Network Functions of Travel Marts in China: Amendments to the Rosson and Seringhaus Network Model

Abstract

The two-dimensional network model proposed by Rosson and Seringhaus in 1995 was a key achievement in the study of trade fair functions. The model incorporates both exhibitor–visitor interactions and the multi-level functions of trade fairs and has attracted considerable scholarly attention. It is based on the case of Western market-oriented trade fairs in which material objects are displayed. However, the model is unable to explain certain aspects of China's travel marts, which are strongly controlled by the government and where the only exhibits are intangible services. Another of the model's shortcomings is that it is limited to two-dimensional exhibitor–visitor interactions. This study tests, complements and amends the Rosson Seringhaus network model for the special case of China. The authors investigate the differences between travel marts and traditional trade fairs, and amend several parts of the model, taking the China International Travel Mart (CITM) and China National Travel Mart (CNTM) as case studies. In light of their analysis, they propose an important amendment to the Rosson Seringhaus model, revising the relationship network, the network boundaries and the multiple participant identities. In addition, they find that the relationship network in a travel mart is much wider and more complex than that in a traditional trade fair, leading to greater complexity and diversification in the functions of a travel mart. Finally, they find that, in a three-dimensional exhibitor–visitor–organizer network, the overlap between identities and network expansion results in a highly complex interaction among stakeholders. Consequently, it is difficult for organizers and exhibitors to handle a travel mart successfully and improve the effectiveness of their trade fair participation.

Keywords

Rosson–Seringhaus network model travel marts trade fairs travel fair organization network function China

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bellizzi

J.A.

Lipps

D. J.

(1984), Managerial guidelines for trade show effectiveness, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol 13, pp 49–52.

Bello

Lohtia

(1993), Improving trade show effectiveness by analysing attendees, Industrial marketing management, Vol 22, No 4, pp 311–318.

Blythe

(2009), ‘Trade fairs as communication: A new model’, Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, Vol 25, No 1, pp 57–62.

Chang

H.L.

Sang

Y.K.

(2008), ‘Differential effects of determinants on multi-dimensions of trade show performance: By three stages of pre-show, at-show, and post-show activities’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol 37, No 7, pp 784–796.

Gopalakrishna

Lilien

G.L.

Williams

J.D.

Sequeira

I.K.

(1995a), ‘Do trade shows pay off?’, Journal of Marketing, Vol 59, pp 75–83.

Gopalakrishna

Lilien

(1995b), ‘A three-stage model of industrial trade shows performance’, Marketing Science, Vol 14, pp 22–42.

Hansen

(1999), ‘Trade show performance: A conceptual framework and its implications for future research’, Academy of Marketing Science Review, Vol 8, pp 1–14.

Herbig

Palumbo

O'Hara

(1996), ‘Differences in trade show behavior between manufacturers and service-oriented firms’, Journal of Professional Services Marketing, Vol 14, No 2, pp 55–78.

Kerin

R.A.

Cron

W.L.

(1987), ‘Assessing trade show functions and performance: An exploratory study’, Journal of Marketing, Vol 51, No 3, pp 87–94.

10.

L.-Y.

(2006), ‘Relationship learning at trade shows: Its antecedents and consequences’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol 35, No 2, pp 166–177.

11.

Luo

Bao

(2007), ‘Study on visitors objectives of attending exhibitions and its categories – a case study of Dongguan international machinery and materials exhibition’, Journal of Guilin Institute of Tourism, Vol 18, No 5, pp 731–735.

12.

O'Hara

B.S.

Herbig

P.A.

(1993), ‘Trade shows: What do the exhibitors think’, Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, Vol 8, No 4, pp 18–25.

13.

Poorani

(1996), ‘Trade-show management: Budgeting and planning for a successful event’, Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Vol 37, No 4, pp 77–84.

14.

Rinallo

Borghini

Golfetto

(2010), ‘Exploring visitor experiences at trade shows’, Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, Vol 25, No 4, pp 249–258.

15.

Rosson

Seringhaus

F.H.

(1995), ‘Visitor and exhibitor interaction at industrial trade fairs’, Journal of Business Research, Vol 32, pp 81–90.

16.

Sharland

Balogh

(1996), ‘The value of nonselling activities at international trade shows’, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol 25, pp 59–66.

17.

Skolnik

(1987), ‘Getting the brass to take trade shows seriously’, Sales and Marketing Management, Vol 139, No 10, pp 99–102.

18.

Chunyan

Wang

Xinkang

Chen

(2008), ‘Literature review on trade show performance and the prospect of localized study in China’, Foreign Economics and Management, Vol 30, No 7, pp 33–35.

19.

Whitfield

Webber

D.J.

(2010), ‘Which exhibition attributes create repeat visitation?’, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol 30, No 2, pp 1–9.

20.

Lingyun

Zhang

(2002), ‘A new opinion on tourism: An illusory theory on sustainable tourism development – with the example of experiences of tourism industry development in China’, Journal of PLA University of Foreign Languages, No 6, pp 13–21.