The history of land control in Indonesia is overwhelmingly one of colonial conquest, government enclosure and expropriation of traditional property rights. However, beneath these great transformations, counter-currents also flow. Encroachment on state land and its gradual privatization by ordinary people sometimes gnaw at government property. Through a series of small, sometimes innocuous actions, people manage to undo the previous ownership regime. This article shows how settlers over a period of some 30 years – through a strategic mixture of civic disobedience and civic compliance – managed to appropriate, formalize and effectively privatize land belonging to the state-owned railway company in the city of Bandung. The authors argue that disobedient occupation and subsequent obedient payment of taxes, documentation of residence and ‘normalization’ of the area have reduced the company's ownership to thin formality, whereas new residents hold all the substantial elements of property rights to the land.
AbeyasekereS. (1989), Jakarta. A History, Oxford University Press, Singapore.
2.
ArendtH. (1979), The Origins of Totalitarianism, Harvest/HB, San Diego, New York, and London.
3.
BednerA. (2001), Administrative Courts in Indonesia. A Socio-Legal Study, Kluwer Law International, The Hague, and London.
4.
BenjaminS.ArifinM.A. (1985), ‘The housing costs of low-income kampung dwellers – a study of product and process in Indonesian cities’, Habitat International, Vol 9, No 1, pp 91–110.
5.
BenjaminsenT.A. (2009), ‘Formalisation of land rights: Some empirical evidence from Mali, Niger and South Africa’, Land Use Policy, Vol 26, No 1, pp 28–35.
6.
BierschenkT.de SardanOlivier J.-P., eds (2014), States at Work, Dynamics of African Bureaucracies, Brill, Leiden.
7.
ColombijnF. (2012), ‘Solid as a rock or a handful of dust? The security of land tenure in Indonesian cities from 1930–1960’, in BogaertsE.RabenR., eds, Beyond Empire and Nation, KITLV Press, Leiden.
8.
ColombijnF. (2013), Under Construction: The Politics of Urban Space and Housing during the Decolonization of Indonesia, 1930–1960, KITLV Press, Leiden.
9.
ColombijnF.CotéJ., eds (2015), Cars, Conduits and Kampongs. The Modernization of the Indonesian City, 1920–1960, Brill, Leiden.
DasV. (2011), ‘State, citizenship, and the urban poor’, Citizenship Studies, Vol 15, Nos 3–4, pp 319–333.
12.
DavidsonJ.S. (2015), Indonesia's Changing Political Economy: Governing the Roads, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
13.
DavisM. (2006), Planet of Slums, Verso, London and New York.
14.
de SotoH. (2000), The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, Basic Books, New York.
15.
FernandezE.VarleyA., eds (1998), Illegal Cities. Law and Urban Change in Developing Countries, Zed Books, London.
16.
FitzpatrickD. (1997), ‘Disputes and pluralism in modern Indonesian land law’, Yale Journal of International Law, Vol 22, pp 171–212.
17.
GuilletD. (1998), ‘Rethinking legal pluralism: Local law and state law in the evolution of water property rights in northwestern Spain’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol 40, No 1, pp 42–70.
18.
HandzicK. (2010), ‘Is legalized land tenure necessary in slum upgrading? Learning from Rio's land tenure policies in the Favela Bairro Program’, Habitat International, Vol 34, No 1, pp 11–17.
19.
HannaS.FolkeC.MälerK.-G. (1995), ‘Property rights and environmental resources’, in HannaS.MunasingheM., eds, Property Rights and the Environment – Social and Ecological Issues, Beijer International Institute of Ecological Economics, Stockholm, and World Bank, Washington, DC.
20.
HolstonJ. (2008), Insurgent Citizenship: Disjunctions of Democracy and Modernity in Brazil, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
21.
HolstonJ. (2009), ‘Insurgent citizenship in an era of global urban peripheries’, City & Society, Vol 21, No 2, pp 245–267.
22.
JellinekL. (1991), The Wheel of Fortune. The History of a Poor Community in Jakarta, Allen and Unwin, London.
23.
JianpingY.JianW. (2009), ‘Peri-urban land tenure legislation: A tale of two districts’, in UbinkJ.M.HoekemaA.AssiesW.J., eds, Legalising Land Rights – Local Practices, State Responses and Tenure Security in Africa, Asia and Latin America, Leiden University Press, Leiden.
24.
KanoH. (2008), Indonesian Exports. Peasant Agriculture, and the World Economy, 1850–2000, Ohio University Press, Athens, OH.
25.
KörlingG. (2011), In Search of the State: An Ethnography of Public Service Provision in Urban Niger, Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis, University of Uppsala.
26.
LeafM. (1993), ‘Land rights for residential development in Jakarta, Indonesia: The colonial roots of contemporary urban dualism’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, Vol 17, No 4, pp 477–491.
27.
LefebvreH. (1996), Writings on Cities, Blackwell, Cambridge, MA.
28.
LipskyM. (1969), Towards a Theory of Street-Level Bureaucracy, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI.
29.
LipskyM. (1971), ‘Street-level bureaucracy and the analysis of urban reform’, Urban Affairs Review, Vol 6, No 4, pp 391–409.
30.
LipskyM. (2010), Street-Level Bureaucracy – Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services, Russell Sage Foundation, New York.
31.
LundC. (2011), ‘Property and citizenship. Conceptually connecting land rights and belonging in Africa’, Africa Spectrum, Vol 46, No 3, pp 71–75.
32.
LundC. (2014), ‘Of what is this a case? Analytical movements in social science research’, Human Organization, Vol 73, No 3, pp 224–234.
33.
LundC.BooneC. (2013), ‘Introduction: Land politics in Africa – constituting authority over territory, property and persons’, Africa, Vol 83, No 1, pp 1–13.
34.
LundC.HahonouE. (2013), ‘Propriété et citoyenneté dans l'Afrique des villes’ (numéro thématique), Politique Africaine, Vol 132.
35.
MacphersonC.B.B. (1978), Property – Mainstream and Critical Positions, University of Toronto Press, and Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
36.
Meinzen-DickR.S.PradhanR. (2001), ‘Implications of legal pluralism for natural resource management’, IDS Bulletin, Vol 32, No 4, pp 10–17.
37.
MoochtarR. (1980), ‘Urban housing in Indonesia’, Habitat International, Vol 4, No 3, pp 325–338.
38.
NielsenM. (2011), ‘Inverse governmentality: The paradoxical production of peri-urban planning in Maputo, Mozambique’, Critique of Anthropology, Vol 31, No 4, pp 329–358.
39.
O'BrienK.J.LiL. (2006), Rightful Resistance in Rural China, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
40.
PetersR. (2010), ‘The wheels of misfortune: The street and cycles of displacement in Surabaya, Indonesia’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, Vol 40, No 4, pp 568–588.
41.
ReerinkG. (2011), Tenure Security for Indonesia's Urban Poor – A Socio-Legal Study on Land, Decentralisation, and the Rule of Law in Bandung, Leiden University Press, Leiden.
42.
ReerinkG.van GelderJ.-L. (2010), ‘Land titling, perceived tenure security, and housing consolidation in the kampongs of Bandung, Indonesia’, Habitat International, Vol 34, No 1, pp 78–85.
43.
RoseC.M. (1994), Property & Persuasion: Essays on the History, Theory, and Rhetoric of Ownership, Westview, Boulder, CO.
44.
SantosB.D.S. (1977), ‘The law of the oppressed: The construction and reproduction of legality in Pasargada’, Law and Society Review, Vol 12, No 1.
45.
SastrosasmitaS.AminA.T.M.N. (1990), ‘Housing needs of informal sector workers’, Habitat International, Vol 14, No 4, pp 75–88.
46.
SchlagerE.OstromE. (1992), ‘Property-rights regimes and natural resources: A conceptual analysis’, Land Economics, Vol 68, No 3.
47.
SikorT.LundC. (2009), ‘Access and property: A question of power and authority’, Development and Change, Vol 40, No 1, pp 1–22.
48.
SikorT.DorondelS.StahlJ. (forthcoming), When Things Become Property, Berghahn Books, London.
49.
SjaastadE.CousinsB. (2009), ‘Formalisation of land rights in the South: An overview’, Land Use Policy, Vol 26, No 1, pp 1–9.
50.
SomersM. (2008), Genealogies of Citizenship. Markets, Statelessness, and the Right to Have Rights, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
51.
TunasD.PeresthuA. (2010), ‘The self-help housing in Indonesia: The only option for the poor?’Habitat International, Vol 34, No 3, pp 315–322.
52.
UbinkJ.M. (2009), ‘Legalising land rights in Africa, Asia and Latin America: An introduction’, in UbinkJ.M.HoekemaA.J.AssiesW.J., eds, Legalising Land Rights – Local Practices, State Responses and Tenure Security in Africa, Asia and Latin America, Leiden University Press, Leiden.
53.
von Benda-BeckmannF. (2003), ‘Mysteries of capital or mystifications of legal property?’Focaal, Vol 41, pp 187–191.
54.
von Benda-BeckmannK.von Benda-BeckmannF.WiberM.G. (2006), ‘The properties of property’, in von Benda-BeckmannF.von Benda-BeckmannK.WiberM.G., eds, Changing Properties of Property, Berghahn Books, New York, pp 1–39.
55.
WinayantiL. (2011), Community Struggles for Land in Jakarta, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
56.
WinayantiL.LangH.C. (2004), ‘Provision of urban services in an informal settlement: A case study of Kampung Penas Tanggul, Jakarta’, Habitat International, Vol 28, No 1, pp 41–65.
