The Edinburgh surgeon Benjamin Bell has been regarded as a scientific thinker in the Enlightenment tradition, despite being accused during his lifetime of both plagiarism and a failure to be innovative. Yet subsequent historical accounts regard him much more favourably. A review of his life and work discusses possible explanations for this apparent lack of concordance.
RichardsonBWMartinMS.Disciples of Æsculapius. London: Hutchinson &Co.; 1900.
2.
MilesA.The Edinburgh school of surgery before Lister. London: A&C Black; 1918.
3.
ComrieJD.History of Scottish medicine to 1860. London: Baillière, Tindall &Cox; 1927.
4.
GuthrieD.A history of medicine. Rev. ed. London, New York: Nelson; 1958.
5.
DingwallHM.A history of Scottish medicine: themes and influences. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 2002.
6.
DawpluckerJ.Number second, being remarks on the first volume of Mr. Benjamin Bell’s System of surgery. London: no publisher cited; 1799. p. xxii.
7.
BellB.The life, character and writings of Benjamin Bell, F.R.C.S.E., F.R.S.E. Edinburgh: Edmonston and Douglas; 1868.
8.
BellB.Observations on the mode of attendance of the surgeons of Edinburgh on the Royal Infirmary. In a letter addressed to the Royal College of Surgeons. Edinburgh: A Neill; 1800.
9.
BellJ.Answer for the junior members of the Royal College of Surgeons, of Edinburgh, to the memorial of Dr James Gregory. Edinburgh: Peter Hill; London: Cadell &Davies, Longman &Rees; 1800.
10.
PottP.The chirurgical works of Percivall Pott, F.R.S. and surgeon to St. Bartholomew’s Hospital. London: Hawes, Clarke and Collins; 1775.
11.
KayJ.A series of original portraits and caricatures etchings by the late John Kay. Edinburgh: Hugh Paton; 1837.
12.
Maxwell-IrvingAM.The Border towers of Scotland: their history and architecture – the West March. Blairlogie: AMT Maxwell-Irving; 2000.
13.
BellB.A system of surgery. 7th ed.Edinburgh: Bell and Bradfute; 1801.
14.
HeisterL.A general system of surgery, in three parts. 8th ed. London: J Whiston ; 1768.
15.
StruthersJ.Historical sketch of the Edinburgh Anatomical School. Edinburgh: Maclachlan and Stewart; 1867.
16.
KaufmanMH.The excoriation of Benjamin Bell: who was ‘Jonathan Dawplucker’?J R Coll Physicians Edinb2005; 35:356–64.
17.
BellJ.Letters on professional character and manners: on the education of a surgeon, and the duties and qualifications of a physician: addressed to James Gregory, M.D. Edinburgh: John Moir; 1810.
18.
BellJ.The principles of surgery. Edinburgh: Cadell; 1801.
19.
HawkinsC, editor. The works of Sir Benjamin Collins Brodie. London: Longman; 1865.
20.
McDougallW.Charles Elliot’s medical publications and the international book trade. In: Withers CW, Wood P, editors. Science and medicine in the Scottish Enlightenment. East Linton: Tuckwell Press; 2002.
21.
MooreJC.A method of preventing or diminishing pain in several operations of surgery. London: Cadell; 1784.
22.
PetitJL.Traité des maladies chirurgicales et des opérations qui leur conviennent. Vol. 3. Paris: Didot jeune; 1774.
23.
MynorsR.Practical thoughts on amputations. London: G Robinson; 1783.
24.
AlansonE.Practical observations on amputation and the aftertreatment. 2nd ed.London: Joseph Johnson; 1782.
25.
BellJ.A manual of the operations of surgery: for the use of senior students, house surgeons, and junior practitioners. 5th ed. Edinburgh: Maclachlan &Stewart; 1883.
26.
MonroA.Remarks on the amputations of the larger extremities. In: Medical essays and observations. Edinburgh: Hamilton, Balfour, Neill.
27.
TröhlerU.‘To improve the evidence of medicine’: the 18th century British origins of a critical approach. Edinburgh: Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh; 2000.
28.
BellB.A treatise on the theory and management of ulcers: with a dissertation on white swellings of the joints. Edinburgh: Charles Elliot; 1789.
29.
SharpS.A treatise on the operations of surgery, with a description and representation of the instruments used in performing them, to which is prefix’d an introduction on the nature and treatment of wounds, abscesses and ulcers. London: J Watts; 1739.
30.
BellB.A treatise on gonorrhoea virulenta, and lues venerea. Edinburgh: James Watson and Co.; 1793.
31.
PalmerJF, editor. The works of John Hunter, with notes. London: Longmans; 1835.
32.
MooreW.The knife man. London: Bantam Press; 2005.
33.
RicordP.Traité pratique des maladies vénériennes, ou recherches critiques et expérimentales sur l’inoculation appliquée à l’étude de ces maladies. Paris: Rouvier and Le Bouvier; 1838.
34.
BellB.A treatise on the hydrocele, on sarcocele, or cancer, and other diseases of the testis. London: GG and J Robinson; 1794.
35.
BellB.Essays on agriculture, with a plan for the speedy and general improvement of land in Great Britain. Edinburgh: Bell &Bradfute; 1802.
36.
CooperS.A dictionary of practical surgery. 3rd ed.London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme and Brown; 1820.
37.
GordonA.A treatise on the epidemic puerperal fever of Aberdeen. London: GG and J Robinson; 1795.
