Quality of life (QoL) has become a mainstay in the outcome assessment of pediatric solid-organ transplant recipients. Yet, how QoL is operationalized and measured varies drastically. It may be very difficult for clinicians and researchers to determine which methods of QoL assessment best meet the needs of their patients or study. The purpose of this literature review is to describe and evaluate the current status of QoL measurement in studies of pediatric solid-organ transplant recipients.
Data Sources
Searches of PubMed and PsycINFO from January 1985 to February 2012.
Study Selection
English peer-reviewed publications that described a method for measuring QoL whether it was a standardized questionnaire, qualitative approach, or another way of operationalizing the construct.
Data Extraction
QoL measurement strategies were extracted from 43 studies that met inclusion criteria.
Data Synthesis
Each article was reviewed and summarized by 2 study team members.
Conclusions
Many different strategies were used for measurement, and some were not consistent with established conceptualizations of QoL. Overall recommendations for best practices are offered. Detailed information about specific measures is included, and measures that seem to capture the construct well are recommended. Additionally, our review highlighted the importance of using a “battery approach,” including child and parent report as well as considering other variables, such as patient's age, when selecting a QoL measurement strategy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ShneiderBLVockleyJMazariegosGV. Trading places: Liver transplantation as a treatment, not a cure, for metabolic liver disease. Liver Transplant.2011;17(6):628–630.
2.
KronstenVFitzpatrickEBakerA. Management of cholestatic pruritus in paediatric patients with alagille syndrome: The King's College Hospital Experience. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr.2013;57(2):149–154.
3.
AnthonySJBar-ZivPollock SLee NgVL. Quality of life after pediatric solid organ transplantation. Pediatr Clin North Am.2010;57(2):559–574.
4.
World Health Organization. WHO Definition of Health. Preamble to the Constitution of the World Health Organization as Adopted by the International Health Conference, New York, 19–22 June, 1946. Signed on 22 July 1946 and Entered Into Force on 7 April 1948. http://www.who.int/governance/eb/who_constitution_en.pdf. Accessed July 9, 2014.
5.
NixonPAMorrisKA. Quality of life in pediatric heart, heart-lung and lung transplant recipients. Int J Sports Med.2000;21(suppl 2):S109–S112.
6.
VarniJWLimbersCABurwinkleTM. Impaired health-related quality of life in children and adolescents with chronic conditions: A comparative analysis of 10 disease clusters and 33 disease categories/severities utilizing the PedsQL 4.0 Generic Core Scales. Health Qual Life Outcomes.2007;5:43.
7.
VarniJWSeidMKurtinPS. PedsQL 4.0: Reliability and validity of the Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory version 4.0 generic core scales in healthy and patient populations. Med Care.2001;39(8):800–812.
8.
HealthActCHQ. Child Health Questionnaire Scoring and Interpretation Manual.Cambridge, MA: HealthActCHQ Inc; 2008.
9.
HullmannSERyanJLRamseyRRChaneyJMMullinsLL. Measures of general pediatric quality of life: Child Health Questionnaire (CHQ), DISABKIDS Chronic Generic Measure (DCGM), KINDL-R, Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL) 4.0 Generic Core Scales, and Quality of My Life Questionnaire (QoML). Arthrit Care Res.2011;63(suppl 11):S420–30. doi:10.1002/acr.20637.
10.
LandgrafJMAbetzL. Functional status and well-being of children representing three cultural groups: Initial self-reports using the CHQ-CF87. Psychol Health.1997;12(6):839–854.
11.
WareJESnowKKKosinskiMGandekB. SF-36 Health Survey. Manual and Interpretation Guide.Boston, MA: The Health Institute, New England Medical Center; 1993.
12.
TsaiCBaylissMWareJ. SF-36 Health Survey Annotated Bibliography.2nd ed.Boston, MA: Health Assessment Lab, New England Medical Center; 1997.
13.
AlonsoEM. Quality of life for pediatric liver recipients. Liver Transplant.2009;15(suppl):S57–S62.
14.
TaylorRFranckLSGibsonFDhawanA. A critical review of the health-related quality of life of children and adolescents after liver transplantation. Liver Transplant.2005;11:51–60.
15.
NobiliVAlisiAPietrobattistaA. Psychosocial condition after liver transplantation in children: Review of the literature from 2006 to 2008. Transplant Proc.2009;41:3779–3783.
16.
Weissberg-BenchellJZielinskiTERodgersS. Pediatric health-related quality of life: Feasibility, reliability and validity of the PedsQL transplant module. Am J Transplant.2010;10:1677–1685.
17.
BucuvalasJCBrittoMKrugS. Health-related quality of life in pediatric liver transplant recipients: A single-center study. Liver Transplant.2003;9(1):62–71.
18.
KosolaSLampelaHLauronenJ. General health, health-related quality of life and sexual health after pediatric liver transplantation: A nationwide study. Am J Transplant.2012;12(2):420–427.
19.
NgVLAlonsoEMBucuvalasJC. Health status of children alive 10 Years after pediatric liver transplantation performed in the US and Canada: Report of the studies of pediatric liver transplantation experience. J Pediatr.2012;160(5):820–826.
20.
SundaramSSLandgrafJMNeighborsKCohnRAAlonsoEM. Adolescent health-related quality of life following liver and kidney transplantation. Am J Transplant.2007;7(4):982–989.
21.
FredericksEMDore-StitesDCalderonSY. Relationship between sleep problems and health-related quality of life among pediatric liver transplant recipients. Liver Transplant.2012;18(6):707–715.
22.
AnthonySJHerbertDToddL. Child and parental perspectives of multidimensional quality of life outcomes after kidney transplantation. Pediatr Transplant.2010;14(2):249–256.
23.
FredericksEMMageeJCOpipari-ArriganLShieckVWellALopezMJ. Adherence and health-related quality of life in adolescent liver transplant recipients. Pediatr Transplant.2008;12(3):289–299.
AlonsoEMNeighborsKBartonFB. Health-related quality of life and family function following pediatric liver transplantation. Liver Transplant.2008;14(4):460–468.
26.
NgoKDFarmerDGMcDiarmidSV. Pediatric health-related quality of life after intestinal transplantation. Pediatr Transplant.2011;15(8):849–854.
27.
SudanDHorlsenSBothaJ. Quality of life after pediatric intestinal transplantation: The perception of pediatric recipients and their parents. Am J Transplant.2004;4(3):407–413.
28.
SudanDLIversonAWisemanRA. Assessment of function, growth and development, and long-term quality of life after small bowel transplantation. Transplant Proc.2000;32(6):1211–1212.
29.
ChiuMCNgCFLeeLPLaiWMLauSC. Automated peritoneal dialysis in children and adolescents—benefits: A survey of patients and parents on health-related quality of life. Perit Dial Int.2007;27(suppl 2):S138–S142.
30.
ParkKSHwangYJChoMH. Quality of life in children with end-stage renal disease based on a PedsQL ESRD module. Pediatr Nephrol.2012;27(12):2293–2300.
31.
UzarkKGriffinLRodriguezR. Quality of life in pediatric heart transplant recipients: A comparison with children with and without heart disease. J Heart Lung Transplant.2012;31(6):571–578.
32.
FredericksEMLopezMJMageeJCShieckVOpipari-ArriganL. Psychological functioning, nonadherence and health outcomes after pediatric liver transplantation. Am J Transplant.2007;7(8):1974–1983.
33.
SanchezCEymannADe CuntoCD'AgostinoD. Quality of life in pediatric liver transplantation in a single-center in South America. Pediatr Transplant.2010;14(3):332–336.
34.
LimbersCANeighborsKMartzK. Health-related quality of life in pediatric liver transplant recipients compared with other chronic disease groups. Pediatr Transplant.2011;15(3):245–253.
35.
DisethTHTangeraasTReinfjellTBjerreA. Kidney transplantation in childhood: Mental health and quality of life of children and caregivers. Pediatr Nephrol.2011;26(10):1881–1892.
36.
HamiwkaLACantwellMCrawfordSClarkCG. Physical activity and health related quality of life in children following kidney transplantation. Pediatr Transplant.2009;13(7):861–867.
37.
MohammadSHormazaLNeighborsK. Health status in young adults two decades after pediatric liver transplantation. Am J Transplant.2012;12(6):1486–1495.
38.
VarniJLimbersCSorensonL. PedsQL™ Cognitive Functioning Scale in pediatric liver transplant recipients: Feasibility, reliability, and validity. Qual Life Res.2011;20(6):913–921.
39.
DevineKAReed-KnightBLoiselleKASimonsLEMeeLLBlountRL. Predictors of long-term health-related quality of life in adolescent solid organ transplant recipients. J Pediatr Psychol.2011;36(8):891–901.
40.
DuffyJPKaoKKoCY. Long-term patient outcome and quality of life after liver transplantation: Analysis of 20-year survivors. Ann Surg.2010;252(4):652–661.
41.
HasegawaAOshimaSTakahashiKUchidaKItoKSonodaT. Improvement of quality of life in tacrolimus-based pediatric renal transplant recipients and their caregivers, including donors. Transplant Proc.2005;37(4):1771–1773.
42.
PetroskiRAGradyKLRodgersS. Quality of life in adult survivors greater than 10 years after pediatric heart transplantation. J Heart Lung Transplant.2009;28(7):661–666.
43.
BuyanNTurkmenMABilgeI. Quality of life in children with chronic kidney disease (with child and parent assessments). Pediatr Nephrol.2010;25(8):1487–1496.
44.
MidgleyDEBradleeTADonohoeCKentKPAlonsoEM. Health-related quality of life in long-term survivors of pediatric liver transplantation. Liver Transplant.2000;6(3):333–339.
45.
ChinSEShepherdRWCleghornGJ. Survival, growth and quality of life in children after orthotopic liver transplantation: A 5 year experience. J Paediatr Child Health.1991;27(6):380–385.
46.
QvistENrhiVApajasaloM. Psychosocial adjustment and quality of life after renal transplantation in early childhood. Pediatr Transplant.2004;8(2):120–125.
47.
ApajasaloMRautonenJHolmbergC. Quality of life in pre-adolescence: A 17-dimensional health-related measure (17D). Qual Life Res.1996;5(6):532–538.
48.
El-HusseiniAHassanRSobhMGhoneimM. The effects of gender on health-related quality of life in pediatric live-donor kidney transplantation: A single-center experience in a developing country. Pediatr Transplant.2010;14(2):188–195.
49.
Riano-GalanIMalagaSRajmilL. Quality of life of adolescents with end-stage renal disease and kidney transplant. Pediatr Nephrol.2009;24(8):1561–1568.
50.
MorelPAlmondPSMatasAJ. Long-term quality of life after kidney transplantation in childhood. Transplantation.1991;52(1):47–53.
51.
StoneRDBeasleyPJTreacySJTwenteAWVacantiJP. Children and families can achieve normal psychological adjustment and a good quality of life following pediatric liver transplantation: A long-term study. Transplant Proc.1997;29(1–2):1571–1572.
52.
OhkohchiNOriiTKawagishiNSatomiS. Quality of life of pediatric patients receiving living donor liver transplantation in long-term follow-up period. Transplant Proc.2001;33(7):3610–3613.
53.
NicholasDBOtleyARTaylorRDhawanAGilmourSNgVL. Experiences and barriers to Health-Related Quality of Life following liver transplantation: A qualitative analysis of the perspectives of pediatric patients and their parents. Health Qual Life Outcomes.2010;8:150. doi:1186/1477-7525-8-150.
54.
DommerguesJPLetierceAGravereauLPlainguetFBernardODebrayD. Current lifestyle of young adults after liver transplantation during childhood. Am J Transplant.2010;10(7):1634–1642.
55.
OlaussonBHanssonSWennerstromMOlaussonMFrimanS. Quality of life after paediatric kidney transplantation: A single-centre experience. Transplant Proc.2001;33(4):2446–2448.
56.
QvistEJalankoHHolmbergC. Psychosocial adaptation after solid organ transplantation in children. Pediatr Clin North Am.2003;50(6):1505–1519.
57.
LaRosaCBaluarteHJMeyersKEC. Outcomes in pediatric solid organ transplantation. Pediatr Transplant.2011;15(2):128–141. doi: 10.1542/peds.2010-1232.
58.
AnnunziatoRAFisherMKJersonBBochkanovaAShawRJ. Psychosocial assessment prior to pediatric transplantation: A review and summary of key considerations. Pediatr Transplant.2010;14(5):565–574.
