In this paper we connect existing work on rooming houses to literature dealing with the meaningful nature of ‘home’ and its impact on individuals' health and social well-being. We then examine the extent to which rooming houses provide low-income tenants with ‘homes’, drawing from in-depth interviews with rooming-house tenants living in Hamilton, a city of 450 000 people in southern Ontario, Canada. Our analysis raises concerns about the capacity of rooming houses to provide affordable and stable accommodation. Poor living conditions and poor relations with rooming-house landlords worked directly against the capacity of rooms to offer private, controllable spaces and a degree of ontological security. Analysis also raised concerns about rooming houses as sites for social relations. Many respondents saw rooming houses as unpredictable and sometimes unhealthy social spaces, forcing them to seek other environments to cultivate and sustain relationships with friends and family. In general, respondents' experiences point to the shortcomings of rooming houses as ‘home’ environments, with implications for the health and social lives of the tenant population. Conceptual and policy implications are discussed in conclusion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ahmadi LewinF, 2001, “The meaning of home among elderly immigrants: Directions for future research and theoretical developments”Housing Studies16353–370.
2.
BaxterJEylesJ, 1997, “Evaluating qualitative research in social geography: Establishing 'rigour’ in interview analysis”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series2505–525.
3.
BourdieuP, 1984Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (Routledge, London).
4.
BourdieuP, 1986, “The forms of capital”, in Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education Ed. RichardsonG (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 241–258.
5.
BurawoyM, 1991, “The extended case method”, in Ethnography Unbound: Power and Resistance in the Modern Metropolis Ed. BurawoyM (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 271–287.
6.
ButzenJ, 1996, “Lakefront SRO Corporation: Reviving single-room occupancy housing”, in Under One Roof: Issues and Innovations in Shared Housing Eds HemmensGHochCCarpJ (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY) pp 75–86.
7.
ChekkiD, 1999, “Poverty amidst plenty: How do Canadian cities cope with rising poverty?”Community Sociology9141–152.
8.
CMHC, 2000Special Studies on 1996 Census Data: Housing Conditions in Metropolitan Areas issue 55-2, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, 700 Montreal Road, Ottawa, K1A 0P7.
9.
CohenCSokolovskyJ, 1989Old Men of the Bowery (Guilford Press, New York).
10.
CohenCSichelWBergerD, 1977, “The use of a mid-Manhattan hotel as a support system”Community Mental Health Journal1376–83.
11.
ColemanJ, 1988, “Social capital in the creation of human capital”American Journal of Sociology94S95–S120.
12.
CraneMWarnesA, 2000, “Evictions and prolonged homelessness”Housing Studies15757–773.
13.
CrystalSBeckP, 1992, “A room on one's own: The SRO and the single elderly”The Gerontologist32684–692.
14.
DalyG, 1996Homeless: Policies, Strategies, and Lives on the Streets (Routledge, New York).
15.
DearMWolchJ, 1987Landscapes of Despair: From Deinstitutionalization to Homelessness (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
16.
DownsA, 1983, “The coming crunch in rental housing”Annals, American Academy of Political and Social Science46576–85.
17.
DunnJ, 2000, “Housing and health inequalities: Reviews and prospects for research”Housing Studies15341–366.
18.
DunnJHayesM, 2000, “Social inequality, population health, and housing: A Study of two Vancouver neighbourhoods”Social Science and Medicine51563–587.
19.
EliasCInuiT, 1993, “When a house is not a home: Exploring the meaning of shelter among chronically homeless older men”The Gerontologist33396–402.
20.
GlasserIFournierLCostopoulosA, 1999, “Homelessness in Québec City and Hartford, Connecticut”Urban Anthropology28141–163.
21.
HemmensGHochC, 1996, “Shared housing in low-income households”, in Under One Roof: Issues and Innovations in Shared Housing Eds HemmensGHochCCarpJ (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY) pp 17–32.
22.
HochC, 2000, “Sheltering the homeless in the US: Social improvement and the continuum of care”Housing Studies15865–876.
23.
HochCSlaytonR, 1989New Homeless and Old: Community and the Skid Row Hotel (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA).
24.
HouseJLandisKUmbersonD, 1988, “Social relationships and health”Science241540–545.
25.
HulchanskiJ D, 1989Low Rent Housing in Vancouver's Central Area: Policy and Program OptionsCentre for Human Settlements, University of British Columbia, Vancouver.
26.
KasinitzP, 1986, “Gentrification and homelessness: The single room occupant and the inner city”Urban and Social Change Review179–14.
27.
KawachiIKennedyBWilkinsonR (Eds), 1999The Society and Population Health Reader: Income Inequality and Health (The New Press, New York).
28.
KearnsRSmithC, 1993, “Housing stressors and mental health among marginalized urban populations”Area25267–278.
29.
KearnsRSmithC, 1994, “Housing, homelessness, and mental health: Mapping an agenda for geographical inquiry”The Professional Geographer46418–424.
30.
KearnsRSmithCAbbottM, 1991, “Another day in paradise? Life on the margins in urban New Zealand”Social Science and Medicine33369–379.
31.
KojimaR, 1995, “Single room occupancy housing policy: a study of Vancouver's SRO housing”, unpublished MPhil thesis, Department of Geography, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario.
32.
LairdK, 2002, “Submission to the Ombudsman Ontario concerning the failure of the Tenant Protection Act and the Rules and Procedures of the Ontario Rental Housing Tribunal to meet Ombudsman Fairness Standards”, 20 June, Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario, 425 Adelaide Street West, 5th floor, Toronto M5V 3C1.
33.
MayJ, 2000, “Housing histories and homeless careers: A Biographical approach”Housing Studies15613–638.
34.
MeansRSmithR, 1996Community Care, Housing and Homelessness (The Policy Press, Bristol).
35.
MerrifieldA, 2001, “Lepers at the city gate: Single room occupancy and the housing crisis”Dissent4878–84.
36.
MillerW, 1997The Anatomy of Disgust (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
37.
NovacSSergeLEberleMBrownJ, 2002On Her Own: Young Women and Homeless in CanadaStatus of Women Canada, MacDonald Building, 123 Slater Street, 10th floor, Ottawa K1P 1H9.
38.
OldmanCBeresfordB, 2000, “Home, sick home: Using the housing experiences of disabled children to suggest a new theoretical framework”Housing Studies15429–442.
39.
OldsK, 1998, “Canada: Hallmark events, evictions and housing rights”, in Evictions and the Right to Housing Eds AzuelaADuhauEOrtizE (International Development Research Centre, Ottawa) pp 1–45.
PomeroyS, 2001Towards a Comprehensive Affordable Housing Strategy for CanadaCaledon Institute of Social Policy, Ottawa.
42.
PortesA, 1998, “Social capital: Its origins and applications in modern sociology”Annual Review of Sociology241–24.
43.
PortesA, 2000, “The two meanings of social capital”Sociological Forum151–12.
44.
RollinsonP, 1991, “The spatial isolation of elderly single-room-occupancy hotel tenants”The Professional Geographer43456–464.
45.
RopersR, 1988The Invisible Homeless: A New Urban Ecology (Human Service Press, New York).
46.
RyanA, 1983, “Public and private property”, in Public and Private in Social Life Eds BennSGausG (Croom Helm, London) pp 223–245.
47.
SaundersP, 1989, “The meaning of 'home’ in contemporary English culture”Housing Studies4177–192.
48.
ShapiroJ, 1966, “Single-room occupancy: Community of the alone”Social Work1124–33.
49.
ShepardM, 1997, “Site-based services for residents of single room occupancy hotels”Social Work42585–592.
50.
SmithCSmithCKearnsRAbbottM, 1993, “Housing stressors, social support, and psychological distress”Social Science and Medicine37603–612.
51.
SomervilleP, 1992, “Homeless and the meaning of home: Rooflessness or rootlessness”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16529–539.
52.
SomervilleP, 1997, “The social construction of home”Journal of Architectural Research14226–245.
53.
StephensonS, 2001, “Street children in Moscow: Using and creating social capital”Sociological Review49530–547.
54.
StraussACorbinJ, 1990Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).
55.
VenessA, 1992, “Home and homelessness in the United States: Changing ideals and realities”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space10445–468.
56.
WaltonJ, 1992, “Making the theoretical case”, in What is a Case? Exploring the Foundations of Social Inquiry Eds RaginCBeckerH (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 121–137.
57.
WernerFBrysonD, 1982, “A guide to the preservation and maintenance of single room occupancy (SRO) housing”Clearinghouse Review April, 999–1009.
58.
WinbergEWilsonT, 1981Single Rooms: Stories of an Urban Subculture (Schenkman, Cambridge, MA).
59.
WolchJDearM, 1993Malign Neglect: Homelessness in an American City (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA).
