The paper explores the extent to which Heads of Department and Pro-Vice
Chancellors, or manager-academics, in UK universities are aware of and prepared
for the so-called ‘risk society’. It draws on a research project funded by the
Economic and Social Research Council concerned with the management of UK
universities and the extent of permeation within universities of recent
ideologies about new practices for managing public services. Recent debates in
social theory about the concept of a risk society and risk cultures, and how
these might be applied to higher education, are considered. Key features of a
rapidly changing environment for the conduct and management of academic work are
also outlined. The focus and methodology of the ESRC research project are
explained. Interview data from Head of Department and Pro-Vice Chancellors are
then used to illustrate a range of responses to notions of risk made by
manager-academics. Finally, the paper examines how the learning of
manager-academics could be better supported, in order that post-holders can
acquire the flexibility and reflexivity which living in a risk society and
culture seems to demand.
AdamB., BeckU, and Van LoonJ (Eds). (2000). The
Risk Society and Beyond: Critical Issues for Social Theory.London,
Sage.
2.
ArchibugiD., and LundvallB.-A. (2001). The
Globalizing Learning Economy.Oxford, Oxford University
Press.
3.
BarnettR. (1999). Realizing
the University in an Age of Supercomplexity.Buckingham, Society for Research
into Higher Education & Open University Press
2000.
4.
BarnettR. (2003). Beyond All
Reason: Living with Ideology in the University.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
5.
BarryD., and ElmesM. (1997).
“Strategy Retold: Toward a Narrative View of Strategic
Discourse.”The Academy of Management Review22(2):
429–452.
6.
BecherT. (1999).
Professional Practices: Commitment and Capability in a Changing
Environment.New Brunswick & London,
Transaction Publishers.
7.
BecherT., and TrowlerP (2001). Academic
Tribes and Territories: Intellectual Enquiry and the Cultures of
Disciplines.Milton Keynes, Society for
Research into Higher Education & Open University
Press.
8.
BeckU. (1992). Risk
Society: Towards a New Modernity.London,
Sage.
9.
BeckU., GiddensA., and LashS. (1994). Reflexive
Modernization.Cambridge,
Polity.
10.
BourdieuP. (1988). Homo
Academicus.Cambridge, Polity
Press.
11.
BrewA. (2001). The Nature
of Research: Inquiry in Academic Contexts.London & New York,
Routledge.
12.
BrownJ. S., CollinsA., and DuguidP (1989).
“Situated Cognition and the Culture of
Learning.”Educational Researcher18(1):
32–42.
13.
CastellsM. (1996). The Rise
of the Network Society.Oxford,
Blackwells.
14.
ClarkB. (1998). Creating
Entrepreneurial Universities: Organisational Pathways of
Transformation.New York & Amsterdam,
Elsevier.
15.
ClarkeJ., and NewmanJ. (1997). The
Managerial State: Power, Politics and Ideology in the Remaking of Social
Welfare.London,
Sage.
16.
CowenR. (1996).
“Performativity, Post Modernity and the
University.”Comparative Education32(2):
245–258.
17.
CuthbertR., (Ed). (1996).
Working in Higher Education.London, Open University
Press.
18.
DamarinS. K. (1993).
“School and Situated Knowledge: Travel or
Tourism?”Educational Technology33(3):
27–32.
19.
DearloveJ. (1997).
“The Academic Labour Process: From Collegiality and
Professionalism to Managerialism and Proleterianisation?”Higher Education Review30(1):
56–75.
20.
DeemR. (2003a).
“Gender, Organisational Cultures and the Practices of
Manager-Academics in UK Universities.”Gender, Work and Organisation10(2):
239–259.
21.
DeemR. (2003b).
Managing to Exclude? Manager-Academic and Staff Communities
in Contemporary Uk Universities. in
TightM. (Ed). International
Perspectives on Higher Education Research: Access and Inclusion,
Elsevier Science JAI:
103–125.
22.
DeemR., FultonO., ReedM, and WatsonS. (2001). New
Managerialism and the Management of UK Universities. End of Award
Report. Swindon, Economic and
Social Research Councilhttp://www.regard.ac.uk/regard/home/index_html.
23.
DeemR., and HillyardS. (2002).
Making Time for Management - the Careers and Lives of
Manager-Academics in Uk Universities'. in
CrowG., and HeathS. J., (Eds). Social Conceptions
of Time.Basingstoke,
Palgrave:
126–143.
24.
DeemR., OzgaJ.T., and
PrichardC. (2000).
“Managing Further Education: Is It Still Men's Work
Too?”Journal of Further and Higher Education24(2):
231–251.
25.
DelantyG. (2001).
Challenging Knowledge: The University in the Knowledge
Society.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
26.
DEPARTMENT for Education, and
Skills (2003). The Future of Higher Education:
DfES White Paper.London,
HMSO.
27.
Du GayP., and SalamanG. (1992).
“The Cult(Ure) of the Customer’.”Journal of Management Studies29(4):
616–633.
28.
ErautM. (2003). Re-Framing
Continuing Professional Development. Paper presented in the Centre
for Management and Policy Studies seminar series, Graduate School of Education,
University of Bristol.
29.
EtzkowitzH., and
LeydesdorffL (1997).
Universities in the Global Knowledge Economy.London, Pinter
Press.
30.
ExworthyM., and HalfordS. (Eds). (1999).
Professionals and the New Managerialism in the Public
Sector.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
31.
FoxS. (1997).
“Situated Learning Theory Versus Traditional Cognitive
Theory: Why Management Education Should Not Ignore Management
Learning.”Systems Practice10(6):
727–747.
32.
GibbonsM., LimgogesC., NowotnyH., SchwartzmanS., ScottP., and TrowM. (1994). The New
Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in
Contemporary Societies.London,
Sage.
33.
GiddensA. (1990). The
Consequences of Modernity.Cambridge,
Polity.
34.
GiddensA. (1991). Modernity
and Self Identity.Cambridge, Polity
Press.
35.
GiddensA. (1992). The
Transformation of Intimacy.Cambridge,
Polity.
36.
GiddensA. (1994).
Living in Post Traditional Society. in
BeckU., GiddensA., and LashS., (Eds). Reflexive
Modernisation.Cambridge,
Polity.
37.
GrayH., (Ed). (1999).
Universities as Wealth Creation.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
38.
HalfordS., SavageM., and WitzA (1997). Gender,
Careers and Organisation.London,
Macmillan.
39.
HalseyA. H. (1992). Decline
of Donnish Dominion: The British Academic Professions in the Twentieth
Century.Oxford,
Clarendon.
40.
HannanA., and SilverH. (2000). Innovating
in Higher Education.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
41.
HarleyS. (2002).
“The Impact of Research Selectivity on Academic Work and
Identity in UK Universities.”Studies in Higher Education27(2):
187–206.
42.
HenkelM. (2000). Academic
Identities and Policy Change in Higher Education.London, Jessica
Kingsley.
43.
JaryD., and ParkerM. (1998). The New
Higher Education: Issues and Directions for the Post-Dearing
University. Stoke on Trent, University of
Staffordshire.
44.
JohnsonR. N., and DeemR (2003).
“Talking of Students: Tensions and Contradictions for the
Manager-Academic and the University in Contemporary Higher
Education.”Higher Education: 46, 3,
289–314.
45.
KoganM., and HanneyS. (2000). Reforming
Higher Education.London, Jessica
Kingsley.
46.
LashS. (2000).
Risk Culture. in
AdamB., BeckU., and Van LoonJ. (Eds). The Risk Society and
Beyond: Critical Issues for Social Theory.London,
Sage.
47.
LashS., and UrryJ. (1994). Economies
of Signs and Space.London,
Sage.
48.
LaveJ., and WengerE. (1991). Situated
Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation.New York, Cambridge University
Press.
49.
LucasL. (2001). The
Research Game: A Sociological Study of Academic Research Work in Two
Universities. Dept of Sociology,
Unpublished PhD thesis, University of
Warwick.
MaceJ. (2000).
“The RAE and University Efficiency.”Higher Education Review32(2):
17–35.
52.
MaddockS. (1999).
Challenging Women: Gender, Culture and Organisation.London,
Sage.
53.
MarginsonS., and ConsidineM. (2000). Enterprise
University in Australia. Governance, Strategy and Reinvention.Cambridge, Cambridge University
Press.
54.
McnayI. (1995).
From the Collegial Academy to Corporate Enterprise; the
Changing Cultures of Universities. in
SchullerT. (Ed). The Changing
University.Buckingham, Open University:
105–115.
55.
MiddlehurstR. (2000). The
Business of Borderless Education: Uk Perspectives - Analysis and
Recommendations.London, Committee of Vice
Chancellors and Principals.
56.
MiddlemissS. (2000).
“Legal Libability of Universities for
Students.”Education and the Law 69-91.12(2):
69–91.
57.
MillerH. (1998).
“Managing Academics in Canada and the United
Kingdom.”International Studies in the Sociology of Education8(1):
3–26.
58.
MorleyL. (2001).
“Subjected to Review: Engendering Quality and Power in Higher
Education.”Journal of Education Policy16(5):
465–478.
59.
MorleyL. (2003). Quality
and Power in Higher Education.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
60.
OsborneT. (2003).
Intellectuals as Mediators: Remarks on Some Aspects of the
Contemporary Ideas Trade. unpublished paper given to the University
of Bristol Faculty of Social Science Research Conference May 7th, Social Science
Complex, Woodland Road, Bristol.
61.
ParryG. (2001a).
Reform of Higher Education in the United
Kingdom. in B. Nolan, (Ed). Public Sector Reform: An
International Perspective.Basingstoke,
Macmillan:
117–132.
62.
PowerM. (1997). The Audit
Society.Oxford, Oxford University
Press.
63.
PrichardC. (1998). ‘It's
Intelligent Life Jim but Not as We Know It’. Re-Wording and Re-Working
Tertiary Education in the Age of the Global Knowledge Economy.
Unpublished paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the New Zealand Association
for Research in Education, University of
Otago.
64.
PrichardC. (2000). Making
Managers in Universities and Colleges.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
65.
ReadingsB. (1996). The
University in Ruins.Cambridge MA, Harvard University
Press.
66.
ReedM., and DeemR (2002). New
Managerialism: The Manager-Academic and Technologies of Management in
Universities - Looking Forward to Virtuality? in
RobinsK, and WebsterF., (Eds). The Virtual University?
Information, Markets and Managements.Oxford, Oxford University
Press:
126–147.
67.
RobinsK., and WebsterF. (Eds). (2002). The
Virtual University? Knowledge, Markets, and Management.Oxford, Oxford University
Press.
68.
RutherfordS. (2001).
“Any Difference? An Analysis of Gender and Divisional
Management Styles in a Large Airline.”Gender, Work and Organisation8(3):
326–345.
69.
SadlakJ. (1998).
Globalisation and Concurrent Challenges for Higher
Education. in ScottP. (Ed). The Globalisation of
Higher Education.Buckingham, Open University
Press:
100–107.
70.
ScottP., (Ed). (1998). The
Globalisation of Higher Education.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
71.
ShattockM. (1999).
“Governance and Management in Universities: The Way We Live
Now.”Journal of Education Policy14(3):
271–282.
72.
ShoreC., and WrightS. (1999).
“Audit Culture and Anthropology: Neo-Liberalism in British
Higher Education.”The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute5(4):
557–575.
73.
SibbaltA. (2003). Higher
Education Staff Development Agency Training for Academic Managers.
Unpublished presentation to the Learning and Teaching Support Network Annual
Conference, Coventry, March 6th.
74.
SlaughterS., and LeslieG. (1997). Academic
Capitalism.Baltimore, John
Hopkins.
75.
SmithA., and WebsterF. (Eds). (1997). The
Postmodern University? Contested Visions of Higher Education in
Society.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
76.
SmithC. W. (2000). Market
Values in American Higher Education: The Pitfalls and Promises.Lanham, Maryland and Oxford,
Rowman and Littlefield.
77.
SmythJ. (1995). Academic
Work.Buckingham, Open University
Press.
78.
StrathernM. (2000). Audit
Cultures: Anthropological Studies in Accountability, Ethics, and the
Academy.London,
Routledge.
79.
TownleyB. (2003).
Understanding Changes in Management in the Public Sector.
unpublished paper given to third event in the Economic and Social Research
Council Seminar Series, ‘Reconfiguring Sociology of Education’,
University of Edinburgh, Centre for Educational
Sociology.
80.
Van LoonJ. (2002). Risk and
Technological Culture.London,
Routledge.
81.
WajcmanJ. (1998). Managing
Like a Man.Cambridge, Polity
Press.
82.
WatsonT., and WatsonD (1999).
“Human Resourcing in Practice: Managing Employment Issues in
the University.”Journal of Management Studies36(4):
484–504.
83.
WebbJ. (1999).
“Work and the New Public Service Class.”Sociology33(4):
747–766.
84.
WeickK. E. (1995).
Sensemaking in Organizations.London,
Sage.
85.
WeickK. E. (2000). Making
Sense of the Organization.Oxford,
Blackwells.
86.
WhiteheadS., and MoodleyR. (Eds). (1999).
Transforming Managers: Engendering Change in the Public
Sector.London, Falmer
Press.
87.
WinterR. (1995). The
University of Life Plc: The ‘Industrialisation of Higher
Education. in SmythJ. (Ed). Academic Work.Buckingham, Open University
Press:
129–143.
