Since its release in the mid-1990s, close to 37 000 facilities have been certified to ISO 14001, the international voluntary standard for environmental management systems. Yet, despite claims that the standard can be readily adapted to very different corporate and geographic settings, its take-up has been highly geographically variable. This paper contributes to a growing body of work concerned with explaining the uneven diffusion of ISO 14001 at the global level. Drawing from the existing theoretical and empirical literature we develop a series of hypotheses about how various economic, market, and regulatory factors influence the national count of ISO 14001 certifications. These hypotheses are then tested using econometric estimation techniques with data for a panel of 142 developed and developing countries. We find that per capita ISO 14001 counts are positively correlated with income per capita, stock of foreign direct investment, exports of goods and services to Europe and Japan, and pressure from civil society. Conversely, productivity and levels of state intervention are negatively correlated. The paper finishes by offering a number of recommendations to policymakers concerned with accelerating the diffusion of voluntary environmental standards.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BansalPBognerW C, 2002, “Deciding on ISO 14001: Economics, institutions and context”Long Range Planning35269–290.
2.
BeckNKatzJ K, 1995, “What to do (and not to do) with time-series cross-section data”American Political Science Review89634–647.
3.
BendellJ, 2000, “Introduction: Working with stakeholder pressure for sustainable development”, in Terms for Endearment: Business, NGOs and Sustainable Development Ed. BendellJ (Greenleaf, Sheffield) pp 14–29.
4.
Chang-XingD, 1999, “ISO 14001: The severe challenge for China. An overview of the problems faced in the implementation and certification of ISO 14001”, in Growing Pains: Environmental Management in Developing Countries Eds WehrmeyerWMulugettaY (Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield) pp 101–116.
5.
ChinK-SPunK-F, 1999, “Factors influencing ISO implementation in the printed circuit board manufacturing industry in Hong Kong”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management42123–134.
6.
CIA, 2002CIA World Factbook 2002 (Central Intelligence Agency, Washington, DC).
7.
ClappJ, 2001Toxic Exports: The Transfer of Hazardous Wastes and Technologies from Rich to Poor Countries (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
8.
CorbettC JKirschD A, 2000, “ISO 14000: an agnostic's report from the front line” ISO 9000+ISO 14000 News 9(2) 4–17.
9.
CorbettC JKirschD A, 2001, “International diffusion of ISO 14000 certification”Production and Operations Management10327–342.
10.
CosbeyA, 2002, “The trade, investment and environment interface”, in Trade and Environment. Difficult Policy Choices at the Interface Ed. ShahrukhR K (Zed Press, London) pp 7–16.
11.
DavyA, 1997, “Environmental management systems: ISO 14001 issues for developing countries”, in ISO 14001 and Beyond Ed. SheldonC (Greenleaf, Sheffield) pp 169–182.
12.
DelmasM A, 2002, “The diffusion of environmental management standards in Europe and the United States: An institutional perspective”Policy Sciences3591–119.
Europa Publications, 2001The Environment Encyclopedia and Directory (Europa, London).
15.
EvansGRussellGSullivanR, 2002, “An international regulatory framework?”, in Moving Mountains: Communities Confront Mining and Globalisation Eds EvansGGoodmanJLansburyN (Zed Press, London) pp 207–222.
16.
FingerMTamiottiL, 1999, “New global regulatory mechanisms and the environment: The emerging linkages between the WTO and the ISO”IDS Bulletin30(3) 8–15.
17.
FinkelS E, 1995Causal Analysis with Panel Data (Sage, London).
18.
Garcia-JohnsonR, 2000Exporting Environmentalism: US Multinational Chemical Corporations in Brazil and Mexico (MIT Press, London).
19.
GunninghamNSinclairD, 2002Leaders and Laggards: Next-Generation Environmental Regulation (Greenleaf, Sheffield).
20.
HanksJ, 2002, “Promoting corporate environmental responsibility: What role for ‘self-regulatory’ and ‘co-regulatory’ policy instruments in South Africa?”, in The Greening of Business in Developing Countries: Rhetoric, Reality, and Prospects Ed. UttingP (Zed Press, London) pp 187–215.
21.
HastingsM, 1999, “A new operational paradigm for oil operations in sensitive environments: An analysis of social pressure, corporate capabilities and competitive advantage”Business Strategy and the Environment8267–280.
22.
HauflerV, 2001A Public Role for the Private Sector: Industry Self-Regulation in a Global Economy (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Washington, DC).
23.
Heritage Foundation, 2003The Index of Economic Freedom (Heritage Foundation, Washington, DC).
24.
HillaryRThorsenN, 1999, “Regulatory and self-regulatory measures as routes to promote cleaner production”Journal of Cleaner Production71–11.
25.
HoffmanA J, 2001From Heresy to Dogma: An Institutional History of Corporate Environmentalismexpanded edition (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA).
26.
ISO, 2002The ISO Survey of ISO 9000 and ISO 14000 Certificates. Eleventh Cycle: Up to and Including 31 December 2001 (International Organization for Standardization, Geneva).
27.
KhannaMAntonWRQ, 2002, “Corporate environmental management: Regulatory and market-based incentives”Land Economics78539–558.
28.
KingA ALenoxM JBarnettM L, 2002,“Strategic responses to the reputation commons problem”, in Organizations, Policy and the Natural Environment Eds HoffmanA JVentrescaM J (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 393–406.
29.
KollmanKPrakashA, 2002, “EMS-based environmental regimes as club goods: Examining variations in firm-level adoption of ISO 14001 and EMAS in U.K., U.S. and Germany”Policy Sciences3543–67.
30.
KrutRGleckmanH, 1998ISO 14001: A Missed Opportunity for Sustainable Global Industrial Development (Earthscan, London).
31.
McConnellK E, 1997, “Income and the demand for environmental quality”Environment and Development Economics2383–399.
32.
MatouqM, 2000, “A case-study of ISO 14001-based environmental management system implementation in the People's Republic of China”Local Environment5415–433.
33.
MbohwaCFukadaS, 2002, “ISO 14001 certification in Zimbabwe: Experiences, problems and prospects”Corporate Environmental Strategy9427–436.
34.
MelnykS ASroufeR PCalantoneR, 2003, “Assessing the impact of environmental management systems on corporate and environmental performance”Journal of Operations Management21329–351.
35.
MendelP J, 2002, “International standardisation and global governance: The spread of quality and environmental management standards”, in Organizations, Policy and the Natural Environment Eds HoffmanA JVentrescaM J (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 407–424.
36.
MielnikOGoldembergJ, 2002, Foreign direct investment and decoupling between energy and gross domestic product in developing countries”Energy Policy30(2) 87–89.
37.
MilsteinM BHartS LYorkA S, 2002, “Coercion breeds variation: The differential impact of isomorphic pressures on environmental strategies”, in Organizations, Policy and the Natural Environment Eds HoffmanA JVentrescaM J (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 151–172.
38.
MorrowDRondinelliD, 2002, “Adopting corporate environmental management systems: Motivations and results of ISO 14001 and EMAS certification”European Management Journal20159–171.
39.
NealeA, 1997, “Organisational learning in contested environments: Lessons from Brent Spar”Business Strategy and the Environment693–103.
40.
NewellP, 2001, “Campaigning for corporate change: Global citizen action on the environment”, in Global Citizen Action Eds EdwardsMGaventaJ (Earthscan, London) pp 189–201.
PatonB, 2002, “Voluntary environmental initiatives and sustainable industry”, in Voluntary Environmental Agreements: Process, Practice and Future Use Ed. ten BrinkP (Greenleaf, Sheffield) pp 37–49.
43.
PerryMSinghS, 2002, “Corporate environmental responsibility in Singapore and Malaysia”, in The Greening of Business in Developing Countries: Rhetoric, Reality, and Prospects Ed. UttingP (Zed Press, London) pp 97–131.
44.
PrakashA, 1999, “A new-institutionalist perspective on ISO 14000 and responsible care”Business Strategy and the Environment8322–335.
45.
QuaziH AKhooY-KTanC-MWongP-S, 2001, “Motivation for ISO 14000 certification: Development of a predictive model”Omega29525–542.
46.
RainesS S, 2002, “Implementing ISO 14001—an international survey assessing the benefits of certification”Corporate Environmental Strategy9418–426.
47.
Reppelin-HillV, 1999, “Trade and environment: An empirical analysis of the technology effect in the steel industry”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management38283–301.
48.
RockM T, 2002Pollution Control in East Asia: Lessons for Newly Industrialising Economies (Resources for the Future, Washington, DC).
49.
RodgersC, 2000, “Making it legit: New ways of generating corporate legitimacy in a globalising world”, in Terms for Endearment: Business, NGOs and Sustainable Development Ed. BendellJ (Greenleaf, Sheffield) pp 40–48.
50.
Roht-ArriazaN, 1997, “Environmental management systems and environmental protection: Can ISO 14001 be useful within the context of APEC?”Journal of Environment and Development6292–316.
51.
RondinelliD ABerryM A, 2000, “Corporate environmental management and public policy: Bridging the gap”American Behavioral Scientist44168–187.
52.
RondinelliD AVastagG, 2000, “Panacea, common sense, or just a label? The value of ISO 14001 environmental management systems”European Management Journal18499–510.
53.
SegersonKLiN, 1999, “Voluntary approaches to environmental protection”, in The International Yearbook of Environmental and Resource Economics 1999/2000 Eds FolmerHTietenbergT (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham) pp 273–306.
54.
StarkeyR, 1996, “The standardization of environmental management systems”, in Corporate Environmental Management: Systems and Strategies Ed. WelfordR (Earthscan, London) pp 59–91.
55.
StegerU, 2000, “Environmental management systems: Empirical evidence and further perspectives”European Management Journal1823–37.
56.
StewartK, 2001, “Avoiding the tragedy of the commons: Greening governance through the market or the public domain?”, in The Market or the Public Domain: Global Governance and the Asymmetry of Power Ed. DracheD (Routledge, London) pp 202–228.
57.
TannerD, 1998, Updates and trends on ISO 14000 implementation in Asia”Corporate Environmental Strategy5(3) 71–76.
58.
TietenbergT, 1998, “Disclosure strategies for pollution control”Environmental and Resource Economics11587–602.
59.
UNCTAD, 1999World Investment Report 1999: Foreign Direct Investment and the Challenge of DevelopmentUnited Nations Conference on Trade and Development (United Nations, Geneva).
60.
UNCTAD, 2003World Investment DirectoryUnited Nations Conference on Trade and Development (United Nations, Geneva).
61.
WelfordR, 2002, “Disturbing development: Conflicts between corporate environmentalism, the international economic order and sustainability”, in The Greening of Business in Developing Countries: Rhetoric, Reality, and Prospects Ed. UttinP (Zed Press, London) pp 135–158.
62.
WillettsP, 1998, “Political globalisation and the impact of NGOs upon transnational companies”, in Companies in a World of Conflict: NGOs, Sanctions and Corporate Responsibility Ed. MitchellJ V (Earthscan, London) pp 195–226.
63.
WilsonG K, 2002, “Regulatory reform on the world stage”, in Environmental Governance: A Report on the Next Generation of Environmental Policy Ed. KettlD F (Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC) pp 118–145.
64.
World Bank, 2000Greening Industry: New Roles for Communities, Markets, and Governments (Oxford University Press, New York).
