This paper begins with the issue of pension security, referencing the desired predictability, stability, long-lived nature of benefits, and coverage of retirement incomes. Also considered is the issue of pension security in the light of global financial market performance and integration. Having discussed issues of nation-state fiscal capacity and the consequences of the technology, media, and telecommunications speculative bubble for stock market returns it is suggested that pension security is also a matter of institutional integrity. This is illustrated with reference to debate in US Congress over the proper response to the Enron debacle. It is argued that no public or private institutions (including the nation-state and large corporations) can now guarantee the final value of pension benefits. As the baby boom generation comes to retirement across the Western world, pension security in the form of guaranteed pension benefit value is a hollow ideal; a chimera on the horizon of nation-state politics that cannot be sustained, notwithstanding the commitment of many to social justice and social solidarity between the generations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArnottRBernsteinP, 2002, “What risk premium is normal?”Financial Analysts Journal58(2) 64–85
2.
AllenFGaleD, 2000Comparing Financial Systems (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
3.
BlackburnR, 2002Banking on Death, or, Investing in Life: The History and Future of Pensions (Verso, London)
4.
BolkesteinF, 2000, “Integration of financial markets in Europe”, DG Single Market, European Commission, Brussels
5.
BuddACampbellN, 1998, “The roles of the public and private sectors in the UK pension system”, in Privatizing Social Security Ed. FeldsteinM (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 99–134
6.
CampbellJViceiraL, 2002Strategic Asset Allocation: Portfolio Choice for Long-term Investors (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
7.
ChoiJLaibsonDMadrianBMetrickA, 2001, “The path of least resistance in 401(K) plans”, WP 8651, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge MA
8.
ClarkG L, 1993Pensions and Corporate Restructuring in American Industry: A Crisis of Regulation (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
9.
ClarkG L, 2000Pension Fund Capitalism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
10.
ClarkG L, 2002, “Age discrimination in financial markets”, Help the Aged, 207–221Pentonville Road, London N1 9UZ
11.
ClarkG L, 2003European Pensions and Global Finance (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
12.
ClarkG LMarshallJ, 2002, “Decision-making in the real world and expertise”, National Association of Pension Funds, NIOC House, 4 Victoria Street, London SW1H 0NX
13.
ClarkG LWhitesideN (Eds.), 2004Pensions Security in the 21st Century: Remaking the Public–Private Divide (Oxford University Press, Oxford) forthcoming
14.
ClarkG LWojcikD, 2003, “How and where should we invest in Europe?”Annals of the Association of American Geographers (forthcoming)
15.
ClausJThomasJ, 2001, “Equity premia as low as three percent? Evidence from analysts' earnings forecasts for domestic and international stock markets”Journal of Finance561629–1666
16.
CrouchCStreeckW, 1997, “Introduction: the future of capitalist diversity”, in Political Economy of Modern Capitalism Eds CrouchCStreeckW (Sage, London) pp 1–18
DimsonEMarshPStauntonM, 2002Triumph of the Optimists: 101 Years of Global Investment Returns (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
19.
DisneyR, 2000, “Crises in public pension programmes in OECD: what are the reform options?”Economic Journal110 (February) 1–23
20.
EmmersonC, 2004, “UK case”, in Pension Security in the 21st Century Eds ClarkG LWhitesideN (Oxford University Press, Oxford) forthcoming
21.
EngelenE, 2003, “The logic of funding European pension restructuring and the dangers of financialisation”Environment and Planning A351357–1372
22.
Esping-AndersenG, 1999Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
23.
Esping-AndersenGGallieDHemerijckAMylesJ, 2001, “New welfare architecture for Europe?”, Report to the Belgium Presidency of the European Union, Brussels
24.
FamaEFrenchK R, 2002, “The equity premium”Journal of Finance57637–659
25.
FeldsteinMSiebertH, 2002Reform of Europe's Social Security Pensions (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
26.
GillionCTurnerJBaileyCLatulippeD, 2000 (Eds) Social Security Pensions: Development and Reform (International Labour Office, Geneva)
27.
GruberJWiseD, 1999, “Introduction and summary”, in Social Security and Retirement Around the World Eds GruberJWiseD (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 1–35
28.
HallPSoskiceD, 2001 (Eds) The Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
29.
JorgensonD, 2001, “Information technology and the US economy”American Economic Review911–32
30.
LonerganEHansonT, 2002, “The European discount”, Global Economic Research, Cazenove & Co, 20 Moorgate, London EC2R 6DA
31.
McConnellP (Ed.), 2002Pro Forma Earnings: A Critical Perspective (Bear Stearns, New York)
32.
McConnellPPeggJZionD, 2001Accounting Issues: Pension and other Retirement Benefits I (Bear Stearns, New York)
33.
MarkowitzH, 1952, “Portfolio selection”Journal of Finance777–91
34.
MitchellO S, 1998, “Administrative costs in public and private retirement systems', in Privatizing Social Security Ed. FeldsteinM (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 403–452
35.
MitchellO SUtkusS P, 2002, “Company stock and retirement plan diversification”, WP 2002–4, Pension Research Council, Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA
36.
MunnellASundenA, 2002, “401 (K)s and company stock: how can we encourage diversification?”, briefing paper, Center for Retirement Research, Boston College, Boston, MA
37.
MunnellASundenAMunnellA, 2004, “US case”, in Pension Security in the 21st Century Eds ClarkG LWhitesideN (Oxford University Press, Oxford) forthcoming
38.
OECD, 1998Maintaining Prosperity in an Ageing Society (OECD, Paris)
39.
OECD, 2000Reforms for an Ageing Society: Social Issues (OECD, Paris)
40.
OrszagP, 2002, “House ‘Enron’ pension legislation includes troubling provisions that could harm rank-and-file workers”, mimeo, Brookings Institution, Washington, DC
41.
PastorLStambaughR F, 2001, “The equity premium and structural breaks”Journal of Finance561207–1239
42.
ReynaudE, 2000, “Introduction and summary”, in Social Dialogue and Pension Reform Ed. ReynaudE (International Labour Organisation, Geneva) pp 1–10
43.
SassS, 1997The Promise of Private Pensions: The First Hundred Years (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
44.
SiegelJ, 2001, “Historical results 1”, in Equity Risk Forum Ed. WilliamsonJ P (Association for Investment Management and Research, Charlottesville VA) pp 30–41
45.
ShillerR, 2000Irrational Exuberance (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
46.
ShillerR, 2002a, “Bubbles, human judgement, and expert opinion”Financial Analysts Journal58(3) 18–26
47.
ShillerR, 2002b, “Current estimates and prospects for change 1”, in Equity Risk Forum Ed. WilliamsonJ P (Association for Investment Management and Research, Charlottesville, VA) pp 51–59
48.
ShleiferA, 1999Market Inefficiency (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
StiglitzJ, 2002Globalization and its Discontents (W W Norton, New York)
51.
StrangeS, 1997, “The future of global capitalism: or will divergence persist forever?”, in Political Economy of Modern Capitalism Eds CrouchCStreeckW (Sage, London) pp 182–190
52.
TeeceD, 2000Managing Intellectual Capital (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
53.
US Department of Labor, 2002Private Pension Plan Bulletin: Abstract of 1998 Form 5500 Annual ReportsDepartment of Labor, Washington, DC
54.
US GAO, 2001Private Pensions: Issues of Coverage and Increasing Contribution Limits for Defined Contribution Plans GAO-01–846, US General Accounting Office, Washington, DC
55.
ViscoI, 2001, “Paying for pensions: how important is economic growth?”Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review21673–102
56.
WhitesideN, 2004, “History chapter”, in Pension Security in the 21st Century Eds ClarkG LWhitesideN (Oxford University Press, Oxford) forthcoming
