On the Relationship between Alonso's Theory of Movement and Wilson's Family of Spatial-Interaction Models

Abstract

This paper compares the system of equations underlying Alonso's theory of movement with that of Wilson's standard family of spatial-interaction models. It is shown that the Alonso model is equivalent to one of Wilson's four standard models depending on the assumption at the outset about which of the total outflows and/or inflows are known. This result turns out to supersede earlier findings—inconsistent only in appearance—which were derived independently by Wilson and Ledent. In addition to this, an original contribution of this paper—obtained as a byproduct of the process leading to the aforementioned result—is to provide an exact methodology permitting one to solve the Alonso model for each possible choice of the input data.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alonso

, 1973 National Interregional Demographic Accounts: A Prototype Monograph 17 (Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, Calif.)

Alonso

, 1975 “Policy-oriented interregional demographic accounting and a generalization of population flow models” WP-278, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, Calif.; also in Internal Migration: A Comparative Perspective Eds Brown

A A

Neuberger

, 1977(Academic Press, New York)

Alonso

, 1976 “A theory of movements: (I) Introduction” WP-266, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, Calif

Alonso

, 1978

“A theory of movements”

International Perspective on Structure, Change, and Public Policy Ed. Hansen

(Ballinger, Cambridge, Mass)

Anselin

Isard

, 1980

“On Alonso's general theory of movement”

Man, Environment, Space, and Time 1(1)

Ledent

, 1980 “Calibrating Alonso's general theory of movement: the case of interprovincial migration flows in Canada” WP-80–41, International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, Austria; forthcoming in Systemi Urbani

Wilson

A G

, 1971

“A family for spatial interaction models, and associated developments”

Environment and Planning 3 1–32

Wilson

A G

, 1974 Urban and Regional Models in Geography and Planning (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)

Wilson

A G

, 1979 “Comments on Alonso's theory of movement” WP-255, School of Geography, University of Leeds, Leeds; published in Environment and Planning A 12(6) 727–732