The Utility of Direct-Current as Compared to Frequency Domain Measurements in Spectrally-Constrained Diffuse Optical Tomography toward Cancer Imaging

Abstract

This work investigates, by means of analytical and simulation studies, the performance of spectrally-constrained image reconstruction in Continuous-Wave or Direct-Current (DC) and Frequency Domain (FD) near-infrared optical tomography. A recent analytic approach for estimating the accuracy of target recovery and the level of background artifact for optical tomography at single wavelength, based on the analysis of parametric reconstruction uncertainty level (PRUL), is extended to spectrally-constrained optical tomography. The analytical model is implemented to rank three sets of wavelengths that had been used as spectral prior in an independent experimental study. Subsequent simulation appraises the recovery of oxygenated hemoglobin (HbO), deoxygenated hemoglobin (Hb), water (H₂O), scattering amplitude (A), and scattering power (b) using DC-only, DC-excluded FD, and DC-included FD, based on the three sets of wavelengths as the spectral prior. The simulation results support the analytic ranking of the performance of the three sets of spectral priors, and generally agree with the performance outcome of DC-only versus that of DC-excluded FD and DC-included FD. Specifically, this study indicate that: 1) the rank of overall quality of chromophore recovery is Hb, H₂O, and HbO from the highest to lowest; and in the scattering part the A is always better recovered than b. This outcome does suggest that the DC-only information gives rise to unique solution to the image reconstruction routine under the given spectral prior. 2) DC-information is not-redundant in FD-reconstruction, as the artifact levels of DC-included FD reconstruction are always lower than those of DC-excluded FD. 3) The artifact level as represented by the noise-to-contrast-ratio is almost always the lowest in DC-only, leading to generally better resolution of multiple targets of identical contrasts over the background than in FD. However, the FD could outperform DC in the recovery of scattering properties including both A and b when the spectral prior is less optimal, implying the benefit of phase-information in scattering recovery in the context of spectrally-constrained optical tomography.

Keywords

Optical tomography Image reconstruction Frequency-domain Continuous-wave

References

Tromberg

B. J.

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

Yodh

A. G.

Boas

D. A.

Cerussi

A. E.

Assessing the future of diffuse optical imaging technologies for breast cancer management. Medical Physics 35, 2443–2451 (2008).

Corlu

Durduran

Choe

Schweiger

Hillman

E. M. C.

Arridge

S. R.

Yodh

A. G.

Uniqueness and wavelength optimization in continuous-wave multispectral diffuse optical tomography. Opt Lett 28, 2339–2341 (2003).

Srinivasan

Pogue

B. W.

Jiang

Dehghani

Paulsen

K. D.

Spectrally constrained chromophore and scattering near-infrared tomography provides quantitative and robust reconstruction. Appl Opt 44, 1858–1869 (2005).

Zhang

Culver

J. P.

Miller

E. L.

Boas

D. A.

Reconstructing chromosphere concentration images directly by continuous-wave diffuse optical tomography. Opt Lett 29, 256–258 (2004).

Jobsis

F. F.

Noninvasive, infrared monitoring of cerebral and myocardial oxygen sufficiency and circulatory parameters. Science 198, 1264–1267 (1977).

Bastian

On uniqueness in diffuse optical tomography. Inverse Problems 25, 055010 (2009).

Arridge

S. R.

Lionheart

W. R. B.

Nonuniqueness in diffusion-based optical tomography. Opt Lett 23, 882–884 (1998).

Corlu

Choe

Durduran

Lee

Schweiger

Arridge

S. R.

Hillman

E. M. C.

Yodh

A. G.

Diffuse optical tomography with spectral constraints and wavelength optimization. Appl Opt 44, 2082–2093 (2005).

McBride

T. O.

Pogue

B. W.

Poplack

Soho

Wells

W. A.

Jiang

Osterberg

U. L.

Paulsen

K. D.

Multispectral near-infrared tomography: A case study in compensating for water and lipid content in hemoglobin imaging of the breast. Journal of Biomedical Optics 7, 72–79 (2002).

10.

Jiang

Piao

Holyoak

G. R.

Ritchey

J. W.

Bartels

K. E.

Slobodov

Bunting

C. F.

Krasinski

J. S.

Trans-rectal Ultrasound-coupled Spectral Optical Tomography of Total Hemoglobin Concentration Enhances Assessment of the Laterality and Progression of a Transmissible Venereal Tumor in Canine Prostate. Urology 77, 237–242 (2011).

11.

Jones

P. B.

Shin

H. K.

Boas

D. A.

Hyman

B. T.

Moskowitz

M. A.

Ayata

Dunn

A. K.

Simultaneous multispectral reflectance imaging and laser speckle flowmetry of cerebral blood flow and oxygen metabolism in focal cerebral ischemia. Journal of Biomedical Optics 13, 044007 (2008).

12.

Springett

Dehghani

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

Dunn

J. F.

Magnetic-resonance-imaging-coupled broadband near-infrared tomography system for small animal brain studies. Appl Opt 44, 2177–2188 (2005).

13.

Brooksby

Srinivasan

Jiang

Dehghani

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

Weaver

Kogel

Poplack

S. P.

Spectral priors improve near-infrared diffuse tomography more than spatial priors. Opt Lett 30, 1968–1970 (2005).

14.

Wang

Davis

S. C.

Srinivasan

Jiang

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

Spectral tomography with diffuse near-infrared light: Inclusion of broadband frequency domain spectral data. Journal of Biomedical Optics 13, 041305–041310 (2008).

15.

Wang

Jiang

Paulsen

K. D.

Pogue

B. W.

Broadband frequency-domain near-infrared spectral tomography using a mode-locked Ti: Sapphire laser. Appl Opt 48, D198–D207 (2009).

16.

Wang

Pogue

B. W.

Jiang

Paulsen

K. D.

Near-infrared tomography of breast cancer hemoglobin, water, lipid, and scattering using combined frequency domain and cw measurement. Opt Lett 35, 82–84 (2010).

17.

Wang

Jiang

diFlorio-Alexander

R. M.

Barth

R. J.

Kaufman

P. A.

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

In vivo quantitative imaging of normal and cancerous breast tissue using broadband diffuse optical tomography. Medical Physics 37, 3715–3724 (2010).

18.

Piao

Bunting

C. F.

Dehghani

Direct-current-based image reconstruction versus direct-current included or excluded frequency-domain reconstruction in diffuse optical tomography. Appl Opt 49, 3059–3070 (2010).

19.

Fantini

Franceschini

Fishkin

J. B.

Barbieri

Gratton

Quantitative determination of the absorption spectra of chromophores in strongly scattering media: A light-emitting-diode based technique. Appl Opt 33, 5204–5213 (1994).

20.

Eames

M. E.

Wang

Pogue

B. W.

Dehghani

Wavelength band optimization in spectral near-infrared optical tomography improves accuracy while reducing data acquisition and computational burden. Journal of Biomedical Optics 13, 054037–054039 (2008).

21.

Grobmyer

S. R.

Chen

Zhang

Fajardo

L. L.

Jiang

Multispectral diffuse optical tomography with absorption and scattering spectral constraints. Appl Opt 46, 8229–8236 (2007).

22.

Eames

M. E.

Dehghani

Wavelength dependence of sensitivity in spectral diffuse optical imaging: Effect of normalization on image reconstruction. Opt Express 16, 17780–17791 (2008).

23.

Prahl

S. A.

Optical absorption of hemoglobin. http://omlc.ogi.edu/spectra/hemoglobin/ (1999). Accessed on May 22, 2011.

24.

Dehghani

Eames

M. E.

Yalavarthy

P. K.

Davis

S. C.

Srinivasan

Carpenter

C. M.

Pogue

B. W.

Paulsen

K. D.

Near infrared optical tomography using NIRFAST: Algorithm for numerical model and image reconstruction. Communications in Numerical Methods in Engineering 25, 711–732 (2009).

25.

Hebden

J. C.

Veenstra

Dehghani

Hillman

E. M. C.

Schweiger

Arridge

S. R.

Delpy

D. T.

Three-dimensional time-resolved optical tomography of a conical breast phantom. Appl Opt 40, 3278–3287 (2001).

26.

Fantini

Franceschini

M. A.

Gratton

Semi-infinite-geometry boundary problem for light migration in highly scattering media: A frequency-domain study in the diffusion approximation. J Opt Soc Am B 11, 2128–2138 (1994).

27.

Boas

D. A.

Diffusion photon probes of structral and dynamical properties of turbid media: theory and biomedical applications. Ph.D dissertation (University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 2000).

28.

Jacques

S. L.

Reflectance spectroscopy with optical fiber devices and transcutaneous bilirubinometers. Biomedical Optical Instrumentation and Laser-Assisted Biotechnology 12 (1996).

29.

Fabbri

Franceschini

M. A.

Fantini

Characterization of Spatial and Temporal Variations in the Optical Properties of Tissuelike Media with Diffuse Reflectance Imaging. Appl Opt 42, 3063–3072 (2003).