A Least-Cost Optimisation Model of C02 Capture Applied to Major UK Power Plants Within The EU-ETS Framework

Abstract

Concerns about the cost of CO2 capture and sequestration, and the effectiveness of carbon abatement policies loom large in discussions on climate change mitigation. Several writers address the issue from various perspectives. This paper attempts to add relative realism to discussions on CO2 capture costs, and, the deployment of carbon capture technology in the UK by using publicly available company data on the long term capacity expansion and CO2 capture investment programmes of selected power plants in the UK. With an estimated £8 billion plan to install a generation capacity of 11 GW and capture capability of 44 MtCO/year, it is imperative to optimise this huge potential investment. A least-cost optimisation model was formulated and solved with the LP algorithm available in GAMS. The model was then applied to address a number of issues, including the choice of an optimal carbon abatement policy within the EU-ETS framework. The major findings of the study include (a) the long term total cost curve of CO2 capture has three phases - rising, plateau, rising; (b) alternative capture technologies do not have permanent relative cost advantages or disadvantages; (c) Government incentives encourage carbon capture and the avoidance of emission penalty charges; and (d) the goals of EU-ETS are more effectively realised with deeper cuts in the EUA ratios than merely hiking the emission penalty, as proposed in EU-ETS Phase II.

Keywords

Least cost optimisation model CO2 capture UK Electricity production EU-ETS Carbon capture technology

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chalmers

Chee

Lucquiaud

Gibbins

Strbac

(2006). Initial Evaluation of Carbon Capture Plant Flexibility, Presented at 8th International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies, 19th - 23 rd June 2006, Trondheim, Norway, www.ghgt8.no.

Davison

(2006). Performance and Costs of Power Plants with Capture and Storage of C02, Energy (2006). doi:10.1016/j.energy.2006.07.039.

Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) (formerly Department for Trade and Industry (DTI)) . (2004). Implementing a Demonstration of Enhanced Oil Recovery Using Carbon Dioxide, London, UK.

DBERR , (2007). Development of a CO2 Transport and Storage Network in the North Sea, Report to the North Sea Basin Task Force, London, UK.

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) (2006). EU Emissions Trading Scheme, UK National Allocation Plan, 2008-2012, August 2006, p.32.

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) . (2007a). UK Biomass Strategy, Working Paper 3—Anaerobic Digestion, May 2007.

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) . (2007b). EU Emissions Trading Scheme, Approved Phase I National Allocation Plan, 2008-2012.

Department of Energy and Environment Protection Agency (DEEPA) . (2006). Carbon Dioxide Emissions from the Generation of Electric Power in the United States, Washington DC, USA, October 1999.

Doosan (formerly Mitsui) Babcock Energy Limited , (2006a). Carbon Capture and Storage: An Industry Perspective.

10.

Doosan (formerly Mitsui) Babcock Energy Limited , (2006b). Clean Coal Technology and the Energy Review http://www.doosanbabcock.com/energyreview/clean%20coal%20energy%20review.pdf .

11.

Drax Power Limited (2006). Coal: Fuelling Our Future Generation, Selby, April 2006.

12.

European Union (2003). Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003, Brussels, Belgium.

13.

European Union (2005). EU Emissions Trading - An Open Scheme Promoting Global Innovation, Brussels, Belgium.

14.

Gibbins

(2006a). Response by the UKCCSC to the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee on Meeting UK Energy and Climate Needs: The Role of Carbon Capture and Storage, London, February 2006.

15.

Gibbins

(2006b). Response by the UKCCSC to HM Treasury Consultation on Barriers to Commercial Deployment of CCS, March 2006.

16.

Georgopoulou

Sarafidis

Mirasgedis

Lalas

D.P.

, (2006). Next Allocation Phase of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme: How Tough Will the Future Be? Energy Policy, 34 (2006) 4002-4023.

17.

Guardian (2007). Energy Firms Seek £1bn for Carbon Capture Projects, http://business.guardian.co.uk/print/0,,330158495-125104,00.html July 9, 2007.

18.

HM Treasury (2006). The Climate Change Levy Package, London, March 2006.

19.

IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (IEA GHG) . (2006). Estimating Future Trends in the Cost of CO2 Capture Technologies, 2006/5, January 2006.

20.

IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (IEA GHG) . (2007). Capturing CO2, May 2007, ISBN 978-1-898373-41-4. 2

21.

IPCC (2005). IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

22.

Jones

, (2005). Clean Coal - A Contradiction in Terms or a Real Sustainable Power Generation Output? Presented at the 54th BCURA Robens Coal Science Lecture at The Royal Institution, October 10, 2005.

23.

Kemp

A.G.

Kasim

(2006). Developing A Supply Curve for CO2 Capture, Sequestration and EOR in the UKCS: An Optimized Least-cost Analytical Framework, North Sea Study Occasional Paper Number 102, Department of Economics, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK.

24.

Kemp

A.G.

Kasim

(2007). A Least-Cost Optimisation Model for CO2 Capture, North Sea Study Occasional Paper Number 107, Department of Economics, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK.

25.

Kemp

A.G.

Swierzbinski

(2007). Long-Term Option Contracts for Carbon Emissions, North Sea Occasional Paper No. 105, Department of Economics, Business School, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK.

26.

Leci

C.L.

(1996). Financial Implications on Power Generation Costs Resulting from the Parasitic Effect of CO2 Capture Using Liquid Scrubbing Technology from Power Station Flue Gases, Energy Conversions Management, 37, 6-8, pp 915-921.

27.

NERA Economic Consulting , (2005). Methodology for Measuring CO2 Pass Through, December 2005.

28.

Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (OFGEM) . (2007). Reform of the Renewables Obligation 2006: Ofgem’s response, Ref: 11/07 p. 16.

29.

Pelster

Favrat

D., von Spakovsky

, (2001). The Thermoeconomic and Environomic Modelling and Optimization of the Synthesis, Design, and Operation of Combined Cycles With Advanced Options, Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, 123, pp 717-726.

30.

Point Carbon (2007). Daily Closing Prices for EU Allowances (vintage 2007 and 2008) and Delivery Volumes, Commodities Now, 11(2). June 2007 p.34.

31.

Rubin

E.S.

Yeh

Antes

Berkenpas

Davison

(2007). Use of Experience Curves to Estimate the Future Cost of Power Plants with CO2 Capture, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 1(2007) pp 188-197.

32.

RWE (2007). Annual Report, 2006.

33.

Scottish and Southern Energy (SSE) . (2007). SSE Preliminary Results for the Year to 31 March 2007, Perth, UK.

34.

Scottish Power (2005). Environmental Performance Report 2004/05, Glasgow.

35.

Scottish Power (2007). Scottish Power Plans Europe’s Biggest Clean Project, Press Release, May 2007, Glasgow.

36.

Wall T . (2007). Combustion Processes for Carbon Capture, Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 31 (2007).

37.

Yeh

Rubin

S., (2007). A Centurial History of Technological Change and Learning Curves for Pulverized Coal-fired Utility Boilers, Energy, 32 (2007) 1996-2005.