Whereas policy makers and industry advocates have hailed the growth of the subprime mortgage market in the US as evidence that financial innovation can more efficiently price and absorb credit risk, the 2007 mortgage crisis provides an opportunity to revisit the nature of financial risk. This paper employs a forensic analysis of the development of the subprime market from the 1980s through 2007 to argue that, in a competitive environment marked by the greater integration between housing finance and capital/equity markets, financial innovations provide new opportunities to hedge risk even as they collapse the barriers to rivalries between firms. This has changed the terrain for risk assessment, promoting new modes of financial competition that have intensified systemic risk and extended it to a widening set of firms, households, and communities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AngellCRowleyC, 2006, “Breaking new ground in US mortgage lending”FDIC Outlook (Summer) 21–29
2.
ApgarWBendimeradAEsseneR, 2007Mortgage Market Channels and Fair Lending: An Analysis of HMDA DataJoint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA
3.
AshcraftASchuermannT, 2008Understanding the Securitization of Subprime Mortgage Credit (Federal Reserve Bank of New York, New York)
4.
Asset Sales Report1994a, “Room for more? Competition heats up in B and C mortgage lending”8(18) page 1
5.
Asset Sales Report1994b“Burgeoning supply of B and C mortgages behooves investors to become familiar with market”8(22) page 7
6.
AveryRBosticRCalemPCannerG, 1996, “Credit risk, credit scoring, and the performance of home mortgages”Federal Reserve Bulletin82621–648
7.
AvidonE, 1997, “Wall Street begins to accept 125 LTV loans as issuance booms”National Mortgage News 30 June, page 23
BajajV, 2006, “Mortgages grow riskier and investors are attracted”New York Times 6 September, page C1
10.
BajajV, 2007, “Slumping confidence in bonds tied to subprime mortgages”New York Times 16 June, page C9
11.
BajajVAndrewsE, 2007, “Reports suggest broader losses from mortgages”New York Times 25 October, page A1
12.
BajajVCreswellJ, 2007, “$3.2 billion move by Bear Stearns to rescue fund”New York Times 23 June, page A1
13.
BallM, 1990Under One Roof: Retail Banking and the International Mortgage Finance Revolution (St Martin's Press, New York)
14.
BoyerR, 2000, “The political in the era of globalization and finance: Focus on some Régulation School research”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research24274–322
15.
BrennerR, 2002The Boom and the Bubble: The US in the World Economy (Verso, New York)
16.
BrooksRFordC, 2007, “The United States of subprime”Wall Street Journal 11 October, page A1
17.
CannerGPassmoreWLadermanE, 1999, “The role of specialized lenders in extending mortgages to lower-income and minority homebuyers”Federal Reserve Bulletin85709–723
18.
ChinloyPMacdonaldN, 2005, “Subprime lenders and mortgage market completion”Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics30153–165
19.
ChiuS, 2006, “Nontraditional mortgages: Appealing but misunderstood”Profitwise News and Views, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago December, 2–10
20.
ChomsisengphetSPennington-CrossA, 2006, “The evolution of the subprime mortgage market”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis88(1) 31–56
21.
CowanC, 2003, “History and overview of securitization”, Testimony before the Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Consumer Credit, United States House of Representatives, 5 November, http://financialservices.house.gov/media/pdf/110503cc.pdf
22.
CRL, 2004, “A review of Wells Fargo's subprime lending”, Center for Responsible Lending, Raleigh-Durham, NC
23.
DymskiG, 1996, “Money as a ‘time machine’ in the new financial world”, in Keynes, Money, and the Open Economy: Essays in Honor of Paul Davidson Ed. ArestisP (Edward Elgar, Northampton, MA) pp 85–104
24.
DymskiG, 1998, “Disembodied risk or the social construction of creditworthiness?”, in New Keynesian Economics/Post Keynesian Alternatives Ed. RotheimR (Routledge, London) pp 241–261
25.
DymskiGIsenbergD, 1998, “Housing finance in the age of globalization: From social housing to life-cycle risk”, in Globalization and Progressive Economic Policy Eds BakerDEpsteinGPollinR (Cambridge University Press, New York) pp 219–239
26.
EngelKMcCoyP, 2002, “A tale of three markets: The law and economics of predatory lending”Texas Law Review801255–1382
27.
FarrellCEdidM, 1986, “Rolling consumer debt into reams of new paper”Business Week 13 January, page 110
28.
FarrisJRichardsonC, 2004, “The geography of subprime prepayment penalties”Housing Policy Debate15687–714
29.
FDIC, 1998Managing the Crisis: The FDIC and RTC Experience, Volume 1Federal Deposit Insurance CorporationWashington, DC
30.
FeltonA, 2006, “Cycles of thought: An historical context for the modern credit cycle”FDIC Outlook Summer, 3–7
Federal Reserve Board, 2007a, “Home mortgage assets of agency- and GSE-backed mortgage pools and private issuers of asset-backed securities”, Flow of Funds Dataset, Series FL413065105.A and FL673065105.A, 1987–2006, Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC, http://www.federalreserve.gov/datadownload/Build.aspx?rel=Z1
33.
Federal Reserve Board, 2007b, “Households and nonprofit organizations home mortgage and consumer credit liabilities”, Flow of Funds Dataset, Series LA153165105.A and LA153166000.A, 1987–2006, Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC, http://www.federalreserve.gov/datadownload/Build.aspx?rel=Z1
34.
Federal Reserve Board, 2007c, “Households and nonprofit organizations real estate excluding nonprofits”, Flow of Funds Dataset, Series FL155035015.Q, 1975–2006,. Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC, http://www.federalreserve.gov/datadownload/Build.aspx?rel=Z1
35.
GrantR, 1998, “B&C issuers use prepay-protected MBS structure”National Mortgage News 20 April, page 29
36.
HarneyK, 2005, “Lies are growing in loan process”Washington Post 30 July, page F1
37.
HarveyD, 1999The Limits to Capital2nd edition (Verso, London)
38.
IsenbergD, 1998, “Post and new Keynesians: The role of asymmetric information and uncertainty in the construction of financial institutions and policy”, in New Keynesian Economics/Post Keynesian Alternatives Ed. RotheimR (RoutledgeLondon) pp 227–240
39.
KrippnerG, 2005, “The financialization of the American economy”Socio-Economic Review3173–208
40.
KrugmanP, 2006, “Progress or regress”New York Times 15 September
41.
LaxHMantiMRacaPZornP, 2004, “Subprime lending: An investigation of economic efficiency”Housing Policy Debate15533–572
42.
LeyshonATickellA, 1994, “Money order? The discursive construction of Bretton Woods and the making and breaking of regulatory space”Environment and Planning A261861–1890
National Mortgage News1996a, “Average size of subprime loans growing”, 3 June, page 32
52.
National Mortgage News1996b, “Countrywide gets into B&C business”, 16 December, page 7
53.
NewmanKWylyE, 2004, “Geographies of mortgage market segmentation: The case of Essex County, New Jersey”Housing Studies19(1) 53–83
54.
O'BrienT, 1997, “Lowering the credit fence; big players are jumping into the risky loan business”New York Times 13 December, page D1
55.
OCC, 2006, “Survey of credit underwriting practices”, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Washington, DC
56.
PollinR, 1987, “Structural change and increasing fragility in the US financial system”, in The Imperiled Economy (Book I) Eds CherryRD'OnofrioCKurdasCMichlTMoseleyFNaplesM (Union for Radical Political Economics, New York) pp 145–158
StrakaJ, 2000, “A shift in the mortgage landscape: The 1990s move to automated credit evaluations”Journal of Housing Research11207–232
62.
TemkinKJohnsonJLevyD, 2002Subprime Markets, the Role of GSEs, and Risk-based PricingOffice of Policy Development and Research, US Department of Housing and Urban Development, Washington, DC
63.
TempkinA, 2001, “Muscling in: Commercial banks take over ABS”Investment Dealers' Digest 30 July, page 30
64.
US Census Bureau, 2007, “Historical income tables—households”, table H.6, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplements, US Census Bureau, Washington, DC
65.
Wall Street Journal2006, “The house the Fed built”, 25 August, page A14
66.
WeicherJ, 1997The Home Equity Lending Industry: Refinancing Mortgages for Borrowers with Impaired Credit (The Hudson Institute, Indianapolis, IN)
