This paper is a report on a simultaneous study of renter movers' mental schemata, their overt search behaviour, and the structure of a housing submarket. Past research suggests that the pattern of intraurban migration can be rationalised using a model based upon an individual's mental image of the city. The mental image both facilitates search, and acts as a behavioural constraint upon the resident when he or she is searching for new accommodation. However, cognitive mapping per se has been less than exemplary in exposing the elusive bond between urban images and housing search behaviour. It is suggested that mental schemata are more appropriate than mental maps in delineating behaviour, as they represent cognitive structures and coding systems which enable the individual to respond to the shifting patterns of environmental stimuli. Personal construct theory is used to investigate the mental schemata of relocating renter households in London, Ontario. A strong correspondence between the respondents' mental construction of their environment and their overt behaviour (that is, where and how they searched) is reported. Several observations are made concerning the characteristics of renters, housing search, and the suburban–downtown split in the rental housing market of London.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsJS, 1969, “Directional bias in intra-urban migration”Economic Geography45302–345
2.
AitkenSC, 1983, “Residential cognition, search, and evaluation: A humanistic perspective and empirical validation”Ontario Geographer number 21, 67–85
3.
AitkenSC, 1984, “Normative views and ordering the urban milieu”The East Lakes Geographer191–15
4.
AitkenSC, 1986, “In search of rental accommodation: Sequential search stages and housing attribute discrimination in renters' home selection” in The Cost of Not Knowing Eds WinemanJBarnesRZimringC, Environmental Design Research Association Inc., PO Box 23129, L'Enfant Plaza Station, Washington, DC 20024; pp 145–155
5.
BarrettF, 1973, “Residential search behaviour: A study of intra-urban relocation in Toronto” Geographical Monographs 1, York University, Toronto, Ontario
6.
BarrettF, 1976, “The search process in residential relocation”Environment and Behaviour8169–199
7.
BellW, 1958, “Social choice, life styles and suburban residence” in The Suburban Community Ed. DobrinerW, (Putman, New York) pp 225–248
8.
BoyceRR, 1969, “Residential mobility and its implications for urban spatial change”Proceedings of the Association of American Geographers122–26
9.
BoyleMJRobinsonME, 1979, “Cognitive mapping and understanding” in Geography in the Urban Environment: Progress in Research and Applications Eds HerbertDJJohnstonRJ, (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp
10.
BrownLAHolmesJ, 1971, “Intraurban migrant lifelines: A spatial view”Demography8103–122
11.
ButlerEWChapinFSHemmensGCKaiserEJStegmanMAWeissSF, 1969, “Moving behavior and residential choice: A national survey” report 81, National Cooperation Highway Research Program, Highway Research Board, Washington, DC
12.
ClarkWAV, 1971, “A test of directional bias in residential mobility” in Perspectives in Geography 1: Models of Spatial Variations Eds McConnellHYaseenDW, (Northern Illinois University Press, De Kalb, IL) pp 1–27
13.
ClarkWAV, 1972, “Behaviour and the constraints of spatial structure”New Zealand Geographer28171–180
14.
ClarkWAV, 1981, “Residential mobility and behavioural geography: Parallelism or interdependence?” in Behavioural Problems in Geography Revisited Eds CoxKGolledgeR, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 182–205
15.
CMHC, 1984, “Local housing market report, London”Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, London Branch, PO Box 2845, 285 King St, London, Ontario N6A 4H4
16.
DonaldsonB, 1973, “An empirical investigation into the concept of sectoral bias in mental maps, search spaces and migration patterns of intra-urban migrants”Geograflska Annaler55013–33
17.
DownsRM, 1976, “Personal constructions of PCT” in Environmental Knowing Eds MooreGTGolledgeR, (Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross, Stroudsburg, PA) pp 72–88
18.
DownsRM, 1981, “Cognitive mapping: A thematic analysis” in Behavioural Problems in Geography Revisited Eds CoxKGolledgeR, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 95–123
19.
FordRGSmithGC, 1981, “Spatial aspects of intraurban migration behaviour in a mixed housing market”Environment and Planning A13355–371
20.
GillASmithG, 1985, “Residents' evaluative structures of Northern Manitoba mining communities”The Canadian Geographer2917–30
21.
GoldJR, 1980An Introduction to Behavioural Geography (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
22.
HarmanEJ, 1975A Behavioural Analysis of the Concepts Used in Housing Choice unpublished doctoral dissertation, Department of Geography, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario
23.
HarrisonJSarreP, 1971, “Personal construct theory in the measurement of environmental images, problems and methods”Environment and Behaviour3351–374
24.
HarrisonJSarreP, 1975, “Personal construct theory in the measurement of environmental images”Environment and Behaviour73–58
25.
HudsonR, 1980, “Personal construct theory, the repertory grid method and human geography”Progress in Human Geography4346–359
26.
HumpreysJSWhitelawJS, 1979, “Immigrants in an unfamiliar environment: Locational decision-making under constrained circumstances”Geographiska Annaler61B8–18
27.
JohnstonRJ, 1972Urban Residential Patterns: An Introductory Review (Praeger, New York)
28.
KellyG, 1955The Psychology of Personal Constructs (W W Norton, New York)
29.
McCarthyM, 1976, “The household life-cycle and housing choices”Papers, Regional Science Association3753–80
30.
McCarthyM, 1982, “An analytical model of housing search and mobility” in Modelling Housing Market Research Ed. ClarkWAV, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 30–54
31.
MaclennanPWoodG, 1982, “Information acquisition: Patterns and strategies” in Modelling Housing Market Research Ed. ClarkWAV, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 134–160
32.
MooreEG, 1986, “Mobility intention and subsequent relocation; insights from a longitudinal study”Urban Geography forthcoming
33.
MunroMLamontD, 1985, “Neighbourhood perception, preference, and household mobility in the Glasgow private housing market”Environment and Planning A171331–1350
34.
NeutzeM, 1968The Suburban Apartment Boom (Resources for the Future Inc. and Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, MD)
35.
PrestonVATaylorSM, 1981a, “Personal construct theory and residential choice”Annals of the Association of American Geographers21437–461
36.
PrestonVATaylorSM, 1981b, “The family life-cycle, leisure activities, and residential area evaluation”The Canadian Geographer25 (1) pp 46–59
37.
RosenbergR, 1976, “New approaches in person perception” in Nebraska Symposium on Motivation (University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, NE) pp A3–76
ShawMLGThomasLF, 1978, “Focus on education—an interactive computer system for the development and analysis of rep grids”International Journal of Man—Machine Studies10139–173
40.
ShawMLG, (Ed.), 1981Recent Advances in Personal Construct Technology (Academic Press, New York)
41.
ShortreedRM, (in progress), “Structural and functional land use change, London, Ontario (1915–1982)” master's dissertation, Department of Geography, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario
42.
SimmonsJWBakerAM, 1972, “Household movement patterns” RR54, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario
43.
StoughR, 1978The Cognitive Behavioral Approach to Geography unpublished PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD
44.
StoughR, 1981, “Systems bias and individual decisions in the intra-urban migration process” in Applied Systems and Cybernetics, volume 3 Ed. LaskerGE, (Pergamon Press, New York) pp 1542–1546
45.
StringerP, 1974, “Repertory grids in the study of environmental perception” in The Intra-Personal Space: Measurement of Subjective Variation by Grid Techniques Ed. SlaterP, (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)) pp 183–208
46.
TimmermansHvan der HeijdeRWesterweldP, 1982, “Cognition of urban retailing structures”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geographie732–12
47.
ThomasLFMendozaS, 1970, “Kelly-McQuitty: A computer programme for use with an on-line terminal”Centre for the Study of Human Learning, Brunei University, Uxbridge, Middx
48.
TuanY, 1975, “Images and mental maps”Annals of the Association of American Geographers65205–213
49.
UrellJT, 1976Residential Mobility Amongst Renter Households unpublished PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH
50.
VaradyP, 1983, “Determinants of residential mobility decisions”Journal of American Planning Association49184–199
