STUDIES ON THE ENHANCED EFFECT OF ACUPUNCTURE ANALGESIA AND ACUPUNCTURE ANESTHESIA BY D-PHENYLALANINE (FIRST REPORT) -- EFFECT ON PAIN THRESHOLD AND INHIBITION BY NALOXONE

Abstract

It has been claimed that the mechanism of acupuncture analgesia can be explained in part by endogenous opioids. If so, it might be possible to enhance the analgesic effect of acupuncture by the administration of endorphins. If D-phenylalanine (DPA), an inhibitor of the endorphin degrading enzyme, is adminstered, the analgesic effect of acupuncture should be prolonged due to the increased level of endorphins.

From the changes of the pain threshold (PT), we investigated whether or not the pre-administrarion of DPA can enhance the analgesic effect of acupuncture in humans. In addition, we examined the inhibitory effect of naloxone.

In all five subjects whose PT was raised after acupuncture anesthesia (respondents), the rise in PT was significantly prolonged by DPA.

Out of 10 subjects whose PT remained almost unchanged after acupuncture anesthesia (non-respondents), the PT was increased by DPA in 5 cases.

The rise in PT was most prominent when DPA was administered 30 minutes before the start of acupuncture anesthesia.

In all 4 respondents in whom the rise in FT persisted after DPA and acupuncture anesthesia, their raised PT dropped after the intravenous injection of naloxone (10 mg).

These findings show that DPA enhances the analgesic effect of acupuncture by the “endorphin mechanism.”

Keywords

D-phenlyalanine Acupuncture Analgesia Acupuncture Anesthesia Pain Threshold Naloxone

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Cheng

Pomeranz

: A Combined Treatment with D-Aminoacids and Electro-acupuncture Produces a Greater Analgesia than either Treatment Alone - Naloxone Reverses These Affects. Pain . Vol. 8: pp 231-236,1980.

2. Ehrenpreis

: An Amino Acid, D-phenylalanine - Shows Promise as a Pain Killer. Chemicalweek . Vol. 123: pp. 47-48,1978.

3. Ehrenpreis

Balagot

Comathy

Myles

: Naloxone Reversible Analgesia in Mice Produced by Inhibitors of Enkephalin Metabolism. Pain Abstracts . Vol. 1 (Second World Congress on Pain (International Association for the Study of Pain, Montreal, Canada, August 27-September 1,1978): p.260,1978.

4. Hachisu

, et.al.: Elimination of Individual Variation by D-phenylalanine in the Effect of Central Grey Matter in the Midbrain (in Japanese). Showa leakukai Zasshi . Vol. 39: 543-550, 1979.

5. Han

Zhang

Tang

Zhou

: Augmentation of Acupuncture Analgesia by Peptidase Inhibitor D-phenylalanine in Rabbits. Acta-Zoologica Clinical . Vol. 27: pp. 133-136,1981.

6. Hosoya

: Substances Enhancing Analgesic Effect of Endogenous Opioids (in Japanese). Pain Clinic . Vol. 3: pp. 89-92,1982.

7. Hyodo

, et. al.: Acupuncture Anesthesia, Especially its Application to Painless Labor, and Pain Threshold (in Japanese). Fuiinka Chiryo . Vol. 31: pp. 401-408,1975.

8. Hyodo

Kitade

Hosoya

: Study on the enhanced Analgesic Effect Induced by Phenylalanine During Acupuncture Analgesia in Humans. Advances in Pain Research and Therapy . Vol. 5: pp. 577-582,1983.

9. Hyodo

: Small Textbook on Anesthesia (in Japanese) . 7th ed., Kinpodo, Kyoto, pp. 225-229,1986.

10.

10. Kitade

Minamikawa

Nawata

Shinohara

Hyodo

and Hosoya

: An Experimental Study on the Enhancing Effects of Phenylalanine on Acupuncture Analgesia. American Journal of Chinese Medicine . Vol. 9:pp, 243-248, 1981.

11.

11. Masayama

: Study of Pain Threshold Under Acupuncture Anesthesia (in Japanese). Masui . Vol. 30, pp. 291-302,1981.

12.

12. Mayer

Price

Barber

Raffi

: Acupuncture Analgesia; Evidence for Activation of a Pain Inhibitory System as a Mechanism of a Pain Inhibitory System as a Mechanism of Action. Advance in Pain Researeh and Therepy . Vol. l:pp. 751-754,1976.

13.

13. Mayer

Price

and Raffi

: Antagonism of Acupuncture Analgesia in Man by the Narcotic Antagonist Naloxone. Brain Res .. Vol. 121: pp. 368-372,1977.

14.

14. Nakahama

Yamamoto

: An improved Radiant Heat Algometer and Its Application to Pain Threshold Measurements in Man. Pain . Vol. 6: pp. 141-148,1979.

15.

15. Oshima

, et al.: Action of D-Phenylalanine on Analgesic Effect of the Percutaneous-Electric Meridian-Point Stimulation Method (in Japanese). Rinsho Masui . Vol. 6: pp. 955-962,1982.

16.

16. Omura

: “Acupuncture and TNS” in the Book Pain -- Basic and Clinical Approach (in Japanese) (edited by Ichioka

Nakahama

Yamamura

). 1st ed., Asakura Shoten, Tokyo, pp, 360-382, 1980.

17.

17. Pomeranz

Ohiu

: Naloxone Blockade of Acupuncture Analgesia: Endorphin Implicate. Life Sei. . Vol. 19, pp. 1757-1762,1976.

18.

18. Takagi

Sato

: Enkephalin. Endorohin and Related Peptides. Enkephalin and Endorphin - Regarding Control of Pain (in Japanese) (edited by Fujimura

Takagi

). 1st Ed. Kodansha, Tokyo, pp. 85-109,1981.

19.

19. Takeshige

Murai

and Hachisu

: Parallel Individual Variation in Effectiveness of Electro-Acupuncture, Morphine Analgesia and Dorsal PAG-SPA and its Abolishment by D-phenylalanine. Acupuncture and Electro-Therapeutics Res. Int. J. . Vol. 5: pp. 251-268, 1980.

20.

20. Takeshige

: Mechanism of Acupuncture Anesthesia (in Japanese). Shinkev-Kenkyu No Shimpo . Vol. 26: pp. 948-965,1982.

21.

21. Tanaka

: Investigation on the Analgesia Enhancing Effect of D-Phenylalanine (in Japanese). Showa Igakukai Zasshi . Vol. 42: pp. 433-440,1982.