An important feature of town-planning practice in Western Europe has been the attempt to control commercial-property development in order to conform with planning principles. The growth history of large stores such as hypermarkets, superstores, and retail warehouses has thus been characterised by disputes between developers and planners. In this paper we examine the responses of large-store developers to UK government planning guidance that retail developments should be of a nature and scale suited to the physical environment of town centres. This goes against some retailers' preferences for large formats which are generally unsuited to town centres. We explain these two opposed views, devoting particular attention to the retail developers' case. We then use findings from two interview surveys with selected retailers to explore how far retail developers are prepared to go in compromising their preferred models of store development in line with government policy. Finally we discuss potential effects of recent changes in government policy.
CPRE, 2004Market Towns: Losing their Character?Campaign to Protect Rural England, 128 Southwark Street, London SE1 0SW.
10.
CullingworthJ BNadinV, 2002Town and Country Planning in the UK13th edition (Routledge, London).
11.
DaviesR L (Ed.), 1995Retail Planning Policies in Western Europe (Routledge, London).
12.
DETR, 2001Environmental Impact of Supermarket Competition, Government ResponseDepartment of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, London.
13.
DoE, 1996Planning Policy Guidance 6: Town Centres and Retail Development Department of the Environment (The Stationery Office, London).
14.
EnglandJ, 2000Retail Impact Assessment: A Guide to Best Practice (Routledge, London).
15.
EversD, 2004Building for Consumption: An Institutional Analysis of Peripheral Shopping Center Development in Northwest Europe PhD dissertation, School of Urban and Regional Research, University of Amsterdam.
16.
FindlayA MSparksL, 2004, “Retail planning: Development control or plan-led?”European Retail Digest4260–62.
17.
FindlayA MSparksL, 2005Publications on Retail Planning in 2004Institute for Retail Studies, University of Stirling, Stirling.
18.
Friends of the Earth, 2003Briefing: How Supermarkets Avoid Planning ControlsFriends of the Earth, 26–28 Underwood Street, London N1 7JQ.
19.
GLA, 2004aMaking Better Use of Supermarket Sites: The London Plan (Spatial Development Strategy for Greater London: Draft Best Practice GuideGreater London Authority, London.
20.
GLA, 2004bThe London Plan: Spatial Development Strategy for Greater London)Greater London Authority, London.
21.
GuyC M, 1994The Retail Development Process: Location, Property and Planning (Routledge, London).
22.
GuyC M, 1998a, “Controlling new retail spaces: The impress of planning policies in western Europe”Urban Studies35953–979.
23.
GuyC M, 1998b, “‘High street’ retailing in off-centre retail parks: A review of the effectiveness of land use planning policies”Town Planning Review69291–313.
24.
GuyC M, 2002, “Is retail planning policy effective? The case of very large store development in the UK”Planning Theory and Practice3319–330.
25.
GuyC M, 2006, “Retail productivity and land-use planning: Negotiating ‘joined-up’ retail planning policy”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24755–770.
26.
GuyC MBennisonD, 2002, “Retail planning policy, superstore development and retailer competition”International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management30431–434.
27.
GuyC MBennisonDClarkeR, 2005, “Scale economies and superstore retailing: New evidence from the UK”Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services1273–81.
28.
HarrisN, 2001, “Planning policy, policy guidance and technical advice: A review and analysis of the Technical Advice Notes (Wales) series”Town Planning Review72393–422.
29.
HarrisNThomasH, 2004, “Planning for a diverse society? A review of the UK government's Planning Policy Guidance”Town Planning Review75473–502.
House of Commons, 2003Select Committee on ODPM: Housing, Planning, Local Government and the Regions, Fourth Report: Planning Competitiveness and Productivity (The Stationery Office, London).
32.
LoweAReevesC, 2000, “Contemporary issues in retailing: Tesco views on planning”Proceedings of the 2000 Manchester Conference for Contemporary Issues in Retail Marketing (Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester) pp 146–150.
33.
New Economics Foundation, 2004Clone Town Britain: The Loss of Local Identity on the Nation's High StreetsNew Economics Foundation, 3 Jonathon Street, London SE11 5NH.
34.
ODPM, Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London2003Consultation Draft Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning for Town Centres.
OwensSCowellR, 2001Land and Limits: Interpreting Sustainability in the Planning Process (Routledge, London).
38.
PalJBennisonDClarkeIByromJ, 2001, “Power, policy networks and planning: The involvement of major grocery retailers in the formulation of Planning Policy Guidance Note 6 since 1988”International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research11225–246.
39.
PéronR, 2001, “The political management of change in urban retailing”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research25847–878.
RustonP, 1999Out of Town Shopping: The Future of Retailing (British Library Publications, London).
42.
Scottish Office, 1998National Planning Policy Guideline 8: Town Centres and RetailingScottish Office, Development Department, Edinburgh.
43.
Tewdwr-JonesM, 1997, “Plans, policies and inter-governmental relations: Assessing the role of national planning guidance in England and Wales”Urban Studies34141–162.
44.
ThomasC JBromleyRDF, 2003, “Retail revitalization and small town centres: The contribution of shopping linkages”Applied Geography2347–71.
45.
WarrenR, 2005, “Mezzanine floor outbreak—a practical reality”Journal of Planning and Environment Law February, 156–158.
WilliamsR H, 1996European Union Spatial Policy and Planning (Paul Chapman, London).
48.
WoodZ, 2005, “Ikea shrinks stores to drive UK growth”Retail Week 28 January, page 1.
49.
WrigleyN, 1998, “Understanding store development programmes in post-property-crisis UK food retailing”Environment and Planning A3015–35.
50.
WrigleyNGuyCLoweM, 2002, “Urban regeneration, social inclusion and large store development: The Seacroft development in context”Urban Studies392101–2114.
