Comprehensive Community Initiatives: Addressing a ‘Problem’ in Local Governance or Creating One?

Abstract

Pervaded by ‘third way’ values and identified as archetypal Comprehensive Community Initiatives (CCIs), programmes such as Education Action Zones (EAZs) and Health Action Zones (HAZs) follow a procedural rationale based on heterarchy and partnership. They are a response to an alleged prior fragmentation of service provision in welfare across sectors. Employing evidence from an evaluation of an EAZ and HAZ in one location, this article makes two claims. First, it is claimed that the extent of the alleged ?problem? of fragmentation across the governance of local social and welfare services prior to the introduction of these CCIs is contestable and was exaggerated for political purposes. Second, despite the application of CCIs in the form of EAZs and HAZs, it is claimed that a continuing problem of fragmentation across local governance of social and welfare services is evident. Several insights from the emerging theory of governance failure are employed to offer an explanation for why this situation has occurred.

Keywords

Comprehensive Community Initiatives Education Acton Zones Fragmentation Governance Health Action Zones Partnerships Third Way

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson

(2000) ‘Narratives of policy: the construction of urban problems and urban policy in the official discourse of the British government 1968-1998’, Critical Social Policy, 20, 2, 211–232.

Ball

(1994) Educational Reform: A Critical and Post-Structural Approach, Buckinghamshire: Open University Press.

Bauld

, JUDGE

, LAWSON , MACKENZIE

, MACKINNION

, and TRUMAN

(2000). Health Action Zones: Progress in 2000, Glasgow, University of Glasgow.

Blair

(1996) New Britain. My Vision of a Young Country, London, Fourth Estate.

Blair

(1998). The Third Way: New Politics for the New Century, London, Fabian Society.

Blair

(1999). ‘Facing the Modern challenge: The Third Way in Britain and South Africa’. Speech given in the Parliament Building, Cape Town, South Africa, January 8th.

Blunkett

(1999). ‘Empowering People and Communities for a Better Future’. Speech to mark the 30th anniversary lecture organised by the National Centre for Social Research, June 16th.

Blunkett

(2000). ‘Democracy needs re-think when as many vote in big brother poll as in the last European election’, DfEE Press Release, 12th October.

Carter

(2000) ‘Strategy and Partnership in Urban Regeneration’, in: Stoker

(editor), The New Politics of Local Governance in Britain, Basingstoke, Macmillan Press Ltd.

10.

Clegg

(1989). Frameworks of Power, London, Sage.

11.

Connell

, KUBISCH

, SCHORR

, and WEISS

(1995). New Approaches to Evaluating Community Initiatives: Concepts, Methods and Contexts, Washington, The Aspen Institute.

12.

DFEE. (1998). Handbook for Education Action Zones, London, DfEE.

13.

DFEE. (1999). Meet the Challenge: Education Action Zones, Sudbury, DfEE.

14.

Dickson

, and POWER

(2001) ‘Education Action Zones: a new way of governing education?’, School Leadership and Management, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 137–141.

15.

Dickson

, HALPIN

, POWER

, TELFORD

, and WHITTY

(2001) ‘Education Action Zones and Democratic Participation’, School Leadership and Management, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 169–181.

16.

Fielding

(1999). Editorial. Taking Education Really Seriously: two years hard labour, Cambridge Journal of Education, Vol. 29, No. 2, pp 173–181.

17.

Giddens

(1994). Beyond left and right: the future of radical politics, Cambridge, Polity Press.

18.

Giddens

(1998). The Third Way: the renewal of social democracy, Cambridge, Polity Press.

19.

Hallgarten

, & WATLING

(2001) ‘Buying Power: the role of the private sector in Education Action Zones’, School Leadership and Management, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 143–157.

20.

Hill

D.M.

(2000). Urban Policy and Politics in Britain, Basingstoke, Macmillan Press Ltd.

21.

Jessop

(2000) ‘Governance Failure’, In: Stoker

(editor), The New Politics of Local Governance in Britain, Basingstoke, Macmillan Press Ltd.

22.

Jessop

(2001). ‘Good Governance and the Urban Question: On Managing the Contradictions of Neo-Liberalism’ <http:www.comp.lancs.ac.uk/sociology/soc075rj.html>.

23.

Jones

, & BIRD

(2000) ‘Partnership as Strategy: public-private relations in Education Action Zones’, British Educational Research Journal, Vol. 26, No. 3, pp. 491–506.

24.

Judge

, and BAULD

(2001) ‘Strong theory, flexible methods: evaluating complex community based initiatives’, Critical Public Health, 11, 1, 19–39.

25.

Malpass

, and WHICKHAM

(1995) ‘Governance and failure: on the limits of sociology’, Australia and New Zealand Journal of Sociology, 31, 3, 37–50.

26.

Malpass

, and WHICKHAM

(1997). ‘Governance and the world: From Joe Dimaggio to Michel Foucault’, The UTS Review: Cultural Studies and New Writing, pp. 91–108.

27.

Peck

, and TICKNELL

(1994) ‘To many partners. the future for local regeneration partnerships’, Local Economy, 9, 251–265.

28.

Powell

, and MOON

(2001) ‘Health Action Zones: the ‘third way’ of a new area based policy?’, Health and Social Care in the Community, 9, 1, 43–50.

29.

Raco

(2000) ‘Assessing community participation in local economic development - lessons for the new urban policy’, Political Geography, 19(5), 573–599.

30.

Rose

(1993) ‘Governmentality and Expertise in Advanced Liberalism’, Economy and Society, 22(3).

31.

SOCIAL EXCLUSION UNIT (1998). Bringing Britain Together: A National Stratgy for Neighbourhood Renewal, London, HMSO.

32.

Stoker

(editor) (2000). The New Politics of Local Governance in Britain, Basingstoke, Macmillan Press Ltd.

33.

Stone

(1989) ‘Causal Stories and the Formation of Policy Agenda’, Political Science Quarterly, 104, 2, 281–300.

34.

SOCIAL EXCLUSION UNIT (1998). Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal, London, HMSO.

35.

TEES HEALTH AUTHORITY (1998). Electoral Ward Profiles, Teesside, Tees Health Authority.

36.

Theakston

, ROBINSON

K.D.

, and BANGS

(2001) ‘Teachers Talking: teacher involvement in Education Action Zones’, School Leadership and Management, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 183–197.

37.

Wodak

, and MEYER

(2001) Methods of critical Discourse Analysis, London: Sage Publications.