1973.

11.

Mann

Acupuncture anaesthesia in dentistry. Lancet Vol.2 849, 1973.

12.

Modell

J.H.

Lee

P.K.Y.

Bingham

H.G

. ., Acupuncture anesthesia - A clinical study. Anesth. and Analg. Vol, 55, 508–512, 1976.

13.

Shealy

C.N.

and Maurer

Transcutaneous nerve stimulation for control of pain. Surgery and Neurology Vol. 2, 45–52, 1974.

14.

Andersson

S.A.

and Holmgren

Pain threshold effects of peripheral conditioning stimulation. Advances in Pain Research and Thrapy Vol. 1, 761–768, 1976.

15.

Hymes

A.C.

Raab

D.E.

Yonehyro

E.G.

Nelson

G.D.

and Printy

A.L.

Acute pain control by electrostimulation. Advances in Neurology, Vol. 4, 761–767, 1974.

16.

Long

Use of peripheral and spinal cord stimulation in the relief of chronic pain. Advances in Pain Research and Therapy Vol. 1, 395–403, 1976.

17.

Melzack

, Prolonged relief of pain by brief intense transcutaneous somatic stimulation. Pain Vol. 1, 357–373, 1975.

18.

Ebersold

M.J.

Laws

Stonnington

and Stillwel

Transcutaneous electrical stimulation for treatment of chronic pain: A preliminary report. Surg. Neurol. Vol. 4, 96–100, 1975.

19.

Vanderark

G.D.

and McGrath

K.A.

Transcutaneous electrical stimulation in treatment of postoperative pain. Am. J. Surg. Vol. 130, 338–342, 1975.

20.

Fox

and Melzack

Comparaison of transcutaneous electrical stimulation and acupuncture in treatment of chronic pain. Advances in Pain Research and Therapy Vol. 1, 797–780, 1976.

21.

Laitinen

Acupuncture and transcutaneous electric stimulation for control of pain. Sm. J. of Chinese Med. Vol. 4, 169–172, 1976.

22.

Poentinen

P.J.

Hakkarainen

Ketovuori

and Salmela

Stimulationproduced analgesia in treatment of postoperative low back pain. American Journal of Acupuncture Vol. 7, 61–66, 1979.

23.

Loan

W.B.

and Morrison

J.D.

The incidence and severity of postoperative pain. Brit. J. Anaesth. Vol. 39, 695–699,1967.

24.

Loan

W.B.

and Dundee

J.W.

The clinical assessment of pain. The Practitioner Vol. 198, 759–763, 1967.

25.

Scott

and Huskinsson

E.C.

Graphic representation of pain. Pain Vol. 2, 175–184, 1976.

26.

Essentials of Chinese Acupuncture. Foreign Language Press, Beijing, 1980.