Due to its potential for interactive communication, the Internet is considered a promising tool for relationship marketing. However, the effects of interactive communication on marketing effectiveness may depend on several factors related to each individual consumer, such as Internet experience. In this study, two of the most common applications for interactive communication—personalized Web sites and customer communities—were compared for their ability to develop consumer-brand relationships as measured by the Brand Relationship Quality (BRQ) framework of Fournier (1998). No main effects of the applications were observed. However, significant effects of Internet applications were found when Internet experience was included as a moderating variable. Specifically, it was found that personalized Web sites developed stronger consumer-brand relationships for respondents with extensive Internet experience than for respondents with limited Internet experience. Conversely, it was found that customer communities developed stronger relationships among respondents with limited Internet experience than among respondents with extensive Internet experience. Implications for marketing management and future research in this area are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlbaJ.W.LynchJ.WeitzB.JaniszewskiC.LutzR.SawyerA.WoodS.Interactive home shopping: Consumer, retailer, and manufacturer incentives to participate in electronic marketsJournal of Marketing61199738–53
2.
AlbaJ.W.HutchinsonJ.W.Dimensions of consumer expertiseJournal of Consumer Research131987411–453
3.
AndersonJ.C.GerbingD.W.Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approachPsychological Bulletin1031988411–434
4.
ArmstrongA.HagelJ.The real value of on-line communitiesHarvard Business Review1996134–141May-June
5.
BagozziR.P.YiY.On the evaluation of structural equation modelsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science161998125–141
6.
BaldingerA.L.RubinsonJ.Brand loyalty: The link between attitude and behaviorJournal of Advertising Research199622–36Nov-Dec
7.
Bezjian-AveryA.CalderB.IacobucciD.New media interactive advertising vs. traditional advertisingJournal of Advertising Research199823–32July-Aug
8.
BrucksM.The effects of product class knowledge on information search behaviorJournal of Consumer Research12198554–73
9.
BrunerG.C.IIKumarA.Web commercials and advertising hierarchy-of-effectsJournal of Advertising Research200035–43January/April
10.
CheluneG.J.RobisonJ.T.KommorM.J.A cognitive interactional model of intimate relationshipsDerlegaV.J.Communicating, intimacy, and close relationships1984Academic PressOrlando, FL11–40
11.
CialdiniR.B.Influence science and practice3rd ed.1993Harper CollinsNew York
12.
DeLoneW.H.Determinants of success of computer usage in small businessMIS Quarterly12198851–62
13.
DeightonJ.The future of interactive marketingHarvard Business Review1996151–161Nov-Dec
14.
DeightonJ.GraysonK.Marketing and seduction: Building exchange relationships by managing social consensusJournal of Consumer Research211995660–676
15.
DickA.S.BasuK.Customer loyalty: Toward an integrated conceptual frameworkJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science22199499–113
16.
FigalloC.Hosting Web communities1998WileyNew York
17.
FodnessD.MurrayB.Tourist information searchAnnals of Tourism Research241997503–523
18.
Fournier, S. (1994). A consumer-brand relationship framework for strategic brand management. Dissertation presented to The Graduate School of the University of Florida, UMI Dissertation Abstracts, Michigan.
19.
FournierS.Consumers and their brands: Developing relationship theory in consumer researchJournal of Consumer Research241998343–373
20.
FournierS.YaoJ.L.Reviving brand loyalty: A reconceptualization within the framework of consumer-brand relationshipsInternational Journal of Research in Marketing141997451–473
21.
GarbarinoE.JohnsonM.S.The different roles of satisfaction, trust, and commitment in customer relationshipsJournal of Marketing63199970–87
22.
HagelJ.Net gain: Expanding markets through virtual communitiesJournal of Interactive Marketing13199955–66
23.
HindeR.A.Towards understanding relationships1979Academic PressNew York
24.
HoffmanD.L.NovakT.P.Marketing in hypermedia computer-mediated environments: Conceptual foundationsJournal of Marketing60199650–68
25.
HollandJ.BakerS.M.Customer participation in site brand loyaltyJournal of Interactive Marketing15200134–45
26.
KhaslavskyJ.ShedroffN.Understanding the seductive experienceCommunication of the ACM42199945–49
27.
KraemerL.DanzingerJ.N.DunkleD.E.KingJ.L.The usefulness of computer-based information to public managersMIS Quarterly171993129–149
28.
LiangT.-P.HuangJ.-S.An empirical study on consumer acceptance of products in electronic markets: A transaction cost modelDecision Support Systems24199829–43
29.
LynchJ.G.ArielyD.Wine online: Search costs and competition on price, quality, and distributionMarketing Science19200083–105
30.
MathwickC.Understanding the online consumer: A typology of online relational norms and behaviorJournal of Interactive Marketing16200240–55
31.
MorganR.M.HuntS.D.The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing58199420–39
32.
NovakT.P.HoffmanD.L.YungY.-F.Measuring the customer experience in online environments: A structural modeling approachMarketing Science19200022–42
33.
OliverR.L.Satisfaction. A behavioral perspective on the consumer1997McGraw-HillSingapore
34.
PearlmanD.FehrB.The development of intimate relationshipsPearlmanD.DuckS.Intimate relationships: Development, dynamics and deterioration1987SageNewbury Park, CA13–42
35.
PeppersD.RogersM.Enterprise one to one. Tools for competing in the interactive age1997Currency DoubledayNew York
36.
PettyR.E.CacioppoJ.T.Attitudes and persuasion: Classic and contemporary approaches1981William C. BrownDubuque, IA
37.
RheingoldH.The virtual community1993Addison WesleyReading, MA
38.
RoehmH.A.HaugtvedtC.P.Understanding interactivity of cyberspace advertisingSchumannD.W.ThorsonE.Advertising and the World Wide Web1999ErlbaumLondon27–39
39.
RogersE.M.Communication technology: New media in society1986Free PressNew York
40.
SchultzD.E.BaileyS.Customer/brand loyalty in an interactive marketplaceJournal of Advertising Research200041–51May-June
41.
SternB.B.Advertising intimacy: Relationship marketing and the services consumerJournal of Advertising2619977–19
42.
SterneJ.Customer service on the Internet1996WileyNew York
43.
SteuerJ.Defining virtual reality: Dimensions determining telepresenceJournal of Communication42199273–93
44.
TakacsJ.ReedW.M.WellsJ.G.DombrowskiL.A.The effect of online multimedia project development, learning style and prior computer experiences on teachers’ attitudes toward the Internet and hypermediaJournal of Research on Computing in Education311999341–359
45.
ThompsonR.L.HigginsC.A.HowellJ.M.Influence of experience on personal computer utilization: Testing a conceptual modelJournal of Management Information Systems111994167–187
46.
VenkateshV.Determinants of perceived ease of use: Integrating control, intrinsic motivation, and emotion into the technology acceptance modelInformation Systems Research112000342–365
47.
VenkateshV.DavisF.D.A model of the antecedents of perceived ease of use: Development and testDecision Science271996451–481
48.
WaringE.MTillmanM.PFrelickL.RusselL.WeiszG.Concepts of intimacy in the general populationThe Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease1681980471–474
49.
WellmanB.GuliaM.Net-surfers don't ride alone: Virtual communities as CommunitiesWellmanB.Networks in the Global Village1999Westview PressBoulder, CO331–366
50.
WindJ.RangaswamyA.Customerization: The next revolution in mass customizationJournal of Interactive Marketing15200113–32
51.
ZaltmanG.PinsonC.R.A.AngelmarR.Metatheory and consumer research1973Holt, Rinehart and WinstonNew York
