The collision between economic systems after 1989 led to significant new forms of mobility. East Central Europe became a legally and institutionally constructed ‘buffer zone’ between Western Europe and the CIS, Commonwealth of Independent States—the former USSR. The opportunities for and costs of migration in the buffer zone were shaped by the ‘double territorial shock’ of the transition: reinterationalisation and the withdrawal of massive state intervention in support of regional convergence. The authors provide a comparative study of mobility and migration into and out of the buffer zone, through case studies of Ukrainians working in Slovakia, and Slovakians working in Austria. Whereas the Ukrainians are largely confined to the secondary-labour market, the Slovakians are found in both segments of the dual labour market. This leads to different implications in respect of ‘brain drain’ and ‘brain waste’ of international skilled-labour mobility, as well as amplifying income differences. The overall effect in both cases is to contribute to the reproduction of economic inequalities in the buffer zone, and this is explored through an analysis of savings and investment and future employment intentions. The conclusions are particularly pessimistic in respect of the wage differentials required to persuade Ukrainian migrants to return to their country of origin.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AppleyardR, 1989, “International migration and developing countries”, in The Impact of International Migration on Developing Countries (OECD, Paris), pp 19–36.
2.
BeaverstockJ V, 1994, “Rethinking skilled international labour migration: World cities and international banking organisations” Geoforum25323–338.
3.
CastlesSMillerM J, 1993The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in the Modern World (Macmillan, London).
4.
CESTAT, 1999Statistical Bulletin (joint publication by the Czech Statistical Office, Prague; Hungarian Central Statistical Office, Budapest; Central Statistical Office of Poland, Warsaw; Statistical Office of the Republic Slovenia, Ljubljana; Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic, Bratislava).
5.
CohenR, 1987The New Helots: Migrants and the International Division of Labour (Gower, Aldershot, Hants).
6.
CohenR, 1997Global Diasporas: An Introduction (UCL Press, London).
7.
DomaradzkaE, 1997, “Incomer from East to Poland: A Report on surveys carried out in the years 1995–1996”, Economic and Labour Market Development and International Migration joint research project, WP P1–22-e, Institute for Employment Research, Nürnberg; Institute of Labour and Social Studies, Migrationspotential Ostmitteleuropa: Struktur und Motivation potentieller Migranten aus Polen, der Slowakei, Tschechien und Ungarn [Migration potential of Eastern Europe: the structure and motivation of potential migrants from Poland, Slovakia, the Czech Republic and Hungary], ISR-Forschungsberichte 15, Institut für Stadt und Regionalforschung Österreichische Akademie der Wischenschaften, Vienna.
8.
FassmannHKollárD, 1996, “The rise of transnational labour markets: The Austrian – Slovakian example”, paper presented to the 36th Europen Congress of the European Regional Science Association, Zurich; copy available from the author.
9.
FassmannHKohlbacherJReegerU, 1993“Suche Arbeit”—Eine empirische Analyse über Stellensuchende aus dem Ausland [“I am looking for a job ”—an empirical analysis on jobseeking by foreigners]ISR-Forschungsberichte 10, Institut für Stadt und Regionalforschung Österreichische Akademie der Wischenscaften, Vienna.
10.
FassmannHKohlbacherJReegerU, 1995Die ‘Neue Zuwandernung aus Ostmitteleuropa’—Eine empirische Analyse am Beispiel der Polen in Österreich [‘The new immigration from Eastern Europe’—an empirical analysis of the example of Poles in Austria] ISR-Forschungsberichte 13, Institut für Stadt und Regionalforschung Österreichische Akademie der Wischenschaften, Vienna.
11.
FindlayAGarrickL, 1990, “Scottish emigration in the 1980s: A Migration channels approach to the study of skilled international migration” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series15177–192.
12.
FindlayALiFJowettASkeldonR, 1996, “Skilled international migration and the global city: A Study of expatriates in Hong Kong” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series2149–61.
13.
FrejkaTBisiR, 1996International Migration in Central and Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States Economic Studies no 8 (United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, United Nations Population Fund, New York).
14.
GhoshB N, 1985, “Brain migration from the Third World: An implicative analysis” Rivista Internazionale di Scienze Economiche en Commerciali34(1) 21–34.
15.
GossJLindquistB, 1995, “Conceptualizing international labor migration: A Structuration perspective” International Migration Review29317–351.
16.
GrečicV, 1993, “Mass migration from Eastern Europe: A Challenge to West?”, in The New Geography of European Migration Ed. KingR (Belhaven Press, London) pp 135–151.
17.
HalfacreeK, 1995, “Household migration and the structuration of patriarchy: Evidence from the USA” Progress in Human Geography19159–182.
18.
HodsonRKaufmanR L, 1982, “Economic dualism: A Critical review” American Sociological Review47727–740.
19.
HorálekMKošMHorákováM, 1996, “Work stays of Czech nationals in Germany”, WP Cz-3-e, Economic and Labour Market Development and International Migration Joint Research Project Institute for Employment Research, Nürnberg; Institute of Labour and Social Studies, Warsaw; Research Institute of Labour and Social Affairs, Prague.
20.
IglickaK, 1999, “The economies of petty trade on the Eastern Polish border”, in The Challenge of the East – West Migration for Poland Eds IglickaKSwordK (Macmillan, London) pp 120–144.
21.
International Organisation for Migration, 1998, “Information campaign against trafficking in women from Ukraine”, research report, International Organisation for Migration, Geneva.
22.
JerczynskiM, 1999, “Patterns of spatial mobility of citizens of the former Soviet Union”, in The Challenge of the East–West Migration for Poland Eds IglickaKSwordK (Macmillan, London) pp 105–119.
KingR, 1993, “Why do people migrate? The geography of departure”, in The New Geography of European Migrations Ed. KingR (Belhaven Press, London) pp 17–46.
25.
KingR, 1998, “From guestworkers to immigrants: Labour migration from the Mediterranean periphery”, in The New Europe: Economy, Society and Environment Ed. PinderD (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 263–280.
26.
KollárD, 1997, “Sozialgeographische aspekte der migration aus de Slowakei nach Österreich” [Social and geographical aspects of migration from Slovakia to Austria] Földrajzi Értesítö46(3–4) 173–182.
27.
KollárD, 1998, “Development of the Slovak labour migration and migration to Austria”, in Ruchliwosc prezsrezcionni ludnosci w okresie przemian ustrojowich [Migration patterns during transition] (Universitet Mikolaja Kopernika, Torun) pp 124–141.
28.
KorczynskaJ, 1997a, “Commuting Polish workers at the border to Germany—survey results”, WP P1–26-e, Economic and Labour Development and International Migration joint research project Institute for Employment Research, Nurνberg; Institute of Labour and Social Studies, Warsaw; Research Institute of Labour and Social Affairs, Prague.
29.
KorczynskaJ, 1997b, “Seasonal labour migration to Germany–survey results”, WP P1–26-e, Economic and Labour Development and International Migration joint research project Institute for Employment Research, Nurνberg; Institute of Labour and Social Studies, Warsaw; Research Institute of Labour and Social Affairs, Prague.
30.
LiF I NFindlayA MJonesH, 1998, “A cultural economy perspective on service sector migration in the global city: The case of Hong Kong” International Migration36(2) 131–157.
31.
MasseyD S, 1986, “The settlement process among Mexican migrants to the United States” American Sociological Review51670–685.
32.
MasseyDArangoJHugoGKouaouchiAPellegrinoATaylorJ, 1993, “Theories of international migration: A Review” Population and Development Review19431–466.
33.
MincerJ, 1978, “Family migration decisions” Journal of Political Economy86769–773.
34.
MolhoI, 1986, “Theories of migration: A Review” Scottish Journal of Political Economy33396–415.
35.
MydelRFassmannH, 1997Nielegalni robotnici cudzoziemscy i carny rynek praci. Polsci nielegalni pracownicy w Wiedniu [Illegal foreign workers and black labour market] (Instytut Geografii Universytetu Jagiellonskiego, Krakov).
36.
ÖbergS, 1997, “Theories of inter-regional migration”, in People, Jobs and Mobility in the New Europe Eds BlotevogelH JFieldingA J (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 24–38.
37.
OdéAvander Knapp B, 1998, “Contemporary patterns of labour based migration to the Netherlands”, in Crossing Borders: Regional and Urban Perspectives on International Migration Eds GorterCNijkampPPootJ (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants), pp 203–221.
38.
OECD, 1998Trends in International Migration: Sopemi Annual Report (OECD, Paris).
39.
OECD, 1999EMU: Facts, Challenges and Policies (OECD, Paris).
40.
PioreM, 1979Birds of Passage: Migrant Labor in Industrial Societies (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
41.
PuglieseE, 1993, “Restructuring of the labour market and the role of Third World migrations in Europe” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space11513–522.
42.
RhodeB, 1993, “Brain drain, brain gain, brain waste: Reflections on the emigration of highly educated and scientific personnel from Eastern Europe”, in The New Geography of European Migration Ed. KingR (Belhaven Press, London) pp 228–245.
43.
SaltJ, 1988, “Highly skilled international migrants, careers and internal labour markets” Geoforum19387–399.
44.
SaltJ, 1992, “Migration processes among the highly skilled in Europe” International Migration Review26484–505.
45.
SaltJClarkeJ, 1996, “European migration report” New Community22513–529.
46.
SaltJFindlayA, 1989, “International migration of highly-skilled manpower: Theoretical and developmental issues”, in The Impact of International Migration on Developing Countries Ed. AppleyardR (OECD, Paris) pp 159–180.
47.
SassenS, 1991The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
48.
SjaastadL A, 1962, “The costs and returns of human migration” The Journal of Political Economy7080–93.
49.
SmithA, 1998, “Breaking the old and constructing the new? Geographies of uneven development in Central and Eastern Europe”, in Geographies of Economies Eds LeeRWillsJ (Arnold, London) pp 331–344.
50.
StalkerP, 1994The Work of Strangers: A Survey of International Labour Migration (International Labour Organization, Geneva).
51.
StarkO, 1991The Migration of Labour (Blackwell, Oxford).
52.
TaylorE J, 1992, “Remittances and inequality considered: Direct, indirect and intertemporal effects” Journal of Policy Modelling14187–208.
53.
United Nations, 2000World Migration Report 2000 (United Nations and International Organization for Migration, New York).
54.
WallaceCChmouliarOSidorenkoE, 1996, “The Eastern frontier of western Europe: Mobility in the buffer zone” New Community22259–286.
55.
WilliamsA MBalážV, 1999, “Transformation and division in Central Europe”, in Divided Europe: Society and Territory Eds HudsonRWilliamsA M (Sage, London) pp 163–184.
56.
WilliamsA MBalážVZujacS, 1998, “The EU and Central Europe: The reinternationalisation of economic relationships” Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie89131–149.
57.
WilpertC, 1998, “Migration and informal work in the new Berlin: New forms of work or new sources of labour” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies24269–294.
