SLAS DISCOVERY: Advancing the Science of Drug Discovery

Epigenetic control of the transciptome is a complex and highly coordinated cellular process. One critical mechanism involves DNA methylation, mediated by distinct but related DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs). Although several DNMT inhibitors are available, most are nonselective; selective DNMT inhibitors, therefore, could be optimal as therapeutics, as well acting as chemical probes to elucidate the fundamental biology of individual DNMTs. DNA methylation is a stable chemical modification, yet posttranslational modification of histones is transitory, with reversible effects on gene expression. Histone posttranslational modifications influence access of transcription factors to DNA target sites to affect gene activity. Histones are regulated by several enzymes, including acetylases (HATs), deacetylases (HDACs), methyltransferases (HMTs), and demethylases (HDMTs). Generally, HATs activate, whereas HDACs suppress gene activity. Specifically, HMTs and HDMTs can either activate or inhibit gene expression, depending on the site and extent of the methylation pattern. There is growing interest in drugs that target enzymes involved in epigenetic control. Currently, a range of high-throughput screening (HTS) technologies are used to identify selective compounds against these enzymes. This review focuses on the rationale for drug development of these enzymes, as well the utility of HTS methods used in identifying and optimizing novel selective compounds that modulate epigenetic control of the human transcriptome.

The sirtuin family of NAD-dependent histone deacetylases (HDACs) consists of seven mammalian proteins, SIRT1–7. Many of the sirtuin isoforms also deacetylate nonhistone substrates, such as p53 (SIRT1) and α-tubulin (SIRT2). The sirtuin literature focuses on pharmacological activators of SIRT1 (e.g., resveratrol, SRT1720), proposed as therapeutics for diabetes, neurodegeneration, inflammation, and others. However, many of the SIRT1 activator results may have been due to artifacts in the assay methodology (i.e., use of fluorescently tagged substrates). A biological role for SIRT1 in cancer has been given less scrutiny but is no less equivocal. Although proposed initially as an oncogene, we present herein compelling data suggesting that SIRT1 is indeed a context-specific tumor suppressor. For oncology, SIRT1 inhibitors (dual SIRT1/2) are indicated as potential therapeutics. A number of sirtuin inhibitors have been developed but with mixed results in cellular systems and animal models. It is unclear whether this has been due to poorly understood model systems, signalling redundancy, and/or inadequately potent and selective tool compounds. This review provides an overview of recent developments in the field of SIRT1 function. While focusing on oncology, it aims to shed light on new concepts of expanding the selectivity spectrum, including other sirtuins such as SIRT2.

Bromodomains are structurally conserved protein modules present in a large number of chromatin-associated proteins and in many nuclear histone acetyltransferases. The bromodomain functions as an acetyl-lysine binding domain and has been shown to be pivotal in regulating protein–protein interactions in chromatin-mediated cellular gene transcription, cell proliferation, and viral transcriptional activation. Structural analyses of these modules in complex with acetyl-lysine peptide ligands provide insights into the molecular basis for recognition and ligand selectivity within this epigenetic reader family. However, there are significant challenges in configuring assays to identify inhibitors of these proteins. This review focuses on the progress made in developing methods to identify peptidic and small-molecule ligands using biophysical label-free and biochemical approaches. The advantage of each technique and the results reported are summarized, highlighting the potential applicably to other reader domains and the caveats in translation from simple in vitro systems to a biological context.

Histone acetyltransferases (HATs) catalyze the transfer of an acetyl group from an acetyl-coenzyme A donor molecule to specific lysine residues within proteins. The acetylation state of proteins, particularly histones, is known to modulate their intermolecular binding properties and control various cellular processes, most notably transcriptional activation. In addition, deregulation of HAT activity has been linked to the development of a number of cancers; therefore, compounds that affect these enzymes have strong potential as therapeutic agents. The research presented here demonstrates three label-free HAT screening approaches, all based on the fast and direct measurement of one or more substrate-product pairs by high-throughput mass spectrometry techniques. The first approach involves monitoring all possible acetylation states of a peptide concurrently to measure HAT activity. The second approach measures acetylation reactions, on both peptides and whole protein substrates, via direct detection of the acetyl-coenzyme A cosubstrate and coenzyme A coproduct. Lastly, the authors demonstrate the ability to monitor directly the acetylation state of whole histone proteins in the same high-throughput manner using time-of-flight mass spectrometry. The generation of compound-mediated inhibition data using each of these techniques establishes mass spectrometry as a versatile, label-free, and biologically relevant screening approach to this challenging target class.

Epigenetic aberrations are increasingly regarded as key factors in cancer progression. Recently, deregulation of histone acetyltransferases (HATs) has been linked to several types of cancer. Monocytic leukemia zinc finger protein (MOZ) is a member of the MYST family of HATs, which regulate gene expression in cell proliferation and differentiation. Deregulation of these processes through constitutively active MOZ fusion proteins gives rise to the formation of leukemic stem cells, rendering MOZ an excellent target for treating myeloid leukemia. The authors implemented a hit discovery campaign to identify small-molecule inhibitors of MOZ-HAT activity. They developed a robust, homogeneous assay measuring the acetylation of synthetic histone peptides. In a primary screening campaign testing 243 000 lead-like compounds, they identified inhibitors from several chemical classes. Secondary assays were used to eliminate assay-interfering compounds and prioritize confirmed hits. This study establishes a new high-throughput assay for HAT activity and could provide the foundation for the development of a new class of drugs for the treatment of leukemias.

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) are important epigenetic factors regulating a variety of vital cellular functions such as cell cycle progression, differentiation, cell migration, and apoptosis. Consequently, HDACs have emerged as promising targets for cancer therapy. The drugability of HDACs has been shown by the discovery of several structural classes of inhibitors (HDACis), particularly by the recent approval of two HDACis, vorinostat (ZOLINZA) and romidepsin (Istodax), for the treatment of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma by the US Food and Drug Administration. The outstanding potential of HDACis, with a defined isoform selectivity profile as drugs against a plurality of diseases, vindicates increased effort in developing high-throughput capable assays for screening campaigns. In this study, a dual-competition assay exploiting changes in fluorescence anisotropy and lifetime was used to screen the LOPAC (Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO) library against the bacterial histone deacetylase homologue HDAH from Bordetella, which shares 35% identity with the second deacetylase domain of HDAC6. The binding assay proved to be highly suitable for high-throughput screening campaigns. Several LOPAC compounds have been identified to inhibit HDAH in the lower micromolar range. Most interestingly, some of the hit compounds turned out to be weak but selective inhibitors of human class IIa and IIb HDACs.

The sirtuin enzymes, a class of NAD⁺-dependent histone deacetylases, are a focal point of epigenetic research because of their roles in regulating gene expression and cellular differentiation by deacetylating histones and a host of transcription factors, including p53. Here, the authors present two label-free screening methodologies to study sirtuin activity using high-throughput mass spectrometry. The first method involves the detection of native peptides and provides a platform for more detailed mechanistic studies by enabling the concurrent and direct measurement of multiple modification states. The second method obviates the need for substrate-specific assay development by measuring the O-acetyl-ADP-ribose co-product formed by sirtuin-dependent deacetylation. Both methodologies were applied to investigating the deacetylation of multiple-peptide substrates by multiple-sirtuin enzymes. Kinetic data, including binding constants, inhibition, and, in some cases, activation, are demonstrated to correlate well, both between the methodologies and with previous literature precedent. In addition, the ability to monitor sirtuin activity via O-acetyl-ADP-ribose production permits experimentation on whole-protein substrates. The deacetylation of whole-histone proteins by SIRT3, and inhibition thereof, is presented and demonstrates the feasibility of screening sirtuins using more biologically relevant molecules.

Histone deacetylase (HDAC) enzymes modify the acetylation state of histones and other important proteins. Aberrant HDAC enzyme function has been implicated in many diseases, and the discovery and development of drugs targeting these enzymes is becoming increasingly important. In this article, the authors report the evaluation of homogeneous, single-addition, bioluminogenic HDAC enzyme activity assays that offer less assay interference by compounds in comparison to fluorescence-based formats. The authors assessed the key operational assay properties including sensitivity, scalability, reproducibility, signal stability, robustness (Z′), DMSO tolerance, and pharmacological response to standard inhibitors against HDAC-1, HDAC-3/NcoR2, HDAC-6, and SIRT-1 enzymes. These assays were successfully miniaturized to a 10 µL assay volume, and their suitability for high-throughput screening was tested in validation experiments using 640 drugs approved by the Food and Drug Administration and the Hypha Discovery MycoDiverse natural products library, which is a collection of 10 049 extracts and fractions from fermentations of higher fungi and contains compounds that are of low molecular weight and wide chemical diversity. Both of these screening campaigns confirmed that the bioluminogenic assay was high-throughput screening compatible and yielded acceptable performance in confirmation, counter, and compound/extract and fraction concentration-response assays.

Posttranslational modifications such as phosphorylation, acetylation, and methylation play important roles in regulating the structures and functions of histones, which in turn regulate gene expression and DNA repair and replication. Histone-modifying enzymes, such as deacetylases, methyltransferases and demethylases, have been pursued as therapeutic targets for various diseases. However, detection of the activities of these enzymes in high-throughput cell-based formats has remained challenging. The authors have developed high-throughput LanthaScreen cellular assays for Histone H3 site-specific modifications. These assays use cells expressing green fluorescence protein–tagged Histone H3 transiently delivered via BacMam and terbium-labeled anti–Histone H3 modification-specific antibodies. Robust time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer signals were detected for H3 lysine-9 acetylation and dimethylation (H3K9me2), serine-10 phosphorylation, K4 di- and trimethylation, and K27 trimethylation. Consistent with previous reports, hypoxic stress increased K4 methylation levels, and methyltransferase G9a inhibitor UNC-0638 decreased K9me2 levels significantly, with little effects on other modifications. To demonstrate the utility of this assay platform in screening, the K9 acetylation assay was used to profile the Enzo Epigenetics Library. Twelve known HDAC inhibitors were identified as hits and followed up in a dose–response format. In conclusion, this assay platform enables high-throughput cell-based analysis of diverse types of posttranslational modifications of Histone H3.

Developing molecularly targeted therapeutics with minimal off-target effects is facilitated by an understanding of compound selectivity. However, for HDAC inhibitors, a clear understanding of specificity has been challenging. In particular, it has been suggested that use of nonspecific substrates and the presence of multiple HDAC activities in enzyme preparations may complicate interpretation of inhibitor experiments. To overcome these and other potential limitations of activity-based HDAC assays, the authors have developed an assay format based on measurement of the binding affinity of inhibitors rather than measurement of enzyme activity. One advantage of this format is that it does not require use of a substrate and thus ameliorates concerns about lack of specificity of existing substrates. This assay is based on an Alexa Fluor® 647-labeled HDAC inhibitor or “tracer,” which binds with a high affinity to Class I and Class IIb HDACs. Unlike activity assays, which can be affected by the presence of residual untagged endogenous HDACs from the host expression system, the signal in this format is dependent on the presence of an epitope tag on the specific HDAC of interest. The authors demonstrate the utility of this method by determining the potencies of commonly used inhibitors for six human HDACs.