Research suggests that conventional wisdom about the ‘miraculous’ reindustrialization of the regional economy of Massachusetts is much too simplistic. The decline in unemployment was as much the result of low average labor-force growth as it was of rapid job creation. Also Massachusetts has experienced increases in income and wage inequality, and there has been a dramatic slowdown in employment growth. The manufacturing sector is still deindustrializing and high-tech job growth has virtually ceased. Several complementary explanations are offered for these changes. First, a chronic labor shortage is constraining company expansion. Second the declining rate of growth of federal military procurement may particularly affect Massachusetts. Third, the state economy may have begun to converge on a new equilibrium structure. A shift–share analysis of employment changes during the periods 1973 – 79, 1979 – 84, and 1984 – 87 reveals that the state's competitive advantage has narrowed to a small number of business services and their associated real estate and construction activities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AzadBFoleyA, 1988, “Average wages and total wage and salary disbursements: Comparison of Suffolk County [Boston] with Massachusetts and the US, 1969 – 1986”, Department of Policy Development and Research, Boston Redevelopment Authority, Boston, MA
2.
BarffR AKnightP LIII, 1988, “The role of federal military spending in the timing of the New England turnaround”Papers of the Regional Science Association63100–114
3.
BartlettS, 1984High Technology Growth and Regional Labor MarketsPhD thesis, Department of Urban Studies and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
BluestoneBHarrisonB, 1982The Deindustrialization of America (Basic Books, New York)
6.
BluestoneRHarrisonBJordanPSullivanM, 1981Aircraft Industry Dynamics (Auburn House, Boston)
7.
BrowneL E, 1978, “How different are regional wages?”New England Economic Review January/February issue, pp 33–43
8.
BrowneL E, 1984, “How different are regional wages? A second look”New England Economic Review March/April issue, pp 40–47
9.
BrowneL E, 1987, “Too much of a good thing? Higher wages in New England”New England Economic Review January/February issue, pp 39–53
10.
Bureau of the Census, US Department of Commerce, March Current Population Survey computer tapes, March 1964-March 1987, Washington, DC
11.
Bureau of the Census, 1985, “Current industrial reports: Shipments to federal government agencies”, US Department of Commerce (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
12.
Bureau of Economic Analysis, US Department of Commerce, “The input-output structure of the US economy, 1977” Survey of Current Business, May 1984 (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
13.
ChinitzB, 1988, “Many threats to continued prosperity”Boston Globe Sunday January 31, page A2
14.
DavisL A, 1982, “Technological intensity of US output and trade”, International Trade Administration, US Department of Commerce, Washington, DC
15.
DET, various years, “ES-202 Employment Data”, 1974 – first quarter, 1988, Division of Employment and Training, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, MA
16.
DET, various years, “BLS-790”, 1974 – 1988, Division of Employment and Training, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, MA
17.
DoeringerP BTerklaD GTopakianG C, 1987Invisible Factors in Local Economic Development (Oxford University Press, New York)
18.
DorfmanN, 1988, “Route 128: The development of a regional high technology center”, inThe Miracle of Massachusetts Ed. LampeD, (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 240–247
19.
FarrantR, 1987, “Disjuncture in Hampden County's metal-working labor market, and what to do about it”, Machine Action Project, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Springfield, MA
20.
FeldmanJ M, 1988, “Converting the military economy through the local state: Local conversion prospects in Massachusetts”Bulletin of Peace Proposals19 (1) 99–116
21.
FergusonRLaddH, 1988, “Massachusetts”, inThe New Economic Role of American States Ed. FosterR S, (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 21–90
22.
GanslerJ S, 1980The Defense Industry (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
23.
GeiserKHarrisonB, 1985, “The high-tech industry comes down to earth”Boston Globe Sunday 23 June, page C1
24.
GlasmeierA, 1985, “Innovative manufacturing industries: Spatial incidence in the United States”, inHigh Technology, Space, and Society Ed. CastellsM, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 55–80
25.
GrahamJRossR, 1989, “Taking the miracle out of Massachusetts: Employment policy in the era of global capitalism”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research forthcoming
26.
GreinerA, 1987, “The housing affordability gap and Boston's economic growth: Potential for crisis”, Boston Redevelopment Authority, Boston, MA
27.
HarrisonB, 1982, “Rationalization, restructuring, and industrial reorganization in older regions: The economic transformation of New England since World War II”, WP-72, Joint Center for Urban Studies of MIT and Harvard University, reprinted 1984 inSunbelt-Snowbelt Eds SawersLTabbW K, (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 48–96
28.
HarrisonBBluestoneB, 1988The Great U-turn: Corporate Restructuring and the Polarizing of America (Basic Books, New York)
29.
HekmanJ SStrongJ S, 1981, “The evolution of New England industry”New England Economic Review March/April issue, pp 35–46
30.
HooverE MVernonR, 1959Anatomy of a Metropolis (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
31.
KluverJ, 1988, “From work to home: Boston's hotel workers and the prospects for union-sponsored housing”, thesis, Master of City Planning Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
32.
KnightP LIIIBarffR A, 1987, “Employment growth and the turnaround in the New England economy”Northeast Journal of Business and Economics Fall/Winter issue, pp 1–15
33.
LampeD, 1988, “The making of a miracle” The Miracle of Massachusetts Ed. LampeD, (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp iii–xx
34.
LeavittR B, 1986, “By the sword we seek peace: Military spending and state government in Massachusetts”, MS dissertation, Department of Political Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
35.
MarkusenA, 1985Profit Cycles, Oligopoly, and Regional Development (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
36.
MarkusenA, 1986, “Defense spending and the geography of high technology industries”, inTechnology, Regions, and Policy Ed. ReesJ, (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ) pp 94–119
37.
MarkusenAHallPDeitrichSCampbellS, 1988The Rise of the Gun Belt book manuscript in preparation, 1988 draft; contact Ann Markusen, Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ
38.
MartinRRowthornB, (Eds) 1986The Geography of Deindustrialization (Macmillan, London)
39.
MasnickG, 1986, “New England loses migrants”New England Economic Project MonitorSchool of Business, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, August issue, pp 6–7
40.
MoritaAReingoldE MShimomuraM, 1986Made in Japan: Akio Morita and Sony (Dutton, New York)
41.
NashG B, 1986The Urban Crucible (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
42.
NelsonK, 1986, “Labor demand, labor supply, and the suburbanization of low-wage office work”, inProduction, Work, Territory Eds ScottA JStorperM, (Allen and Unwin, Winchester, MA) pp 149–171
43.
NortonR D, 1987, “The role of services and manufacturing in New England's economic resurgence”New England Economic IndicatorsFederal Reserve Bank of Boston, Second Quarter 1987, pp iv–viii
O'hUallachianB, 1987, “Regional and technological implications of the recent buildup in American defense spending”Annals of the Association of American Geograhers77 (2) 208–223
46.
OsborneD, 1988Laboratories of Democracy (Harvard Business School Press, Boston)
47.
PattersonG, 1987, “Defense industry sees hard times ahead”Boston Globe Sunday 22 November, page A1
48.
PersonickV A, 1987, “Projections 2000: Industry output and employment through the end of the century”Monthly Labor Review11030–45
49.
PioreM JSabelC, 1984The Second Industrial Divide (Basic Books, New York)
50.
RenshawVTrottE AJrFriedenbergH L, 1988, “Gross state product by industry, 1963 – 86”Survey of Current Business68 pp 30–46
51.
RodwinLSazanamiH, (Eds) 1989Deindustrialization and Regional Economic Transformation (Unwin Hyman, London)
52.
SassenS, 1988The Mobility of Labor and Capital (Cambridge University Press, New York)
53.
SaxenianA L, 1986, “In search of power: The organization of business interests in Silicon Valley and Route 128”, working paper, Department of Political Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
54.
Senate Committee on Ways and Means, 1984, “There is more than one Massachusetts economy” Chairman Chester Atkins, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, State Senate, Boston, MA
55.
ThurowL, 1985The Zero-sum Solution (Simon and Schuster, New York)
