Agro-Environmental Project Duration and Effectiveness in South-East Asia

Abstract

Considerable emphasis has been placed on developing technologies for agricultural sustainability. Many bilateral projects are working to achieve this outcome. A desk review was conducted to study the importance of project duration for the effectiveness of sustainable agricultural projects. Longer-duration projects were successful in addressing more holistic issues than short projects. However, funding agencies tend to fund shorter-duration projects, so projects become progressively shorter. At the same time, the number of projects implemented each year is increasing. Despite the decrease in total development assistance, increases in project numbers, particularly since 1986, appear to be at the cost of project duration. Short project duration was one of the most cited reasons for not completing essential dissemination activities for wider adoption, whereas longer-duration projects were usually considered more successful in addressing more holistic issues. It is difficult to produce tangible outputs from agricultural and soil conservation projects within five years. Considering the slow changes in the system and in agricultural and environmental sustainability, the authors suggest that project developers should be advised to plan for a minimum of 5–10 years, depending on the nature of activities. It is time for funding agencies to reconsider their tendency to fund shorter-duration projects.

Keywords

project duration project effectiveness sustainability

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ADB (1999), ‘Poverty reduction and environmental management in remote Greater Mekong Sub-region (GMS) watersheds (Phase I): Final Report’,Asian Development Bank Website: http://www.mekonginfo.org/mrc_en/doclib.nsf/0/DB60A148CB7239EEC725683300275159/$FILE/FULLTEXT.html.

Agenda 21 (1992), Agenda 21, Program of Action for Sustainable Development, United Nations Publications, New York.

AusAID (1999), Targeting Poor Farmers: Contributions to Rural Development in Thailand, Quality Assurance Series No 16, The Australian Government's Overseas Aid (AusAID) Program, Website: http://www.ausaid.gov.au/publications/pdf/qas16_thailandfarmers.pdf.

Bie

S. W.

Baldascini

Tschirley

(1997), ‘The context of indicators in FAO’, in Land Quality Indicators and their Use in Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development, FAO, Rome.

Bridges

E. M.

Oldeman

L. R.

(2001), ‘Food production and environmental degradation’, in Bridges

E. M.

, eds, Responses to Land Degradation, Science Publishers Inc, Enfield, NH.

CIMMYT (2004), CIMMYT in Asia, International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), El Batan, Mexico, Website: http://www.cimmyt.cgiar.org/worldwide/CIMMYT_Regions/CIMMYT_Asia/cimmyt_in_asia/cimmyt_in_asia.htm.

Development Gateway (2003), ‘AiDA – Accessible Information on Development Activities’, Development Gateway Foundations, Washington, DC, Website: http://aida.developmentgateway.org/AidaHome.do.

Dirksen

(2001), Considerations and Lessons from Implementing the Thai–German Highland Development Program (TG-HDP) in Northern Thailand, Thai–German Highland Development Program (TG-HDP), Website: http://www.gtz-asia-online.org/hdp/frame.htm?lib.nsf?OpenDatabase.

Dirksen

(2002), 18 Years of the Thai–German Highland Development Program – Has it Been a Success Story? German Technical Co-operation (GTZ), Website: http://www.gtz.de/drogen/download/english/publications/dirksen_02.pdf.

10.

Do Thi Ngoc Oanh Le Am, Kauppi

Jussi

Lehtonen

Aleksi

(1997), Study on Agroforestry Systems and Soil Survey, Technical Report No 8, The Vietnam–Finland Forestry Sector Cooperation Program and the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development of Bac Kan Province, Website: http://www.mekonginfo.org/mrc_en/doclib.nsf/0/9279765061EA0ACC472568E90016516A/$FILE/FULLTEXT.html.

11.

Dumanski

, eds (1991), ‘Evaluation for sustainable land management in the developing world. Volume 2: Technical Papers’ IBSRAM Proceedings, Vol 12, No 2.

12.

Evans

L. T.

(1998), Feeding Ten Billion: Plants and Population Growth, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

13.

Evans

P. T.

Sophana

(2004), ‘Lessons from the “Participatory Natural Resource Management in the Tonle Sap Region” project’, in Torell

Salamanca

A. M.

Ratner

B. D.

, eds, Wetlands Management in Cambodia: Socio-economic, Ecological, and Policy Perspectives, Technical Report 64, WorldFish Center, Penang, Malaysia.

14.

Gerpacio

R. V.

, ed (2001), Impact of Public- and Private-Sector Maize Breeding Research in Asia, 1966-1997/98, International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), El Batan, Mexico.

15.

Gowda

C. L. L.

, eds (1996), Approaches to On-Farm Research in Asia: Summary Proceedings of the Regional Workshop on On-Farm Adaptive Research, International Crops Research Institute for the Semi Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), Patancheru, India.

16.

Howeler

R. H.

(1996), ‘The use of farmer-participatory research methodologies to enhance the adoption of soil conservation practices in cassava-based cropping systems in Asia’, in Sombatpanit

, eds, Soil Conservation Extension: From Concepts to Adoption, Science Publishers Inc, Enfield, NH.

17.

Hudson

N. W.

(1991), ‘A study of the reasons for success or failure of soil conservation projects’ FAO Soils Bulletin, Vol 64.

18.

Hurni

(2000), ‘Soil conservation policies and sustainable land management: A global overview’, in Napier

T. L.

Napier

S. M.

Tvrdon

, eds, Soil and Water Conservation Policies and Programs: Successes and Failures, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.

19.

ICIMOD (1999), Manual on Contour Hedgerow Inter-cropping Technology, International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD), Kathmandu, Nepal.

20.

ICRISAT (2002), ‘This is ICRISAT’, International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), Patancheru, India, Website: http://www.icrisat.org/web/uploads/presentations/07032003202810ThisisIcrisat.pdf.

21.

IRRI (2003), ‘Cambodia and IRRI’, International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), Los Banos, The Philippines, Website: http://www.irri.org/media/facts/pdfs/cambodia.pdf.

22.

Kokubun

(1998), ‘JIRCAS projects for the development of technologies for sustainable agriculture in Asia’, in Horiuchi

Tsubota

, eds, The 4th JIRCAS International Symposium: Sustainable Agricultural Development Compatible with Environmental Conservation in Asia, JIRCAS International Symposium Series, Japan International Research Center for Agricultural Research, Tsukuba, Japan.

23.

Lal

Miller

F. P.

Logan

T. J.

(1988), ‘Are intensive agricultural practices environmentally and ethically sound?’ Journal of Agricultural Ethics, Vol 1, pp 193–210.

24.

Guobin

Liu

(1999), ‘Soil conservation and sustainable agriculture on the Loess Plateau: Challenges and prospects’ Ambio, Vol 28, No 8 pp 663–668.

25.

Maglinao

, eds (1995), ‘International workshop on conservation farming for sloping uplands in Southeast Asia: Challenges, opportunities, and prospects’, IBSRAM Proceedings, No 14, The International Board for Soil Research and Management (IBSRAM), Bangkok.

26.

McKemey

, (2003), Farmers' Attitudes Towards Land Management Strategies: A Theory of Reasoned Action Analysis, Working Paper 5, DfID NRSP project R7958, ‘Developing supportive policy environments for improved land management strategies – Nepal’, University of Reading, Reading.

27.

Monschein

(1999), ‘Poverty reduction and food security in China: The Sino–German food security program Shandong’ Agriculture and Rural Development, Vol 2, pp 61–63.

28.

Munasinghe

Shearer

, eds (1995), Defining and Measuring Sustainability: the Biophysical Foundation, World Bank, Washington, DC.

29.

Nesbitt

H. J.

, ed (1997), Rice Production in Cambodia, International Rice Research Institute, Los Banos, The Philippines.

30.

Neupane

Ojha

Garforth

(2002), Scaling Up of Sustainable Soil Management Practices: Case Studies of Panchkhal and Sanga Villages in Kavre District, Nepal, ForestAction, Kathmandu, and the University of Reading, Reading.

31.

Nutalaya

(1991), ‘Pollution and other off-site effects on sustainable land development’, in Dumanski

, eds, Evaluation for Sustainable Land Management in the Developing World: Technical Papers, IBSRAM Proceedings, Vol 12, No 2.

32.

Pinstrup-Anderson

Pandya-Lorch

(1998), ‘Food security and sustainable use of natural resources: A 2020 vision’ Ecological Economics, Vol 26, pp 1–10.

33.

Pratap

Watson

H. R.

(1994), Sloping Agricultural Land Technology (SALT): A Regenerative Option for Sustainable Mountain Farming, International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD), Kathmandu.

34.

Rigby

(2001), ‘Constructing a farm level indicator of sustainable agricultural practice’ Ecological Economics, Vol 39, pp 463–478.

35.

Röling

(2005), ‘Gateway to the global garden: Beta/gamma science for dealing with ecological rationality’, in Pretty

, ed, The Earthscan Reader in Sustainable Agriculture, Earthscan, London.

36.

Ruaysoongnern

(1999), ‘Adoption of sloping land conservation practices by farmers in the northeast of Thailand’, in McDonald

Brown

, eds, Issues and Options in the Design of Soil and Water Conservation Projects, School of Agriculture and Forest Sciences Publication Number 17, University of Wales, Bangor.

37.

Sajjapongse

, ed (1992), Technical Report on the Management of Sloping Lands for Sustainable Agriculture in Asia, Phase 1, 1988–1991 (IBSRAM/ASIALAND), Network Document No 2, International Board for Soil Research and Management (IBSRAM), Bangkok.

38.

Sajjapongse

Elliott

C. R.

, eds (1995), ASIALAND: The Management of Sloping Lands for Sustainable Agriculture in Asia (Phase 2, 1992–1994), Network Document No 12, IBSRAM, Bangkok.

39.

Sajjapongse

Leslei

R. N.

, eds (1998), ASIALAND: The Management of Sloping Lands for Sustainable Agriculture in Asia (Phase 3, 1995–1997), IBSRAM Proceedings No 23, IBSRAM, Bangkok.

40.

Sombatpanit

(2001), ‘Thailand's response to land degradation: The need to control soil erosion’, in Bridges

E. M.

, eds, Responses to Land Degradation, Science Publishers Inc, Enfield, NH.

41.

SUAS (1990), Evaluation of the Chinese–Swedish Soil Conservation Co-operation Project, Working Paper No 147, International Rural Development Department, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SUAS), Uppsala.

42.

SUAS (1991), Chinese–Swedish Soil Conservation Project 1987–1990: Final Report, International Rural Development Department, SUAS, Uppsala.

43.

Tang

(1999), ‘Factors influencing farmers’ adoption of soil conservation programs in Hindu Kush Himalayan region’, in McDonald

Brown

, eds, Issues and Options in the Design of Soil and Water Conservation Projects, School of Agriculture and Forest Sciences Publication Number 17, University of Wales, Bangor.

44.

TG-HDP (1999), ‘TG-HDP Human Resources Development Study. Thai–German Highland development program’, Internal Paper No 188, Website: http://www.gtz-asiaonline.org/hdp/frame.htm?lib.nsf?OpenDatabase.

45.

Trotter

Gordon

(2000), ‘Charting change in official assistance to agriculture’ Food Policy, Vol 25, pp 115–124.

46.

van Keer

, eds (1998), Options for Soil and Farmer Friendly Agriculture in the Highlands of Northern Thailand, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH, Eschborn.

47.

Walmsley

J. J.

(2002), ‘Framework for measuring sustainable development in catchment systems’ Environmental Management, Vol 29, No 2 pp 195–206.

48.

Wills

J. B.

, eds (1987), Coordination of Grain Legumes Research in Asia: Summary Proceedings of the Review and Planning Meeting for Asian Regional Research on Grain Legumes (Groundnut, Chickpea, and Pigeonpea), 16–18 Dec 1985, International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), Patancheru, India.