The Missing Link between Technological Standards and Value-Chain Governance: The Case of Patent-Distribution Strategies in the Mobile-Communication Industry
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2010
The Missing Link between Technological Standards and Value-Chain Governance: The Case of Patent-Distribution Strategies in the Mobile-Communication Industry
In this paper we explore the effects of technological standards on the governance structure of production networks by investigating patent-distribution strategies in the global mobile-communication industry. Through a comparative analysis of two mobile-communication technology standards—GSM and CDMA—we find that there exist significantly different patent-distribution strategies which result in varied governance structure as well as power relations within seemingly similar production networks. Furthermore, the different social–institutional processes of standard setting and implementation of GSM and CDMA contribute to this varied governance structure to a significant degree. Thus, we highlight the role of patent-distribution strategies in influencing value-chain governance, and provide a dynamic view of technological standards.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AokiM, 2001Information, Corporate Governance, and Institutional Diversity (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
2.
BairJGereffiG, 2001, “Local clusters in global chains: The causes and consequences of export dynamism in Torreon's blue jeans industry”World Development291885–1903.
3.
BaldwinC YClarkK B, 1997, “Managing in an age of modularity”Harvard Business Review584–93.
4.
BaldwinC YClarkK B, 2000Design Rules: The Power of Modularity (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
5.
BekkersRDuystersGVerspagenB, 2002, “Intellectual property rights, strategic technology agreements and market structure: The case of GSM”Research Policy311141–1161.
6.
Casadesus-MasanellRYoffieD B, 2007, “Wintel: Cooperation and conflict”Management Science53584–598.
7.
ChesbroughH, 2003Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology (Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA).
8.
CoeN MHessM, 2006, “Global production networks: debates and challenges”, a position paper for the Geographical Political Economy Research Group, workshop, 25–26 January, School of Geography, University of Manchester.
9.
CoeN MDickenPHessM, 2008, “Global production networks: Realizing the potential”Journal of Economic Geography8271–295.
10.
CookeM T, 2004, “The politics of greater China's integration into the global Info Tech (IT) supply chain”Journal of Contemporary China13(40) 491–506.
11.
DavidP A, 1995, “Standardization policies for network technologies: The flux between freedom and order revisited”, in Standards, Innovation and Competitiveness Eds HawkinsR WMansellRSkeaJ (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants) pp 15–35.
DickenPKellyP FOldsKYeungHWC, 2001, “Chains and networks, territories and scales: Toward a relational framework for analyzing the global economy”Global Network1(2) 89–112.
14.
DolanCHumphreyJ, 2004, “Changing governance patterns in the trade in fresh vegetables between Africa and the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning A36491–509.
15.
FrenkelS J, 2001, “Globalization, athletic footwear commodity chains and employment relations in China”Organization Studies22531–562.
16.
FunkJ LMetheD T, 2001, “Market- and committee-based mechanisms in the creation and diffusion of global industrial standards: The case of mobile communication”Research Policy30589–610.
17.
GereffiG, 1996, “Global commodity chains: New forms of coordination and control among nations and firms in international industries”Competition and Change1427–439.
18.
GereffiG, 1999, “International trade and upgrading in the apparel commodity chain”Journal of International Economics4837–70.
19.
GereffiGKorzeniewiczM (Eds), 1994Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism (Praeger, New York).
20.
GereffiGHumphreyJSturgeonT, 2005, “The governance of global value chains”Review of International Political Economy1278–104.
21.
GibbonPPonteS, 2008, “Global value chains: From governance to governmentality”Economy and Society37365–392.
22.
GlimstedtH, 2001, “Competitive dynamics of technological standardization: The case of third generation cellular communications”Industry and Innovation849–78.
23.
GreensteinSStangoV (Eds), 2007Standards and Public Policy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
24.
HallP ASoskiceD (Eds), 2001Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
25.
HendersonJDickenPHessMCoeNYeungHWC, 2002, “Global production networks and the analysis of economic development”Review of International Political Economy9436–464.
26.
HessMCoeN, 2006, “Making connections: Global production networks, standards, and embeddedness in the mobile-telecommunications industry”Environment and Planning A381205–1227.
27.
HodgsonG M, 1996, “Varieties of capitalism and varieties of economic theory”Review of International Political Economy3380–433.
28.
HollingsworthJ RBoyerR (Eds), 1997Contemporary Capitalism: The Embeddedness of Institutions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
HughesA, 2000, “Retailers, knowledge and changing commodity networks: The case of the cut flower trade”Geoforum31175–190.
31.
HumphreyJ, 2004, “Globalisation and supply chain networks: The auto industry in Brazil and India.”Global Networks3121–141.
32.
HumphreyJSchmitzH, 2002, “How does insertion in global value chains affect upgrading in industrial cluster?”Regional Studies361017–1027.
33.
LangloisR N, 2002, “Modularity in technology and organization”Journal of Economic Behavior and Corporate Change4919–37.
34.
LangloisR N, 2003, “The vanishing hand: The changing dynamics of industrial capitalism”Industrial and Corporate Change12351–385.
35.
LangloisR N, 2004, “Chandler in a larger frame: Markets, transaction costs, and organizational form in history”Enterprise and Society5355–375.
36.
LangloisR NRobertsonP L, 1995Firms, Markets and Economic Change: A Dynamic Theory of Business Institutions (Routledge, London).
37.
LeinbachTBrunnS, 2002, “National innovation systems, firm strategy, and enabling mobile communications: The case of Nokia”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie93489–508.
38.
LiHLiF, 2004, “The origin of value and its theory research”China Industrial Economy352–60.
39.
LiL, 2006, “The lawsuit of CDMA”IT Times Weekly issue 7 (March), 65–67.
40.
LiZYangS, 2003, “GSM: A Successful case of strategic standardization alliance”China Industrial Economy789–95.
Luosheng Consultation Company, 2006, “The intellect right of TD”The Daily of First Finance and Economics 19 October.
43.
MullerJ M, 2002, “Patent misuse through the capture of industrial standards”Berkeley Technology Law Journal17245–273.
44.
NadviK, 2008, “Global standards, global governance and the organization of global value chains”Journal of Economic Geography8323–334.
45.
NadviKWältringF, 2004, “Making sense of global standards”, in Local Enterprises in the Global Economy: Issues of Governance and Upgrading Ed. SchmitzH (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 53–94.
46.
OzsomerACavusgilS T, 2000, “The effects of technology standards on the structure of the global PC industry”European Journal of Marketing341199–1220.
47.
PeckJ, 2005, “Economic sociologies in space”Economic Geography81129–176.
48.
PonteSGibbonP, 2005, “Quality standards, conventions and governance of global value chains”Economy and Society341–31.
49.
RiainS Ó, 2004, “The politics of mobility in technology-driven commodity chains: Developmental coalitions in the Irish software industry”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research28642–663.
50.
ShurmerMLeaG, 1995, “Telecommunications standardization and intellectual property rights: A Fundamental dilemma?”Standard View3(2) 50–59.
51.
SilvermanD, 2006Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Talk, Text, and Interaction (Sage, London).
52.
SturgeonT J, 2002, “Modular production networks: A New American model of industrial organization”Industrial and Corporate Change11451–496.
53.
SturgeonT J, 2003, “What really goes on in Silicon Valley: Spatial clustering and dispersal in modular production networks”Journal of Economic Geography3199–225.
54.
TakahashiTNamikiF, 2003, “Three attempts at “de-Wintelization”: Japan's TRON project, the US government's suits against Wintel, and the entry of Java and Linux”Research Policy321589–1606.
55.
YangDYRCoeN M, 2009, “The governance of global production networks and regional development: A Case study of Taiwanese PC production networks”Growth and Change4030–56.
56.
YangY RHsiaC J, 2007, “Spatial clustering and organizational dynamics of transborder production networks: A Case study of Taiwanese information-technology companies in the Greater Suzhou Area, China”Environment and Planning A391346–1363.
57.
ZhouY, 2008The Inside Story of China's High-Tech Industry: Making Silicon Valley in Beijing (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD).
