Arthur Hurst was a British First World War physician, best known for his films of shell shock, ‘War Neuroses'. He has often been portrayed an innovative pioneer of somewhat mysterious ‘suggestion’ techniques for functional motor disorders but also as an ambitious clinician who exaggerated the effectiveness of his treatments and failed to address psychological factors. His use of suggestion, persuasion and re-education together with occupational therapy, for chronic or severe cases of shell shock stirred controversy at the time because of the dramatic nature of some of his treatment responses and lack of outcome data. In part, this was a turf war between neurologists and psychiatrists for a dominant therapeutic model. A re-evaluation of his publications and new research into soldiers treated at Seale Hayne in Devon show that Hurst pioneered multidisciplinary and empathetic treatments for functional motor disorders with good short-term outcomes, though insufficient data survives to assess longer term outcomes.
NielsenG, StoneJ, MatthewsA. Physiotherapy for functional motor disorders: a consensus statement. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry2015; 86 (10), 1113–1119.
3.
NielsenG, BuszewiczM, StevensonF. Randomised feasibility study of physiotherapy for patients with functional motor symptoms. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry2017; 88(6), 484–90.
4.
EspayAJ, AybekA, CarsonA. Current Concepts in Diagnosis and Treatment of Functional Neurological Disorders. JAMA Neurol. 2018; 75(9), 1132.
5.
Anonymous. Fourth Annual Report of the Medical Research Committee 1917-1918. HMSO, London, 1918; 63, The National Archives (TNA), FD2/4.
6.
PowellJM. Shock troupe: medical film and the performance of ‘shell shock’ for the British nation at war. Soc. Hist. Med. 2017; 30, 323–345, 333.
7.
JonesE. War Neuroses and Arthur Hurst: a pioneering medical film about the treatment of psychiatric battle casualties. J. Hist. Med. Allied Sci. 2012; 67, 345-373, 365–368.
HurstAF.. Medical Diseases of War Edward Arnold, London, 1944;41–42.
12.
HurstAF. Cinematograph demonstration of war neuroses. Proc. R. Soc. Med. 1918; 11, 39–42, 40.
13.
HurstAF.. A Twentieth Century Physician, Being the Reminiscences of Sir Arthur Hurst. Edward Arnold, London, 1949;120.
14.
HurstA. War neuroses. Br. Med. J 1 1943;299.
15.
JohnsonW, RowsRG.. Neurasthenia and war neuroses. In MacPherson WG, Herringham WP, Elliott TR, Balfour A, (eds), Medical Services: diseases of the war, HMSO, London, 1923; 2–67, 36, 35.
16.
DeeleyQ.. Hypnosis as therapy for functional neurologic disorders. In Hallett M, Stone J and Carson A, (eds), Handbook of Clinical Neurology, Volume 139, Functional Neurological Disorders, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2016; 585–95, 588–89.
17.
BabinskiJ.. Définition de l'hystérie, Revue Neurologique 9 1901;1074–1080.
18.
HurstAF.. A Twentieth Century Physician, Being the Reminiscences of Sir Arthur Hurst, Edward Arnold, London, 1949;103.
19.
ThomasGM.. Treating the Trauma of the Great War, Soldiers, Civilians and Psychiatry in France, 1914–1940. University of Louisiana, Baton Rouge, 2009; 27, 38.
20.
BabinskiJ, FromentJ.. Hysteria or Pithiatism and Reflex Nervous Disorders in the Neurology of War [1917] Translated by J.D. Rolleston, University of London Press, London, 1918.
21.
HurstAF.. Medical Diseases of War, Edward Arnold, London, 1940;16.
22.
LeeRupert, the ‘'war strained'’ artist inspired at Seale-Hayne Military Hospital to help others, a descriptive panel at the Seale Hayne Centenary Exhibition, provided by Raymond Bartlett.
23.
JonesE. ‘An atmosphere of cure': Frederick Mott, shell shock and the Maudsley. Hist. Psychiatry2014; 25, 412–21.
24.
GordonRG. The mental factor in the neuroses of war. Seale Hayne Neurological Studies1918; 1(2), 81–87, 82.
25.
HallJB.. Nervous mimicry of disease, A visit to Seale Hayne Hospital, Newton Abbott, War Pensions Gazette1918; 17, 218.
26.
LondonWS.. Seale Hayne Military Hospital, The wonders of neurology, War Pensions Gazette1919; 27, 335–36, 335.
27.
HurstAH, SymnsJLM.. The Rapid Cure of Hysterical Symptoms in Soldiers, Lancet, 1918; 192 (4953), 139–141, 140.
28.
JonesE.. Filming Trauma, The Psychologist, 2015, 28 (5), 424–426.
29.
HurstAF.. Royal Society of Medicine, Section of Neurology, Lancet1918; 191 (4934); 437–439, 439.
30.
HurstAF, SymnsJLM.. The treatment of war neuroses, Lancet1918; 192 (4958), 341–42, 341.
31.
HurstAF.. A Twentieth Century Physician, Being the Reminiscences of Sir Arthur Hurst, Edward Arnold, London, 1949; 152
32.
MyersCS.. Shell Shock in France 1914–18, Based on a War Diary, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1940;122–127.
33.
LumsdenT. Treatment of war neuroses. Lancet1918; 192 (4955), 219.
34.
WrightMB.. Treatment of psychological casualties during war, Br. Med. J 2, 1939; 615–617, 615.
35.
TippetJA.. Psychological casualties in war, Br. Med. J 2 1939; (4109), 742.
36.
JonesE.. War Neuroses and Arthur Hurst: a pioneering medical film about the treatment of psychiatric battle casualties, J. Hist. Med. Allied Sci. 2012; 67, 345–373, 365.
37.
HurstAF, SymnsJLM.. The rapid cure of hysterical symptoms in soldiers, Seale Hayne Neurological Studies, 1918; 1(1), 27–42, 34.
38.
HurstAF.. Medical Diseases of War, Edward Arnold, London, 1944;6–7.
39.
Personal communication from Raymond Bartlett and Tim Whiteaway, 14 June 2018.
40.
McDougallW.. An Outline of Abnormal Psychology, Methuen, London, 1926;289–292.
41.
HurstAF. A case note of Percy Meek, 1918, Devon Record Office, 1262M/OLD/113/68.
HurstAF, SymnsJLM.. The rapid cure of hysterical symptoms in soldiers, Seale Hayne Neurological Studies1918; 1(1), 27–42, 37.
44.
War pension file for Private George Chamberlain, Hurst AF, Medical Board, 1 February 1919; TNA, PIN26/2639.
45.
Sapper Wilson May, War Pension file for hysterical vomiting, TNA, PIN26/9691.
46.
GordonRG.. The after-treatment of war neuroses with special consideration of the question of pensions, Seale Hayne Neurological Studies1920; 6, 308–12, 309.
47.
CohenD.. The War come home, Disabled veterans in Britain and Germany, 1914–1939, University of California Press, Berkeley, 2001;29–44.
48.
Interview of Dr J. MacGregor by Ben Shephard, 14 July 1990, quoted in B. Shephard, ‘Pitiless Psychology': the role of prevention in British military psychiatry in the Second World War. Hist. Psychiatry 1999; 10, 491–542, 459.
49.
MottFW.. The effects of high explosives upon the central nervous system, Lancet, 1916; 187 (4824), 331–38, 331.
50.
LindenS.. Jones E, Lees A, Shell shock at Queen's Square: Lewis Yealland a hundred years on, Brain, 2013; 136 (6), 1976–1988.
51.
YeallandLR.. Hysterical Disorders of Warfare, Macmillan, London, 1918;3.
52.
MyersCS.. The justifiability of therapeutic lying, Lancet1919; 194 (5026), 1213–1214.
53.
JonesE, WesselyS.. Battle for the Mind: The First World War and the birth of military psychiatry, Lancet2014; 384 (9955), 1708–14, 1711.
54.
Anonymous. British Medical Association: special clinical meeting, section of medicine, War neuroses, Lancet, 1919; 193 (4991), 709–11, 711.
55.
Crichton MillerH.. War Neuroses, Lancet1919; 193 (4992)766.
56.
FairbairnWRD.. War neuroses: their nature and significance, Br. Med. J 1 1943; (4284), 183–86.
57.
HurstA.. War Neuroses, Br. Med. J 1 1943; (4287), 299.
58.
HurstA.. War Neuroses, Br. Med. J 1 1943; (4292), 459.
59.
JonesE.. ‘'LMF'': the use of psychiatric stigma in the Royal Air Force during the Second World War, J Milit. Hist., 2006; 70, 439–58.
60.
HurstAF.. Medical Diseases of War, Edward Arnold, London, 1944;75.
61.
NicholsonC.. Edwards MJ, Carson AJ, et al. Occupational therapy consensus recommendations for functional neurological disorder, J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry2020. doi/10.1136/jnnp-2019-322281
