The growing trends for political and economic integration within the European Union signal a need for improved cohesion of national data sets to allow for comparative cross-national research on socioeconomic topics. Difficulties in achieving comparability of variables and spatial bases can apply whether analysis is undertaken at the most macro level (that of entire nations) or at more micro spatial scales. In this paper we will discuss the methodological problems which can arise from comparative cross-border analysis by using small-area census data within Ireland (North and South) as illustration. As this analysis demonstrates, limited overlap between the specific variables in national data sets, different national contexts for socioeconomic indicators, and variations between data sets in the size of spatial units can all cause analytical problems at this spatial scale. In particular, scale mixing can potentially result in very misleading interpretations. Possible solutions to these problems are discussed, and policy recommendations are made in relation to microscale spatial data sets at the national, as well as at the pan-European, level.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmrheinC G, 1995, “Searching for the elusive aggregation effect: Evidence from statistical simulations”Environment and Planning A27105–119
2.
ArnaudR, 1991La France en Chiffres 1992 (Hatier, Paris)
3.
BlankR M, 1995, “Changes in inequality and unemployment over the 1980s—comparative cross-national responses”Journal of Population Economics8(1) 1–21
4.
BoalF WDohertyPPringleD G, 1974The Spatial Distribution of Some Social Problems in the Belfast Urban Area (Northern Ireland Community Relations Commission, Belfast)
5.
BoalF WDohertyPPringleD G, 1978, “Social problems in the Belfast urban area: An exploratory analysis”, OP-12, Department of Geography, Queen Mary College, London
6.
BurrowsR, 1999, “Residential mobility and residualisation in social housing in England”Journal of Social Policy28(1) 27–52
7.
CavenNEvansTBeattyR, 1998, “The Northern Ireland census of population and housing: Looking back and looking forward”, paper presented to the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland, Belfast; copy available from the authors
8.
ComptonP A, 1993, “Population censuses in Northern Ireland: 1926–1991”, in The 1991 Census User's Guide Eds DaleAMarshC, (HMSO, London) pp 330–351
9.
DaviesHJoshiHClarkeL, 1997, “Is it cash that the deprived are short of?”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A160(1) 107–126
10.
DugganC, 1999, “Locally based interventions to combat poverty and exclusion: How effective can they be?”Administration47(2) 56–77
11.
Eurostat, 1995Regions: Nomenclature of Territorial Units for Statistics (Office for Official Publications of the European Community, Luxembourg)
12.
Eurostat, 1996Population, Households and Dwellings in Europe (Office for Official Publications of the European Community, Luxembourg)
13.
FaganCRuberyJ, 1996, “The salience of the part-time divide in the European Union”European Sociological Review12227–250
14.
GoodyearP MEastwoodD A, 1978, “Spatial variations in level of living in Northern Irleand”Irish Geography1154–67
15.
HaaseT, 1995, “The designation of disadvantaged areas in the local development programme”, report to Area Development Management Ltd to facilitate the designation of areas under the Operational Programme for Local Urban and Rural Development, 1995–1999; copy available from the authors
16.
HaaseT, 1999, “Affluence and deprivation: A spatial analysis based on the 1991 Census of Population”, in Poor People, Poor Places Eds PringleD GWalshJHennessyM, (Oak Tree Press, Dublin) pp 13–35
17.
HaggettP, 1965Locational Analysis in Human Geography (Edward Arnold, London)
18.
HakimC, 1991, “Cross-national comparative research on the European Community: The EC Labour Force Surveys”Work, Employment and Society5(1) 101–117
19.
HowellFO'MahoneyMDevlinJO'ReillyOButtanshawC, 1993, “A geographical distribution of mortality and deprivation”Irish Medical Journal8696–99
20.
IshidaHMullerWRidgeJ M, 1995, “Class origin, class destination, and education: A cross-national-study of 10 Industrial Nations”American Journal of Sociology101(1) 145–193
21.
JacksonJ AHaaseT, 1996, “Demography and the distribution of deprivation in rural Ireland”, in Poverty in Rural Ireland Eds CurtinCHaaseTToveyH, (Combat Poverty Agency, Dublin) pp 59–85
22.
JowellR, 1998, “How comparative is comparative research?”American Behavioral Scientist42168–177
23.
LamN S-N, 1983, “Spatial interpolation methods: A review”American Cartographer10129–149
24.
LangevinBBegeotFPearceD, 1992, “Censuses in the European Community”Population Trends6833–36
25.
LangfordI H, 1994, “Using empirical Bayes estimates in the geographical analysis of disease risk”Area26142–149
26.
LinehanT P, 1991–92, “History and development of Irish population censuses”Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland26(4) 91–125
27.
MartinD, 1991Geographic Information Systems and their Socioeconomic Applications (Routledge, London)
28.
MooreA J, 1995, “Deprivation payments in general practice: Some spatial issues in resource allocation in the UK”Health and Place1(2) 121–125
29.
NolanBWhelanC TWilliamsJ, 1998Where Are Poor Households? (Oak Tree Press/Combat Poverty Agency, Dublin)
30.
NolanBWhelanC TWilliamsJ, 1999, “Spatial aspects of poverty and deprivation in Ireland”, in Poor People, Poor Places Eds PringleD GWalshJHennessyM, (Oak Tree Press, Dublin) pp 37–74
31.
O'ConnellC, 1994, “Housing in the Republic of Ireland: Review of trends and recent policy measures”Administration42159–169
32.
O'DowdLCorriganJMooreT, 1995, “Borders, national sovereignty and European integration: The British-Irish case”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research19272–285
33.
OpenshawS, 1984The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem Concepts and Techniques in Modern Geography series, number 38 (Geo Books, Norwich)
34.
PinchemelP, 1987France: A Geographical, Social and Economic Survey (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
35.
PooleM A, 1995, “The spatial distribution of political violence in Northern Ireland: An update to 1993”, in Terrorism's Laboratory: The Case of Northern Ireland Ed. O'DayA, (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants) pp 27–45
36.
Project Team, 1976Belfast Areas of Special Social Need (HMSO, London)
37.
RobsonBBradfordMDeasI, 1994Relative Deprivation in Northern IrelandCentre for Urban Policy Studies, Manchester University, Manchester
38.
SAHRU, 1997, “A national deprivation index for health and health services research”, technical report number 2, Small Area Health Research Unit, Department of Community Health and General Practice, Trinity College, Dublin
39.
SweeneyP, 1998The Celtic Tiger (Oak Tree Press, Dublin)
40.
TanenbaumEMochmannE, 1994, “Integrating the European database—infrastructure services and the need for integration”International Social Science Journal46499–511
41.
TsakloglouP, 1996, “Elderly and non-elderly in the European Union: A comparison of living standards”Review of Income and Wealth42271–291
42.
UN/ECE, 1997, “Recommendations for the 2000 Censuses of Population and Housing in the ECE Region”, Statistical Standards and Studies, number 49 (United Nations, Geneva)
43.
VisvalingamM, 1978, “The signed chi-square measure for mapping”Cartographic Journal1593–98
44.
WatersR, 1995, “Data sources and their availability for business users across Europe”, in GIS for Business and Service Planning Eds LongleyPClarkeG, (GeoInformation International, Cambridge) pp 33–47
45.
WilliamsJ, 1993, “Spatial variations in deprivation surrogates—a preliminary analysis”, report to the Combat Poverty Agency, Economic and Social Research Institute, Dublin
46.
WrightJ K, 1937, “Some measures of distributions”Annals of the Association of American Geographers27177–211
