In this paper I study the choice of residence of ethnic Estonians from the Soviet Union in Estonia. The aim is to clarify the extent to which the differences in the current residence of ethnic return migrants stem from their childhood growth environment. First, the groups of foreign-born Estonians are compared based on 1989 Soviet census data. The ethnic return migrants' place of residence is significantly related to their level of education and language skills: two variables corresponding to their previous residence, migration experience, and generational belonging. Second, the survey data are used to measure how closely the return migrants' current level of education and language skills correspond to their early socialization environment. The parents' level of education and the language of childhood significantly impact upon the level of education and language skills that return migrants have today. However, the current differences in the level of education and language skills have also been influenced by their life environment in Estonia. Yet, even when the influence of the current life environment on these variables has been eliminated, the levels of education and language skills appear to be an important source of the differences in residence. Thus, the research supports the idea that an individual's earlier socialization environment has a critical impact on their choice of residence.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AldrichJ HNelsonF D, 1984Linear Probability, Logit, and Probit Models Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 45 (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
2.
AmemyiaT, 1981, “Qualitative response models: A survey”Journal of Economic Literature191483–1536.
3.
AsherH B, 1983Causal Modeling Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 3, 2nd edition (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
4.
BarnettC, 1998, “The cultural turn: Fashion or progress in human geography?”Antipode30379–394.
5.
BerryW D, 1984Nonrecursive Causal Models Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 37 (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
6.
BlossfeldH-PRohwerG, 1995Techniques of Event History Modeling: New Approaches to Causal Analysis (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ).
BrownL AMooreE G, 1970, “The intra-urban migration process: A perspective”Geografiska Annaler B521–13.
9.
CadwalladerM, 1985, “Structural-equation models of migration: An example from the Upper Midwest USA”Environment and Planning A17101–113.
10.
CadwalladerM, 1986, “Structural equation models in human geography”Progress in Human Geography1024–47.
11.
CadwalladerM, 1989, “A conceptual framework for analysing migration behaviour in the developed world”Progress in Human Geography13494–511.
12.
CadwalladerM, 1991, “Metropolitan growth and decline in the United States: An empirical analysis”Growth and Change221–16.
13.
CadwalladerM, 1992Migration and Residential Mobility: Macro and Micro Approaches (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI).
14.
Census, 1989, “The micro-data on 40 271 foreign-born ethnic Estonians”, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
15.
DesbaratsJ M, 1983, “Constrained choice and migration”Geografiska Annaler B6511–22.
16.
Détang-DessendreC, 1999, “Reciprocal link between exit from unemployment and geographical mobility”Environment and Planning A311417–1431.
17.
FindlayA MGrahamE, 1991, “The challenge facing population geography”Progress in Human Geography15149–162.
18.
FindlayA MLiF L N, 1997, “An auto-biographical approach to understanding migration: The case of Hong Kong emigrants”Area2934–44.
19.
FindlayA MLiF L N, 1999, “Methodological issues in researching migration”The Professional Geographer5150–59.
20.
GrahamE, 1999, “Breaking out: The opportunities and challenges of multi-method research in population geography”The Professional Geographer5176–89.
21.
GuttingD, 1996, “Narrative identity and residential history”Area28482–490.
22.
HalfacreeK H, 1995, “Household migration and the structuration of patriarchy: Evidence from the USA”Progress in Human Geography19159–182.
23.
HalfacreeK HBoyleP J, 1993, “The challenge facing migration research: The case for a biographical approach”Progress in Human Geography17333–348.
24.
HeckmanJ J, 1978, “Dummy endogenous variables in a simultaneous equation system”Econometrica46931–959.
25.
HedströmPSwedbergR, 1998, “Social mechanisms: An introductory essay”, in Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory Eds HedströmPSwedbergR, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 1–31.
26.
JamesL RSinghB K, 1978, “An introduction to the logic, assumptions, and basic analytic procedures of two-stage least squares”Psychological Bulletin851104–1122.
27.
KatusK, 1990, “Demographic trends in Estonia throughout the centuries”Yearbook of Population Research in Finland2850–66.
28.
KatusKPuurA, 1992Eesti rahvastiku suremustrend elutabelite analüüsi põhjal [Mortality trends of the Estonian population on the basis of life tables] Population Studies B14, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
29.
KatusKPuurA, 1993The 1989 Estonian Population and Housing Census: Data Description Population Studies A33, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
30.
KatusKSakkeusL, 1993Foreign-born Population in Estonia Population Studies B19, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
31.
KleckaW R, 1980Discriminant Analysis Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 19 (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
32.
KuluH, 1997Eestlaste tagasiränne 1940–1989. Lääne-Siberist pärit eestlaste näitel [Estonian return migration 1940–1989. A case of West-Siberian Estonians] Publicationes Instituti Geographici Universitatis Helsingiensis C9, University of Helsinki, Helsinki.
33.
KuluH, 1998a, “Ethnic return migration: An Estonian case”International Migration36313–336.
34.
KuluH, 1998bForeign-born Population in Estonia: Formation and Migration Population Studies B 38, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
35.
KuluH, 2000, “An individual's growth environment and migration behaviour: The case of foreign-born Estonians”International Journal of Population Geography6367–381.
36.
LawsonV A, 1998, “Hierarchical households and gendered migration in Latin America: Feminist extensions to migration research”Progress in Human Geography2239–53.
37.
LawsonV A, 1999, “Questions of migration and belonging: Understandings of migration under neoliberalism in Ecuador”International Journal of Population Geography5261–276.
38.
LeitnerH, 1995, “International migration and the politics of admission and exclusion in postwar Europe”Political Geography14259–278.
39.
LiF L NJowettA JFindlayA MSkeldonR, 1995, “Discourse on migration and ethnic identity: Interviews with professionals in Hong Kong”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series20342–356.
40.
McHughK E, 2000, “Inside, outside, upside down, backward, forward, round and round: A case for ethnographic studies in migration”Progress in Human Geography2471–89.
41.
McKenderickJ H, 1999, “Multi-method research: An introduction to its application in population geography”The Professional Geographer5140–50.
42.
MarksooA, 1976, “On the regularities of the concentration process in the settlement system of the Estonian S.S.R.”Transactions of the Tartu State University, Publications on Geography1394–108.
43.
OlssonG, 1965Distance and Human Interaction: A Review and Bibliography Bibliography Series Number Two, Regional Science Research Institute, Philadelphia, PA.
44.
OstergrenR C, 1988A Community Transplanted: The Trans-Atlantic Experience of a Swedish Immigrant Settlement in the Upper Middle West, 1835–1915 (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI).
45.
ReaT, 1960, “Eesti NSV linnaliste asulate geneetilisest klassifikatsioonist (sotsialismieelsel perioodil)” [On the genetic classification of the Estonian urban settlements (in the presocialist period)]Transactions of the Tartu State University, Publications on Geography118–44.
46.
RukavishnikovV O, 1978, “Ethnosocial aspects of population distribution in cities of Tataria”Soviet Sociology359–79.
47.
SakkeusL, 1991Post-war Migration Trends in Estonia Population Studies B15, Estonian Interuniversity Population Research Centre, Tallinn.
48.
SchroederL DSjoquistD LStephanP E, 1986Understanding Regression Analysis: An Introductory Guide Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 57 (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
49.
SjöbergÖTammaruT, 1999, “Transitional statistics: Internal migration and urban growth in post-Soviet Estonia”Europe-Asia Studies51821–842.
50.
Survey, 1998, “The survey data on 250 foreign-born ethnic Estonians”, Center for Estonian Diaspora Studies, Tartu University, Tartu.
51.
TesfahuneyM, 1998, “Mobility, racism and geopolitics”Political Geography17499–515.
52.
TsoppE, 1976, “Local centres in settlement systems”Transactions of the Tartu State University, Publications on Geography13109–121.
53.
VikatA, 1994Family Formation in Estonia Publications of the Finnish Demographic Society 15 (Finnish Demographic Society, Helsinki).
54.
WhitePJacksonP, 1995, “(Re)theorising population geography”International Journal of Population Geography1111–123.
55.
WhiteS, 1980, “Philosophical dichotomy in migration research”The Professional Geographer2947–52.
