Recent reorganization of the US iron and steel industry provides a useful setting for an analysis of the relationship between industrial location and institutional forms. Regression analysis shows that institutional shifts in the organization of production dominated geographical shifts in employment and product value as integrated maxi-mills sought to raise productivity. The reorganization of production includes mill abandonment, increased subcontracting by maxi-mills in the initial stages of production, horizontal penetration by mini-mills in the sheet-steel market, and the growing integration of steel finishing and automobile assembly as firms that belong to Japanese corporate groups expand their operations in the USA. Maxi-mills are concentrating investment and production in the Midwest states as their joint ventures with Japanese steel firms specialize in the mass production of galvanized sheets for the automobile industry. Locational shifts also include the national spread of scrap-processing mini-mills and the rapid decline of raw-steel production in Pittsburgh as maxi-mills close furnaces and mills producing construction-grade bars and rods.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsW, 1964, “Vertical power, dual distribution, and the squeeze: A case study in steel”Antitrust Bulletin9493–508
2.
AISE, 1988Directory Iron and Steel PlantsAssociation of Iron and Steel Engineers, 3 Gateway Center, Suite 2350, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
3.
AISI, 1973, 1990aList of Raw Steel ProducersAmerican Iron and Steel Institute, 1133 15th Street NW, Washington, DC 20005
4.
AISI, 1975, 1990bAnnual Statistical ReportAmerican Iron and Steel Institute, 1133 15th Street NW, Washington, DC 20005
5.
AlchianAADemsetzH, 1972, “Production, information costs, and economic organization”The American Economic Review62777–795
6.
AMM, 1989, “Foreign investment in the US steel industry”American Metal Market97(196) 4A
7.
AMM, 1991Metal Statistics 1990–91eighty-third edition, American Metal Market, 825 7th Avenue, New York, NY 10019
8.
AMM, 1992, “Vertical integration is target”American Metal Market100(183) 3
AokiM, 1990, “Toward an economic model of the Japanese firm”Journal of Economic Literature281–27
11.
AsanumaB, 1985, “The organization of parts purchases in the Japanese automotive industry”Japanese Economic Studies1332–53
12.
BalcerekT, 1989a, “Japanese companies grab big stake in US integrated steel”American Metal Market97(79) 1, 8
13.
BalcerekT, 1989b, “Japanese partners give US bar makers an edge”American Metal Market97(85) 1, 16
14.
BalcerekT, 1989c, “USS/Kobe aim: Record of earnings”American Metal Market97(107) 2A
15.
BalcerekT, 1989d, “Electrogalvanizing comes on strong: Japanese transplant auto plants add to the demand”American Metal Market97(131) 2A
16.
BalcerekT, 1989e, “Japanese steelmakers go slow in US ventures”American Metal Market97(196) 4A
17.
BarnettDFSchorschL, 1983Upheaval in a Basic Industry (Ballinger, Cambridge, MA)
18.
BaumolWJPanzarJCWilligRD, 1982Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York)
19.
BeesonPE, 1992, “Agglomeration economies and productivity growth”, in Sources of Metropolitan Growth Eds MillsESMcDonaldJF (Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 19–38
20.
BerryB, 1989a, “Organic coatings are taking hold”American Metal Market97(131) 6A
21.
BerryB, 1989b, “Galvanizing puts on new coats”Iron Age5(9) 55–61
22.
BerryB, 1989c, “Galvanized steels shine brighter in Detroit”Iron Age6(7) 18–24
23.
BrownRE, 1990, “Iron and steel scrap”, in Minerals Yearbook, volume 1, US Department of the Interior (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC) pp 553–575
24.
CalemPSCarlinoGA, 1991, “Urban agglomeration economies in the presence of technical change”Journal of Urban Economics2982–95
25.
ClarkGL, 1988, “Corporate restructuring in the steel industry: Adjustment strategies and local labor relations”, in America's New Market Geography Eds SternliebGHughesJ (Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 179–214
26.
ClarkGL, 1991, “Regulating the restructuring of the US steel industry: Chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code and pension obligations”Regional Studies25135–153
27.
CrandallRW, 1987, “The effects of U.S. trade protection for autos and steel”Brookings Papers on Economic Activity1271–287
28.
CrandallRWBarnettDF, 1986Up from the Ashes: The Rise of the Steel Minimill in the United States (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
29.
DemsetzH, 1991, “The theory of the firm revisited”, in The Nature of the Firm: Origins, Evolution, and Development Eds WilliamsonOEWinterSG (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 159–178
30.
DennisonSR, 1939, “Vertical integration in the iron and steel industry”Economic Journal49244–258
31.
EdgingtonDW, 1993, “The globalisation of Japanese manufacturing corporations”Growth and Change2487–106
32.
EngelbertRW, 1989, “USX and Kobe announce joint venture to operate Lorain works”Iron and Steel Engineer66(9) 52–53
33.
FloridaRKenneyM, 1990, “High-technology restructuring in the USA and Japan”Environment and Planning A22233–252
34.
FloridaRKenneyM, 1992, “Restructuring in place: Japanese investment, production organization, and the geography of steel”Economic Geography61146–173
35.
FurukawaT, 1989, “Nippon pushing research for corrosion resistance”American Metal Market97(234) 6A
36.
GiuniperoLCO'NealC, 1988, “Obstacles to JIT procurement”Industrial Marketing Management1735–41
37.
HaflichF, 1992, “Nucor, Oregon go separate ways: Joint study to buy or build plant for hot-briquetted iron is aborted”American Metal Market100(181) 1, 7
HoerrJP, 1988And the Wolf Finally Came: The Decline of the American Steel Industry (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
43.
HoganW, 1984Steel in the United States: Restructuring to Compete (Lexington Books, Lexington, MA)
44.
HoganW, 1987, “The steel industry today”Iron and Steel Engineer64(4) 50–52
45.
HolmesJ, 1983, “Industrial reorganization, capital restructuring and locational change: An analysis of the Canadian automobile industry in the 1960's”Economic Geography59251–271
46.
HuskonenWD, 1988, “New technology, cost control ahead for mini-mills”33 Metal Producing26(3) 20–22
47.
ImaiKItamiH, 1984, “Interpenetration of organization and market: Japan's firm and market in comparison with the U.S.”International Journal of Industrial Organization2263–310
48.
InabaM, 1989, “Planned joint venture may export EG sheet”American Metal Market97(119) 1, 16
49.
Iron Age1988, “USX selling rail and shipping operations to investment group”4(8) 13
50.
Iron Age1989, “National Steel may add coke batteries at Great Lakes”5(8) 11–15
51.
Iron Age1990, “Bethlehem Steel plans freight car and ore boat sales”6(9) 10
52.
Iron Age1991, “Clean air act leaves steel in a fog”7(8) 30–32
53.
IsrailevichP, 1986, “The birth of the competitive market in the steel industry”, WP-8606, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, Cleveland, OH 44101
54.
ItamiH, 1987Mobilizing Invisible Assets (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
55.
JewkesJ, 1930, “Factors in industrial integration”Quarterly Journal of Economics44621–638
56.
JudgeGGGriffithsWEHillCarter RLeeT, 1980The Theory and Practice of Econometrics (John Wiley, New York)
57.
KarlsonSH, 1983, “Modeling location and production: An application to the U.S. fully integrated steel plants”The Review of Economics and Statistics6541–50
58.
KehoeB, 1991, “The PBGC's asset-minded professor lays down the law”Iron Age7(7) 27–29
59.
KenneyMFloridaR, 1992, “The Japanese transplants: Production organization and regional development”Journal of the American Planning Association5821–38
60.
LabeeCJSamwaysNL, 1990, “Developments in the iron and steel industry U.S. and Canada—1989”Iron and Steel Engineer67(2) D1–D40
61.
LabeeCJSamwaysNL, 1991, “Developments in the iron and steel industry U.S. and Canada—1990”Iron and Steel Engineer68(2) D1–D40
62.
LoveringJ, 1990, “Fordism's unknown successor: A comment on Scott's theory of flexible accumulation and the re-emergence of regional economies”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research14159–174
63.
McManusGJ, 1987, “The return to stand alone steelmaking”Iron Age3(5) 18–30
64.
McManusGJ, 1989, “Taking the wraps off Nucor's sheet mill”Iron Age5(6) 18–26
65.
McManusGJ, 1991, “On your mark, get set, grow”Iron Age7(5) 14–19
66.
McManusGJ, 1993, “Will iron carbide revolutionize steelmaking?”Iron Age920–22
67.
MairAFloridaRKenneyM, 1988, “The new geography of automobile production: Japanese transplants in North America”Economic Geography64352–373
68.
MarcusPFKirsisKM, 1989, “Steel on verge of fierce restructuring”American Metal Market97(141) 26–27
69.
MarkusenA, 1986, “Neither ore, nor coal, nor markets: A policy-oriented view of steel sites in the USA”Regional Studies20449–462
70.
MarleyM, 1992, “The better the scrap, the better the melt”American Metal Market100(183) 8A, 18A
71.
MasseyDMeeganR, 1982The Anatomy of Job Loss: The How, Why, and Where of Employment Decline (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
72.
Moody's Investors Service Inc., 1989Moody's Industrial Manual, Volume 2New York, page 6382
73.
NewmanRG, 1988, “The buyer-supplier relationship under just-in-time”Production and Inventory Management Journal2945–49
74.
PollockB, 1992, “Bethlehem shuts bar unit”American Metal Market100(20) 1, 4
75.
ReidNÓhuallacháinB, 1990, “Comments on Japan's direct manufacturing investment”The Professional Geographer42223–226
76.
ReveT, 1990, “The firm as a nexus of internal and external contracts”, in The Firm as a Nexus of Treaties Eds AokiMGustafssonBWilliamsonOE (Sage, London) pp 133–161
77.
RodgersA, 1952, “Industrial inertia, a major factor in the location of the steel industry in the United States”Geographical Review4256–66
78.
RubensteinJM, 1987, “Further changes in the American automobile industry”Geographical Review77359–362
79.
SayerA, 1986, “New developments in manufacturing: The just-in-time system”Capital and Class3043–72
80.
SayerA, 1989, “Postfordism in question”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research13666–695
81.
ScolieriP, 1990, “Armco gets nod from Toyota: Emission grades of stainless meet automaker's standards”American Metal Market98(39) 2, 20
82.
ScolieriP, 1991, “Bethlehem places coal units on block”American Metal Market99(171) 2
83.
ScolieriP, 1992, “U.S. steel to shut South Works mill”American Metal Market100(7) 1, 6
84.
ScottAJ, 1988, “Flexible production systems and regional development: The rise of new industrial spaces in North America and Western Europe”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12171–185
85.
SerjeantsonRCorderoRCookeH (Eds), 1987Iron and Steel Works of the World9th edition (Metal Bulletin Books Ltd, London)
86.
SmithSK, 1991, “Technological integration and fragmented labour market structures. The decline and restructuring of the US steel integrated sector”International Contributions to Labour Studies127–57
87.
Standard and Poor's Corporation, 1990, “Railroads and trucking”Industry Surveys, Volume 2 July, R1–R58
88.
USDoC, 19811977 Census of Manufacturers US Department of Commerce (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
89.
USDoC, 1991a1989 Annual Survey of Manufacturers US Department of Commerce (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
90.
USDoC, 1991b1987 Census of Manufacturers US Department of Commerce (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
91.
WarrenAM, 1992, “Working with suppliers in a tough market”American Metal Market100(233) 12A, 18A
92.
WilliamsonOE, 1975Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications (The Free Press, New York)
93.
WilliamsonOE, 1983, “Credible commitments: Using hostages to support exchange”American Economic Review73519–540
94.
WilliamsonOE, 1985The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets and Relational Contracting (The Free Press, New York)
95.
WilliamsonOE, 1990, “The firm as a nexus of treaties: An introduction”, in The Firm as a Nexus of Treaties Eds AokiMGustafssonBWilliamsonOE (Sage, London) pp 1–25
96.
WilloughbyWF, 1901, “The integration of industry in the United States”Quarterly Journal of Economics1694–115
97.
WozniakG, 1987, “Human capital, information, and early adoption of new technology”Journal of Human Resources22101–112
98.
WrigleyAL, 1992, “New Mazda plan uses all U.S. produced steel”American Metal Market100(225) 1, 6
99.
33 Metal Producing1988, “Mini-Mill Directory”26(3) 34–43
