It is argued that there are important parallels and intersections between critical theoretical analysis in legal studies and in geography. Each critical tradition is sceptical about the ontological status of its disciplinary foundation—‘law’ in legal studies, and ‘space’ in geography. Furthermore, the reification of particular distinctions in legal discourse is deepened by spatial distinctions. A convergence of critical legal and geographic analyses can thus have powerful analytical consequences, and the authors attempt to demonstrate this point by investigating judicial approaches to the regulation of worker health and safety in two federal states, Canada and the United States. They conclude with a discussion of the theoretical and political significance of critical legal geography, and suggest some directions it might take in the future.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alltrans, 1983Re Alltrans Express Ltd and Workers' Compensation Board of BC (1983), 149 D.L.R. (3d) 385 (B.C.C.A.)
2.
Alltrans, 1988Alltrans Express Ltd v Workers' Compensation Board of British Columbia [1988] 1 S.C.R. 897, 51 D.L.R. (4th) 253
3.
AndersonK J, 1987, “The idea of Chinatown: The power of place and institutional practice in the making of a racial category”Annals of the Association of American Geography77580–598
4.
Asta v Illinois, 1989 U.S., 110 S. Ct. 52, cert denied, sub nom.
5.
BakanJ C, 1991, “Constitutional interpretation and social change: You can't always get what you want (nor what you need)”, in Canadian Perspectives in Legal Theory Ed. DevlinREmond-Montgomery, Toronto) pp 445–465
6.
Bell, 1985Bell Canada v Commission de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (1985) 16 D.L.R. (4th) 345 (Que. C.A.)
7.
Bell, 1988Bell Canada v Commission de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (1988) 1 S.C.R. 749, 51 D.L.R. (4th) 161
8.
BermanH J, 1983Law and Revolution: The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
9.
BennettR J, 1989, “Assignment of competency and resources”, in Territory and Administration in Europe Ed. BennettRFrances Pinter, London) pp 54–71
10.
BennettR J, 1990, “Decentralization, local governments and markets: Towards a post welfare agenda”, in Decentralization, Local Governments and markets: Towards a Post Welfare Agenda Ed. BennettRClarendon Press, Oxford) pp 1–26
11.
BlomleyN K, 1989, “Text and context: Rethinking the law geography nexus”Progress in Human Geography13512–534
12.
BlomleyN K, 1990, “Federalism, place and the regulation of worker safety”Economic Geography6622–46
13.
BowlbyS R, 1984, “Planning for women to shop in post-war Britain”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space2179–199
14.
BoydS, 1989, “Child custody, ideologies and employment”Canadian Journal of Women and Law3111–133
15.
BrodyH, 1988Maps and Dreams: Indians and the British Columbia Frontier (Douglas and McIntyre, Vancouver)
16.
CarterP, 1988The Road to Botany Bay: An Exploration of Landscape and History (Alfred A Knopf, New York)
17.
Committee on Government Operations, 1988Getting Away with Murder in the Workplace: OSHA's Non-use of Criminal Penalties for Safety Violations (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
18.
Constitution Act, 186730 & 31 Victoria chapter 3
19.
CosgroveD E, 1984Social Formation and Symbolic Landscape (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants)
20.
Courtois, 1988Canadian National Railway Co. v Courtois [1988] 1 S.C.R. 868, 51 D.L.R. (4th) 271
21.
DevlinR (Ed.), 1991Canadian Perspectives in Legal Theory (Emond-Montgomery, Toronto)
22.
ElyJ H, 1980Democracy and Distrust (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
23.
Factum of the Attorney-General of Quebec in Bell, 1988Mémoire du mis-en-cause, Le procureur général du Québec filed 20 January 1986, Supreme Court of Canada
24.
FishmanR, 1987Bourgeois Utopias: The Rise and Fall of Suburbia (Basic Books, New York)
25.
FudgeJ, 1987, “The public/private distinction: The possibilities of and the limits to the use of charter litigation to further feminist struggles”Osgoode Hall Law Journal25485–554
26.
FudgeJ, 1988, “Labour, the new constitution and old style liberalism”, in Labour Law Under the Charter (Queen's Law Journal and Industrial Relations Centre, Kingston) pp 61–82
27.
GaviganS, 1988, “Law, gender and ideology” in Legal theory meets legal practice Ed. BayefskyA FAcademic Printing and Publishing, Edmonton) pp 283–298
28.
GlabersonW, 1988, “States are toppling workplace convictions”New York Times 19 September, pages A1, D5
29.
GordonR, 1984, “Critical legal histories”Stanford Law Review3657–125
30.
HarveyD, 1989The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
31.
HayD, 1975, “Property, authority and the criminal law” in Albion's Fatal Tree: Crime and Society in Eighteenth Century England Eds. Hay (Pantheon Books, New York) pp 17–63
32.
Hegedus, 1989People v Hegedus1989, 443 N W 2d 127 (Mich.)
33.
HelgersonR, 1986, “The land speaks: Cartography, chorography and subversion in Renaissance England”Representations1651–85
34.
HoggP, 1985Constitutional Law of Canada (Carswell, Toronto)
35.
HutchinsonA (Ed.), 1989Critical Legal Studies (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ)
36.
HutchinsonA, 1991, “Crits and cricket: A deconstructive spin (or was it googly?)”, in Canadian Perspectives on Legal Theory Ed. DevlinREmond-Montgomery, Toronto) pp 181–206
37.
JonesS D, 1990–91, “State prosecutions for safety-related crimes in the workplace: Can D.A.'s succeed where OSHA failed?”Kentucky Law Journal79139–158
38.
KairysD, 1991The Politics of Law (Pantheon Books, New York)
39.
KelmanM, 1987A Guide to Critical Legal Studies (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
40.
KinneyJ A, 1989, “Jail terms for negligent bosses”New York Times 20 November, page A23
41.
KlareK, 1982, “The public private distinction in labour law”University of Pennsylvania Law Review1301358–1422
42.
KlineM, 1991, “Child welfare law, ideology, and the first nations” LLM thesis, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University, North York, Ontario; forthcoming in Osgoode Hall Law Journal
43.
LefebvreH, 1979, “Reflections on the politics of space”Antipode8(2) 30–37
44.
MacklemP, 1990, “Property, status, and workplace organizing”University of Toronto Law Journal4074–108
45.
Magnet Wire, 1987People v Chicago Magnet Wire Corporation, 1987, 510 N.E.2d 1173 (Ill.)
46.
Magnet Wire, 1989People v Chicago Magnet Wire Corporation, 1989, 534 N.E.2d 962 (Ill.)
47.
MardenP, 1992, “‘Real’ regulation considered”Environment and Planning A24751–767
48.
MagnusonJ, 1987, “Interview”Corporate Crime Reporter 27 April, pp 8–14
49.
Note, 1987, “Getting away with murder: Federal OSHA preemption of state criminal prosecutions for industrial accidents”Harvard Law Review101535–554
50.
Note, 1990, “Constructing the state extraterritoriality: Jurisdictional discourse, the national interest and transnational norms”Harvard Law Review1031273–1305
51.
NSWI, 1990Criminal Job Safety Prosecutions: Lessons Learned, Prospects for the FutureNational Safe Workplace Institute, Suite 1450, 122 South Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL 60603)
52.
NSWMA, 1990National Solid Waste Management Ass. v Director EPA and A-G. Illinois, 1990, 918 F.2d 671 (Ill.)
53.
OlsenF, 1983, “The family and the market: A study of ideology and legal reform”Harvard Law Review961497
54.
OSH Act, Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, 29 USC sections 651–78 (1982)
55.
PascalB, 1670—republished in 1960 as Pensées: Notes on Religion and Other Subjects (Dent, London)
56.
PellerG, 1985, “The metaphysics of American Law”California Law Reviews731152–1290
57.
PondS, 1986, “Local officials set up new programs as others urge caution over trend to use criminal prosecutions for workplace hazards”Occupational Safety and Health Reporter 4 October, pp 1132–1135
58.
Pred, 1990Lost Words and Lost Worlds: Modernity and the Language of Everyday Life in Late Nineteenth Century Stockholm (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
59.
PrescottJ R V, 1987Political Frontiers and Boundaries (Allen and Unwin, London)
60.
Pymm, 1990People v Pymm1990, 563 N.E.2d 1 (NY)
61.
ReedI, 1989, “The black pathology biz”The Nation249597–598
62.
Sabine, 1988Sabine Consolidated Inc. v State1988, 756 S.W.2d 865 (Tex.)
63.
SimeonR, 1983, “Criteria for choice in federal systems”Queen's Law Review8131–157
64.
StinchombeA L, 1963, “Institutions of privacy in the determination of police administrative practice”American Journal of Sociology69150–180
65.
TigarM ELevyM R, 1977Law and the Rise of Capitalism (Monthly Review Press, New York)
66.
WeinsteinH, 1989, “Protections for workers now challenged by federal laws”Los Angeles Times 21 February, page D1
