“Entropy and Information Theory”: Critique,Comments,and Reply

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975a, “A note on the entropy formulation of distribution models” Operational Research Quarterly 26 755–758

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975b, “Social physics and quantum statistics” unpublished report; copy available from the first author

Haynes K E Phillips F Y Mohrfield J W , 1980, “The entropies; some roots of ambiguity” Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 14 137–145

Huang K , 1963 Statistical Mechanics (John Wiley, New York)

Jaynes E T , 1957, “Information theory and statistical mechanics I” Physical Review 106 620–630

Kullback S , 1959 Information Theory and Statistics (John Wiley, New York)

Lesse P F Brotchie J F Roy J R Sharpe R , 1978, “A new philosophy for regional modelling” in Proceedings of the Third Annual Conference of the Regional Science Association held at Melbourne, Australia; copy obtainable from Department of Geography, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria; pp 165–178

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1981, “On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling” Transportation Research 15B 85–96

Rushbrook G E , 1949 Introduction to Statistical Mechanics (Oxford University Press, Oxford)

Shannon C E , 1948, “A mathematical theory of communication” Bell System Technical Journal 27 379–423; 623–656; reprinted in The Mathematical Theory of Communication 1949, Shannon C E Weaver W , (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL)

Snickars F Weibull J W , 1977, “A minimum information principle: Theory and practice” Regional Science and Urban Economics 7 137–168

Webber M J , 1979 Information Theory and Urban Spatial Structure (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)

Wilson A G , 1967, “A statistical theory of spatial distribution models” Transportation Research 1 253–269

Wilson A G , 1970 Entropy in Urban and Regional Modelling (Pion, London)

Beckmann M J Golob T F , 1972, “A critique of entropy and gravity in travel forecasting” in Traffic Flow and Transportation Ed. Newell G F (American Elsevier, New York) pp 109–117

Charnes A Raike W M Bettinger C O , 1972, “An extremal and information-theoretic characterization of some interzonal transfer models” Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 6 531–537

Gokhale D V Kullback S , 1978 The Information in Contingency Tables (Marcel Dekker, New York)

Gould P , 1972, “Pedagogic review” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 62 689–700

Haining R P , 1978, “The moving average model for spatial interaction” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 3 202–205

Haynes K E Phillips F Y Mohrfield J W , 1980, “The entropies: Some roots of ambiguity” Socio-Economic Planning Science 14 137–145

Hoeffding W , 1965, “Asymptotically optimal tests for multinomial distributions” Annals of Mathematical Statistics 36 369–408

Jaynes E T , 1957a, “Information theory and statistical mechanics I” Physical Review 106 620–630

Jaynes E T , 1957b, “Information theory and statistical mechanics II” Physical Review 108 171–190

Jaynes E T , 1968, “Prior probabilities” IEEE Transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics SSC-4 227–248

Kullback S , 1959 Information Theory and Statistics (John Wiley, New York)

Kullback S Leibler R A , 1951, “On information and sufficiency” Annals of Mathematical Statistics 22 79–86

March L Batty M , 1975, “Generalized measures of information, Bayes' likelihood ratio and Jaynes' formalism” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 2 99–105

Renyi A , 1965, “On the foundations of information theory” Review of the International Statistical Institute 33 1–14

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1981, “On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling” Transportation Research 15B 85–96

Smith T E , 1977, “A general efficiency principle of spatial interaction” in Spatial Interaction Theory and Planning Models Eds Karlqvist A Lundqvist L Snickars F Weibull J W (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 97–119

Smith T E , 1978, “A cost-efficiency principle of spatial interaction” Regional Science and Urban Economics 8 313–337

Smith T E , 1980, “A central limit theorem for spatial samples” Geographical Analysis 12 299–324

Smith T E , 1983, “A cost-efficiency approach to the analysis of congested spatial-interaction behavior” Environment and Planning A 15 435–464

Smith T E , 1985, “Most-probable-state analysis: A general approach to testing probabilistic theories of behavior” in preparation

Snickars F Weibull J W , 1977, “A minimum information principle: Theory and practice” Regional Science and Urban Economics 7 137–168

Theil M , 1967 Economics and Information Theory (North-Holland, Amsterdam)

Webber M J , 1975, “Entropy-maximising location models for nonindependent events” Environment and Planning A 7 99–108

Webber M J , 1976, “The meaning of entropy maximizing models” in Mathematical Land Use Theory Ed. Papageorgiou G J (D C Heath, Lexington, MA) pp 277–292

Webber M J , 1979 Information Theory and Urban Spatial Structure (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)

Wilson A G , 1967, “A statistical theory of spatial distribution models” Transportation Research 1 253–269

Hobson A , 1969, “A new theorem of information theory” Journal of Statistical Physics 1 383–391

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1981, “On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling” Transportation Research 15B 85–96

Shannon C Weaver W , 1949 The Mathematical Theory of Communication (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL)

Snickars F Weibull J W , 1977, “A minimum information principle: Theory and practice” Regional Science and Urban Economics 7 137–168

Wilson A G , 1967, “A statistical theory of spatial distribution models” Transportation Research 1 253–269.

Batty M March L 1976, “Dynamic urban models based on information-minimizing” Geographical Papers 48, Department of Geography, University of Reading, Reading, Berks

Beckmann M J Wallace J P 1969, “Evaluation of user benefits from change in transportation systems” Transportation Science 4 344–351

Charnes A Raike W M Bettinger C O 1972, “An extremal and information-theoretic characterization of some interzonal transfer models” Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 6 531–537

Dantzig G B 1963 Linear Programming and Extensions (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)

Erlander S 1977, “Accessibility, entropy and the distribution and assignment of traffic” Transportation Research 11 149–153

Erlander S 1980 Optimal Spatial Interaction and the Gravity Model Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Sciences (Springer, Berlin)

Erlander S 1982, “On the classical problem of equilibrium in statistical mechanics” report LiTH-MAT-R-82-50, Department of Mathematics, Linkoping Institute of Technology, Linkoping, Sweden; revised September 1983

Erlander S 1984, “On the principle of monotone likelihood and log-linear models” report LiTH-MAT-R-84-3, Department of Mathematics, Linkoping Institute of Technology, Linkoping, Sweden

Huang K 1963 Statistical Mechanics (John Wiley, New York)

Jaynes E T 1957a, “Information theory and statistical mechanics I” Physical Review 106 620–630

Jaynes E T 1957b, “Information theory and statistical mechanics II” Physical Review 108 171–190

Jaynes E T 1979, “Where do we stand on maximum entropy?” in The Maximum Entropy Formalism Eds Levine R D Tribus M (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 15–118

Kullback S 1959 Information Theory and Statistics (John Wiley, New York)

Münster A 1969 Statistical Thermodynamics (Springer, Berlin)

Shannon C E 1948, “A mathematical theory of communication” Bell System Technical Journal 27 379–423; 623–656; reprinted in The Mathematical Theory of Communication, 1979

Shannon C E Weaver W (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL)

Shannon C E Weaver W 1949 The Mathematical Theory of Communication (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL)

Smith T E 1977, “A general efficiency principle of spatial interaction” in Spatial Interaction Theory and Planning Models Eds Karlqvist A Lundqvist L Snickars F Weibull J W (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 97–119

Smith T E 1978, “A cost-efficiency principle of spatial interaction” Regional Science and Urban Economics 8 313–337

Snickars F Weibull J W 1977, “A minimum information principle: Theory and practice” Regional Science and Urban Economics 1 137–168

Spurkland S 1966, “Mathematical tools for urban studies” reprint 14, Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research, Nycoveien 1, Oslo 4

Wilson A G 1967, “A statistical theory of spatial distribution models” Transportation Research 1 253–269

Wilson A G 1970, “The use of the concept of entropy in system modelling” Operational Research Quarterly 21 247–265

Batten D F , 1983 Spatial Analysis of Interacting Economies (Kluwer Nijhoff, Boston)

Dacey M P Norcliffe A , 1976, “New entropy models in the social sciences” Environment and Planning A 8 299–310

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975a, “A note on the entropy formulation of distribution models” Operational Research Quarterly 26 755–758

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975b, “Social physics and quantum statistics” unpublished report; copy available from Dr Fisk, Transportation Planning Group, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign, Urbana, IL

Fotheringham A S , 1983a, “A new set of spatial-interaction models: The theory of competing destinations” Environment and Planning A 15 15–36

Fotheringham A S , 1983b, “Some theoretical aspects of destination choice and their relevance to production-constrained gravity models” Environment and Planning A 15 1121–1132

Lesse P F Brotchie J F Roy J R Sharpe R , 1978, “A new philosophy for regional modelling” in Proceedings of the Third Annual Conference of the Regional Science Association held at Melbourne, Australia; copy obtainable from Department of Geography, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria; pp 165–178

Roy J R , 1983, “Estimation of singly-constrained nested spatial interaction models” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 10 269–274

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1981, “On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling” Transportation Research 15B 85–96

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1985a, “Entropy models with entropy contraints on aggregated events” submitted to Environment and Planning A

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1985b, “Modelling commodity flows under uncertainty” Environment and Planning A (forthcoming)

Theil H , 1972 Statistical Decomposition Analysis (North-Holland, Amsterdam)

Wilson A G , 1967, “A statistical theory of spatial distribution models” Transportation Research 1 253–269

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975a, “A note on the entropy formulation of distribution models” Operational Research Quarterly 26 755–758

Fisk C S Brown G R , 1975b, “Social physics and quantum statistics” unpublished report; copy available from the first author

Roy J R Lesse P F , 1981, “On appropriate microstate descriptions in entropy modelling” Transportation Research 15B 85–96

Walsh P K Gibberd R W , 1983, “A probability analysis of some spatial interaction models” Transportation Research 17B 193–200