Standpoint,Objectivity,and Social Construction: Reflections from the Study of Gay and Lesbian Communities

Abstract

This article considers a number of related concepts – standpoint, objectivity, emancipation – in the light of my own research which looked at gay and lesbian communities in the north-west of England. It advocates and promotes the use of gay and lesbian standpoint and defends research with emancipatory aims, notably in the light of academic and theoretical developments which eschew real-life experience and categories of identity rooted in lived actuality. Suggesting that queer theory is largely irrelevant to the lives of gay men and lesbians, it advocates a return to an engaged and practical sociology which acknowledges the benefit of research which has potential for application by the communities it observes.

Keywords

Standpoint Gay Lesbian Queer Essentialism Social Construction Realism Emancipation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altman

(1989). Which Homosexuality? (London, GMP)

Bamforth

(1997). Sexuality, Morals and Justice (London, Cassell)

Bates

(2004). A Church at War (London, I. B. Tauris)

Bell

(1993). Communitarianism and its Critics (Oxford, Oxford University Press)

Butler

(1997). Excitable Speech (London, Routledge)

Conerly

(2000). ‘Are you Black First or are you Queer?’ in Constantine-Simms

(ed.) The Greatest Taboo (Los Angeles, Alyson)

Dunne

(1997). Lesbian Lifestyles (Basingstoke, Macmillan)

Finch

(1984). ‘“It's Great to Have Someone to Talk to”: the Ethics and Politics of Interviewing Women’ in Hammersley

(ed.) (1993) Social Research (London, Sage)

Green

S.F.

(1997). Urban Amazons (Basingstoke, Macmillan)

10.

Greenberg

(1988). The Construction of Homosexuality (Chicago, University of Chicago Press)

11.

Hammersley

(ed.) (1993). Social Research (London, Sage)

12.

Hammersley

(1995). The Politics of Social Research (London, Sage)

13.

Hammersley

(2000). Taking Sides in Social Research (London, Routledge)

14.

Hammersley

, and Gomm

(1997). ‘A Response to Romm’, Sociological Research Online, 2.4, <http://www.socresonline.org.uk/2/4/7.html>

15.

Hartsock

(1998). The Feminist Standpoint Revisited and Other Essays (CO, Westview Press)

16.

Herman

(1994). Rights of Passage (Toronto, University of Toronto Press)

17.

Herman

(1997). The Antigay Agenda (Chicago, University of Chicago Press)

18.

Homfray

(2007). Provincial Queens: the gay and lesbian community in the north-west of England (Oxford, Peter Lang)

19.

Humphries

(2000) ‘From Critical Thought to Emancipatory Action’ in Truman

, Mertens

, and Humphries

(eds) Research and Inequality (London, Routledge)

20.

Iganski

(ed.) (2002). The Hate Debate (London, Profile Books)

21.

Jacobs

, and Potter

(1998). Hate Crimes (Oxford, Oxford University Press)

22.

Jeffreys

(2002). Unpacking Queer Politics (Cambridge, Polity Press)

23.

Jenness

, and Grattet

(2001). Making Hate a Crime (New York, Russell Sage Foundation)

24.

Kirsch

(2001). Queer Theory and Social Change (London, Routledge)

25.

Lucas

(1998). Outrage!: An Oral History (London, Cassell)

26.

Mcintosh

(1981). ‘The Homosexual Role’ in Plummer

(ed.) The Making of the Modern Homosexual (London, Routledge and Kegan Paul)

27.

Mcintosh

(1997). ‘Seeing the World from a Lesbian and Gay Standpoint’ in Segal

(ed.) New Sexual Agendas (Basingstoke, Macmillan)

28.

Norton

(1997). The Myth of the Modern Homosexual (London, Cassell)

29.

Plummer

(1998) ‘Afterword’ in Nardi

, and Schneider

(eds) Social Perspectives in Lesbian and Gay Studies: A Reader (London, Routledge)

30.

Renzetti

, and Lee

(ed.) (1993). Researching Sensitive Topics (London, Sage)

31.

Sedgwick

E.K.

(1990). Epistemology of the Closet (Harmondsworth, Penguin)

32.

Song

, and Parker

(1995). ‘Commonality, Difference and the Dynamics of Disclosure in In-Depth interviewing’, Sociology, 29.2: 241–56

33.

Spargo

(1999). Foucault and Queer Theory (Cambridge, Icon Books)

34.

Stanley

, and Wise

(1983). Breaking Out: Feminist Consciousness and Feminist Research (London, Routledge)

35.

Stanley

, and Wise

(1993). Breaking Out Again (London, Routledge)

36.

Truman

(2000) ‘New Social Movements and Social Research’ in Truman

, Mertens

, and Humphries

(eds) Research and Inequality (London, UCL Press)

37.

Turner

(2000). A Genealogy of Queer Theory (Philadelphia PA, Temple University Press)

38.

Weeks

(1990). Coming Out (London, Routledge)

39.

Whisman

(1996). Queer by Choice (London, Routledge)

40.

Yip

(1997). Gay Male Christian Couples (Westport CT, Praeger)