The paper draws a distinction between customer lifetime value (CLV) and willingness to spend (WTS). By WTS we mean the maximum amount the firm should be willing to spend to acquire (retain) the customer relationship. In order to avoid the double counting of cash flows when summing the CLVs of customers, we suggest including only direct cash flows in the formulation of CLV. This convention means that CLV will equal WTS if (and, for the most part, only if) the firm's relationships with customers are independent. By independent we mean that the acquisition (retention) of Jane Doe has no effect on the cash flows of any other current or future customers. In contrast to well-understood demand-side dependencies among customer relationships (such as referrals), this paper highlights a particular kind of supply-side dependency—that created when the firm is limited in the number of customers it can serve. Using an extended version of the model of Blattberg and Deighton (“Manage Marketing by the Customer Equity Test,” Harvard Business Review, July–August 1996, 136–144) of customer equity, we demonstrate that, for a firm at capacity (in this model), CLV is no longer relevant to marketing spending decisions and the firm can prefer a lower-CLV customer.
BayonTomasGutscheJensBauerHansCustomer Equity Marketing: Touching the IntangibleEuropean Management Journal2032002213–222
2.
BelobabaPeter B.Back to the Future? Directions for Revenue ManagementJournal of Revenue and Pricing Management11200287–89
3.
BergerPaul D.Nasr-BechwatiNada I.The Allocation of Promotion Budget to Maximize Customer EquityOmega292001200149–61
4.
BergerPaul D.EechambadiNarasGeorgeNirrusLehmannDonald R.RizleyRossVenkatesanRajkumarFrom Customer Lifetime Value to Shareholder Value: Theory, Empirical Evidence, and Issues for Future ResearchJournal of Service Research922006156–167
5.
BlattbergRobert C.DeightonJohnManage Marketing by the Customer Equity TestHarvard Business Review19961996136–144(July–August)
6.
BlattbergRobert C.GetzGaryThomasJacquelin S.Customer Equity: Building and Manageing Relationships as Valuable Assets2001Harvard Business School PressBoston, MA
7.
BlattbergRobert C.KimByung-DoNeslinScott A.Database Marketing: Analyzing and Managing Customers2008Springer Science + business Media, L.L.C
8.
BlattbergRobert C.MalthouseEdward C.NeslinScott A.Customer Lifetime Value: Empirical Generalizations and Some Conceptual QuestonsJournal of Interactive Marketing2322009157–168
9.
BurskEdward C.View Your Customers as InvestmentsHarvard Business Review1966196691–94(May/June)
10.
CrossRobert G.HigbieJon A.CrossDavid Q. (Dax)Revenue Management Renaissance: A Rebirth of the Art and Science of Profitable Revenue GenerationCornell Hospitality Quarterly200956–81February
11.
DayGeorge S.MontgomeryDavid B.Diagnosing the Experience CurveJournal of Marketing47198344–58Spring
12.
DickinsonC.B.CRM-enhanced Revenue Management in the Hospitality IndustryHospitality Upgrade2001136–138Summer
13.
DongWeiminSwainScott D.BergerPaul D.The Role of Channel Quality in Optimal Allocation of Acquisition and Retention SpendingJournal of Business Research6020071243–1252
14.
DwyerF. RobertCustomer Lifetime Valuation to Support Marketing Decision MakingJournal of Direct Marketing3419898–15
15.
FaderPeter S.HardieBruce G.S.How to Project Customer RetentionJournal of Interactive Marketing211200776–90
16.
GuptaSunilHanssensDominiqueHardieBruceKahnWilliamKumarV.LinNathanielRavishankerNaliniSriramS.Modeling Customer Lifetime ValueJournal of Service Research922006139–155
17.
HoganJohn E.LemonKatherine N.LibaiBarakWhat is the True Value of a Lost Customer?Journal of Service Research532003196–208
18.
JonasD.Carriers Melding Revenue Management and CRM SystemsBusiness Travel News200118–1926th March
19.
KaradjovY.HornickS.Yield Managing Your Customers—One at a TimeHospitality Upgrade2000122–123Spring
20.
KeaveneySusan M.Customer Switching Behavior in Service Industries: An Exploratory StudyJournal of Marketing59199571–82April
21.
KumarV.PetersenJ. AndrewLeoneRobert P.How Valuable is Word of Mouth?Harvard Business Review2007139–146October
22.
KumarV.AksoyLerzanDonkersBasVenkatesanRajkumarWieselThorstenTillmannsSebastianUndervalued or Overvalued Customers: Capturing Total Customer Engagement ValueJournal of Services Research1332010297–310
23.
LiebermanWarren H.Revenue Management: What Lies Ahead?Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management122002189–195
24.
LiuBen Shaw-ChingPetruzziNicholas C.SudharshanD.A Service Effort Allocation Model for Assessing Customer Lifetime Value in Service MarketingJournal of Services Marketing211200724–35
NooneBreffni M.KimesSheryl E.RenaghanLeo M.Integrating Customer Relationship Management and Revenue Management: A Hotel PerspectiveJournal of Revenue and Pricing Management2120037–21
27.
OvchinnikovAntonBouluBeatricePfeiferPhillip E.Revenue Management with Lifetime Value ConsiderationsDarden School working paper2011
28.
PfeiferPhillip E.On the Use of Customer Lifetime Value as a Limit on Acquisition SpendingJournal of Database Marketing71199981–86
29.
PfeiferPhillip E.The Optimal Ratio of Acquisition and Retention CostsJournal of Targeting, Measurement, and Analysis for Marketing1322005179–188
30.
PfeiferPhillip E.HaskinsMark E.ConroyRobert M.Customer Lifetime Value, Customer Profitability, and the Treatment of Acquisition SpendingJournal of Managerial IssuesXVII1200511–25
31.
RoemerEllenThe Impact of Dependence on the Assessment of Customer Lifetime Value in Buyer–Seller RelationshipsJournal of Marketing Management22200689–109
32.
RustRoland T.ZeithamlValerie A.LemonKatherine N.Driving Customer Equity: How Customer Lifetime Value is Reshaping Corporate Strategy2000The Free PressNew York, NY
33.
SchmittleinDavid C.MorrisonDonald G.ColomboRichardCounting Your Customers: Who They Are and What Will They Do Next?Management Science33119871–24
34.
ThomasJacquelyn S.A Methodology for Linking Customer Acquisition to Customer RetentionJournal of Marketing ResearchXXXVII2001262–268May
35.
Von MartensTobiasHilbertAndreasCustomer-value-based Revenue ManagementJournal of Revenue and Pricing Management2009published online 10 April 2009
