The Potential and Limits of Progressive Neopluralism: A Comparative Study of Forest Politics in Coastal British Columbia and South East New South Wales during the 1990s
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 2002
The Potential and Limits of Progressive Neopluralism: A Comparative Study of Forest Politics in Coastal British Columbia and South East New South Wales during the 1990s
During the 1990s the management of forests in British Columbia (Canada) and New South Wales (Australia) underwent many changes. For most of the decade the governments in both of these political jurisdictions were more socially and environmentally aware than their immediate predecessors. They were, however, far short of what many environmental and social activists desired. The New Democratic Party in British Columbia, led to government by Mike Harcourt, and the Australian Labor Party in New South Wales led by Bob Carr, may both be described as ‘centre-left/light-green’ in their political persuasions. This paper develops the regulation approach to explore the achievements, the potential and the limitations of these governments in the area of forest politics. It is argued that these governments implicitly adopted a progressive neopluralist approach to forest politics and attempted to manage environmental conflict by securing the agreement of many diverse interest groups. The experience of these two governments raises questions about the potential and limitations not just of the particular governments, but of a progressive neopluralist political strategy to achieve sustainable forest management.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABARE, 1998Economic Assessment of Selected Forest Uses in the Eden Region of New South WalesAustralian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics, GPO Box 1563, Canberra, ACT 2601
2.
AgliettaM, 1979A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience (New Left Books, London)
3.
AlnasseriSBrandUSablowskiTWinterJ, 2001, “Space, regulation and the periodization of capitalism”, in Phases of Capitalist Development: Booms, Crises and Globalizations Eds AlbrittonRItohMWestraRZuegeAPalgrave, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 162–178
4.
AltvaterE, 1993The Future of the Market: An Essay on the Regulation of Money and Nature after the Collapse of ‘Actually Existing Socialism’ (Verso, London)
5.
AltvaterE, 1994, “The global order of the societal relationship with nature”, unpublished paper, Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University, Toronto
6.
ApseyMLaishleyDNordinVPailleG, 2000, “The perpetual forest: using lessons from the past to sustain Canada's forests in the future”The Forestry Chronicle7629–53
7.
AthanasiouT, 1996, “The age of greenwashing”Capitalism, Nature, Socialism71–36
8.
BainR, 1998, “Carr Eden proposal unsustainable for jobs or the forests”, media release by the National Association of Forest Industries, http://www.nafi.com.au/media/view.php3?id=80 accessed 15 March 2000
9.
BakkerK, 1998, “Yorkshire Water and Yorkshire's water: flows of water/capital in the drought of 1995”, WP 98/01, Economic Geography Research Group, Royal Geographical Society/Institute of British Geographers, London
10.
BarnesTHayterRHayE, 1999, “‘Too young to retire, too bloody old to work’: forest industry restructuring and community response in Port Alberni, British Columbia”The Forestry Chronicle75781–792
11.
BeaverstockJTaylorPSmithR, 1999, “A roster of world cities”Cities16445–458
12.
BederS, 1997Global Spin: The Corporate Assault on Environmentalism (Scribe Publications, Melbourne)
BernsteinSCashoreB, 1999, “World trends and Canadian forest policy: exploring the influence of consumers, environmental group activity, international trade rules and world forestry negotiations”The Forestry Chronicle7534–38
15.
Boycott Woodchipping Campaign, 1999, “Daishowa Paper Manufacturing Company Ltd.: corporate overview June, 1999”, http://www.green.net.au/boycott/daishowa4.html accessed 23 November 2000
16.
BoyerR, 1990The Regulation School: A Critical Introduction (Columbia University Press, New York)
17.
BrandD, 1997, “Forest management in New South Wales, Australia”The Forest Chronicle73578–585
18.
BrayG, 1998New South Wales Year Book, No. 78, 1988Australian Bureau of Statistics, St. Andrew's House, Sydney Square, Sydney, NSW 2000
19.
BrennerN, 1999, “Regulation theory and the regionalization debate: recent German contributions”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17645–650
20.
BrennerRGlickM, 1991, “The regulation approach: theory and history”New Left Review number 188, 45–119
21.
Brett-DaviesN, 1998, “Emerging trends in Canadian forest policy”The Forestry Chronicle7472–74
22.
BridgeGMcManusP, 2000, “Sticks and stones: environmental narratives and discursive regulation in the forestry and mining sectors”Antipode3210–47
23.
British Columbia Ministry of Forests, 1994Forestry in British Columbia: The Answer BookBritish Columbia Ministry of Forests, 595 Pandora Avenue, Victoria
24.
BurdaCGaleFM'GonigleM, 1998, “Eco-forestry versus the state(us) quo: or why innovative forestry is neither contemplated nor permitted within the state structure of British Columbia”BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterlynumber 119, 45–72
25.
ButtoudG, 2000, “How can policy take into consideration the ‘full value’ of forests?”Land Use Policy17169–175
26.
Canadian Institute of Forestry, 1998, “Aboriginal forestry—special theme issue”The Forestry Chronicle74323–371
27.
CoadyL, 2000, “What I saw of the revolution: reflections of a corporate environmental manager in the 1990s BC coastal forest industry”The Forestry Chronicle76263–274
Commonwealth of Australia, 1998Australia's Forests—The Path to Sustainability (Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra)
30.
CORE, 1995British Columbia's Strategy for Sustainability: Report to the Legislative Assembly, 1994 – 95Commission on Resources and Environment, Victoria
31.
Council of Forest Industries, 1997Council of Forest Industries Annual ReportCouncil of Forest Industries, 1200-Two Bentall Centre, 555 Burrard Street, PO Box 276, Vancouver, BC V7X 157
32.
CrononW, 1996, “The trouble with wilderness: or, getting back to the wrong nature”, in Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature Ed. CrononWW W Norton, New York) pp 69–90
33.
DahlR, 1961Who Governs? (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
34.
DahlR, 1967Pluralist Democracy in the United States (Rand McNally, Chicago, IL)
35.
DesforGKeilR, 1999, “Contested and polluted terrain”Local Environment4331–352
36.
DevallB, 1993Clearcut: The Tragedy of Industrial Forestry (Sierra Club Books, San Francisco, CA)
37.
DargavelJ, 1998, “Politics, policy and process in the forests”Australian Journal of Environmental Management525–30
38.
DrummondI, 1996, “Conditions of unsustainability in the Australian sugar industry”Geoforum27345–354
Forest Alliance of British Columbia/Vancouver Board of Trade, 1997, “The economic impact of the forest industry on Metropolitan Vancouver”, Forest Alliance of British Columbia, BC-Suite 1200, 1130 Pender Street West, Vancouver, BC V6E 4A4, Vancouver Board of Trade, World Trade Centre, Suite 400, 999 Canada Place, Vancouver, BC V6C 3C1
43.
GandyM, 1997, “The making of regulatory crisis: restructuring New York City's water supply”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series22338–358
GibbsD, 1996, “Integrating sustainable development and economic restructuring: a role for regulation theory”Geoforum271–10
46.
GibbsDJonasA, 2000, “Governance and regulation in local environmental policy: the utility of a regime approach”Geoforum31299–313
47.
GoodwinMPainterJ, 1997, “Concrete research, urban regimes and regulation theory”, in Reconstructing Urban Regime Theory; Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy Ed. LauriaMSage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 13–29
48.
GoodwinMDuncanSHalfordS, 1993, “Regulation theory, the local state, and the transition of urban politics”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1167–88
49.
GoodwinMClokePMilbourneP, 1995, “Regulation theory and rural research: theorising contemporary rural change”Environment and Planning A271245–1260
50.
GrayS, 1989, “The government's timber business: forest policy and administration in British Columbia, 1912 – 1928”BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterlynumber 81, 24–29
51.
HagerNBurtonB, 1999Secrets and Lies: The Anatomy of An Anti-environmental PR Campaign (Craig Potton Publishing, Nelson, New Zealand)
52.
Harris-Daishowa, undated, “Some background information about Harris-Daishowa (Australia) Pty. Ltd”, Harris-Daishowa (Australia) Pty Ltd, PO Box 189, Eden, NSW 2551
53.
HaughtonG, 1998, “Private profits—public drought: the creation of a crisis in water management in West Yorkshire”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series23419–434
54.
HayC, 1994, “Crisis, what crisis? Re-stating the problem of regulation”, WP 47, Lancaster working papers in political economy, political economy of local governance series, University of Lancaster, Lancaster
55.
HayC, 1995, “Restating the problem of regulation and reregulating the local state”Economy and Society24387–407
56.
HayterR, 2000Flexible Crossroads: The Restructuring of British Columbia's Forest Economy (UBC Press, Vancouver)
57.
HobergG, 2001, “‘Don't forget government can do anything’: policies towards jobs in the British Columbia forest sector”, in In Search of Sustainability: British Columbia Forest Policy in the 1990s Eds CashoreBHobergGHowlettMRaynerJWilsonJUBC Press, Vancouver) pp 207–231
58.
HowlettM, 2001, “Policy venues, policy spillovers, and policy change: The courts, Aboriginal rights, and British Columbia forest policy”, in In Search of Sustainability; British Columbia Forest Policy in the 1990s Eds CashoreBHobergGHowlettMRaynerJWilsonJUBC Press, Vancouver) pp 94–119
59.
HowlettMRaglonR, 1992, “Constructing the environmental spectacle: green advertisements and the greening of the corporate image, 1910 – 1990”Environmental History Review Winter, 53–68
60.
HuttonT, 1997, “Vancouver as a control centre for British Columbia's resource hinterland: Aspects of linkage and divergence in a provincial staple economy”, in Troubles in the Rainforest Eds BarnesTHayterRWestern Geographical Press, Victoria) pp 233–261
61.
JessopB, 1995, “The regulation approach, governance and post Fordism: alternative perspectives on economic and political change?”Economy and Society24307–333
62.
JessopB, 1997, “Capitalism and its future: remarks on regulation, government and governance”Review of International Political Economy4561–581
63.
JonesM R, 1997, “Spatial selectivity of the state? The regulationist enigma and local struggles over economic governance”Environment and Planning A29831–864
64.
KirkpatrickJ, 1998, “Nature conservation and the Regional Forest Agreement process”Australian Journal of Environmental Management531–37
65.
KumiJ, 1997, “British Columbia's Forest Practices Code: back to basics”The Forest Chronicle77353–355
66.
LaclauEMouffeC, 1985Hegemony and the Socialist Strategy: Toward a Radical Democratic Politics (Verso, London)
MacLeodGJonesM, 1999, “Reregulating a regional rustbelt: institutional fixes, entrepreneurial discourse, and the ‘politics of representation’”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17575–605
73.
McLennanW, 19991999 Year Book AustraliaAustralian Bureau of Statistics, ABS House, 45 Benjamin Way, Belconnen ACT 2617
74.
McLennanW, 20002000 Year Book Australia (Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra)
75.
McManusP, 1999, “Histories of forestry: ideas, networks and silences”Environment and History5185–208
76.
McManusPAlbrechtG, 2000, “Environmental and Aboriginal issues: the emergence of new tensions in rural and regional politics”, in Land of Discontent: The Dynamics of Change in Rural and Regional Australia Eds PritchardBMcManusPUniversity of New South Wales Press, Sydney) pp 105–122
77.
McManusPPritchardB, 2000, “Geography and the emergence of rural and regional Australia”Australian Geographer31383–391
78.
MahoodIDrushkaK, 1990Three Men and a Forester (Harbour Publishing, Madeira Park, BC)
79.
M'GonigleM, 1997, “Behind the green curtain”Alternatives Journal2316–21
80.
MickleburghRKennedyPGibbonA, 1999, “B.C. forest giant to be sold: Premier hails U.S. company's ‘breathtaking’ plan to buy out venerable MacMillan Bloedel”The Globe and Mail 22 June, page A1
81.
MouffeC, 1996, “Democracy, power and the ‘political’”, in Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political Ed. BenhabibS, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, pp 246–256
82.
MoulaertFSwyngedouwE, 1989, “A regulation approach to the geography of flexible production systems”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space7327–345
83.
MyreP, 1998, “Changing forest values, forest legislation and management in Canada”The Forestry Chronicle74236–240
84.
NathanH, 1993, “Aboriginal forestry: the role of the first nations”, in Touch Wood: BC Forests at the Crossroads Eds DrushkaKNixonBTraversRHarbour Publishing, Madeira Park, BC) pp 137–170
85.
Native Forest Network, 1995, “Who's who of Australian export woodchipping”, Native Forest Network (Southern Hemisphere), PO Box 301, Deloraine, Tasmania 7304
New South Wales Government/Commonwealth of Australia Government, 1998Eden CRA/RFA Project SummariesNew South Wales Government, Sydney, Commonwealth of Australia Government, Canberra
89.
NorcliffeG, 1993, “The regulation of Gerland: from mass production to flexible production in Tony Garnier's ‘Cité Industrielle’”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research4195–212
90.
Open University, 1997Clayoquot Sound: Final Cuts (Open University, Milton Keynes)
91.
PedersenL, 1995, “Forestry in British Columbia: the current situation”Forestry6883–92
92.
PyersG, 1996Chipping Away: Woodchipping and Logging in Native Forests (Reed, Melbourne)
93.
ReedM, 1999, “‘Jobs talk’: retreating from the social sustainability of forest communities”The Forestry Chronicle75755–763
94.
RoseD B, 1996Nourishing Terrains: Australian Aboriginal Views of Landscape and Wilderness (Australian Heritage Commission, Canberra)
95.
RoutleyRRoutleyV, 1975Fight for the Forests: The Takeover of Australian Forests for Pines, Wood Chips, and Intensive Forestry3rd edition, Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Canberrra
96.
RowellA, 1996Green Backlash: Global Subversion of the Environmental Movement (Routledge, New York)
97.
SalazarDAlperD, 1996, “Perceptions of power and the management of environmental conflicts: forest politics in British Columbia”The Social Science Journal33381–399
98.
SchlosbergD, 1998, “Resurrecting the pluralist universe”Political Research Quarterly51583–616
99.
SchlosbergD, 1999Environmental Justice and the New Pluralism: The Challenge of Difference for Environmentalism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
100.
Senate Standing Committee, 1997Woodchips and the Environment report from the Senate Standing Committee on Science and the Environment (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra)
101.
SimonA, 1998, “Backlash! Corporate front groups and the struggle for sustainable forestry in British Columbia”Capitalism, Nature, Socialism93–37
SwyngedouwE, 1996, “Reconstructing citizenship, the rescaling of the state, and the new authoritarianism: closing of the Belgian mines”Urban Studies331499–1521
104.
TarloK, 1986, “Forest and jobs in Eden”, Total Environment Centre, Level 2, 362 Kent Street, Sydney, NSW 2000
105.
The Globe and Mail1998, “B.C. forest workers swamp jobs program. High unemployment blamed on collapse of Japan's lumber market, restraints on U.S.”, 19 January, page B7
TickellAPeckJ, 1995, “Social regulation after Fordism: regulation theory, neoliberalism and the global – local nexus”Economy and Society24357–386
108.
TraversO R, 1993, “Forest policy: rhetoric and reality”, in Touch Wood: B C Forests at the Crossroads Eds DrushkaKNixonBTraversRHarbour Publishing, Madeira Park, BC) pp 171–224
WildePHayterR, 1990, “Introduction: industrial transformation in a changing global economy”, in Industrial Transformation and Challenge in Australia and New Zealand Eds HayterRWildePCarleton University Press, Ottawa) pp 1–6
111.
Willems-BraunB, 1997, “Buried epistemologies: the politics of nature in (post)colonial British Columbia”Annals of the Association of American Geographers873–31
112.
WilsonBWangSHaleyD, 1999, “British Columbia”, in Forest Policy: International Case Studies Eds WilsonBVan KootenG CVertinskyIArthurLCABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxon) pp 81–107
113.
WilsonJ, 1997, “Implementing forest policy change in British Columbia: comparing the experiences of the NDP governments of 1972 – 75 and 1991 –?”, in Troubles in the Rainforest; British Columbia's Forest Economy in Transition Eds BarnesTHayterRWestern Geographical Press, Victoria) pp 75–97
114.
WilsonJ, 2001, “Experimentation on a leash: forest land use planning in the 1990s”, in In Search of Sustainability: British Columbia Forest Policy in the 1990s Eds CashoreBHobergGHowlettMRaynerJWilsonJUBC Press, Vancouver) pp 31–60
115.
World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987Our Common Future (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
