In 1999 Goodwin announced ‘the transformation of transport policy in Great Britain’. His central point was that consensus was emerging among policy makers and academics, based on earlier work, including “Transport: the new realism”, which rejected previous orthodoxy that the supply of road space could and should be continually expanded to match demand. Instead, a combination of investment in public transport, walking and cycling opportunities, and—crucially—demand management, should form the basis of transport policy to address rising vehicle use and associated increases in congestion and pollution/carbon emissions. This thinking formed the basis of the 1997 Labour government's ‘sustainable transport’ policy, but after thirteen years in power ministers had neither transformed policy nor tackled longstanding transport trends. Our main aim in this paper is to revisit the concept of New Realism and reexamine its potential utility as an agent of change in British transport policy. Notwithstanding the outcome of Labour's approach to transport policy, we find that the central tenets of the New Realism remain robust and that the main barriers to change are related to broader political and governance issues which suppress radical policy innovation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AnableJShawJ, 2007, “Priorities, policies and (time)scales: The delivery of emissions reductions in the UK transport sector”Area39443–457
BakerSWhiteP, 2010, “Impacts of free concessionary travel: Case study of an English rural region”Transport Policy1720–26
4.
BanisterCGallentN, 1998, “Trends in commuting in England and Wales—becoming less sustainable?”Area30331–342
5.
BanisterD, 2003, “Critical pragmatism and congestion charging in London”International Social Science Journal176249–264
6.
BanisterD, 2004, “Implementing the possible?”Planning Theory and Practice5499–501
7.
BanisterDPucherJLee-GosselinM, 2007, “Making sustainable transport politically and publicly acceptable”, in Institutions and Sustainable Transport: Regulatory Reform in Advanced Economies Eds RietveldPStoughR (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 17–50
8.
BanksNBaylissDGlaisterS, 2007Motoring Towards 2050: Roads and RealityRAC Foundation, London
9.
BBC, 2010, “The derailing of Transport 2010”, Radio 4 broadcast, 18 January
10.
BeggD, 2003, “Foreword”, in A New Deal for Transport? The UK's Struggle with the Sustainable Transport Agenda Eds DochertyIShawJ (Blackwell, Oxford) pp xiv–xvii
BonsallP, 2000, “Legislating for modal shift: Background to the UK's new transport act”Transport Policy7179–184
13.
BovairdT, 2007, “Triggering change through culture clash: The UK Civil Service reform program, 1999–2005”, in Cultural Aspects of Public Management Reform Eds SchedlerKProellerI (Emerald, Bingley, W. Yorks) pp 323–350
14.
BovairdTRussellK, 2007, “Civil service reform in the UK, 1999–2005: Revolutionary failure or evolutionary success”?Public Administration85301–332
15.
BulkeleyHRaynerT, 2003, “New realism and local realities: Local transport planning in Leicester and Cambridgeshire”Urban Studies4035–55
CfIT, 2007Transport and Climate ChangeCommission for Integrated Transport, London
19.
ChapmanRO'TooleB, 2010, “Leadership in the British Civil Service: An interpretation”Public Policy and Administration25123–136
20.
ChatterjeeKBonsallP, 2009, “Editors’ introduction to special issue on evaluation of programmes promoting voluntary change in travel behavior”Transport Policy16 (6) 279–280
21.
ChurchAFrostMSullivanK, 2000, “Transport and social exclusion in London”Transport Policy7 (3) 195–205
22.
CnossenS, 2005Theory and Practice of Excise Taxation: Smoking, Drinking, Gambling, Polluting, Driving (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
23.
ConklinJE, 2006Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems (Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
DochertyI, 2003, “Policy, politics and sustainable transport: The nature of Labour's dilemma”, in A New Deal for Transport? The UK's Struggle with the Sustainable Transport Agenda Eds DochertyIShawJ (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 3–29
42.
DochertyIMackieP, 2010, “Planning for transport in the wake of Stern and Eddington”Regional Studies44546–567
43.
DochertyIShawJ (Eds), 2003A New Deal for Transport? The UK's Struggle with the Sustainable Transport Agenda (Blackwell, Oxford)
44.
DochertyIShawJ, 2008Traffic Jam: 10 Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK (Policy Press, Bristol)
45.
DochertyIShawJKnowlesRMackinnonD, 2009, “Connecting for competitiveness: The future of transport in UK city regions”Public Money and Management29321–328
46.
DoT, 1989Roads for Prosperity Cm 693, Department of Transport (HMSO, London)
47.
DudleyGRichardsonJ, 2000Why Does Policy Change?: Lessons from British Transport Policy, 1945–99 (Routledge, London)
48.
ECMT, 1989Transport Policy and the Environment European Conference of Ministers of Transport (OECD, Paris)
49.
EddingtonR, 2006The Eddington Transport Study: The Case for Change Sir Rod Eddington's Advice to the Government (HM Treasury, London)
50.
FischerF, 2003Reframing Public Policy: Discursive Politics and Deliberative Practices (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
51.
ForsterA, 2010, “Calls grow for root and branch review of transport appraisal”Local Transport Today number 541, 1
52.
Friends of the Earth, 2000, “Paved with good intentions? Government transport plans”, press release, Friends of the Earth, London
53.
FultonJ (Lord), 1968Report of the Committee on the Civil Service (HMSO, London)
54.
GauntMRyeTIsonS, 2008, “Edinburgh's congestion charging plans: An analysis of reasons for non-implementation”Transportation Planning and Technology31641–661
55.
GladwellM, 2002The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference (Back Bay Books, New York)
56.
GlaisterS, 2001, “UK transport policy, 1997–2001”Oxford Review of Economic Policy18154–186
57.
GlazebrookG, 2009, “Taking the con out of convenience: The true cost of transport modes in Sydney”Urban Policy and Research275–24
58.
GoodwinP, 1996, “Empirical evidence on induced traffic: A review and synthesis”Transportation2335–54
59.
GoodwinP, 1997, “Solving congestion (when we must not build roads, increase spending, lose votes, damage the economy or harm the environment and will never find equilibrium)”, inaugural lecture delivered at UCL, 23 October, http://www2.cege.ucl.ac.uk/cts/tsu/tplist.htm
60.
GoodwinP, 1999, “Transformation of transport policy in Great Britain”Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice33 (7/8) 655–669
61.
GoodwinP, 2001Running to Stand Still?: An analysis of the 10 Year Plan for TransportCampaign for the Protection of Rural England, London
62.
GoodwinP, 2008, “Traffic jam? Policy debates after 10 years of ‘sustainable’ transport”, in Traffic Jam: 10 Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 231–239
63.
GoodwinPLyonsG, 2010, “Public attitudes to transport”Transportation Planning and Technology333–17
64.
GoodwinPHallettSKennyFStokesG, 1991Transport: The New RealismTransport Studies Unit, Oxford
65.
GordonIBuckNHallPHarloeMKleinmanM, 2004, “London: Competitiveness, cohesion and the policy environment”, in City Matters Eds BoddyMParkinsonM (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 71–92
66.
HambletonRSweetingD, 2004, “US-style leadership for English local government?”Public Administration Review64474–488
67.
HamerM, 1987Wheels within Wheels: Study of the Road Lobby (Routledge, London)
68.
HeadicarP, 2009Transport Policy and Planning in Great Britain (Routledge, London)
69.
HineJ, 2000, “Integration, integration, integration: Planning for sustainable and integrated transport systems in the new millennium”Transport Policy7175–177
70.
HineJPrestonJ, 2003Integrated Futures and Transport Choices: UK Transport Policy Beyond the 1998 White Paper and Transport Act (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
71.
HM Treasury, 2009Public Expenditure Statistical Analyses 2009 Cm 7630, HM Treasury, London
JessopB, 1990State Theory: Putting Capitalist States in Their Place (Blackwell, Oxford)
78.
KenyonSLyonsGRaffertyJ, 2002, “Transport and social exclusion: Investigating the possibility of promoting inclusion through virtual mobility”Journal of Transport Geography10207–219
79.
KnowlesRAbrantesP, 2008, “Buses and light rail: Stalled en route?”, in Traffic Jam: Ten Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 97–116
80.
LabourParty, 1996, “Consensus for change: Labour's transport strategy for the 21st century”, Labour Party, London
81.
Local Transport Act, 2008Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 26 (The Stationery Office, London)
82.
LyonsGChatterjeeK (Eds), 2002Transport Lessons from the Fuel Tax Protests of 2000 (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
83.
LyonsGUrryJ, 2005, “Travel time use in the information age”Transportation Research Part A39257–276
84.
MacKinnonDShawJDochertyI, 2008Diverging Mobilities? Devolution, Transport and Policy Innovation (Elsevier, Oxford)
85.
MacKinnonDShawJDochertyI, 2010, “Devolution as process: Institutional structures, state personnel and transport policy in the United Kingdom”Space and Polity14271–287
86.
MaddockS, 2002, “Making modernisation work: New narratives, change strategies and people management in the public sector”International Journal of Public Sector Management15 (1) 13–43
87.
MarsdenG, 2005, “The multi modal transport investment plans—how they all add up”Transport15875–87
88.
MawsonJ, 2007, “Regional governance in England: Past experience, future directions?”International Journal of Public Sector Management20548–566
89.
MetzD, 2008, “The myth of travel time saving”Transport Reviews28321–336
90.
Ministry of Transport, 1963Traffic in Towns (HMSO, London)
91.
MorganK, 2007, “The polycentric state: New spaces of empowerment and engagement?”Regional Studies411237–1251
92.
MurrayJ, 2008, “Service, counsel and values: Managing strategically in the public sector”, in Strategy, Innovation, Change Eds GalalvanRMurrayJMarkidesC (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 111–130
93.
PierreJ, 2000Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
94.
PotterS, 2007, “Eddington—another New Realism for transport?”Town and Country Planning7624–25
95.
PrestonJ, 2008, “Is Labour delivering a sustainable railway?”, in Traffic Jam: Ten Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 75–96
96.
ProostSVan DenderK, 2008, “Optimal urban transport pricing in the presence of congestion, economies of density and costly public funds”Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice421220–1230
RajéF, 2003, “The impact of transport on social exclusion processes with specific emphasis on road user charging”Transport Policy10321–338
99.
RauxCSoucheS, 2004, “The acceptability of urban road pricing: A theoretical analysis applied to experience in Lyon”Journal of Transport Economics and Policy38191–215
100.
RhodesR, 1996, “From institutions to dogma: Tradition, eclecticism, and ideology in the study of British public administration” Public Administration Review56 507–516 Rittel H, Webber M, 1973, “Dilemmas in a general theory of planning”Policy Sciences4155–169
101.
RobsonW, 1968, “The Fulton Report on the Civil Service”Political Quarterly39397–414
102.
SACTRA, 1994Trunk Roads and the Generation of Traffic Standing Advisory Committee on Trunk Road Assessment (HMSO, London)
103.
SchaefferKSclarE, 1975Access for All: Transportation and Urban Growth (Penguin, London)
104.
Scottish National Party, 2010Elect a Local Champion: Westminster 2010 ManifestoSNP, Edinburgh
105.
ShawJDochertyI, 2008, “New deal or no new deal? A decade of ‘sustainable’ transport in the UK”, in Traffic Jam: Ten Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 3–28
106.
ShawJHunterCGrayD, 2006, “Disintegrated transport policy: The multimodal studies process in England”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24575–596
107.
ShawJMacKinnonDDochertyI, 2009, “Divergence or convergence? Devolution and transport policy in the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy27546–567
SmeedR, 1964Road Pricing: The Economic and Technical Possibilities (HMSO, London)
110.
SmithT, 2003, “Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue: Themes of Tony Blair and his government”Parliamentary Affairs56580–596
111.
SmythA, 2003, “Devolution and sustainable transport”, in A New Deal for Transport? The UK's Struggle with the Sustainable Transport Agenda Eds DochertyIShawJ (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 229–244
112.
SweetingD, 2002, “Leadership in urban governance: The Mayor of London”Local Government Studies283–20
113.
TaylorMAmptE, 2003, “Travelling smarter down under: Policies for voluntary travel behaviour change in Australia”Transport Policy10165–177
TomaneyJ, 2000, “End of the Empire State? New Labour and devolution in the United Kingdom”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research24675–688
116.
Transport Act, 1968Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 73 (HMSO, London)
117.
VandenabeeleWHortonS, 2008, “The evolution of the British public service ethos: A historical institutional approach to explaining continuity and change”, in Ethics and Integrity of Governance: Perspectives Across Frontiers Eds HubertsL W J CMaesschalckJJurkiewiczC L (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 7–24
118.
VigarG, 2001, “‘Implementing transport's new realism’? The dissemination of demand-management policies in UK transport planning”Town Planning Review72423–443
119.
WackernagelMReesW, 1995One Ecological Footprint: Reducing Human Impact on the Earth (New Society Publishers, Gabricola Island, BC)
120.
WardmanM, 2005, “Demand for rail travel and the effects of external factors”, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds
121.
WhiteP, 2008, “Transport for London: Success despite Labour?”, in Traffic Jam: Ten Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 183–204
122.
WilsonR, 2008, “Policy analysis as policy advice”, in The Oxford Handbook of Public Policy Eds MoranMReinMGoodinR (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 152–168
123.
WolmarC, 2005On the Wrong Line: How Ideology and Incompetence Wrecked Britain's Railways (Aurym Books, London)
124.
WolmarC, 2008“Foreword”, in Traffic Jam: 10 Years of ‘Sustainable’ Transport in the UK Eds DochertyIShawJ (Policy Press, Bristol) pp viii–x
