This paper is an Illustration of how different state practices have had a direct impact on uneven development between, and within, two adjacent regions in the United Kingdom. In one case, South Wales, state intervention has taken the form of regional assistance, nationalisation of the dominant industries, and public-sector employment. In the other case, the Bristol subregion, it has taken the form of defence activities, and especially support for the aerospace industry. These influences have had a major impact on the spatial pattern of investment, regional specialisation, and the internal articulation of each subregion. Defence procurement has resulted in an inflow of government spending to the Bristol area, which is greater than that going to South Wales via regional assistance. The paper concludes with a comment on the spatial significance of different coalitions of interests, and a suggestion that more attention should be given to the specificities of nation-states.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlfordB W E, 1976, “The economic development of Bristol in the nineteenth-century: An enigma?” in Essays in Bristol and Gloucestershire History Eds McGrathPCannonJ, Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society, Bristol; copy available from the author
BassettK, 1984, “Corporate structure and corporate change in a local economy: The case of Bristol”Environment and Planning A16879–900
4.
BeecheyV, 1983, “What's so special about women's employment? A review of some recent studies of women's paid work”Feminist Review523–46
5.
BoddyMLoveringJ, 1985, “High technology industry in Bristol: The aerospace/defence nexus”Regional Studies (forthcoming)
6.
BrittonJ N H, 1967Regional Analysis and Economic Geography. A Case Study of Manufacturing in the Bristol Region (Bell and Hyman, London)
7.
BrowettJ, 1984, “On the necessity and inevitability of uneven spatial development under capitalism”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research8155–175
8.
CAAT, 1980The Arms TradersCampaign Against Arms Trade, 5 Caledonian Road, London N1
9.
CampbellD, 1982War Plan UK (Burnett Books, London)
10.
CookeP, 1981, “Local class structure in Wales” Papers in Planning Research 31, Department of Town Planning, University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology, Cardiff, S Glam
11.
CookeP, 1982a, “Class interests, regional restructuring and state formation in Wales”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research6187–203
12.
CookeP, 1982b, “Dependency, supply factors and uneven development in Wales and other problem regions”Regional Studies16211–227
13.
CookeP, 1983, “Regional restructuring: Class politics and popular protest in South Wales”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1265–280
14.
CrosslandN, (Ed.), 1984, “Survey of Bristol”The Times 11 July
DoE, 1983New Earnings Survey: Analysis by OccupationDepartment of Employment (HMSO, London)
17.
DunfordM F, 1977, “Regional policy and the restructuring of capital” WP-4, School of Urban and Regional Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex
18.
DunfordM FGeddesMPerronsD, 1981, “Regional policy and the crisis in the UK: A long-run perspective”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research5377–410
FrancisHSmithD, 1980The Fed: A History of the South Wales Miners in the Twentieth Century (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
21.
GanslerJ, 1982The Defense Industry (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
22.
GiddensA, 1981A Contemporary Critique of Historical Materialism (Macmillan, London)
23.
GoddardJ B, 1983, “Structural change in the British space economy” in The Urban and Regional Transformation of Britain Eds GoddardJ BChampionA G, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp1–26
24.
GoddardJ BThwaitesA T, 1984, “Unemployment in the North; jobs in the South” in New Technology: The Future of Work and Skills Ed. MarstrandP, (Frances Pinter, London) pp 45–66
25.
HartleyKCorcoranW J, 1975, “Short-run employment functions and defence contracts in the UK aircraft industry”Applied Economics7223–233
26.
HobsbawmE J, 1969Industry and Empire (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
27.
HumphrysG, 1977, “Industrial Wales” in Wales: A New Study Ed. ThomasD, (David and Charles, Newton Abbot, Devon) pp 154–189
28.
HumphrysG, 1983, “Problems in the regeneration of the South Wales economy” mimeo, Department of Geography, University College of Swansea, Swansea, W Glam
29.
JonesG S, 1984Outcast London (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
30.
KaldorM, 1982, “Warfare and capitalism” in Exterminism and Cold War Eds E P Thompson and others (Verso, London) pp 261–288
31.
KohanC M, 1952History of the Second World War, Civil SeriesWorks and Buildings (HMSO, London)
32.
LawC M, 1983, “The defence sector in British regional development”Geoforum14169–184
33.
LawrenceS, 1984, “The strike barricade: It's just not Bristol”Bristol Evening Post 15 August page 5
34.
LeninV, 1934, “Armaments and capitalism” in Lenin on Britain Ed. PollitH, (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 43–45
35.
LipietzA, 1980, “The structuration of space, the problem of land and spatial policy” in Regions in Crisis Eds CarneyJHudsonRLewisJ, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 60–75
36.
LoveringJ, 1983a, “Gwynedd—a county in crisis” Occasional Papers in Welsh Studies 2, Coleg Harlech, Harlech, Gwynedd
37.
LoveringJ, 1983b, “Uneven development in Wales: The changing role of the British state” in Crisis of Economy and Ideology: Essays on Welsh Society 1840–1980 Ed. WilliamsG, SSRC/BSA Sociology of Wales Study Group, University College of North Wales, Bangor, Gwynedd
38.
LoveringJ, 1984, “The development of the aerospace industry in Bristol 1910–1984” Bristol Project Working Paper 5, ESRC Inner City in Context Research Programme, School for Advanced Urban Studies and Department of Geography, University of Bristol, Bristol, Avon
39.
MacinnesC M, 1939A Gateway of Empire (J W Arrowsmith, Bristol)
40.
MaleckiE J, 1984, “Military spending and the US defense industry: Regional patterns of military contracts and subcontracts”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy231–44
41.
MannM, 1984, “Capitalism and militarism” in War, State and Society Ed. ShawM, (Macmillan, London) pp 26–42
42.
MannersG, (Ed.), 1964South Wales in the Sixties (Pergamon Press, Oxford)
43.
MannersG, 1972, “The South West and South Wales” in Regional Development in Britainfirst edition, Eds MannersGKeebleDWarrenK, (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 231–266
44.
MannersG, 1976, “Bristol, South Wales, and the Bridge”New Society10 (6 June) 7–10
45.
MarquandJ, 1983, “The changing distribution of service employment” in The Urban and Regional Transformation of Britain Eds GoddardJ BChampionA G, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 99–134
46.
MasseyD B, 1979, “In what sense a regional problem?”Regional Studies13233–243
47.
MasseyD B, 1982, “Industrial restructuring and class restructuring: Production decentralisation and local uniqueness”Regional Studies1773–89
48.
MasseyD BCatalanoA, 1978Capital and Land (Edward Arnold, London)
49.
MasseyD BMilesN, 1983, “Sex, grouse and happy workers”New Statesman 22 April, page 15
50.
MilibandR, 1983Class Power and State Power (Verso, London)
51.
MillerRSawyersD, 1968The Technical Development of Modern Aviation (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)
52.
MingioneE, 1978, “Capitalist crisis, neo-dualism, and marginalisation”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research2213–221
53.
MoretonA, 1983, “Welsh industry: The hunt for high-tech winners”Financial Times 8 September, page 31
54.
MorganK, 1981Rebirth of a Nation: Wales 1880–1980 (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
55.
MorganK O, 1979, “State regional interventions and industrial reconstruction in post-war Britain: The case of Wales” WP-16, School of Urban and Regional Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex
56.
MorganK O, 1983, “Restructuring steel: The crises of labour and locality in Britain”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research7175–201
57.
MorganK OSayerA, 1983, “Regional inequality and the state in Britain” in Redundant Spaces? Eds AndersonJDuncanSHudsonR, (Academic Press, London) pp 17–50
58.
MorganK OSayerA, 1984, “A ‘modern’ industry in a ‘mature’ region” WP-39, School of Urban and Regional Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex
59.
MSC, 1979–1982Annual Census of Employment (unpublished) Manpower Services Commission, Selkirk House, High Holborn, London WC1
60.
NairnT, 1981The Break-up of Britain (Verso, London)
61.
PavittKSoeteL, 1980, “Innovative activities and export share” in Technical Innovation and British Economic Performance Ed. PavittK, (Macmillan, London) pp 38–66
62.
PickvanceC G, 1981, “Policies as chameleons, an interpretation of regional policy and office policy in Britain” in Urbanisation and Planning in Capitalist Societies Eds DearMScottA, (Maaroufa Press, Chicago, IL) pp 231–266
63.
PiteC, 1980, “Employment and defence”Statistical NewsCentral Statistical Office (HMSO, London) November issue, pages 51.17–51.19
64.
PollardS, 1983The Development of the British Economy 1914–1980 (Edward Arnold, London)
65.
PollardS, 1984The Wasting of the British Economysecond edition (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
66.
ReesG, 1980, “Uneven development, state intervention, and the generation of inequality: The case of industrial South Wales” in Poverty and Social Inequality in Wales Eds ReesGReesT L, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 185–204
67.
ReesGReesT L, (Eds), 1980Poverty and Social Inequality in Wales (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
68.
RSA, 1983, “Report of an inquiry into regional problems in the United Kingdom”Regional Science Association, Department of Civic Design, University of Liverpool, Liverpool
69.
SaxenianA, 1984, “The genesis of Silicon Valley”Built Environment97–17
70.
ShortJ, 1981, “Defence spending in the UK regions”Regional Studies15101–110
71.
TaylorMThriftN, 1983, “Business organisation, segmentation and location”Regional Studies17445–465
72.
ThomasA, 1983, “Essential service routes” in War and Order: Researching State Structures Ed. BledowskaC, (Junction Books, London) pp 60–66
73.
UrryJ, 1981, “Localities, regions and social class”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research5455–474
74.
WalkerF, 1972The Bristol Region (Nelson, Walton-on-Thames, Surrey)
75.
WalkerM, 1982, “The boom that's by-passing the new towns of Britain”The Guardian 26 April, page 12
76.
WarrenK, 1980, “The South West Region” in Regional Development in Britainsecond edition Eds MannersGKeebleDWarrenK, (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 329–344
77.
WilliamsG A, 1978The Merthyr Rising (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
78.
WilliamsG A, 1982, “Land of our fathers”Marxism Today2622–30
79.
WinklerV, 1983, “Tertiarisation and feminisation at the periphery” paper presented to the British Sociological Association Annual Conference, Cardiff; copy obtainable from Department of Town Planning, University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology, Cardiff, S Glam
