Background

Orbital decompression is an essential tool for reducing proptosis in thyroid eye disease (TED), yet the impact of surgical approach and preoperative factors on outcomes remains uncertain.

Objective

To compare proptosis reduction following different orbital decompression techniques, identify additional risk factors that may play a role in surgical orbital decompression outcomes, and develop clinical decision-making recommendations based on these results.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was performed on TED patients who underwent endoscopic medial wall, orbital floor, and/or open lateral wall decompression. We evaluated the influence of preoperative comorbidities, anatomic and laboratory values, and surgical approach on postdecompression Hertel exophthalmometry outcomes.

Results

Analysis encompassed 130 orbits from 80 patients, 83% female, 48 with preoperative diplopia, and mean age of 54.4 years. Preoperative Hertel measurement was predictive of extent of proptosis reduction (P < .0001), indicating that higher initial Hertel measurement predicts greater absolute reduction following surgical intervention. Surgical technique correlated with outcome on univariate analysis (P = .04), but not multivariate (P = .13) analyses. When categorized into preoperative Hertel ranges, combined endoscopic medial and open lateral wall decompression resulted in mean proptosis reduction of 3.13 mm for range 20.01 to 24 mm and 3.85 mm for range 24.01 to 28 mm. Three-wall decompression resulted in mean proptosis reduction of 2.49 mm for and 3.84 mm for these ranges, respectively. Variables such as smoking, body mass index, orbital wall height, and TRAb level, did not affect outcomes. Nine patients had new onset diplopia.

Conclusions

Preoperative Hertel exophthalmometry is the strongest predictor of proptosis reduction following orbital decompression in TED. Surgical technique appears to be less impactful on outcome than expected. Surgical decision making should be individualized based on patient goals; these findings can be used to achieve proptosis reduction and limit the risk of new onset diplopia.