In this paper we compare periods of low-paid employment between urban and rural areas in the United Kingdom. Using the British household panel survey, we estimate the probability that a period of low-paid employment will end, followed by a number of possible outcomes, namely a higher-paid job, self-employment, unemployment, and leaving the labour force. The results show that there are statistically significant differences in the dynamics of low pay across urban and rural labour markets, particularly in terms of exits to higher pay and out of the labour force. After controlling for different personal and job characteristics across markets, urban low-pay durations are somewhat shorter on average, with a higher probability of movement to a higher-paid job. The results suggest that any urban–rural differences in the typical low-pay experience are concentrated among certain types of individuals, such as young workers and women without qualifications.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AltonjiJGBlankR, 1999, “Race and gender in the labor market”, in Handbook of Labor Economics, Volume 3 Eds AshenfelterOCCardD (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 3144–3260
2.
BarkleyDL, 1995, “The economics of change in rural America”American Journal of Agricultural Economics771252–1258
3.
BoheimRTaylorM, 2002, “Tied down or room to move? Investigating the relationships between housing tenure, employment status and residential mobility in Britain”Scottish Journal of Political Economy49369–392
4.
Cabinet Office, 1999Rural Economies report of the Performance and Innovation Unit, London (The Stationery Office, London)
5.
ClokePGoodwinMMilbournePThomasC, 1995, “Deprivation, poverty and marginalization in rural lifestyles in England and Wales”Journal of Rural Studies11351–365
6.
Countryside Agency, 2001The State of the Countryside 2001 report of The Countryside Agency (The Stationery Office, London)
7.
DavisSJHaltiwangerJSchuhS, 1996, “Small business and job creation: Dissecting the myth and reassessing the facts”Small Business Economics8297–315
8.
FindeisJLJensenL, 1998, “Employment opportunities in rural areas: Implications for poverty in a changing policy environment’American Journal of Agricultural Economics801000–1007
9.
FrankRH, 1978, “Why women earn less: The theory and estimation of differential overqualification”American Economic Review68360–373
10.
FreshwaterD, 1997, “Farm production policy versus rural life policy”American Journal of Agricultural Economics791515–1524
11.
GlaeserE, 1999, “Learning in cities”Journal of Urban Economics46254–277
12.
GlaeserEMaréD, 2001, “Cities and skills”Journal of Labour Economics19316–342
13.
GilbertAPhimisterETheodossiouI, 2003, “Low pay and income in urban and rural areas: Evidence from the British household panel survey”Urban Studies401207–1222
14.
GoslingAJohnsonPMcCraeJPaullG, 1997The Dynamics of Low Pay and Unemployment in Early 1990s Britain (Institute for Fiscal Studies and Joseph Rowntree Foundation, London)
15.
GregoryMEliasP, 1994, “Earning transition of the low paid in Britain, 1976–91: A longitudinal study”International Journal of Manpower15170–188
16.
HanAKHausmanJA, 1990, “Flexible parametric estimation of duration and competing risk models”Journal of Applied Econometrics51–28
17.
HeckmanJJ, 1981, “Heterogeneity and state dependence”, in Studies in Labour Markets Ed. RosenS (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 91–139
18.
HodgeIDunnJMonkSFitzgeraldM, 2002, “Barriers to participation in residual rural labour markets”Work, Employment and Society16457–476
19.
IhlanfeldtKRSjoquistDL, 1998, “The spatial mismatch hypothesis: A review of recent studies and their implications for welfare reform”Housing Policy Debate9849–892
20.
JenkinsS, 1995, “Easy estimation methods for discrete-time duration models”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics57129–138
21.
KaplanELMeierP, 1958, “Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations”Journal of the American Statistical Association53457–481
22.
KruegerABSummersLH, 1988, “Efficiency wages and the inter-industry wage structure”Econometrica56259–293
23.
LichterDTCostanzoJA, 1987, “Nonmetropolitan underemployment and labour-force composition”Rural Sociology52329–344
24.
LindsayCMcCrackenMMcQuaidRW, 2003, “Unemployment duration and employability in remote rural labour markets”Journal of Rural Studies19187–200
25.
MaddenJChiuL-I C, 1990, “The wage effects of residential location and commuting constraints on employed married women”Urban Studies27353–369
26.
MetcalfD, 1999, “The low pay commission and the national minimum wage”Economic Journal109F46–F66
27.
MillsB, 2000, “Are spells of unemployment longer in nonmetropolitan areas? Nonparametric and semiparametric evidence”Journal of Regional Science40697–718
28.
MonkSHodgeI, 1995, “Labour markets and employment opportunities in rural Britain”Sociologia Ruralis35153–172
29.
NealD, 1998, “The link between ability and specialization: An explanation for observed correlations between wages and mobility rates”Journal of Human Resources33173–200
30.
OiWIdsonTL, 1999, “Firm size and wages”, in Handbook of Labor Economics, Volume 3 Eds AshenfelterOCCardD (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 2165–2214
31.
PavisSHubbardGPlattS, 2001, “Young people in rural areas: Socially excluded or not”Work, Employment and Society15291–309
32.
PhimisterEShucksmithMVera-ToscanoE, 2000, “The dynamics of low pay in rural households: Exploratory analysis using the British household panel”Journal of Agricultural Economics5161–77
33.
PrenticeRLGloecklerLA, 1978, “Regression analysis of grouped survival data with application to breast cancer”Biometrics3457–67
34.
PorterfieldSL, 1998, “On the precipice of reform: Welfare spell durations for rural female headed families”American Journal of Agricultural Economics80994–999
35.
SloanePJTheodossiouI, 1996, “Earnings mobility, family income and low pay”Economic Journal106657–666
36.
StataCorp, 2001Stata Statistical Software; Release 7.0 (StataCorp, College Station, TX)
37.
StewartM, 1996, “Heterogeneity specification in unemployment duration models”, Department of Economics, University of Warwick, Coventry
38.
StewartMSwaffieldJK, 1998, “Earnings mobility of low paid workers in Britain”, in Low Pay and Earnings Mobility in Europe Eds AsplundRSloanePJTheodossiouI (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 134–156
39.
TarlingRRhodesJNorthJBroomG, 1993The Economy and Rural England (Rural Development Commission, London)
40.
ThomasJM, 1996, “An empirical model of sectoral movements by unemployed workers”Journal of Labour Economics14126–153
41.
TopelRHWardMP, 1992, “Job mobility and the careers of young men”Quarterly Journal of Economics107439–479
42.
UpwardR, 1999, “Constructing data on unemployment spells from the PSID and the BHPS”, Centre for Research on Globalisation and Labour Markets, School of Economic Studies, University of Nottingham, Nottingham
43.
WheelerCH, 2001, “Search, sorting and urban agglomeration”Journal of Labour Economics19879–899
44.
WoolridgeJM, 2002Econometric Analysis of Cross-section and Panel Data (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
