Within a context of public policy debate in the United Kingdom on social exclusion, health inequalities, and food poverty, the metaphor of the ‘food desert’ caught the imagination of those involved in policy development. Drawing from a major cross-disciplinary investigation of food access and food poverty in British cities, the authors report in this paper findings from the first ‘before/after’ study of food consumption in a highly deprived area of a British city experiencing a sudden and significant change in its food-retail access. The study has been viewed as the first opportunity in the United Kingdom to assess the impact of a non-healthcare intervention (specifically a retail-provision intervention) on food-consumption patterns, and by extension diet-related health, in such a deprived, previously poor-retail-access community. The paper offers evidence of a positive but modest impact of the retail intervention on diet, and the authors discuss the ways in which their findings are potentially significant in the context of policy debate.
References
1.
AchesonD, 1998Independent Inquiry into Inequalities in Health (The Stationery Office, London).
2.
BarrattJ, 1997, “The cost and availability of healthy food choices in southern Derbyshire”Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics1063–69.
3.
BeaumontJLangTLeatherSMucklowC, 1995Report from the Policy Sub-Group to the Nutrition Task Force: Low Income Project TeamInstitute of Grocery Distribution, Letchmore Heath, Watford.
4.
BelsleyD AKuhEWelschR E, 1980Regression Diagnostics (John Wiley, New York).
5.
BerndtE R, 1991The Practice of Econometrics: Classic and Contemporary (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA).
6.
BlandJ MAltmanD G, 1986, “Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement”The Lancet1(8476) 307–310.
7.
BraunerS, 2001, “Setting store by recruits”Regeneration and Renewal 20 July, 21.
CarleyMKirkKMcIntoshS, 2001Retailing, Sustainability and Neighbourhood RegenerationJoseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP.
10.
ClarkeG PEyreHGuyC M, 2002, “Deriving indicators of access to food retail provision in British cities: Studies of Leeds, Bradford and Cardiff”Urban Studies392041–2060.
11.
Competition Commission2000Supermarkets: A Report on the Supply of Groceries from Multiple Stores in the United Kingdom3 volumes, Cm 4842(The Stationery Office, London).
12.
CookR DWeisbergS, 1982Residuals and Influence in Regression (Chapman and Hall, London).
13.
CumminsSMacintyreS, 1999, “The location of food stores in urban areas: A Case study in Glasgow”British Food Journal101545–553.
14.
CumminsSMacintyreS, 2002, “ ‘Food deserts’—evidence and assumption in health policy making”British Medical Journal325436–438.
15.
DETR, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions; now Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions, London.
16.
2000a, “Minister tells retailers and planners to tackle ‘food deserts’”, News Release 471, 12 July.
17.
2000bIndices of Deprivation 2000.
18.
DoH, Department of Health, Richmond House, 79 Whitehall, London SW1A 2NL.
19.
1996Low Income, Food, Nutrition and Health: Strategies for Improvement a report from the Low Income Project Team to the Nutrition Task Force.
20.
1999aReducing Inequalities in Health: An Action Report.
21.
1999bImproving Shopping Access for People Living in Deprived Neighbourhoods discussion paper, Policy Action Team 13 of the National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal.
22.
DonkinA JDowlerE AStevensonS JTurnerS A, 1999, “Mapping access to food at a local level”British Food Journal101554–564.
23.
DonkinA JDowlerE AStevensonS JTurnerS A, 2000, “Mapping access to food in a deprived area: The development of price and availability indices”Public Health Nutrition331–38.
24.
DorlingD, 1997Death in Britain: How Local Mortality Rates Have Changed, 1950s–1990sJoseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP.
25.
DorlingDWoodwardR, 1996, “Social polarization 1971–91: A Micro-geographical analysis”Progress in Planning451–66.
26.
ELCHA, 1999aFood Access in East LondonEast London and The City Health Authority, 81–91 Commercial Road, London E1 1RP.
27.
ELCHA, 1999bFood Access in East London: East London Health Action ZoneEast London and The City Health Authority, 81–91 Commercial Road, London E1 1RP.
28.
GreenA E, 1994The Geography of Poverty and WealthInstitute for Employment Research, University of Warwick, Coventry.
29.
GreenA EGreggPWadsworthJ, 1998, “Regional unemployment changes in Britain”, in Unemployment and Social Exclusion: Landscapes of Labour Inequality Eds LawlessPMartinR LHardyS (Jessica Kingsley, London pp 65–94.
30.
GregoryJFosterKTylerHWisemanM, 1990The Dietary and Nutritional Survey of British AdultsThe Stationery Office, London.
31.
GuyC M, 1996, “Corporate strategies in food retailing and their local impacts: A Case study of Cardiff”Environment and Planning A281575–1602.
32.
HausmanJ A, 1978, “Specification tests in econometrics”Econometrica461251–1271.
33.
HibbertS APiacentiniMAl-DajaniH, 1999, “Faifley community action on food: exploring the potential for community development”, Greater Glasgow Health Board, Dalian House, PO Box 15329, 350 St Vincent Street, Glasgow G3 8XZ.
34.
LangTCaraherM, 1998, “Access to healthy foods. Part II. Food poverty and shopping deserts: What are the implications for health promotion policy and practice?”Health Education Journal57202–211.
35.
LardaroL, 1993Applied Econometrics (Harper Collins, New York).
36.
LevitasR, 1998The Inclusive Society: Social Exclusion and New Labour (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
37.
LevitasR, 1999, “Defining and measuring social exclusion”Radical Statistics7110–27.
38.
McGuirkA MDriscollP JAlwangJ, 1993, ‘Misspecification testing: A Comprehensive approach”American Journal of Agricultural Economics751044–1055.
39.
MaddalaG S, 1988Introduction to Econometrics (Macmillan, New York).
40.
MargettsB MNelsonM, 1997Design Concepts in Nutritional Epidemiology2nd edition (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
41.
MargettsB MThompsonR LSpellerV MMcVeyD, 1998, “Factors which influence ‘healthy’ eating patterns: Results from the 1993 Health Education Authority health and lifestyle survey in England”Public Health Nutrition1193–198.
42.
MargettsB MWarmD LWrigleyNJacksonA, 2002, “Hunger and food insecurity in the UK: Is there a problem?”, manuscript available from Institute of Human Nutrition, University of Southampton, Southampton.
43.
MohanJ, 2000, “Geographies of welfare and social exclusion”Progress in Human Geography24291–300.
44.
MohanJ, 2002, “Geographies of welfare and social exclusion: Dimensions, consequences and methods”Progress in Human Geography2665–75.
45.
NelsonM, 1997, “Developments in the UK: Work of the Low Income Project Team”Proceedings of the Nutrition Society56(1A) 91–100.
46.
PetersonE BVan EenooEMcGuirkAPreckelP V, 2001, “Perceptions of fat content in meat products”Agribusiness17437–453.
47.
PetticrewMCumminsSSparksL, 2002, “Reducing inequalities in health and diet: The impact of a food retail development—a pilot study”, MRC Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow.
48.
PiacentiniM GHibbertS AAl-DajaniH, 2001, “Diversity in deprivations: Exploring the grocery shopping behaviour of disadvantaged consumers”International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research11141–158.
49.
PindyckR SRubinfeldD L, 1991Econometric Models and Economic Forecasts3rd edition (McGraw-Hill, New York).
50.
RaynsfordN, 2000, Speech to LGN/NRPF Conference on “Town Centres: Turning the Lights On ”, available from www.nrpf.org.
51.
Regeneration and Renewal2000, “It seems everyone's jumping on the regeneration bandwagon” 8 December, page 32.
52.
Social Exclusion Unit, 1998Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal Cm 4045 (The Stationery Office, London).
53.
Social Exclusion Unit, 2001aA New Commitment to Neighbourhood Renewal—National Strategy Action PlanThe Cabinet Office, 35 Great Smith Street, London.
54.
Social Exclusion Unit, 2001bNational Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal: Policy Action Team AuditThe Cabinet Office, 35 Great Smith Street, London.
55.
SpeakSGrahamS, 1999, “Service not included: Private services restructuring, neighbourhoods, and social marginalisation”Environment and Planning A311985–2001.
56.
The Times2001, “Health minister refuses ‘nanny state’ medicine”, 30 March, page 14.
57.
ThomasC JBromleyR D F, 1993, “The impact of out-of-town retailing”, in Retail Change: Contemporary Issues Eds BromleyR D FThomasC J (UCL Press, London pp 126–152.
58.
ThompsonR LMargettsB MSpellarV MMcVeyD, 1999, “The Health Education Authority's health and lifestyle survey 1993: Who are the low fruit and vegetable consumers?”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health53294–299.
59.
WhiteheadM, 1998, “Food deserts: What's in a name?”Health Education Journal57189–190.
60.
WilliamsJ, 2000, “District centres have no need requirement”Planning 24 November, page 20.
61.
WillisB, 2001, “Supermarket forces”Regeneration and Renewal 20 July, pages 17–19.
62.
WrigleyN, 1998, “How British retailers have shaped food choice”, in The Nation's Diet: The Social Science of Food Choice Ed. MurcottA (Longman, Harlow, Essex pp 112–128.
63.
WrigleyN, 2002, “Food deserts in British cities: Policy context and research priorities”Urban Studies392029–2040.
64.
WrigleyNGuyC MDunnRO'BrienL G, 1985, “The Cardiff Consumer Panel: Methodological aspects of the conduct of a long-term panel survey”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series1063–76.
65.
WrigleyNGuyC MLoweM S, 2002a, “Urban regeneration, social inclusion and large store development: The Seacroft development in context”Urban Studies392101–2114.
66.
WrigleyNWarmD LMargettsB MWhelanA, 2002b, “Assessing the impact of improved retail access on diet in a ‘food desert’: A Preliminary report”Urban Studies392061–2082.
