Are We All Europeans Now? Local,National and Supranational Identities of Young Adults

Abstract

The continued expansion and deepening of the European Union state raises important questions about whether there will be a corresponding development of pro-supranational feeling towards Europe. This paper is based on data drawn from a European Commission (EC) funded project on the ‘Orientations of Young Men and Women to Citizenship and European Identity’. The project includes comparative surveys of ‘representative samples’ of young men and women aged 18-24 and samples of this age group on educational routes that potentially orient them to Europe beyond their national boundaries. This comparison of samples is made in paired sites with contrasting cultural and socio-political histories in terms of European affiliations and support for the European Union. The sites are: Vienna and Vorarlberg in Austria; Chemnitz and Bielefeld in East and West Germany; Madrid and Bilbao in Spain; Prague and Bratislava, the capitals of the Czech and Slovak Republics; Manchester, England and Edinburgh, Scotland in the UK. This paper examines patterns of local, national and supranational identity in the British samples in comparison to the other European sites. The typical respondent from Edinburgh and Manchester have very different orientations to their nation-state but they share a lack of European identity and disinterest in European issues that was matched only by residents of Bilbao. International comparision further demonstrates that a general correlation between levels of identification with nation-state and Europe masks a range of orientations to nation, state and Europe nurtured by a variety of geo-political contexts.

Keywords

Europe European Nation Citizen Identity Young Adult

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barth

(1969) Ethnic Groups and Boundaries. Boston: Little Brown and Co.

Bechhofer

, McCrone

, Kiely

, and Stewart

(1999) Constructing National Identity: Arts and Landed Elites in Scotland. Sociology, 33(3): 515–34.

Billig

(1995) Banal Nationalism London: Sage.

Bynner

, Chisholm

, and Furlong

(eds.) (1997) Youth, Citizenship and Social Change in Europe. Aldershot: Ashgate.

Chisholm

, Buchner

, Kruger

H.H.

(1995). Growing up in Europe. Walter de Gruyter.

Cohen

(1994). Frontiers of identity: The British and Others. London: Longman.

Condor

(1996). Unimagined community? Some social psychological aspects of English national identity In Breakwell

, and Lyons

(eds) Changing European Identities. Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.

Condor

(2000) Pride and prejudice: Identity management in English people's talk about ‘this country’ Discourse and Society, 11, 163–193.

Della Cava

M. R.

(2003). Ugly Sentiments Sting American Tourists. USA Today.com, http://www.USAToday.com 2003.

10.

Delanty

(2000). Citizenship in a Global Age: Society. Culture and Politics. Buckingham, Open University Press.

11.

Fuss

; Garcia-Albacete

, and Rodriguez-Monter

(2004) ‘The Role of Language Skills and Foreign Country Experiences in the Development of European Identity’ Sociológia, 53(3), 273–292.

12.

Grad

; Ros

; Garcia-Albacete

; Rodríguez-Monter

(2004) ‘The Meaning and Importance of European Identity and Its Relationship to Regional and National Identities in Spain: Some contributing factors to the development of European identity’ Sociológia, 53(3), 219–236.

13.

Habermas

(1998). The Inclusion of Others: Studies in Political Theory Cambridge, Mass., the MIT Press.

14.

Iacovou

(1998). Young People in Europe: Two Models of Household Formation. Institute of Social and Economic Research Working Paper. University of Essex.

15.

Jamieson

(2002). Theorizing Identity, Nationality and Citizenship: Implications for European Citizenship Identity. SOCIOLOGIA, 34.6

16.

Jamieson

(2005). ‘Orientations of Young Men and Women to Citizenship and European Identity’ Final Report to European Commission, Contract no HPSE-CT-2001-00077, Project no SERD-2000-00260.

17.

Kiely

, McCrone

, Bechhofer

, and Stewart

(2000). ‘Debatable Land: National and Local Identity in a Border Town. Sociological Research Online, 5. http://www.socresonline.org.uk/5/2/kiely.html

18.

Kiely

, Bechhofer

, Stewart

, and McCrone

(2001). The markers and rules of Scottish national identity. Sociological Review 33–55.

19.

Macdonald

(1993) Identity Complexes in Western Europe: Social Anthropological Perspectives. Inside European Identities. S. Macdonald (ed). Oxford, Berg: 1–26.

20.

Mccrone

(2000). The Sociology of Nationalism. London: Routledge.

21.

Mccrone

(2002) ‘Who do you say you are?’ Making sense of national identities in modern Britain. Ethnicities, 2, 301–320.

22.

Mccrone

, and Kiely

(2000) Nationalism and Citizenship. Sociology 34(1): 19–34.

23.

Nagel

, & Wallace

(1997). Structure and Agency: participation and risk for young people in European societies. In Bynner et al. (eds.)

24.

Osler

, and Starkey

(2002). Young People, Citizenship and Identity. Keele University, ESRC Conference on Youth Citizenship and Social Change.

25.

Paterson

, Brown

, Curtice

, Hinds

, McCrone

, Park

, Sproston

, and Surridge

(2001). New Scotland, New Politics? Edinburgh, Polygon.

26.

Pickering

(2001). Stereotyping: The Politics of Representation. Hampshire, Palgrave.

27.

Saeed

, Blain

(1999) New Ethnic and National Questions in Scotland: post-British Identities Among Glasgow Pakistani Teenagers. Ethnic and Racial Studies 22(5): 821–844.

28.

Smith

A.D.

(1995). Nations and Nationalism in a Global Era Cambridge, Polity Press.

29.

Werbner

, & Yuval-Davis

(1999). Women and the New Discourse of Citizenship. In: Werbner

, and Yuval-Davis

(eds.) Women, Citizenship and Difference. Zed Books, London.

30.

Worcester

(2002). Young People and Citizenship. London, ATL Conference. http://www.mori.com/pubinfo/social.shtml