Housing reform in urban China has introduced market mechanisms into a previously welfare-oriented housing system. Although microlevel factors such as household characteristics begin to shape housing behavior in urban China as is the case in the West, macrolevel constraints and opportunities defined by not only housing stocks and housing markets but also local government behaviors continue to be crucial. By studying housing choice in Beijing, Chongqing, and Jiangyin, I find that local governments in different cities behave differently in reforming the housing system, which in turn create different housing stocks and housing markets and thus lead to different patterns of housing behavior. A housing stock dominated by public housing, a tight housing market, and a conservative local government all encourage households to choose public housing and rental, as is the case in Beijing, while a diverse housing stock with affordable housing prices, and an aggressive local government often encourage households to choose private housing and homeownership, indicated by the case of Jiangyin.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArnottR, 1987, “Economic theory and housing”, in Handbook of Regional Urban Economics: Volume 2, Urban Economics Ed. MillsE S (Elsevier Science, Amsterdam) pp 959–998
2.
BCB, 1998, “A report on housing construction in Beijing”, Beijing Construction Bureau Survey and Law (Internal Publication) number 25
3.
BHRO, 1996, “Beijing Shi Renming Zhenfu Fanggai Baigongshi Guanyu 1996 Nian Xiang Zhigong Chushou Gongyou Zhuzi Loufang De Jiage Ji Youguan Zhence De Tongzi” [A notice from Beijing Municipal Government on prices of public housing sold to employees in 1996 and related policies] Beijing Housing Reform Office, Document No. 002
4.
BHRO, 2000, “Guanyu Beijing shi tigao gongyou zhufang zujing zengfa butie youguan wenti de tongzhi” [A notice on increasing rent and rent subsidies for public housing in Beijing] Beijing Housing Reform Office, Document No. 080
5.
BianYLoganJ RLuHPanYGuanY, 1997, “‘Working units’ and the commodification of housing: observations on the transition to a market economy with Chinese characteristics”Social Sciences in China18(4) 28–35
6.
BMG (Beijing Municipal Government). 1992, “Beijingshi Zhufang Zhidu Gaige Shishi Fangai” [An implementation plan for the housing reform in Beijing] Document No. 35
7.
1994, “Beijingshi Renmen Zhenfu Guance Guowuyuan Guanyu Shenhua Chenzhen Zhufang Zhidu Gaige Jueding De Tongzhi” [A notice on Beijing Municipal Government implementing the decision on deepening urban housing reform by the State Council] Document No. 71
8.
1998, “Beijing shi renming zhengfu baigongting zhuanfa shi jianwei guaiyu jiakuai jingji shiyong fang jianshe de ruogan guiding [Beijing Municipal Government Office distributes regulations on speeding up the construction of affordable housing by the Construction Committee] Document No. 54
9.
1999, “Beijing shi jinyibu shenghu chenzhen zhufang zhidu gaige jiakuai zhufang jianshe shishi fangan” [The implementation plan for further deepening housing reform and accelerating housing construction in Beijing] Document No. 21
10.
2000, “Beijing shi chengzhen gongyou zhufang zujing jianmian zaixing baifa” [A temporary regulation on waiving rent for public housing in Beijing] Document No. 7
11.
BSB, 1999Beijing 50 nian [Beijing in 50 years] Beijing Statistical Bureau (China Statistics Press, Beijing)
12.
BSB, 2002Beijing shi 2000 nian renkou pucha ziliao [Tabulation of 2000 Population Census in Beijing] Beijing Statistical Bureau (China Statistics Press, Beijing)
13.
BurrowsR, 1999, “Residential mobility and residualization in social housing in England”Journal of Social Policy2827–52
14.
CCP COB, 1999, “Zai jing zhongyang he guojia jiguan jinyibu shenhua zhufang zhidu gaige shishi fangan” [The implementation plan for further deepening housing reform in central and state agencies in Beijing] Chinese Communist Party Central Office Bureau Document No. 10
15.
CHRO, Chongqing Housing Reform Office. 1995, “Chongqing shi zhufang zhidu gaige baigongshi guanyu Chongqing shi gongyou zhufang chushou shengban chengxu” [An application procedure on the sale of public housing] Document No. 110
16.
1997, “Chongqing shi zhufang zhidu gaige lingdao xiaozu guanyu guifan fazha Chongqing shi chengzhen jizi hezuo jianfang de tongzi” [A notice on developing self-building housing in Chongqing] Document No. 7
17.
1999, “Chongqing shi zhufang huobihua fengpei shishi xize” [The implementation plan for housing monetary allocation in Chongqing] Chongqing Housing Reform Office
18.
CIPD, 1996, “Chongqing shi gaikuang” [Basic information about Chongqing] Chongqing Institute of Planning and Design
19.
ClarkW A VDielemanF M, 1996Households and Housing: Choice and Outcomes in the Housing Market (Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ)
20.
ClarkW A VDeurlooM CDielemanF M, 1994, “Tenure changes in the context of micro-level family and macro-level economic shifts”Urban Studies31137–154
21.
CMG, 1997Chongqing Shi Renmin Zhengfu Guanyu Pizhuan Shi Zhufang Zhidu Gaige Lingdao Xiaozu “Guanyu Jingyibu Shenhua Chengzhen Zhufang Zhidu Gaige De Yijian” De Tongzhi [A notification from Chongqing Municipal Government on “the Suggestion for Further Deepening Housing Reform” by Municipal Housing Reform Steering Team] Chongqing Municipal Government, Document No. 43
DeurlooM CClarkW A VDielemanF M, 1994, “The move to housing ownership in temporal and regional contexts”Environment and Planning A261659–1670
25.
ECCRESY, 1999Zhongguo fangdichan tongji nianjie 1999 [China real estate statistical yearbook 1999] Editorial Committee of China Real Estate Statistical Yearbook (China City Press, Beijing)
26.
GOSC, 1991, “Guangyu zhufang gaige de jige zhengce xing wenti” [About several policy issues in housing reform] General Office of State Council, Document No. 73
27.
HendersonJ VIoannidesY M, 1989, “Dynamic aspects of consumer decisions in housing markets”Journal of Urban Economics26212–230
28.
HouMXuX, 1998, “Jianchi chichang jiuye huanjie jiuye maodum—1997 nian Chongqing shi jiuye xingshi ji 1998 nian yuce yu duice” [Insist on employment through the market, relieve employment conflicts—the employment trend in 1997 and the prospects and solutions in 1998], in 1998 Chongqing lanpishu: jingji shehui xingshi: fengxi yu yuce [1998 Chongqing blue book: economic and social trends: analysis and prospects] Chongqing Social Science Academy (Chongqing Press, Chongqing)
JHRO, 2000, “Jiangyin fanggai licheng” [The path of housing reform in Jiangyin] Jiangyin Housing Reform Office
34.
JMG, Jiangyin Municipal Government. 1993, “Jiangyin shi zhufang zhidu gaige shishi fangan” [An implementation plan for housing reform in Jiangyin] Document No. 129
35.
1997, “Jiangyin shi 1997 nian fanggai shishi yijian” [Jingyin housing reform implementation suggestion in 1997] Document No. 93
36.
1998, “Jiangyin shi 1998 nian fanggai shishi fangan” [Jingyin housing reform implementation suggestion in 1998] Document No. 94
37.
2002, “Jiangyin shi renming zhengfu guanyu tiaozhen 2002 niandu fanggai youguan zhence de yijian” [A suggestion on the revision of relevant policies on housing reform in 2002] Document No. 112
38.
JSB, Jiangyin Statistical Bureau. 1998Jiangyin Shi Tong Ji Nian Jian 1998 [Jiangyin City statistical yearbook 1998] (Suzhou University Press, Suzhou)
2003Jiangsu sheng Jiangyin shi 2000 nian renkou pucha ziliao [Tabulation of 2000 Population Census in Jiangyin city Jiangsu Province] (Wuxi #2 Publishing Company, Wuxi)
42.
LiS, 2000a, “The housing market and tenure decision in Chinese cities: a multivariate analysis of the case of Guangzhou”Housing Studies15213–236
43.
LiS, 2000b, “Housing consumption in urban China: a comparative study of Beijing and Guangzhou”Environment and Planning A321115–1134
44.
LiYDongJ, 1999, “1998–1999 nian Chongqing zhufang zhidu gaige ji anju gongcheng jianshe zhaiwuang” [Chongqing housing reform in 1998–1999 and the prospects for the affordable housing project], in 1999 Chongqing lanpishu: jingji shehui xingshi: fengxi yu yuce [1999 Chongqing blue book: economic and social trends: analysis and prospects] Chongqing Social Science Academy (Chongqing Press, Chongqing) pp 255–262
45.
LoganJBianYBianF, 1999, “Housing inequality in urban China in the 1990s”International Journal of Urban and Regional Development23(1) 7–25
46.
MasseyDDentonN, 1993American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
47.
Morrow-JonesH A, 1988, “The housing life-cycle and the transition from renting to owning a home in the United States: a multistate analysis”Environment and Planning A201165–1184
48.
NBSC, 2000China Statistical Yearbook 2000 National Bureau of Statistics of China (China Statistical Press, Beijing)
49.
NBSC, 2002Tabulation on the 2000 Population Census of the People's Republic of China National Bureau of Statistics of China (China Statistical Press, Beijing)
50.
PlautS E, 1987, “The timing of housing tenure transition”Journal of Urban Economics21312–322
51.
QiJ C, 1995, “The role of the local state in China's transitional economy”The China Quarterly number 144, 1132–1149
52.
QianYStiglitzJ, 1996, “Institutional innovations and the role of local government in transition economies: the case of Guangdong province of China”, in Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions Eds McMillanJNaughtonB (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 175–193
53.
RudelT K, 1987, “Housing price inflation, family growth, and the move from rented to owner-occupied housing”Urban Studies24258–267
54.
SaundersP, 1990A Nation of Home Owners (Unwin Hyman, London)
55.
SitV F S, 1995Beijing: The Nature and Planning of a Chinese Capital City (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
56.
SSB, 1999Xin zhongguo wushi nian tongji ziliao huibian[Comprehensive statistical data and materials on 50 years of new China] State Statistics Bureau (China Statistics Press, Beijing)
57.
State Council, 1988Guanyu Zhubu shishi chenzhen zhufang zhidu gaige de fang'an [Implementation plan for gradual housing system reform in cities and towns] document No. 11
58.
State Council, 1994Guowuyuan Guanyu Shenhua Chengzhen Zuhfang Zhidu Gaige De Jueding [A decision from the State Council on deepening the urban housing reform] Document No. 43
59.
State Council, 1998Guowuyuan Guanyu Jingyibu Shenhua Chengzhen Zhufang Zhidu Gaige Jiakuai Zhufang Jianshe De Tongzhi [A notification from the State Council on further deepening the reform of the urban housing system and accelerating housing construction] Document No. 23
60.
State Council, 1999, “Zhufang gongjijing guanli tiaoli” [A regulation on the management of Housing Provident Fund] Document No. 262
61.
WangY PMurieA, 1999Housing Policy and Practice in China (Macmillan, London)
62.
World Bank, 1992China: Implementation Options for Urban Housing Reform (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
63.
WuF, 1996, “Changes in the structure of public housing provision in urban China”Urban Studies331601–1627
