Wage Differentials and Their Determinants in US Tourism and Tourism-Associated Industries

Abstract

This paper examines variations in wages for tourism and tourism-associated industries in the USA for the period 2004–2009. It critically assesses the extent to which tourism and tourism-associated activities conform to their low-wage stereotype and finds this to be true in general, but not universally. It then considers the possibility that wages in US tourism and tourism-associated industries can be explained by observable characteristics of these industries. Recent research suggests that the use of wage data at the level of highly detailed occupations is an effective alternative to other ways of capturing underlying skill differences. Accordingly, data from the US Occupational Employment Statistics (OES) were used to provide this detail. The results strongly support the importance of difference in wages between occupations in understanding differences between industries. They also support the importance of a number of industry characteristics, including profitability, multi-factor productivity and demand growth. The paper also considers the relevance of an industry wage premium or discount for tourism and tourism-associated activities in the USA over the same period. It estimates an industry wage model separately for five individual occupations across all industries that employ for the occupation concerned. The analysis shows that workers in the two more highly paid occupations exhibit evidence of a tourism and tourism-associated discount but that workers in the three more lowly paid occupations exhibit a tourism and tourism-associated wage premium.

Keywords

wages occupations tourism industry skills US tourism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abowd

J.M.

Kramarz

Margolis

D.N.

(2003), ‘High wage workers and high wage firms’, Econometrica, Vol 67, No 2, pp 251–333.

Abraham

K.G.

Spletzer

J.R.

(2010), ‘Are the new jobs good jobs?’, in Abraham

K.G.

Spletzer

J.R.

Harper

, eds, Labor in the New Economy, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, pp 102–143.

Aiyar

Dalgaard

C.-J.

(2005), ‘Total factor productivity revisited: A dual approach to development accounting’, IMF Staff Papers, Vol 52, pp 82–102.

Andrews

Schank

Upward

(2006), ‘Practical fixed-effects estimation methods for the three-way error-components model’, Stata Journal, Vol 6, No 4, pp 461–481.

Barros

C.P.

Santos

C.M.

(2009), ‘Earnings of hotel managers: Comparing the human and social capital approach’, Tourism Economics, Vol 15, No 1, pp 87–103.

Bernard

Redding

Schott

Simpson

(2008), ‘Relative wage variation and industry location in the United Kingdom’, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, Vol 70, pp 431–459.

Blake

Arbache

J.S.

Sinclair

M.T.

Teles

(2008), ‘Tourism and poverty relief’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 35, pp 107–126.

Blanchflower

D.G.

Oswald

A.J.

Sanfey

(1996), ‘Wages, profits, and rent-sharing’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol 111, No 1, pp 227–251.

Ritchie

J.B. Brent

Molinar

C.M.A.

Frechtling

D.C.

(2010). ‘Impacts of the world recession and economic crisis on tourism: North America’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 49, No 1, pp 5–15.

10.

Campos-Soria

J.A.

Ortega-Aguaza

Ropero-Garcia

M.A.

(2009), ‘Gender segregation and wage difference in the hospitality industry’, Tourism Economics, Vol 15, No 4, pp 847–866.

11.

Chen

Edin

P.-A.

(2002), ‘Efficiency wages and inter-industry wage differentials: A comparison across methods of pay’, Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol 84, pp 617–631.

12.

Choy

(1995), ‘The quality of tourism employment’, Tourism Management, Vol 16, pp 129–137.

13.

Daniels

M.J.

Norman

W.C.

Henry

M.S.

(2004), ‘Estimating income effects of a sport tourism event’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 31, No 1, pp 180–199.

14.

Santos

L. Delfim

Varejão

(2007), ‘Employment, pay and discrimination in the tourism industry’, Tourism Economics, Vol 13, pp 225–240.

15.

Dickens

Katz

L.F.

(1987), ‘Inter-industry wage differences and theories of wage determination’, NBER working paper No 2271.

16.

Du Caju

Lamo

Poelhekke

Kátay

Nicolitsas

(2010), ‘Inter industry wage differentials in EU countries: What do cross country time varying data add to the picture?’, Journal of the European Economic Association, Vol 8, Nos 2–3, pp 478–486.

17.

Du Caju

Rycx

Tojerow

(2011), ‘Inter industry wage differentials: How much does rent sharing matter?’, The Manchester School, Vol 79, No 4, pp 691–717.

18.

Fletcher

(1989) ‘Input–output analysis and tourism impact studies’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 16, pp 514–529.

19.

Gibbons

Katz

(1992), ‘Does unmeasured ability explain inter-industry wage differentials’, Review of Economic Studies, Vol 59, pp 515–535.

20.

Girma

Gorg

(2007), ‘Evaluating the foreign ownership wage premium using a difference-in differences matching approach’, Journal of International Economics, Vol 72, pp 97–112.

21.

Gould

E.D.

(2002), ‘Rising wage inequality, comparative advantage, and the growing importance of general skills in the United States’, Journal of Labor Economics, Vol 20, pp 105–147.

22.

Heyman

Sjöholm

Tingvall

P.G.

(2007), ‘Is there really a foreign ownership wage premium? Evidence from matched employer–employee data’, Journal of International Economics, Vol 73, No 2, pp 355–376.

23.

Hibbs

Locking

(2000), ‘Wage dispersion and productive efficiency: Evidence for Sweden’, Journal of Labor Economics, Vol 18, pp 755–782.

24.

Jones

J.I.

(2009), ‘What do OES data have to say about increasing wage inequality?’, Monthly Labor Review, Vol 132, pp 39–49.

25.

Krueger

Summers

(1988), ‘Efficiency wages and the inter-industry wage structure’, Econometrica, Vol 56, pp 259–293.

26.

Lane

J.I.

Salmon

L.A.

Spletzer

J.R.

(2007), ‘Establishment wage differentials’, Monthly Labor Review, Vol 130, pp 3–17.

27.

Lillo-Banuls

Casado-Diaz

(2010), ‘Rewards to education in the tourism sector: One step ahead’, Tourism Economics, Vol 16, No 1, pp 11–23.

28.

Lundin

Yun

(2009), ‘International trade and inter industry wage structure in Swedish manufacturing: Evidence from matched employer–employee data’, Review of International Economics, Vol 17, No 1, pp 87–102.

29.

Machin

(2008), ‘An appraisal of economic research on changes in wage inequality’, Labour, Vol 22, pp 7–26.

30.

Marchante

A.J.

Ortega

Pagan

(2005), ‘Educational mismatch and wages in the hospitality sector’, Tourism Economics, Vol 11, No 1, pp 103–117.

31.

Martins

(2004), ‘Industry wage premia: Evidence from the wage distribution’, Economics Letters, Vol 83, pp 157–163.

32.

Maskus

Sveikauskus

Webster

(1994), ‘The composition of the human capital stock and its relation to international trade: Evidence from the US and Britain’, Review of World Economics, Vol 130, pp 50–76.

33.

Mincer

(1974), Schooling, Experience and Earnings, Columbia University Press, New York.

34.

Muñoz-Bullón

(2009), ‘The gap between male and female pay in the Spanish tourism industry’, Tourism Management, Vol 30, No 5, pp 638–649.

35.

Osburn

(2000), ‘Interindustry wage differentials: Patterns and possible sources’, Monthly Labor Review, Vol 123, pp 34–46.

36.

Sicherman

Bartel

, (1999), ‘Technological change and wages: An inter-industry analysis’, Journal of Political Economy, Vol 107, pp 285–325.

37.

Szivas

Riley

Airey

(2003), ‘Labor mobility into tourism: Attraction and satisfaction’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 30, pp 64–76.

38.

Thrane

(2008), ‘Earnings differentiation in the tourism industry: Gender, human capital and socio-demographic effects’, Tourism Management, Vol 29, No 3, pp 514–524.

39.

Thrane

(2010), ‘Education and earnings in the tourism industry the role of sheepskin effects’, Tourism Economics, Vol 16, No 3, pp 549–563.

40.

Zemanek

S.L.

(2012), ‘US travel and tourism satellite accounts for 2003–2011’, Survey of Current Business, June, pp 19–27.