Third World countries are evidencing a dramatic growth of informal services that has made the size of their tertiary sector relative to the secondary considerably larger than that observed historically in the now industrialized countries. Although this phenomenon of tertiary sector hypertrophy has received much attention in the literature, the possibility of regional variation within the Third World has been relatively unexplored. It is argued that there are strong rationales for expecting a spatial variation in the sectoral partitioning of labor and in tertiary sector hypertrophy, and that the experiences of less developed countries cannot be generalized. Empirical analysis using 1980 data from 108 countries shows that countries in Africa exhibited the highest levels of tertiary hypertrophy at a given income level, followed by Asia and Latin America. Regional differences are apparent in the income level at which the maximum hypertrophy is observed. It is suggested that analyses of structural changes in development need to be sensitive to the spatial, temporal, and contextual milieux.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdelmanIMorrisC, 1967Society, Politics and Economic Development (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
2.
AlamMAzharR, 1987, “Determinants of employment expansion in the services sector: A cross-country study of LDCs”The Journal of Developing Areas2225–40
3.
AminS, 1974Accumulation on a World Scale: A Critique of the Theory of Underdevelopment (Monthly Review Press, New York)
4.
BaerWHerveM E A, 1966, “Employment and industrialization in developing countries”Quarterly Journal of Economics888–107
5.
BaerWSamuelsonL, 1981, “Towards a service-oriented growth strategy”World Development9499–514
6.
BairochP, 1973Urban Unemployment in Developing Countries (International Labour Office, Geneva)
7.
BairochPLimborJ, 1968, “Changes in the industrial distribution of the world labor force by region, 1880–1960”International Labour Review98311–336
8.
BaranP, 1957The Political Economy of Growth (Monthly Review Press, New York)
9.
BauerP TYameyB S, 1951, “Economic progress and occupational distribution”Economic Journal61741–755
10.
BerryA, 1978, “A positive interpretation of the expansion of urban services in Latin America, with some Colombian evidence”Journal of Development Studies14210–231
11.
BhallaA, 1973, “A disaggregative approach to employment in the LDCs”Journal of Development Studies1050–75
12.
CasettiE, 1972, “Generating models by the expansion method: Applications to geographic research”Geographical Analysis481–91
13.
CasettiE, 1982, “Mathematical modeling and the expansion method”, in Statistics for Social Geographers and Social Scientists Ed. MandaiR, (Concept Publishing, New Delhi) pp 81–95
14.
CheneryH, 1960, “Patterns of industrial growth”American Economic Review50624–654
15.
CheneryHSyrquinM, 1975Patterns of Development 1950–1970 (Oxford University Press, New York)
16.
ClarkC, 1940The Conditions of Economic Progress (Macmillan, London)
17.
ClarkC, 1957The Conditions of Economic Progress3rd edition (Macmillan, London)
18.
Dos SantosT, 1970, “The structure of dependence”American Economic Review60231–236
19.
DurandJ, 1975The Labor Force in Economic Development (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
20.
ECLA, 1965, “Structural changes in employment within the context of Latin America's economic development”, Economic Commission for Latin America, Economic Bulletin for Latin America10163–187
21.
FisherA G B, 1935, “Economic implications of material progress”International Labour Review3224–38
22.
FisherA G B, 1939, “Production, primary, secondary and tertiary”Economic Record1524–38
23.
FourastieJ, 1949Le Grand Espoir du XX Siècle (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
24.
FrankA G, 1966, “The development of underdevelopment”Monthly Review1817–31
25.
FuchsV, 1968The Service Economy (Columbia University Press, New York)
26.
GalensonW, 1963, “Economic development and the sectoral expansion of employment”International Labour Review87505–519
27.
GemmellN, 1982, “Economic development and structural change: The role of the service sector”Journal of Development Studies1937–66
28.
GershunyJMilesI, 1983The New Service Economy (Frances Pinter, London)
29.
HamiltonR, 1989, “Unemployment and business formation rates: Reconciling time-series and cross-section evidence”Environment and Planning A21249–255
30.
HarrisJTodaroM P, 1970, “Migration, unemployment and development: A two-sector analysis”American Economic Review60126–142
31.
HartK, 1973, “Informal income opportunities and urban employment in Ghana”Journal of Modern African Studies1161–89
32.
ILO, 1972Employment, Incomes and Inequality: A Strategy for Increasing Productive Employment in Kenya (International Labour Office, Geneva)
33.
ILO, 1983–85Yearbook of Labour Statistics (International Labour Office, Geneva)
34.
KamerschenD, 1969, “Further analysis of overurbanization”Economic Development and Cultural Change17235–253
35.
KatouzianM, 1970, “The development of the service sector: A new approach”Oxford Economic Papers22362–382
36.
KiernanV, 1974, “Marx and India”, in Marxism and Imperialism Ed. KiernanV, (Edward Arnold, Sevenoaks, Kent)
37.
KuznetsS, 1966Modern Economic Growth: Rate, Structure and Spread (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
38.
LaneJ-EErssonS, 1988, “Correlates of development”International Social Science Journal115271–284
39.
LewisW A, 1954, “Economic development with unlimited supplies of labour”Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies22139–192
40.
LittleIScitovskyTScottM, 1970Industry and Trade in Some Developing Countries (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
41.
MazumdarD, 1976, “The urban informal sector”World Development4655–679
42.
MorawetzD, 1974, “Employment implications of industrialization in developing countries: A survey”Economic Journal84491–542
43.
MoserC, 1978, “Informal sector or petty commodity production: Dualism or dependence in urban development?”World Development61041–1064
44.
MouleyJCostaE, 1974Employment Policies in Developing Countries: A Comparative Analysis (International Labour Office, Geneva)
45.
OberaiA S, 1978Changes in the Structure of Employment with Economic Development (International Labour Office, Geneva)
46.
PanditKCasettiE, 1989, “Shifting patterns of sectoral labor allocation: MDCs versus LDCs”Annals of the Association of American Geographers79329–344
47.
RamR, 1987, “Wagner's hypothesis in time-series and cross-section perspectives: Evidence form ‘real’ data for 115 countries”The Review of Economics and Statistics69194–204
48.
RamosJ, 1970Labor and Development in Latin America (Columbia University Press, New York)
49.
ReitsmaHKleinpenningJ, 1985The Third World in Perspective (Rowman and Allanheld, Totowa, NJ)
50.
ReynoldsL, 1965, “Wages and employment in a labor-surplus economy”American Economic Review5519–39
51.
RostowW, 1960Stages of Economic Growth (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
52.
SaboloY, 1975aThe Service Industries (International Labour Office, Geneva)
53.
SaboloY, 1975b, “Employment and unemployment, 1960–90”International Labour Review112401–407
54.
SchultzT P, 1981Economics of Population (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA)
55.
SilberJ, 1983, “ELL (the equivalent length of life) or another attempt at measuring development”World Development1121–29
56.
SquireL, 1979Labor Force, Employment, and Labor Markets in the Course of Economic Development World Bank Staff WP-336 (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
57.
SzabadiB, 1975, “Relationship between the level of economic development and the services”Acta Oeconomica15343–364
58.
TaylorL, 1969, “Development patterns: A simulation study”Quarterly Journal of Economics83220–241
59.
TodaroM P, 1985Economic Development in the Third World3rd edition (Longman, New York)
60.
TurnhamD, 1971The Employment Problem in Less Developed Countries (OECD, Paris)
61.
UdallA, 1976, “The effects of rapid increases in labor supply on service employment in developing countries”Economic Development and Cultural Change24765–785
62.
WeeksJ, 1975, “Policies for expanding employment in the informal urban sector of developing economies”International Labour Review1111–13
63.
World Bank, 1983World Tables (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
