Are Rumination and Worry Two Sides of the Same Coin? A Structural Equation Modelling Approach

Abstract

Worry and rumination are two types of Repetitive Negative Thinking (RNT) that have been shown to be related to the development and maintenance of emotional problems. Whereas these two forms of RNT have traditionally been regarded as distinct and differentially related to psychopathology, researchers have recently argued that worry and rumination share the same process and show a very similar relationship to different forms of psychopathology. In a series of three studies, we employed a structural equation modelling approach to compare these competing hypotheses. Results showed that a bi-factor model (representing RNT by one latent factor with two uncorrelated method factors) provided a better fit to the data than a two-factor model (with worry and rumination represented by separate factors). In addition, the shared variance within the bi-factor model fully accounted for changes in symptom levels of depression and anxiety in two prospective studies. These findings support a transdiagnostic account of RNT. Implications for theory, measurement and clinical practice are discussed.

Keywords

Repetitive Negative Thinking Worry Rumination Transdiagnostic Structural Equation Modelling

References

Abouserie

(1994). Sources and levels of stress in relation to locus of control and self- esteem in university students. Educational Psychology, 14, 323–330. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/0144341940140306

Baer

R. A.

, Peters

J. R.

, Eisenlohr-Moul

T. A.

, Geiger

P. J.

, & Sauer

S. E.

(2012). Emotion-related cognitive processes in borderline personality disorder: A review of the empirical literature. Clinical Psychology Review, 32, 359–369. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.cpr.2012.03.002

Beck

A. T.

, Brown

, Steer

R. A.

, Eidelson

J. I.

, & Riskind

J. H.

(1987). Differentiating anxiety and depression: A test of the cognitive content-specificity hypothesis. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 96, 179. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0021-843X.96.3.179

Bollen

K. A.

, & Long

J. S.

(Eds.) (1993). Testing structural equation models. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Borkovec

T. D.

(1994). The nature, functions, and origins of worry. In Davey

G. C. L.

, & Tallis

(Eds.), Worrying: Perspectives in theory, assessment and treatment (pp. 5–33). England: John Wiley and Sons.

Borkovec

T. D.

, & Hu

(1990). The effect of worry on cardiovascular response to phobic imagery. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 28(1), 69–73. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/0005-7967(90)90056-O

Borkovec

T. D.

, Robinson

, Pruzinsky

, & Depree

J. A.

(1983). Preliminary exploration of worry - some characteristics and processes. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 21, 9–16. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/0005-7967(83)90121-3

Borkovec

T. D.

, Ray

W. J.

, & Stöber

(1998). Worry: A cognitive phenomenon intimately linked to affective, physiological, and interpersonal behavioral processes. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 22, 561–576. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1018790003416

Borsboom

, & Mellenbergh

G. J.

(2002). True scores, latent variables, and constructs: A comment on Schmidt and Hunter. Intelligence, 30, 505–514. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/S0160-2896(02)00082-X

10.

Brinker

J. K.

, & Dozois

D. J.

(2009). Ruminative thought style and depressed mood. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 65, 1–19. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1002/jclp.20542

11.

Brown

T. A.

(2003). Confirmatory factor analysis of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire: Multiple factors or method effects? Behaviour Research and Therapy, 41(12), 1411–1426. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/S0005-7967(03)00059-7

12.

Burns

D. D.

, & Eidelson

R. J.

(1998). Why are depression and anxiety correlated? A test of the tripartite model. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 66, 461. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0022-006X.66.3.461

13.

Byrne

B. M.

, Shavelson

R. J.

, & Muthén

(1989). Testing for the equivalence of factor covariance and mean structures: The issue of partial measurement invariance. Psychological Bulletin, 105, 456. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0033-2909.105.3.456

14.

Calmes

C. A.

, & Roberts

J. E.

(2007). Repetitive thought and emotional distress: Rumination and worry as prospective predictors of depressive and anxious symptomatology. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 31, 343–356. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-006-9026-9

15.

Carney

C. E.

, Harris

A. L.

, Moss

T. G.

, & Edinger

J. D.

(2010). Distinguishing rumination from worry in clinical insomnia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 48, 540–546. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.brat.2010.03.004

16.

Ciesla

J. A.

, Dickson

K. S.

, Anderson

N. L.

, & Neal

D. J.

(2011). Negative repetitive thought and college drinking: Angry rumination, depressive rumination, co-rumination, and worry. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 35, 142–150. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-011-9355-1

17.

De Beurs

, den Hollander-Gijsman

, Helmich

, & Zitman

(2007). The tripartite model for assessing symptoms of anxiety and depression: Psychometrics of the Dutch version of the mood and anxiety symptoms questionnaire. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 45, 1609–1617. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.brat.2006.07.004

18.

D'Hudson

, & Saling

L. L.

(2010). Worry and rumination in older adults: Differentiating the processes. Aging & Mental Health, 14, 524–534. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/13607861003713141

19.

Dickson

K. S.

, Ciesla

J. A.

, & Reilly

L. C.

(2012). Rumination, worry, cognitive avoidance, and behavioral avoidance: examination of temporal effects. Behavior therapy, 43(3), 629–640. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.beth.2011.11.002

20.

Dolan

C. V.

(1994). Factor analysis of variables with 2, 3, 5 and 7 response categories: A comparison of categorical variable estimators using simulated data. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 47, 309–326. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1111/j.2044-8317.1994.tb01039.x

21.

Ehring

, Zetsche

, Weidacker

, Wahl

, Schönfeld

, & Ehlers

(2011). The Perseverative Thinking Questionnaire (PTQ): Validation of a content-independent measure of repetitive negative thinking. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 42, 225–232. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.jbtep.2010.12.003

22.

Ehring

, & Watkins

E. R.

(2008). Repetitive negative thinking as a transdiagnostic process. International Journal of Cognitive Therapy, 1, 192–205. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1521/ijct.2008.1.3.192

23.

Finlay-Jones

, & Brown

G. W.

(1981). Types of stressful life event and the onset of anxiety and depressive disorders. Psychological Medicine, 11, 803–815. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1017/S0033291700041301

24.

Fresco

D. M.

, Frankel

A. N.

, Mennin

D. S.

, Turk

C. L.

, & Heimberg

R. G.

(2002). Distinct and overlapping features of rumination and worry: The relationship of cognitive production to negative affective states. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 26, 179–188. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1014517718949

25.

Goring

H. J.

, & Papageorgiou

(2008). Rumination and worry: Factor analysis of self-report measures in depressed participants. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 32, 554–566. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-007-9146-x

26.

Harvey

A. G.

, Watkins

, Mansell

, & Shafran

(2004). Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

27.

Hazlett-Stevens

, Ullman

, & Craske

M. G.

(2004). Factor structure of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire - examination of a method factor. Assessment, 11, 361–370. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1177/1073191104269872

28.

Hirsch

C. R.

, & Mathews

(2012). A cognitive model of pathological worry. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 50, 636–646. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.brat.2012.06.007

29.

Hong

R. Y.

(2007). Worry and rumination: Differential associations with anxious and depressive symptoms and coping behavior. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 45, 277–290. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.brat.2006.03.006

30.

Horn

J. L.

, & McArdle

J. J.

(1992). A practical and theoretical guide to measurement invariance in aging research. Experimental Aging Research, 18, 117–144. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/03610739208253916

31.

Hoyer

, Gloster

A. T.

, & Herzberg

P. Y.

(2009). Is worry different from rumination? Yes, it is more predictive of psychopathology! Psycho-Social-Medicine, 6, 1–9. doi: 10.3205/psm000062

32.

, & Bentler

P. M.

(1999). Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 6, 1–55. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/10705519909540118

33.

Joormann

(2010). Cognitive inhibition and emotion regulation in depression. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 19, 161–166. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1177/0963721410370293

34.

Kendall

P. C.

, & Ingram

R. E.

(1989). Cognitive-behavioral perspectives: Theory and research on depression and anxiety. In Kendall

, & Watson

(Eds.), Anxiety and depression: Distinctive and overlapping features. (pp. 27–53). Orlando, FL: Academic Press.

35.

Leventhal

A. M.

, Ameringer

K. J.

, Osborn

, Zvolensky

M. J.

, & Langdon

K. J.

(2013). Anxiety and depressive symptoms and affective patterns of tobacco withdrawal. Drug and Alcohol Dependence. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2013.06.015

36.

McEvoy

P. M.

, & Brans

(2013). Common versus unique variance across measures of worry and rumination: Predictive utility and mediational models for anxiety and depression. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 37, 183–196. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-012-9448-5

37.

McEvoy

P. M.

, Mahoney

A. E.

, & Moulds

M. L.

(2010). Are worry, rumination, and post-event processing one and the same: Development of the Repetitive Thinking Questionnaire. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 24, 509–519. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.janxdis.2010.03.008

38.

McLaughlin

K. A.

, Borkovec

T. D.

, & Sibrava

N. J.

(2007). The effects of worry and rumination on affect states and cognitive activity. Behavior Therapy, 38, 23–38. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.beth.2006.03.003

39.

Mellenbergh

G. J.

(1994). A unidimensional latent trait model for continuous item responses. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 29, 223–236. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1207/s15327906mbr2903_2

40.

Meredith

(1993). Measurement invariance, factor analysis and factorial invariance. Psychometrika, 58, 525–543. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/BF02294825

41.

Meyer

T. J.

, Miller

M. L.

, Metzger

R. L.

, & Borkovec

T. D.

(1990). Development and validation of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 28, 487–495. doi: 10.1016/0005-7967

42.

Mitchell

, Mogg

, & Bradley

B. P.

(2012). Relationships between insomnia, negative emotionality and attention control. Sleep and Biological Rhythms, 10, 237–243. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1111/j.1479-8425.2012.00567.x

43.

Muris

, Roelofs

, Meesters

, & Boomsma

(2004). Rumination and worry in nonclinical adolescents. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 28, 539–554. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/B: COTR.0000045563.66060.3e

44.

Muris

, Roelofs

, Rassin

, Franken

, & Mayer

(2005). Mediating effects of rumination and worry on the links between neuroticism, anxiety and depression. Personality and Individual Differences, 39, 1105–1111. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.paid.2005.04.005

45.

Muthén

L. K.

, & Muthén

B. O.

(2007). Mplus user's guide (5th ed.). Los Angeles: Muthén & Muthén.

46.

Nolen-Hoeksema

(2004). The response styles theory. In Papageorgiou

, & Wells

(Eds.), Depressive rumination: Nature, theory and treatment (pp. 107–123). Chichester, UK: Wiley.

47.

Nolen-Hoeksema

, Wisco

B. E.

, & Lyubomirsky

(2008). Rethinking rumination. Perspectives on psychological science, 3(5), 400–424. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1111/j.1745-6924.2008.00088.x

48.

Nolen-Hoeksema

, & Morrow

(1991). A prospective study of depression and distress following a natural disaster: The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 61, 105–121. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0022-3514.61.1.115

49.

Nolen-Hoeksema

, & Watkins

E. R.

(2011). A heuristic for developing transdiagnostic models of psychopathology explaining multifinality and divergent trajectories. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 6, 589–609. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1177/1745691611419672

50.

Nolen-Hoeksema

, Stice

, Wade

, & Bohon

(2007). Reciprocal relations between rumination and bulimic, substance abuse, and depressive symptoms in female adolescents. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 116, 198–207. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0021-843X.116.1.198

51.

Papageorgiou

, & Wells

(2003). An empirical test of a clinical metacognitive model of rumination and depression. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 27, 261–273. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1023962332399

52.

Papageorgiou

, & Wells

(1999). Process and meta-cognitive dimensions of depressive and anxious thoughts and relationships with emotional intensity. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 6, 156–162. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1099–0879(199905)

53.

Raes

(2011). The effect of self-compassion on the development of depression symptoms in a non-clinical sample. Mindfulness, 2, 33–36. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s12671-011-0040-y

54.

Roach

A. R.

, Salt

C. E.

, & Segerstrom

S. C.

(2010). Generalizability of repetitive thought: Examining stability in thought content and process. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 34, 144–158. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-009-9232-3

55.

Rood

, Roelofs

, Bögels

S. M.

, & Alloy

L. B.

(2010). Dimensions of negative thinking and the relations with symptoms of depression and anxiety in children and adolescents. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 34, 333–342. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10608-009-9261-y

56.

Samejima

(1969). Estimation of latent ability using a response pattern of graded scores. Psychometrika Monograph Supplement, 17, (4, Pt.2).

57.

Satorra

, & Bentler

P. M.

(2001). A scaled difference chi-square test statistic for moment structure analysis. Psychometrika, 66, 507–514. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/BF02296192

58.

Schermelleh-Engel

, Moosbrugger

, & Müller

(2003). Evaluating the fit of structural equation models: Tests of significance and descriptive goodness-of-fit measures. Methods of Psychological Research Online, 8, 23–74.

59.

Schoofs

, Hermans

, & Raes

(2010). Brooding and reflection as subtypes of rumination: Evidence from confirmatory factor analysis in nonclinical samples using the Dutch Ruminative Response Scale. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 32, 609–617. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/s10862-010-9182-9

60.

Segerstrom

S. C.

, Tsao

J. C.

, Alden

L. E.

, & Craske

M. G.

(2000). Worry and rumination: Repetitive thought as a concomitant and predictor of negative mood. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 24, 671–688. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1005587311498

61.

Spinhoven

, Bamelis

, Molendijk

, Haringsma

, & Arntz

(2009). Reduced specificity of autobiographical memory in cluster C personality disorders and the role of depression, worry, and experiential avoidance. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 118, 520. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/a0016393

62.

Steiger

J. H.

, Shapiro

, & Browne

M. W.

(1985). On the multivariate asymptotic distribution of sequential chi-square statistics. Psychometrika, 50, 253–263. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/BF02294104

63.

Stöber

, Tepperwien

, & Staak

(2000). Worrying leads to reduced concreteness of problem elaborations: Evidence for the avoidance theory of worry. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, 13, 217–227. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/10615800008415725

64.

Szabó

, & Lovibond

P. F.

(2002). The cognitive content of naturally occurring worry episodes. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 26, 167–177. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1014565602111

65.

Topper

, Emmelkamp

P. M. G.

, & Ehring

(2010). Improving prevention of depression and anxiety disorders: Repetitive negative thinking as a promising target. Applied & Preventive Psychology, 14, 57–71. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.appsy.2012.03.001

66.

Treynor

, Gonzalez

, & Nolen-Hoeksema

(2003). Rumination reconsidered: A psychometric analysis. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 27, 247–259. doi: 10.1023/A: 1023910315561https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1023/A:1023910315561

67.

Van der Linden

W.J.

, Hambleton

R.K.

(1996). Handbook of Modern Item Response Theory. New York: Springer.

68.

Van Rijsoort

, Emmelkamp

, & Vervaeke

(1999). The penn state worry questionnaire and the worry domains questionnaire: Structure, reliability and validity. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 6(4), 297–307. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1002/(SICI)1099-0879(199910)6:4<297::AID-CPP206>3.0.CO;2-E

69.

Verstraeten

, Bijttebier

, Vasey

M. W.

, & Raes

(2011). Specificity of worry and rumination in the development of anxiety and depressive symptoms in children. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 50, 364–378. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1348/014466510X532715

70.

Wardenaar

K. J.

, van Veen

, Giltay

E. J.

, de Beurs

, Penninx

B. W.

, & Zitman

F. G.

(2010). Development and validation of a 30-item short adaptation of the mood and anxiety symptoms questionnaire (MASQ). Psychiatry Research, 179, 101–106. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.psychres.2009.03.005

71.

Watkins

(2004). Appraisals and strategies associated with rumination and worry. Personality and Individual Differences, 37, 679–694. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.paid.2003.10.002

72.

Watkins

E. R.

(2008). Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought. Psychological Bulletin, 134, 163–206. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0033-2909.134.2.163

73.

Watkins

, Moulds

, & Mackintosh

(2005). Comparisons between rumination and worry in a non-clinical population. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 43, 1577–1585. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.brat.2004.11.008

74.

Watkins

, & Teasdale

J. D.

(2001). Rumination and overgeneral memory in depression: effects of self-focus and analytic thinking. Journal of abnormal psychology, 110, 353. doi: 10.1037//0021-843X.110.2.353

75.

Watson

, Weber

, Assenheimer

J. S.

, Clark

L. A.

, Strauss

M. E.

, & McCormick

R. A.

(1995). Testing a tripartite model: I. evaluating the convergent and discriminant validity of anxiety and depression symptom scales. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 104, 3–14. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/0021-843X.104.1.3

76.

Westland

C.J.

(2010). Lower bounds on sample size in structural equation modeling. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications, 9, 476–487. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.elerap.2010.07.003

77.

Wicherts

J. M.

, Dolan

C. V.

, Hessen

D. J.

, Oosterveld

, Van Baal

, Caroline

, Boomsma

D. I.

, & Span

M. M.

(2004). Are intelligence tests measurement invariant over time? investigating the nature of the Flynn effect. Intelligence, 32, 509–537. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.intell.2004.07.002

78.

Wirth

, & Edwards

M. C.

(2007). Item factor analysis: Current approaches and future directions. Psychological Methods, 12, 58–79. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1037/1082-989X.12.1.58

79.

Yook

, Kim

, Suh

S. Y.

, & Lee

K. S.

(2010). Intolerance of uncertainty, worry, and rumination in major depressive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 24, 623–628. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.janxdis.2010.04.003

80.

Yung

, Thissen

, & McLeod

L. D.

(1999). On the relationship between the higher-order factor model and the hierarchical factor model. Psychometrika, 64, 113–128. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/BF02294531