This paper presents an object-centred account of the politics of memory at a National Historic Landmark: Angel Island Immigration Station, San Francisco. Once a port of entry and detention for Chinese immigrants arriving in the United States, the Immigration Station exists today as a historic site managed by California State Parks who are in the midst of implementing a new interpretive programme with a mission to: ‘turn a history of exclusion into a future of inclusion’. The discussion fixes on three objects located within the park which play an important role in the representation of the site's past despite being labelled as ‘noncontributing’ in the site's National Historic Landmark's nomination. The biographies of a bronze bell, a granite monument, and a group of wax mannequins as sketched out here suggest novel ways to be sensitive to the many and often unexpected contributions brought by the materiality of an object in practices of remembrance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsP CHoelscherSTillK E (Eds), 2001Textures of Place: Exploring Humanist Geographies (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
2.
AldermanD, 2002, “Writing on the Graceland wall: on the importance of authorship in pilgrimage landscapes”Tourism Recreation Research2727–34
3.
AndersonBTolia-KellyD, 2004, “Matter(s) in social and cultural geography”Geoforum35669–674
4.
AndersonK, 2003a, “White natures: Sydney's Royal Agricultural Show in post-humanist perspective”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series28422–441
5.
AndersonK, 2003b, “Post-humanist geographies”, in Handbook of Cultural Geography Eds AndersonKDomoshMPileSThriftN (Sage, London) pp 18–23
6.
AppaduraiA (Ed.), 1986The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
7.
BellV, 1999, “Historical memory, global movements and violence: Paul Gilroy and Arjun Appadurai in conversation”Theory, Culture and Society1621–40
8.
BinghamN, 1996, “Object-ions: from technological determinism towards geographies of relations”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14635–657
9.
BloomM E, 2003Waxworks: A Cultural Obsession (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
10.
BrochuC, 2003Interpretive Planning: The 5-M Model for Successful Planning Projects (Interprress, Fort Collins, CO)
California Department of Parks and Recreation, 2001Immigration Station tour script, 27 March
13.
California Department of Parks and Recreation, 2002Angel Island Fact/Fiction internal training document, 27 March
14.
CallonM, 1986, “The sociology of an actor-network: the case of the electric vehicle”, in Texts and their Power Eds CallonMLawJRipA (Macmillan, London)
15.
CastreeN, 2001, “Social nature: theory, practice and policies”, in Social Nature: Theory, Practice and Politics Eds CastreeNBraunB (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 1–21
16.
CastreeNBraunB (Eds), 1998Remaking Reality: Nature at the Millennium (Routledge, London)
ChoyP, 1995National Register of Historic Places Registration Form copy available from
19.
National Register of Historic Places, National Park Service, 1839 C Street, NW (MS 2280), Washington, DC 20240, USA
20.
CrangM, 1996, “Envisioning urban histories: Bristol as palimpsest, postcards, and snapshots”Environment and Planning A28429–452
21.
CresswellT, 2003, “Landscape and the obliteration of practice”, in Handbook of Cultural Geography Eds AndersonKDomoshMPileS (Sage, London) pp 269–281
22.
DavisonMMeierL, 2002, “Cultural landscape report for Angel Island Immigration Station”, copy available from The Olmsted Center for Landscape Preservation, Charlestown, MA
23.
DeLyserD, 2004, “Recovering social memories from the past: the 1884 novel Ramona and tourist practices in turn-of-the-century southern California”Social and Cultural Geography5483–496
24.
DeLyserD, 2005Ramona Memories: Tourism and the Shaping of Southern California (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
25.
DesforgesLMaddernJ, 2004, “Front doors to freedom, portal to the past: history at the Ellis Island Immigration Museum, New York”Social and Cultural Geography5437–457
26.
EdensorT, 2005Industrial Ruins: Aesthetics, Materiality and Memory (Berg, Oxford)
27.
FooteK, 1997Shadowed Ground: America's Landscape of Violence and Tragedy (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX)
28.
GibsonJ J, 1977, “The theory of affordances”, in Perceiving, Acting, Knowing: Toward an Ecological Psychology Ed ShawR EBransfordJ (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ) pp 62–82
29.
GosdenCMarshallY, 1999, “The cultural biography of objects”World Archeology31169–178
30.
HallS, 1997, “Culture and power”Radical Philosophy8624–41
31.
HamS, 1992Environmental Interpretation: A Practical Guide for People with Big Ideas and Small Budgets (North America Press, Golden, CO)
32.
HannahS PDel CasinoV JSeldenCHiteB, 2004, “Representation as work in ‘America's most historic city’”Social and Cultural Geography5459–481
33.
HarreR, 2002, “Material objects in social worlds”Theory, Culture and Society1923–33
34.
HoskinsG, 2005, “A place to remember: scaling the walls of Angel Island Immigration Station”Journal of Historical Geography30685–700
35.
HoskinsJ, 1998Biographical Objects: How Things Tell the Stories of People's Lives (Routledge, London)
36.
JacksonH H, 1984Ramona: A Story (Robert Brothers, Boston, MA)
37.
JacksonP, 2000, “Rematerializing social and cultural geography”Social and Cultural Geography19–14
38.
JacobsJ M, 2006, “A geography of big things”Cultural Geographies131–27
39.
KadoyamaM, 2001Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation Education Plan 2001–2004 copy available from Margaret Kadoyama, 7 Sherman Court, Fairfax, CA 94930
40.
Kirshenblatt-GimblettB, 1998Destination Culture: Tourism, Museums, and Heritage (University of California Press, Los Angeles, CA)
41.
KopytoffI, 1986, “The cultural biography of things: commoditization as process”, in The Social Life of Things Ed. AppaduraiA (Cambridge University Press, New York)
42.
LaiHLimGYungJ, 1980Island: Poetry and History of Chinese Immigrants on Angel Island, 1910–1940 (University of Washington Press, London)
43.
LarsenD L, 2003Meaningful Interpretation: How to Connect Hearts and Minds to Places, Objects, and Other Resources (Eastern National, Fort Washington, PA)
44.
LatourB, 1988Science in Action (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
45.
LatourB, 1996, “On interobjectivity”Mind, Culture and Activity3228–245
46.
LawJ, 1999, “After ANT: complexity, naming and topology”, in Actor Network Theory and After Eds LawJHassardJ (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 1–14
47.
LeeE, 2003At America's Gates: Chinese Immigration during the Exclusion Era (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
48.
LeesL, 2002, “Rematerializing geography: the ‘new’ urban geography”Progress in Human Geography26101–112
49.
LefebvreH, 1990The Production of Space (Blackwell, Oxford)
50.
LimerickP N, 1992, “Disorientation and reorientation: the American landscape discovered from the West”Journal of American History791021–1049
51.
LorimerH, 2005, “Cultural geography: the busyness of being ‘more-than-representational’”Progress in Human Geography2983–94
52.
MartinA, 1997, “The practice of identity and an Irish sense of place”Gender, Place and Culture489–119
53.
MeeKWaittG, 2003, “Culture matters”Social and Cultural Geography4131–138
54.
MillerD, 1987Material Culture and Mass Consumption (Blackwell, Oxford)
55.
MitchellD, 1995, “There is no such thing as culture: towards a reconceptualization of the idea of culture in geography”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series20102–116
56.
Moore Iacofano Goltsmann Inc., 1999, “Angel Island Immigration Station visioning workshops report”, Moore Iacofano Goltsmann, Berkeley, CA
PearceS M, 1992Museums, Objects and Collections: A Cultural Study (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
59.
PelsDHetheringtonKVandenberghF, 2002, “The status of the object: performances, mediations and techniques”Theory, Culture and Society191–21
60.
PhiloC, 2000, “More words, more worlds: reflections on the ‘cultural turn’ and human geography”, in Cultural Turns/Geographical Turns: Perspectives on Geography Eds CookICrouchDNaylorSRyanJ R (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ) pp 26–53
61.
PhiloCWilbertC (Eds), 2000Animal Spaces, Beastly Places: New Geographies of Human—Animal Relations (Routledge, London)
62.
RadstoneSHodgkinK (Ed.), 2003Regimes of Memory (Routledge, London)
63.
RoseM, 2002, “Landscape and labyrinths”Geoforum33455–467
64.
RothermichNEichingerL (Eds), 2002, “Ding one good bell story”The Halo: Volunteers for Angel Island State Park newsletter, 27 March, page 2
65.
RubensteinS, 1998, “Missing in action: Angel Island museum mystery is exceedingly slow to unravel”San Francisco Chronicle 22 July
ScheidJ, 2001, “Angel Island Immigration Station”Las Vegas Review-Journal 9 September
68.
SoennichsenJ, 2001Miwoks to Missiles: A History of Angel IslandAngel Island Assocation, PO Box 866, Tiburon, CA 94920
69.
SpencerTWhatmoreS, 2001, “Biogeographies: putting life back into the discipline”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series26139–141
70.
ThomasonC, 1982Making Sense of Reification (Macmillan, London)
71.
ThriftN, 2004, “Intensities of feeling: towards a spatial politics of affect”Geografiska Annaler: Series B8657–78
72.
TildenF, 1977Interpreting Our Heritage (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
73.
Tolia-KellyD, 2004, “Materializing post-colonial geographies: examining the textual landscapes of migration in the South Asian home”Geoforum35675–688
74.
VeverkaJ A, 1994Interpretive Master Planning (Falcon, Helena, MT)
75.
WangL, 1976, “The Yee version of poems from the Chinese Immigration Station”Asian American Review117–126
76.
WongMKadoyamaM, 2001, “Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation Strategic Plan 2001–2006: Executive Summary”, copy available from Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation, San Francisco, CA
77.
WylieJ, 2002, “An essay on ascending Glastonbuy Tor”Geoforum33441–454
78.
YoungJ E, 1993The Texture of Memory: Holocaust Memorials and Meaning (Yale University Press, London)
79.
YuC Y, 1977, “Rediscovered voices: Chinese immigrants and Angel Island”Amerasia Journal4123–139
