The author examines the impact of rapid social change and economic development on family support for older parents in contemporary urban China. Based on the 1992 Survey on China's Support Systems for the Elderly, the author uses three levels of economic development as proxies for developmental stages in a study carried out from a geodevelopmental perspective. It is found that intergenerational support in urban China is persistent as far as instrumental support is concerned, and that the level of support follows a U-shaped pattern along the axis of economic development. It is in the mid-developed urban areas that intergenerational support seems the weakest. If the pattern from the less-developed to the developed urban areas reflects a time path, then the suggested trajectory will not lead to a convergence with the old-age support system found in the West. The author concludes that, although some aspects of economic support for the elderly will likely be consistent with modernization theory, the old-age support system in China is, on the whole, likely to diverge from the path seen in the West.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AaronH, 1999, “Chinese social security reform; security and economic development”, paper in Social Security Reform in China Eds XuDYinJZhangY (Economic Science Press, Beijing) pp 74–90
2.
AdamsB, 1968Kinship in an Urban Setting (Markham, Chicago, IL)
3.
AndrewsG REstermanA JBraunak-MayerA JRungieC M, 1986Aging in the Western PacificWHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific, PO Box 2932, 1000 Manila
4.
BartlettHPhillipsD, 1997, “Aging and aged care in the People's Republic of China: national and local issues and perspectives”Health and Place3149–159
5.
BianFLoganJBianY, 1998, “Intergenerational relations in urban China: proximity, contact, and help to parents”Demography35115–124
6.
BongaartsJZimmerZ, 2001, “Living arrangements of older adults in the developing world: an analysis of DHS household surveys”, WP 148, Policy Research Division, Population Council, One Dag Hammarskjold Plaza, New York, NY 10017
7.
CaldwellJ W, 1976, “Toward a restatement of demographic transition theory”Population and Development Review2321–366
8.
CaldwellJ WCaldwellP, 2001, “Regional paths to fertility transition”Journal of Population Research1891–117
9.
ChewS BLeuGTanK H, 1998Values and Lifestyles of Young Singaporeans (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
10.
China Civil Affairs, 2001Annual Statistical Yearbook, 2000Ministry of Civil Affairs, Beijing
11.
China Research Center on Aging, 1992, “Data from the Survey on support systems for the elderly”, China Research Center on Aging, Beijing
12.
CrimminsEIngegneriD C, 1990, “Interaction and living arrangements of older parents and their children”Research on Aging123–35
13.
DaVanzoJChanA, 1994, “Living arrangements of older Malaysians: who coresides with their adult children?”Demography3195–113
14.
Davis-FriedmannD, 1991Long Lives: Chinese Family and the Communist Revolution2nd edition (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
15.
DuP, 2001, “Changes in elderly living arrangements in mainland China”, in Proceedings: Symposium on Population Aging between Taiwan and Mainland China, Volume B (National Taiwan University, Taipei) pp 79–91
16.
DuPGuoZ, 2000, “Population ageing in China”, in Ageing in the Asia-Pacific Region: Issues, Policies and Future Trends Ed. PhillipsDRoutledge, London) pp 194–209
17.
DuPWuC, 1998, “The analysis of primary source of economic support among the elderly in China”Population Research2351–57
18.
FreedmanRMootsBSunTWeinbergerM B, 1978, “Household composition and extended kinship in Taiwan”Population Studies3265–80
19.
GoodeW, 1970World Revolution and Family Patterns (The Free Press, New York)
20.
GoodyJ, 1996, “Comparing family systems in Europe and Asia: are there different sets of rules?”Population and Development Review22(1) 1–20
21.
GuoZ, 1994Population Development and Changes in Family Households in Contemporary China (People's University Press, Beijing)
22.
GuoZZhangK, 1996, “Retesting the role of number of children in family support for the elderly”Population Research2027–15
23.
HajnalJ, 1982, “Two kinds of preindustrial household formation systems”Population and Development Review8449–494
24.
HallerA, 1961, “The urban family”American Journal of Sociology66621–623
25.
HermalinA, 1990, “Patterns of support among the elderly in Taiwan”Comparative Studies of Elderly in Asia, No 90-4Population Studies Center, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
26.
HashimotoA, 1992, “Living arrangements of the aged in 7 developing countries: a preliminary analysis”Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology6359–381
27.
HugoG, 1988, “The changing situation in Southeast Asia and Australia: some implications for the elderly”, paper prepared for International Conference on Aging Populations in the Context of Urbanization, Sendai, Japan, 12 – 16 September; copy available from the author
28.
HugoG, 2000, “Lansia—elderly people in Indonesia at the turn of the century”, in Ageing in the Asia-Pacific Region: Issues, Policies and Future Trends Ed. PhillipsDRoutledge, London) pp 298–321
29.
InglehartR, 1997Modernization and Postmodernization: Cultural, Economic, and Political Change in 43 Societies (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 324–342
30.
KnodelJChayovanNGraisurapongSSuraratdechaC, 2000, “Ageing in Thailand: an overview of formal and informal support”, in Ageing in the Asia-Pacific Region: Issues, Policies and Future Trends Ed. PhillipsDRoutledge, London) pp 243–266
31.
Labor and Social Security Ministry, 2001Annual Report of Labor and Social Security DevelopmentLabor and Social Security Ministry, Beijing
32.
LawtonLSilversteinMBengtsonV, 1994, “Affection, social contact, and geographic distance between adult children and their parents”Journal of Marriage and the Family5657–68
33.
LeeJWangF, 2000, “Malthusian models and Chinese realities: the Chinese demographic system 1700 – 2000”Population and Development Review2533–65
34.
LeeYXiaoZ, 1998, “Children's support for elderly in urban and rural China: results from a national survey”Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology1339–62
35.
LeeteR, 1987, “The post-demographic transition in East and Southeast Asia: similarities and contrasts with Europe”Population Studies42187–206
36.
LinG, 1999, “Changes in interstate elderly migration patterns: 1965 – 1990”International Journal of Population Geography5411–424
37.
LinGRogersonP A, 1995, “Elderly parents and the geographic availability of their adult children”Research on Aging17303–331
38.
LinJ, 1994, “Parity and security: a simulation study of old-age support in rural China”Population and Development Review20423–448
39.
LitwakE, 1960, “Geographic mobility and extended family cohesion”American Sociological Review25385–394
40.
LoganJBianFBianY, 1998, “Tradition and change in the urban Chinese family: the case of living arrangements”Social Forces76851–882
41.
McDonaldP, 1992, “Convergence or compromise in historical family change?”, in Family Systems and Cultural Change Eds BerquoEXenosPOxford University Press, New York) pp 15–30
42.
MaedaDIshikawaH, 2000, “Ageing in Japan: retirement, daily lives, pensions and social security”, in Ageing in the Asia-Pacific Region: Issues, Policies and Future Trends Ed. PhillipsDRoutledge, London) pp 113–132
43.
MarshR, 1996The Great Transformation: Social Change in Taipei, Taiwan since the 1960s (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY)
44.
MasonK, 1992, “Family change and support in Asia: what do we know?”Asia-Pacific Population Journal7(3) 13–32
45.
MorganPHirosimaK, 1982, “The persistence of extended family residence in Japan: anachronism or alternative”American Sociological Review48269–281
46.
NugentJ, 1985, “The old-age security motive for fertility”Population and Development Review1175–99
47.
PalmoreEMantonK, 1974, “Modernization and the status of the aged: international correlation”Journal of Gerontology29205–210
48.
ParsonsT, 1943, “The kinship system of the contemporary United States”American Anthropologist4522–38
49.
PhillipsD, 1992Aging in East and Southeast Asia (Edward Arnold, London)
50.
PhillipsD, 2000Ageing in the Asia-Pacific Region: Issues, Policies and Future Trends (Routledge, London)
51.
ReddingS G, 1990The Spirit of Chinese Capitalism (de Gruyter, Berlin)
52.
ReherD, 1998, “Family ties in Western Europe: persistent contrasts”Population and Development Review24203–234
53.
RogersonPBurrJLinG, 1997, “Changes in geographic proximity between parents and their adult children”International Journal of Population Geography3121–136
54.
ShenY, 1987, “Selected findings from recent fertility surveys in three regions in China”International Family Planning Perspectives13(3) 80–85
55.
ShenYTongZ, 1992Population Migration in China (Zhounguo Rekou Qianyi) (State Statistic Press, Beijing)
56.
SkinnerW, 1999, “Classifying settlement types in the census data file and positioning households in hierarchical regional space”, in Proceedings: International Symposium on Geoinformatics and Socioinformatics CD-Rom, International Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
57.
SpitzeGLoganJ, 1990, “Sons, daughters and intergenerational social support”Journal of Marriage and the Family52420–430
58.
TaiH, 1989Confucianism and Economic Development (The Washington Institute Press, Washington, DC)
59.
ThorntonALinH, 1994Social Change and the Family in Taiwan (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
60.
TsuyaNMartinL, 1992, “Living arrangements of elderly Japanese and attitudes toward inheritance”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences47S45–S54
61.
WangG, 1997Population Distribution and Regional Economic Development in China—A New Approach of Population Distribution Economics (Eastern China Normal University Press, Shanghai)
62.
WangMXiaS, 1994, “Assessing the burden of old-age support in China”Population Science of China4337–43
63.
WeinsteinMSunTChangMFreedmanR, 1990, “Household composition, extended kinship, and reproduction in Taiwan: 1965 – 1985”Population Studies44217–239
64.
World Bank, 1997Old Age Security: Pension Reform in China (World Bank, Washington, DC)
65.
XuDYinJZhangY, 1999Social Security Reform in China (Economic Science Press, Beijing)
66.
ZhangM, 2001, “Changes in elderly living arrangements and support in Taiwan”, in Proceedings of the Symposium on Population Aging between Taiwan and Mainland China, Volume B (National Taiwan University, Taipei) pp 55–77
