Development of the Personal Qualities Assessment as a Tool for Selecting Medical Students

Abstract

A review of the medical student selection literature and our own past research (Lowe, Kerridge, Bore, Munro and Powis (2001) has indicated that competent and ethical practice of medicine requires doctors to possess a range of personal qualities in addition to high-level academic ability. A three-part test battery called the Personal Qualities Assessment (PQA) has been developed as a measure of some of these qualities: it consists of the Mental Agility Test (MAT), which measures cognitive skills, the Mojac scale, which measures moral orientation, and the NACE scale, which measures Narcissism, Aloofness, Confidence and Empathy. Five hundred and seven applicants for entry in October 2003 to the Scottish medical schools volunteered to complete the MAT, Mojac and NACE tests in January 2003. The test results played no part in making or informing selection decisions. The scores obtained by the candidates on each test covered a wide range, indicating that each test component has good discriminating power. Correlations between the test components were low (−0.02 to +0.17), indicating that they each measure different attributes. Since the test results were not used in making selection decisions it will be possible to relate outcome indices (e.g., examination and professional performance as the students progress through medical school) to the test component scores to seek evidence for the predictive validity of the PQA battery and thereby indicate its potential usefulness as a selection tool.

Keywords

medical education psychometric testing access selection personal qualities

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altemeyer

(1981) Right-Wing Authoritarianism, Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press.

Best

(1989) ‘The politics of the sand pit’, Medical Journal of Australia, vol 150, pp 158–61.

Bore

M R

Munro

Kerridge

Powis

D A

(2005a) ‘Selection of medical students according to their moral orientation’, Medical Education, (in press).

Bore

M R

Munro

Kerridge

Powis

D A

(2005b) ‘Not moral “reasoning”: A Libertarian-Communitarian dimension of moral orientation and Schwartz's value types’, Australian Journal of Psychology, vol 57(1), pp 49–60.

Bore

M R

(2001) ‘The psychology of morality: A Libertarian-Communitarian dimension and a dissonance model of moral decision making’, Doctoral dissertation, The University of Newcastle, Australia.

Campbell

E F

Rank

B K

Sinclair

A J M

(1974) ‘Selection of medical students – a burning question’, Medical Journal of Australia, vol 1, pp 785–9.

Cattell

R B

Cattell

A K

Cattell

H E

(1993) Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire, Fifth Edition, Champaign, IL, Institute for Personality and Ability Testing, Inc.

Editorial (1984) ‘Medical student selection in the UK’, Lancet, November 24, pp 1190–91.

Eysenck

S B G

Eysenck

H J

Barrett

(1985) ‘A revised version of the Psychoticism scale’, Personality and Individual Differences, vol 6, pp 21–9.

10.

Ferguson

James

Madely

(2002) ‘Factors associated with success in medical school: Systematic review of the literature’, British Medical Journal, vol 324, pp 952–7.

11.

Goldberg

L R

(1990) ‘An alternative “description of personality”: The big-five factor structure’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol 59, pp 1216–29.

12.

Goldberg

L R

(2000) The development of five factor domain scales from the IPIP item pool Available at www.ipip.ori.org/.

13.

Lockhart

L B

(1981) ‘Why aren't they choosing the right candidates for medicine?’ Lancet, March 7, pp 546–8.

14.

Lowe

Kerridge

Bore

Munro

Powis

D A

(2001) ‘Is it possible to assess the “ethics” of medical school applicants?’ Journal of Medical Ethics, vol 27, pp 404–8.

15.

Lumsden

M A

Bore

Millar

Jack

Powis

(2005) ‘The assessment of personal qualities in relation to admission to medical school’, Medical Education, vol 39, pp 258–65.

16.

McManus

I C

Smithers

Partridge

Keeling

Fleming

P R

(2003) ‘A-levels and intelligence as predictors of medical careers in UK doctors: 20 year prospective study’, British Medical Journal, vol 327, pp 139–42.

17.

Munro

(1998) ‘Assessing interpersonal sensitivity in a professional context: Some initial indicators’, Australian Journal of Psychology, vol 50, 1998 Supplement, p 106.

18.

Munro

Bore

M R

Powis

D A

(2005) ‘Personality factors in professional ethical behaviour: Studies of empathy and narcissism’, Australian Journal of Psychology, vol 57(1), pp 38–48.

19.

Schwartz

S H

(1992) ‘Universals in the content and structure of values: Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries’, Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, vol 25, pp 1–65.