Centres of Excellence in the Context of Further Education and Training in South Africa

Abstract

Since 1994 South African further education and training (FET) has undergone significant and fundamental changes. These changes include the transfer of colleges between state departments, curriculum revision, forced mergers and a shift in the student population. As a result of the growing interest in, and funding of, vocationally aligned education, education and training excellence models have permeated into the management portfolio of South Africa's FET. FET colleges (FETCs) have been faced with the emerging excellence discourses in the higher education and business sectors, as well as funding and accreditation linked motivators. How FETC managers have chosen to incorporate, or not to incorporate, centres of excellence (CoEs) into their organizational structures indicates both the difference in the application of CoE models to the sector compared with the higher education and business sectors and the way FETCs are managed in their volatile environment. This paper uses data initially gathered for a funded project aimed at identifying excellence indicators applicable to the FET sector, and a comparative content analysis of related publications and telephone interviews with senior staff responsible for innovation. The authors argue that higher education or business excellence models cannot be applied to the further education and training college environment; models need to be adapted to suit this specific type of environment.

Keywords

centres of excellence further education and training quality FETCs South Africa

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akoojee

Gewer

McGrath

(2005), Vocational Education and Training in Southern Africa: A Comparative Study, Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) Press, Cape Town.

Bell

(1996), ‘University–industry interaction in the Ontario Centres of Excellence’, Journal of Higher Education, Vol 67, No 3, pp 322–348.

Beraud

(2000), ‘Questioning a tradition: A French way of excellence’, European Journal of Engineering Education, Vol 25, No 4, pp 369–375.

De Wit

P.C.W.

Hammersma

S.A.

(1992), Production and Operational Management: A Practical Approach, International Thomson, Halfway House, SA.

Clouder

Oliver

Tait

(2008), ‘Embedding CETLs in a performance-oriented culture in higher education: Reflections on finding creative space’, British Educational Research Journal, Vol 34, No 5, pp 635–650.

College of Cape Town (2010), Personal correspondence.

Crosser

McGrath

Baroodien

Maja

(2003), Technical College Responsiveness: Learner Destinations and Labour Market Environments in South Africa, Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) Press, Cape Town.

Du Toit

G.S.

Erusmus

B.J.

Strydom

J.W.

(2007), Introduction to Business Management, Oxford University Press, Cape Town.

Garrison

Kanuka

(2004), ‘Blended learning: Uncovering its transformative potential in higher education’, Internet and Higher Education, Vol 7, pp 95–105.

10.

Gray-Donald

Selby

(2004), ‘Through the (not so) Green Door: University campus greening and curriculum change’, Ekistics, Vol 71, pp 203–212.

11.

Gosling

Hannan

(2007), ‘Responses to a policy initiative: The case of Centres for Excellence in teaching and learning’, Studies in Higher Education, Vol 32, No 5, pp 633–646.

12.

Henning

Van Rensburg

W.A.

Smit

(2004), Finding Your Way in Qualitative Research, Van Schaik, Pretoria.

13.

Hawes

Stephens

(1990), Questions of Quality: Primary Education and Development, Longman, Harlow.

14.

Holm

Pederson

(2000), The Emergence and Impact of MNE Centres of Excellence, Macmillan, London.

15.

McDonald-Hooks

L.M.

Randolph

(2004), ‘Excellence in teacher preparation’, Childhood Education, Vol 80, No 5, pp 231–236.

16.

King

(2010), ‘Evidencing impact of educational developments: The “influence wheel” and its use in a CETL context’, Journal of Further and Higher Education, Vol 34, No 1, pp 35–46.

17.

Kotler

Murphy

P.E.

(1981), ‘Strategic planning for higher education’, Journal of Higher Education, Vol 52, No 5, pp 470–489.

18.

Kraft

R.G.

(2000), ‘Teaching excellence and the inner life of faculty’, Change, Vol 32, No 3, pp 48–52.

19.

Levine

(1997), ‘Can professional development schools help us achieve what matters most?’, Action in Teacher Education, Vol XIX, No 2, pp 63–73.

20.

Lewis

H.R.

(2006), Excellence Without a Soul: How a Great University Forgot Education, Public Affairs Press, New York.

21.

Macleod

A.M.

Baxter

L.F.

(2001), ‘The contribution of business excellence models in restoring failed improvement initiatives’, European Management Journal, Vol 19, No 4, pp 342–403

22.

Nealy

(2005), ‘Worthy of recognition’, Black Issues in Higher Education, Vol 22, No 12, p 27.

23.

Nelson

Winter

S.G.

(1982), An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change, Harvard University Press, Harvard, MA.

24.

Nonaka

Takeuchi

(1995), The Knowledge-Creating Company: How Japanese Companies Create the Dynamics of Innovation, Oxford University Press, New York.

25.

NRF (2004), Handbook to Assist with the Operation of a Centre of Excellence, NRF, Pretoria.

26.

Ostar

A.W.

(1991), ‘Partnerships between the interactive university and its constituencies’, Economic Development Review, Vol 8, No 1, pp 56–57.

27.

Papier

(2010), ‘From policy to curriculum in South African vocational teacher education: A comparative perspective’, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, Vol 62, No 2, pp 153–162.

28.

Pittendrigh

(1988), Technikons in South Africa, The Building Industries Federation (South Africa), Halfway House, SA.

29.

Powel

P.A.

Landman

J.J.

(1999), DACUM Facilitator Manual, Canadian Vocational Association, Seadoone.

30.

Pycraft

Singh

Khomotso

(1997), Operations Management, Pitman, London.

31.

Rankin

(2004), ‘University research: Where gift and market economics meet’, New Zealand Journal of Tertiary Education Policy, Vol 1, pp 1–3.

32.

Rip

(2004), ‘Strategic research, post-modern universities and research training’, Higher Education Policy, Vol 17, pp 153–166.

33.

Robson

Yarrow

Owen

(2005), ‘Does quality drive employee satisfaction in the UK learning sector?’, Journal of Quality and Reliability Management, Vol 22, pp 465–488.

34.

Ruben

D.R.

, ed. (2004), Pursuing Excellence in Higher Education: Eight Fundamental Challenges, Jossey-Bass/John Wiley, San Francisco, CA.

35.

Russell

R.S.

Taylor

B.W.

(1997), Production and Operations Management, 5th edition, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.

36.

South Africa (2008) Draft National Policy Framework For Lecturer Qualifications and Development in FET Colleges in South Africa, Government Printers, Pretoria.

37.

Turner

Young

Menon

Stone

(2008), ‘In the sunshine: A case study exploring the impact of a CETL award scheme’, Journal of Further and Higher Education, Vol 32, No 4, pp 441–448.