The author argues that organic-coffee certification enacted under the rubric of transnational certification norms alters the logic and practice of economic management and governance in an Oaxacan (Mexican) peasant producers' union. As the title indicates, these changes are productive of social and economic tensions. An economic and ethnographic analysis of ‘certification labor’ demonstrates (a) that the work of certification is distributed within producer organizations such that village and regional leaders become burdened by significant new responsibilities, and (b) that practical changes—including a new producer logic (‘market-price interdependence’) and village certification-service providers (‘peasant inspectors’ and ‘community technical officers’)—have a significant qualitative impact upon household and village economic governance. In addition, certification (c) affects the operation of statewide producer unions, altering the ways in which these interact both with their member organizations and with certifiers: unions must intervene to aid (regional) member organizations in their efforts to certify, yet also find that certification norms, such as conflict-of-interest provisions, constrain the union's ability to promote producer interests. Thus a qualification to an organic and ethical-products literature that conflates quality certification with the protection of smallholder cultural and economic independence is provided. The author concludes that a rethinking of certification norms, together with efforts to assist producer certification, should be a priority for supporters of sustainable agriculture.
BoydWWattsM, 1997, “Agro-industrial just-in-time: the chicken industry”, in Globalising Foods: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring Eds GoodmanDWattsMRoutledge, New York) pp 192–225
3.
BurawoyM, 1979Manufacturing Consent (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
4.
BurawoyM, 2000Global Ethnography (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
5.
CarneyJWattsM, 1991, “Disciplining women? Rice, mechanization, and the evolution of mandinka gender relations in Senegambia”Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society16651–681
6.
CEPCO, 1996, “Coordinadora Estatal de Productores de Café Oaxaqueños”, Annual Report 1996, Escuela Naval Militar #708, Oaxaca
7.
ChariS, 2000, “The agrarian origins of the knitwear industrial cluster in Tiruppur, India”World Development28579–599
CohenJ, 1999Cooperation and Community (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX)
10.
Contreras MurphyE, 1995, “La Selva and the magnetic pull of markets: organic coffee-growing in Mexico”Grassroots Development19(1) 27–34
11.
FantasiaR, 1988Cultures of Solidarity (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
12.
FischerE F, 1999, “Cultural logic and Maya identity: rethinking constructivism and essentialism”Current Anthropology40473–499
13.
FoucaultM, 1979Discipline and Punish (Vintage Books, New York)
14.
FoxJArandaJ, 1996Decentralization and Rural Development in MexicoCenter for US – Mexican Studies, University of California, San Diego, CA)
15.
FreidbergS, 1997, “Contacts, contracts, and green bean schemes: liberalisation and agro-entrepreneurship in Burkina Faso”The Journal of Modern African Studies35101–28
16.
GereffiG, 1999, “International trade and industrial upgrading in the apparel commodity chain”Journal of International Economics4837–70
17.
GfRS Information Service, 1996 Reglamento (CEE) 2092/91 “Agricultura Ecológica” y sus Modificaciones [Regulation (CEE) 2092/91 “ecological agriculture” and its modifications]Gesellschaft für Ressourcenschutz mbH, Göttingen
18.
GobiJ A, 2000, “Is biodiversity-friendly coffee financially viable? An analysis of five different coffee production systems in western El Salvador”Ecological Economics33267–281
19.
Gomez TovarLGomez CruzM ASchwentesius RindermannR, 1999Desafíos de la agricultura orgánica: comercialización y certificación [Challenges of organic agriculture: commercialization and certification]Grupo Mundi-Prensa, Mexico
HabermasJ, 1990Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
22.
HartG, 1991, “Everyday resistance: gender, patronage and production politics in rural Malaysia”Journal of Peasant Studies19(1) 93–121
23.
HernándezL, 1991, “Nadando con los Tiburones: la Coordinadora Nacional de Organizaciones Cafetaleras”, in Cafetaleros: la Construcción de la Autonomía [Swimming with sharks: The National Coffee Organization's Coordinating Committee] Eds CelisFCoboRGarcíaALópez SierraPMoguelJOlveraA JParéLPaz ParedesLPérez ArceFEjeaGHernándezL, Coordinadora Nacional de Organizaciones Cafetaleras, Colonia Roma CP 06700, México, DF, pp 17–48
24.
Hernandez-CastilloR ANighR, 1998, “Global processes and local identity among Mayan coffee growers in Chiapas, Mexico”American Anthropologist100136–147
25.
HoffmannO, 1992, “Renovación de los actores sociales en el campo: un ejemplo en el sector cafetalero en Veracruz” [Renovation of social actors in the countryside: an example from the coffee sector in Veracruz, Mexico]Estudios Sociológicos30523–554
KaplinskyR, 2000, “Globalization and unequalisation: what can be learned from value chain analysis?”Journal of Development Studies37117–146
29.
KearneyM, 1996, “Migration, the new indígena, and the formation of multi-ethnic autonomous regions in Oaxaca”, paper distributed at the American Anthropological Association annual meeting 24 November; copy available from the author, Department of Anthropology, University of California, Riverside, CA
30.
LatourB, 1999Pandora's Hope (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
31.
LeeC K, 1998Gender and the South China Miracle (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
32.
LohrL, 1998, “Implications of organic certification for market structure and trade”American Journal of Agriculture Economics801125–1129
33.
MichelsenJ, 2001, “Organic farming in a regulatory perspective”Sociologia Ruralis41(1) 65–84
34.
MoguelPToledoV M, 1999, “Biodiversity conservation in traditional coffee systems of Mexico”Conservation Biology1311–21
35.
MountzAWrightR A, 1996, “Daily life in the transnational migrant community of San Agustín, Oaxaca, and Poughkeepsie, New York”Diaspora5403–428
36.
MutersbaughT, 2002, “Migration, common property, and communal labor: cultural politics and agency in a Mexican village”Political Geography21473–494
37.
Naturland, 1999, “Desarrollo de sistemas de control internos en organizaciones de productores (organizaciones de pequeños agricultores” [The development of systems of internal control in small farmers' organizations], UC/12/95 Naturland-Verband e.V., Kleinhaderner Weg 1, D-82166 Gräfelfing
38.
NighR, 1997, “Organic agriculture and globalization: a Maya associative corporation in Chiapas, Mexico”Human Organization56427–435
ParéL, 1991, “Adelgazamiento del INMECAFE o de los pequeños productores de café?” [A slimming of INMECAFE or of small coffee producers?], in Cafetaleros: la Construcción de la Autonomía Eds CelisFCoboRGarcíaALópez SierraPMoguelJOlveraA JParéLPaz ParedesLPérez ArceFEjeaGHernándezL, Coordinadora Nacional de Organizaciones Cafetaleras, Colonia Roma CP 06700, Mexico, DF, pp 49–61
41.
Piñón JiménezGHernández-DíazJ, 1998El Café: Crisis y organización, los pequeños productores en Oaxaca [Coffee: crisis and organization, smallholders in Oaxaca]Universidad Autónoma Benito Juárez de Oaxaca, Oaxaca México
42.
PredA, 1990Lost Words and Lost Worlds (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
43.
PringleR, 1989Secretaries Talk: Sexuality, Power and Work (Verso, London)
44.
RenardM-C, 1999, “The interstices of globalization: the example of fair coffee”Sociologia Ruralis39484–500
45.
RiceP DMcLeanJ, 1999Sustainable Coffee at the CrossroadsConsumer's Choice Council, 2000 P Street NW, Suite 540, Washington, DC 20036
46.
RiceR A, 2001, “Noble goals and challenging terrain: organic and fair trade coffee movements in the global marketplace”Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics1439–66
47.
RiceR AWardJ, 1996Coffee, Conservation and Commerce in the Western HemisphereSmithsonian Migratory Bird Center, Washington, DC
48.
SaxenianA, 1994Regional Advantage: Culture and Competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
49.
SayerAWalkerR, 1992The New Social Economy: Reworking the Division of Labor (Blackwell, Oxford)
50.
SchroederR, 1999Shady Practices: Agroforestry and Gender Politics in The Gambia (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
51.
ScottJ, 1990Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
52.
Sosa MaldonadoL, 1995, “Cooperativa Tosepan Titataniske: plan de conversion de café orgánico” [Tosepan Titataniske Cooperative: plan for conversión to organic coffee], in Conferencia internacional sobre café orgánico: memorias [Proceedings of the International Conference on Organic Coffee]International Federation of Movements for Organic Agriculture, Mexican Association of Ecological Agriculturalists (Imprenta Universitaria de Chapingo, Chapingo, Mexico) pp 77–89
53.
Sosa MaldonadoLEscamilla PradoEDíaz CárdenasS, 1999, “Café orgánico: producción y certificación en México” [Organic coffee: production and certification in Mexico]El Jarocho Verde1113–25
54.
Soto-PintoLPerfectoICastillo-HernandezJCaballero-NietoJ, 2000, “Shade effect on coffee production at the northern Tzeltal zone of the state of Chiapas, Mexico”Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment8061–69
55.
StephenL, 1993, “Weaving in the fast lane: class, ethnicity, and gender in Zapotec craft comercialization”, in Crafts in the World Market Ed. NashJState University of New York Press, Albany) pp 25–57
WattsM, 1992, “Living under contract”, in Reworking Modernity: Capitalisms and Symbolic Discontent Eds PredAWattsM (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick) pp 65–105
58.
WattsMGoodmanD, 1997, “Agrarian questions: global appetite, local metabolism”, in Globalising Food: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring Eds GoodmanDWattsMRoutledge, New York) pp 1–32
59.
WhatmoreSThorneL, 1997, “Nourishing networks”, in Globalising Food: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring Eds GoodmanDWattsMRoutledge, New York) pp 287–304
60.
WillerHYussefiM, 2000Organic Agriculture WorldwideStiftung Ökologie & Landbau, Bad Dürkheim
61.
WolfD, 1992Factory Daughters: Gender, Household Dynamics, and Rural Industrialization in Java (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
